Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think London commute towns are no better than Edinburgh for raising a family?

583 replies

JenXG · 10/12/2020 09:38

So basically DH and I are having a debate on whether to leave Edinburgh and move to a commute town outside London. (we have to stick with Edinburgh / London as working in financial sector but both of us would avoid London because of traffic/pollution/crowded streets).

The main reason for DH favouring those commute towns is that they seem to have loads of good schools for DS (4mo) to choose from compared to Edinburgh where there are only a few (or hardly any if his standard). He has high hope for DS. Also the A-level system is widely recognised across different countries (so potential for studying overseas) but the same cant be said for the Scotland system.

My worry is that we are giving up preferred lifestyle for a very small difference in schooling. I grew up in a big city and always need busy streets nearby. I understand some places such as Guildford will have its own town centre but there are still fewer things going on compared to Edinburgh. For example, there are a wide range of fine restuarants, several theatres & cinemas, pubs, etc in Edinburgh but living in Guildford we'd still have to go to London for a night out? I'd assume activities for young kids are more available in Edinburgh than in Guildford? E.g. Edinburgh has a zoo, lots of museums, and a coastline where you can do kayaking. Also Guildford is one of the busier towns as I understand. Some other commute towns are even quieter. So we'd highly likely end up travelling to London a lot which is not fun (I'm far more used to walking or driving a little bit to favourite places than hours of trains/tubes).

What do people think? I haven't been to many places in the southern area. Maybe I have misunderstood what life would be like there? Would you relocate if you were us?

OP posts:
EvelynBeatrice · 10/12/2020 11:01

Re Scottish kids not getting into Oxbridge etc, I think there’s some misunderstanding here. Any Scottish child wishing to study at a good English university needs to sit Scottish Advanced Highers in 6th year. - usually 3 AHs for law, medicine, vet medicine etc. Most good state schools offer this as par for the course and all independents too (who don’t do A levels instead) . Scottish Advanced Highers are actually regarded by unis as slightly higher in value than A levels and are pitched closer to undergraduate level year 1. So you’ll see that value weighting in offers received from Russell Group unis.
It’s also key to remember that many able Scottish students choose not to apply or even take up Oxbridge etc offers because they can get free tuition at excellent Scottish unis - top rankings for eg vet science up here - or because they want to study Scots and not English law etc. I know too that eg Heriot’s has classes on oxbridge entrance and arranges mock interviews etc. I can assure you that Scottish kids have a very high acceptance rate from top ranked English unis when they apply. They often don’t.

PatriciaPerch · 10/12/2020 11:00

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Quartz2208 · 10/12/2020 10:59

I live near Guildford and have spent time in Edinburgh and the biggest thing missing from your OP is family - where are your friends and family - your roots?

HallFloor · 10/12/2020 10:58

The one family I know who made loads of life changing plans around their son's private education and future Oxbridge education had a very troubled teen and now, eventually, have a happy 30 something parks gardener for a son. Do tread carefully.

hopingforonlychild · 10/12/2020 10:57

I am a Londoner who lives in zone 3. DH and I also work in finance. Frankly this thread has made me consider Edinburgh;)

The only cons are the tiny liberal synagogue and the threat of independence. OP the SE commuter fares are not to be sniffed at. 8k per annum for you and DH together. I think £8k would probably be enough to hire more tutors so that your child is able to get into Oxbridge. Even in the SE and London, most kids who go to the top schools have tutors.

AngelicaElizaAndPeggy · 10/12/2020 10:57

Not really sure your husband's academic credentials are all that if he believes that moving his brand new little family to a small commuter town is going to somehow launch your baby straight to Oxbridge in 18 years' time.

Put it this way- I went to school in Edinburgh (not Heriot's but one v like Heriot's) and I managed to get into St. Andrews and then Cambridge. As did a whole host of other kids in the city. But it's a great city for a whole host of more important and interesting reasons than that. Also, of the 1000s of kids who chose to attend other universities in Scotland or elsewhere, loads have still managed to do other amazing things, like be journalists or marine biologists or successful restaurant entrepreneurs. Edinburgh is a tremendously exciting and inspiring place to grow up and I'm bloody gutted I can't bring up my own children there.

