Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think London commute towns are no better than Edinburgh for raising a family?

583 replies

JenXG · 10/12/2020 09:38

So basically DH and I are having a debate on whether to leave Edinburgh and move to a commute town outside London. (we have to stick with Edinburgh / London as working in financial sector but both of us would avoid London because of traffic/pollution/crowded streets).

The main reason for DH favouring those commute towns is that they seem to have loads of good schools for DS (4mo) to choose from compared to Edinburgh where there are only a few (or hardly any if his standard). He has high hope for DS. Also the A-level system is widely recognised across different countries (so potential for studying overseas) but the same cant be said for the Scotland system.

My worry is that we are giving up preferred lifestyle for a very small difference in schooling. I grew up in a big city and always need busy streets nearby. I understand some places such as Guildford will have its own town centre but there are still fewer things going on compared to Edinburgh. For example, there are a wide range of fine restuarants, several theatres & cinemas, pubs, etc in Edinburgh but living in Guildford we'd still have to go to London for a night out? I'd assume activities for young kids are more available in Edinburgh than in Guildford? E.g. Edinburgh has a zoo, lots of museums, and a coastline where you can do kayaking. Also Guildford is one of the busier towns as I understand. Some other commute towns are even quieter. So we'd highly likely end up travelling to London a lot which is not fun (I'm far more used to walking or driving a little bit to favourite places than hours of trains/tubes).

What do people think? I haven't been to many places in the southern area. Maybe I have misunderstood what life would be like there? Would you relocate if you were us?

OP posts:
JeezyPeeps · 10/12/2020 15:54

Funny how people are speaking about 'hacking the weather' in Edinburgh, with no mention of having to hack the heatwaves in built up southern England in the height of summer. Give me Edinburgh winter weather over that any day! 30-odd degrees is probably okay on a beach somewhere, but trying to negotiate Tesco and subterranean trains with a two year old... No thanks!

Mildura · 10/12/2020 15:47

It should come as no surprise to anyone that Guildford, a town of around 60,000 inhabitants, does not offer quite as much as Edinburgh, a capital city of around 500,000 people.

Edinburgh is an amazing place to live, but Guildford is hardly the boring hole which some posters have suggested they would need to be paid to live in.

As for deciding where to live based on the chances of the child gaining a place at Oxbridge, when the child is 4months old, well I think that's probably been covered already!

Simarilion · 10/12/2020 15:42

I'd seriously look at private school fees in south east England - I understand they are much higher than in Scotland. Relocating in Edinburgh so you are in a catchment for a good state secondary would surely be a better option, then your child/children would still be entitled to free university which is another massive consideration! I'd only move if I really couldn't hack the Edinburgh weather any more- I think the house prices are worse down South and total gamble on whether the state schools will live up to your OH's expectations

Wbeezer · 10/12/2020 15:30

@nibdedibble we aren't allowed to be happy to do things differently, it's taken as implied criticism.

Moo678 · 10/12/2020 15:26

I assume you will be sending your 4 month old to private school in which case they can do A levels in Edinburgh as many if not all of the private schools follow the English system.

I love edinburgh for its history, because it’s small but with plenty going on. For its great night buses. For the ready access to beautiful countryside. For its awesome charity shops. Turns out I really love edinburgh even though I am a west coast girl at heart. I can’t understand why anyone would leave somewhere like edinburgh for a soulless commuter town.

mellicauli · 10/12/2020 15:14

I live in a London commuter town. It's great. Plenty to do. Lovely place. A But you want to stay in Edinburgh - which is also a great place - and your husband's idea of moving to Guildford to increase a 4 month old's chances of getting into Oxford is completely ridiculous. Your son is his own person. Although you can influence him, he's not a blank page for you to write on. He will decide if he is interested in achieving highly in academia - or like most people, he'll decide that's not really what he's into. I would tell your husband if at the age of 10 he looks like he might want to go to Oxford, then maybe you'll consider it.

crackofdoom · 10/12/2020 15:14

To add to my previous post: I have now realised that there is a Royal Grammar School in Guildford, as well as a Royal Grammar School in HIgh Wycombe Blush. As you were...

nibdedibble · 10/12/2020 15:11

I don’t know if it’s my chip or if anybody really thinks this: going to Oxbridge isn’t the pinnacle of ambition. It might be if you’ve been to Oxbridge but for many people it doesn’t really register because there are less odd institutions to be part of.