I think the real conversation worth having here is what you believe it is most important for you in raising your tiny child. A set of academic results isn't everything. What kind of person would you like them to be? What would you like to show them in the world and what do you think it's important to teach them about? What if you move to Guildford and it turns out he/she isn't academic at all? What back up options would this place be able to offer them?

Congratulations on your new baby by the way!

MaryLennoxsScowl · 10/12/2020 10:56

I don’t know Guildford but I live in and love Edinburgh - the architecture, the castle, Arthur’s Seat, the Meadows, Leith, the museums and galleries, Portobello, Stockbridge, the Botanics, the art and festival scenes - plus access to the Highlands, endless coastline, skiing, surfing, all kinds of outdoor sports, and free university for your possibly-gifted child and any others that come along! Not to mention it’s probably cheaper to get a decent house up here than near London. I would never move to a town from here. It’d be either this or the middle of nowhere for me!

YoniAndGuy · 10/12/2020 10:56

You would be absolutely mad to leave Edinburgh, a world class city and one of the cultural capitals of the world, for a shitty, over populated commuter town in the SE imo.

This. No, your DS probably won't thank you for being brought up in Guildford rather than Edinburgh. There's no comparison that I can think of - yes to better and more accessible art, culture, music - the list goes on.

The thing about A levels being more widely recognised just isn't the slightest bit relevant. Far more so is the potential for free Uni tuition from Scotland, plus the catchment system differences. The English system is awful in that respect.

Your problem here just might be a DH with 'high hopes' for a 4-month old which include worrying about schools. If he really is focued on that, there is no doubt at all that his focus would be better put to saving for private.

Don't move. You've said yourself that you prefer a city bustle - what matters more than practically any of the issues above is a happy home, and I think you personally sound as if you'd regret it deeply.

Move into the best Edinburgh catchment you can afford.

Haventbeenthere · 10/12/2020 10:55

I'd choose Edinburgh over a commuter town. But, being commuter towns, they do have easy access to central London, which has a zoo and all the theatres, museums, etc you could possibly wish for.

diplodocusinermine · 10/12/2020 10:55

Just one point, I really wouldn't count on free university educationby the time your baby is 17/18.

Wbeezer · 10/12/2020 10:54

@FelicityPike you missed the bit where I said money was a reason Smile.

BiscuitDrama · 10/12/2020 10:53

Are you thinking private or state schools?

LemonBreeland · 10/12/2020 10:52

Bloody hell! You have Fettes on your doorstep, can afford it, and your DH is worried about schooling. He needs to give his head a wobble

thereplycamefromanchorage · 10/12/2020 10:52

Very odd to consider that no school in Edinburgh will be able to give your DC an adequate education to get into Oxbridge, and even stranger to make a life changing decision when your DC is only 4 months.

Your DH does realise that your DC might have their own ideas about this, this might even involve not going to uni!

Wbeezer · 10/12/2020 10:47

Oh bloody hell, i knew this would be about Oxbridge! The numbers getting into Oxbridge are lower because the numbers applying are lower, my DS2 got 3As at Advanced Highers (from a state school) that's the equivalent of 3A*s and he declined to apply to Oxford (despite me taking him for a visit the year before to broaden his horizons ). It's a cultural thing not an ability thing.
For what it's worth, anecdotally, the only child of my DS's age I know who applied to Cambridge got in and there is someone on Scotsnet who's son got in to study law (also from a State school).
You really need to look beyond the bare statistics.
From my friends experience schooling in Guilford is very high pressure, not what I'd choose but it's what their mother wants.

tunnocksreturns2019 · 10/12/2020 10:47

You would be absolutely insane to move, IMO, for all the reasons already mentioned and the sheer bloody BEAUTY of the place.