Lots of Scottish-educated kids don’t fancy it, thanks, especially the fees. That’s not poverty of ambition.

toconclude · 10/12/2020 15:07

Guildford is nice but expensive. Schools are decent but unless you go private nothing fancy and kindly, you have no idea if your baby will be academic, or even bright but not bothered.

crackofdoom · 10/12/2020 15:04

DH doesn't like the fact that very few some years nil students get into Oxbridge from these schools while schools like Royal Grammar School sends c20% to oxbridge each year

So you're considering High Wycombe and the surrounding area, as well as Surrey? Seriously, don't. The area is a shithole. I grew up there- and attended the sister school to the RGS, My perceptions may be clouded by my miserable childhood, but I still hate going back (and then again, my DC hate visiting too). It's bland, ugly, built up, and has very little discernible culture considering its levels of affluence.

JeezyPeeps · 10/12/2020 15:03

Its very difficult to go from one side of the city centre to the other by bus

Utter tosh. If you think that's hard, you haven't tried public transport in rural areas! I was so delighted with the public transport here that I sold my car a few months after moving here. I just don't need it, I can get unlimited bus travel for £600 pa and cycling is better than I had hoped.

You clearly have a massive chip, as you can't bear to say anything remotely hinting at a positive.

Is it perfect? No. Is anywhere? But you'd think from your description it was full of inward looking Scots, when in fact its a city that attracts people from all over the world to come and settle here.

I was always told to ignore the most positive and the most negative reviews on anything - holidays, products etc, as they are potentially the ones with skin in the game or an axe to grind.

GreenlandTheMovie · 10/12/2020 15:00

There's actually an old railway tunnel right under Princes Street *wbeezer" so obviously it is possible to tunnel into even the hallowed earth of Scotland. Let's tell the Norwegians their rock is nice and soft!

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 10/12/2020 14:59

Well silly Daddy. Edinburgh has some very academic state schools and all you have to do is live in catchment -- compare that with the London area! DS went to Oxbridge via an Edinburgh state school. There's also a huge choice of good private schools, many of DS's state primary friends went to one the merchant schools for secondary, or there are prep schools for the public/boarding school route later on, plus Fettes or Merchiston Castle locally. DS visited Fettes for a maths day and thought it was fabby. What schooling does your DH think would be so much better in Guildford?

Fewer Scots go to Oxbridge beacuse (a) no fees in Scotland and (b) they're a very long way away from home, and yes there's St Andrews or Edinburgh instead. Or Glasgow - maybe not so well known outside Scotland but highly thought of here. DS claims that in the Oxbridge access stats, due to Edinburgh's unusual demographics he is not "middleclass as fuck" but an "inner city state comp kid" Grin

Scottish qualifications are no better or worse understood internatonally than A levels. One of my English nephews gave up on applying to a German medical school because it was just too complicated.

I would have moved to Scotland years ago but DH wouldn't due to climate.

OK, right now do I see your DH's point. Edinburgh is east-coast dry not west-coast damp but it wont get light again til March. On the other hand May is wonderful and on a clear June night the sky doesn't get dark at all.

we'd highly likely end up travelling to London a lot which is not fun (I'm far more used to walking or driving a little bit to favourite places than hours of trains/tubes).

Families tend not to, they drive to other places round the edges of the Londond area.

I've lived in The Netherlands, Belgium and Germany in recent years, and can confirm [the bus service] is completely outdated and hopeless.

But the OP isn't going to the Netherlands, Belgium or Germany. She's going to Guildford. You think Guildford's bus service is better than Edinburgh's?

I was brought up in an outer London 'burb. I live in Edinburgh.

EvelynBeatrice · 10/12/2020 14:58

I think that your husband is getting a slightly unfair panning on here. We all want the best for our children. Wanting to give them the best chance of a top notch education doesn’t mean that you don’t also have other aspirations for their happiness and character etc. too. It’s sad actually. Poverty of ambition and chips on shoulders. Back in the day the vast majority of Scots really valued education and you still see that attitude in many of our immigrant groups from Eastern Europe and Asia for example which is so welcome. I think it’s pretty normal for people who benefited from a university education ( and the fun and freedom of that experience) and who make a good living in professional careers to want the same for their kids.

SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 14:57

@GreenlandTheMovie

And so many people are killed dicing with death, by cycling on shared narrow busy roads in Edinburgh. Chris Boardman's mother was one casualty.

I don’t where you’re getting your info from, but a lot of it is bollocks.

TikTokFinger · 10/12/2020 14:57

I’d choose London over Edinburgh. You could move to Cobham or Esther, not just Guildford. Or Winchester or Farnham. Even places like St Albans and Harpenden. And the weather is a lot better down South.
I’d probably live in a nice commuter town over Edinburgh but I actually like the rat race.

Wbeezer · 10/12/2020 14:57

@nibdedibble that's what I thought, good luck tunnelling through giant lumps of igneous rock and under huge numbers of listed buildings!

gongy · 10/12/2020 14:48

Some of my neighbours have just moved back to Edinburgh as now switched to remote working & they prefer it.

gongy · 10/12/2020 14:46

I'm in London but if it was a choice of outer suburbs or commuter towns I would much rather a smaller city eg Bristol, Edinburgh etc. I like having everything on my doorstep.

nibdedibble · 10/12/2020 14:45

Geology and plague history mean not a hope of an underground.

Bad luck on the buses. Now if you want to moan about the constant road digging, I’m sure we could agree. Also, Leith is north Smile

Wbeezer · 10/12/2020 14:40

Enough already with the parochial comments! Ambitious people leaving is just something that always happens when people live in a small country or rural region with access to a big city, its the same all over the world and it something unique to Scots.
Lots of people leave then come back (my siblings lived in London and New York and I lived in London in my twenties) because we do a considered cost benefit analysis of where to live not because we have failed or lack ambition.

GreenlandTheMovie · 10/12/2020 14:39

Its very difficult to go from one side of the city centre to the other by bus. It takes a long time and there aren't many. I still remember the time I got a bus from the West End to Leith - it took 1 hour. I missed my appointment.

I cycle in Edinburgh - nowhere is as good as Netherlands, Denmark etc but I don’t recognise the picture painted here. It’s fine, bit dicey at times, but fine.

Well, yes, its kind of like Lithuania or Estonia but worse in terms of infrastructure, so I suppose there is a vague European comparison.

An underground (apparently Edinburgh is "too small" although Newcastle is not) or an overground light railway (like a German S-Bahn) would be great. So would motorways between the cities . There is still only a dual carriageway between Perth and Aberdeen and Perth and Inverness. The infrastructure is dire and outdated and it is important. I'd rather jump on a regular train to London from Guildford than try to get a bus from Musselburgh or Portobello into Edinburgh City Centre.

LakieLady · 10/12/2020 14:38

I'd stay in Scotland.

I think there will have to be an Indyref2 after Brexit, given that being in the EU was such a big factor in people rejecting independence last time, and I think the nationalists will win it when it happens. And even if there isn't, the devolved powers may shield the Scots from some of the worst bits of Brexit fallout.

I'd rather be in an independent Scotland than a post-Brexit England and Wales, and I think the EU would allow Scotland to join.

I'd seriously consider moving to Scotland myself, tbh, if it meant I could be an EU citizen again.

nibdedibble · 10/12/2020 14:35

I cycle in Edinburgh - nowhere is as good as Netherlands, Denmark etc but I don’t recognise the picture painted here. It’s fine, bit dicey at times, but fine.

Buses are fine. What do you mean you can’t go east to west? What crap. 😂

Anyway the OP asked about none of that.

KatieGGGG · 10/12/2020 14:34

Sure thing. Have a lovely day @GreenlandTheMovie