St Andrews graduate. The subject I studied was recently top in one of the national league tables, ahead of Oxbridge.

Also, the school I went to in SW Scotland was really pretty bad! I got prizes and a First at university. Schools aren’t everything.

And FWIW, I’m hoping my eldest DC does an apprenticeship at college. It would suit his leaning style much better. He’s not a mini me (thank goodness!).

citycitycity · 10/12/2020 10:44

@JenXG

Oh wow thanks for the comments. Seems Edinburgh is the definite answer here.

Just to clarify the school bit...we are mainly looking at private schools. In Edinburgh we have Fetties, George Heriot and a handful of others. DH doesn't like the fact that very few some years nil students get into Oxbridge from these schools while schools like Royal Grammar School sends c20% to oxbridge each year (yes..I know. Having eyes on oxbridge with DS only being 4mo sounds crazy. But i'm not blaming him for having high hope as both families run a history of being very academic. I'd put that one aside for the sake of this particular post. He's not a pushy parent from what i see by far...).

I didn't appreciate how convenient Edinburgh was before reading some of the comments so thanks mumsnet'ers. I'll show this post to DH now!

I imagine they stay in Scotland for the free universities!

We lived in Glasgow for work when DD was a baby and really wish we’d stay - it’s an amazing country and DD wants to go there for uni - should have stayed for the free uni.

You’ll find Guildford very dull compared to Edinburgh (no offence to Guildford!)

oneglassandpuzzled · 10/12/2020 10:43

When did they become commute towns? Commuter towns, surely.

Your husband can’t really know what your son will be like educationally at this stage. I’d stay where you are.

abitnotfit · 10/12/2020 10:43

I'm sorry OP but this is madness.
You have no idea what your DC will want to do when they reach university age.
Scottish students do go to Oxbridge (if they want to), they just don't apply in large numbers because they can go to St Andrews, Glasgow or Edinburgh for free.

HallFloor · 10/12/2020 10:42

I wouldn't want to be the child whose family uprooted 400 miles for a lifestyle their mother clearly feels is inferior only for the sake of an education their father is going to pin everything on.

If your earning power is roughly the same in London and Edninburgh, then by the time you factor in the increased cost of living, including huge commuting costs from any commuter town, you'll be able to buy private schooling with the difference.

tabulahrasa · 10/12/2020 10:42

“DH doesn't like the fact that very few some years nil students get into Oxbridge from these schools”

Because they can go to St. Andrews or Edinburgh for free...

randomsabreuse · 10/12/2020 10:41

I assume the Scottish schools are less focussed Oxbridge because of interest rather than ability. Especially given fee difference (none vs 9k/year is quite a difference) as I get the impression that people able to afford school fees do so for the perceived benefits rather than just because they can!

Unless crossrail has made a massive difference I'm not sure how convenient Guildford is for Canary Wharf and from my commuter days a short commute involving changes is more annoying than a slightly longer one that is just one means of transport followed by a short walk.

The absolute top day schools are probably the central London ones (Westminster, St Paul's) and if boarding is likely to be a thing your home location is less crucial.

I'd stick with Edinburgh if you don't want to be in London itself - commuter belt is crap for family life because of commuting.

Melange99 · 10/12/2020 10:39

What if the child has other ideas about further education? The kid's 4 months old. Is this a wind up?

speakout · 10/12/2020 10:37

I wouldn't leave Edinburgh.
JK Rowling chooses to live here, and send her children to a school in Edinbugh ( my friend's sister teaches one of the children)
Presumably JK could live anywhere, and choose any education for her children- but prefers Edinburgh schooling.

Edinburgh is a magnificent city.

chipsarnie · 10/12/2020 10:37

This seems to be all about what your husband wants.

What do you want?

Edinburgh is a world-class, beautiful city. I wouldn't swap that for some SE dormitory town. If I had to move from Edinburgh it would be have to be to London 'proper' - Zones 1-3 (maybe 4) and enjoy everything the capital has to offer.