Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think London commute towns are no better than Edinburgh for raising a family?

583 replies

JenXG · 10/12/2020 09:38

So basically DH and I are having a debate on whether to leave Edinburgh and move to a commute town outside London. (we have to stick with Edinburgh / London as working in financial sector but both of us would avoid London because of traffic/pollution/crowded streets).

The main reason for DH favouring those commute towns is that they seem to have loads of good schools for DS (4mo) to choose from compared to Edinburgh where there are only a few (or hardly any if his standard). He has high hope for DS. Also the A-level system is widely recognised across different countries (so potential for studying overseas) but the same cant be said for the Scotland system.

My worry is that we are giving up preferred lifestyle for a very small difference in schooling. I grew up in a big city and always need busy streets nearby. I understand some places such as Guildford will have its own town centre but there are still fewer things going on compared to Edinburgh. For example, there are a wide range of fine restuarants, several theatres & cinemas, pubs, etc in Edinburgh but living in Guildford we'd still have to go to London for a night out? I'd assume activities for young kids are more available in Edinburgh than in Guildford? E.g. Edinburgh has a zoo, lots of museums, and a coastline where you can do kayaking. Also Guildford is one of the busier towns as I understand. Some other commute towns are even quieter. So we'd highly likely end up travelling to London a lot which is not fun (I'm far more used to walking or driving a little bit to favourite places than hours of trains/tubes).

What do people think? I haven't been to many places in the southern area. Maybe I have misunderstood what life would be like there? Would you relocate if you were us?

OP posts:
GreenlandTheMovie · 10/12/2020 22:31

AlizarinRed Visit a non SNP area and find out what isn't great about Scotland

I don't dislike the whole of Scotland. I like the rural parts and the north. But the trouble is that its very hard to live there (and not that many people do) as there are so few jobs and the transport links aren't great. I also think Scottish rural people are great, but the fervent type of SNP support you come across in cities like Glasgow and Dundee I honestly find a bit stomach churning.

hulahooper2 · 10/12/2020 22:27

I don’t understand your issue with Scottish schools , pupils can and do study and work worldwide

HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 10/12/2020 22:26

You have a 4mth baby and you’ve discounted fettes as too low grade.haha
You are aware in the intervening 4.5 years your baby genius will just be a regular kid
Guildford and Home Counties are waaay more expensive than Edinburgh
Different countries different lifestyles and pressures

JohnnyDory · 10/12/2020 22:24

Guildford is... affluent and bland. I'd stay in Edinburgh if I were you. Londoner here.

AlizarinRed · 10/12/2020 22:24

Visit a non SNP area and find out what isn't great about Scotland GrinGrin

GreenlandTheMovie · 10/12/2020 22:23

Oh and really, saying Scots students aren't interested in Oxbridge is ridiculous. Students travel from all over the world to study at Oxford and Cambridge even though their own countries contain world renowned universities. If Scots students aren't willing to travel to another part of the UK, then perhaps we should be asking what is holding them back (compared to international students), not giving them a pat on the back and telling them they're wonderful for not going.

GreenlandTheMovie · 10/12/2020 22:20

Sabrina Oh, and I’m sceptical because this particular poster claims to live in the New Town on this thread, yet on a thread from a couple of days ago they live a mile from the nearest town

Well, if you'd stalked a little more in earnest, you'd have discovered that I'm a landlord (a recent one) and have lived in my flat in the New Town til recently.

So be sceptical indeed but don't unduly try to make a fool out of people because they aren't a fan of the SNP. Or is this what awaits Scotland?

I have no idea why I thought Chris Boardman's poor mother was killed by a driver in Edinburgh. For some reason I actually remember reading about it happening near Portobello, but having checked the awful tragedy did happen in North Wales. Why on earth I thought that I do not know and I hope her death isn't being used to start an internet farce. My point remains that Edinburgh isn't great for cycling in because the roads are narrow and busy, and the traffic is heavy.

But I really don't like Scotland that much and I hope to get another job and move away relatively soon. This sort of attitude (of pouring scorn on anyone who criticises it) is one of the reasons I don't like it. Also the attitude that everything here is perfect. It just reminds me a bit too much of the thinking behind the Soviet Union, where everyone had to pretend everything was wonderful when it wasn't. I haven't felt like this in other countries I've lived in and I do find it quite oppressive.

mawbroon · 10/12/2020 22:14

I'd being staying in Edinburgh and sending the DH to Guildford Grin

Possums4evr · 10/12/2020 21:48

Does Guildford have an Ikea?

tabulahrasa · 10/12/2020 21:29

@mellicauli

It's true Edinburgh is a world class city. But the sad fact is once you have a 4 month old you might as well be in Guildford for all the use you get of those world class facilities. I mean, where's the buggy ramp to those underground streets?
Pfft... you borrow a Scottish granny and she helps you bump up and down the stairs in the close...

Also, I feel like if we’re discounting things by buggy accessibility - Guildford loses it’s dry ski slope, surely?...

VerlynWebbe · 10/12/2020 21:28

New Town...1950s bungalow...hmmmmmm

SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 20:59

Oh, and I’m sceptical because this particular poster claims to live in the New Town on this thread, yet on a thread from a couple of days ago they live a mile from the nearest town 🤔

SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 20:49

You’d think that someone who owns a 1950s bungalow and lives in the New Town and has a lot to say about cycling in Edinburgh would at least know these things?

Janegrey333 · 10/12/2020 20:47

@MillieEpple

Guildford high street is a bit of a pain with a pram. Granite setts.
Oh no! Major problem!
To think London commute towns are no better than Edinburgh for raising a family?
Janegrey333 · 10/12/2020 20:45

@SabrinaThwaite
But Chris Hoy’s mum isn’t a cyclist, and Chris Boardman’s mum was killed in a different country.

Sloppy work, especially from a poster deriding others for not doing their research grin

Indeed. Chris Boardman’s mother was sadly killed in Wales. Very sloppy detective work, indeed. But hey, Scotland... Wales...same difference, I imagine.

SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 20:40

@Janegrey333

Re the Chris confusion. I reckon the Chris is Chris Hoy. He went to a private school - Watson’s I think. Go him!
But Chris Hoy’s mum isn’t a cyclist, and Chris Boardman’s mum was killed in a different country.

Sloppy work, especially from a poster deriding others for not doing their research Grin

MillieEpple · 10/12/2020 20:36

Guildford high street is a bit of a pain with a pram. Granite setts.

myla1 · 10/12/2020 20:35

Hi OP. Obviously, Scotland is highly likely to go independent in the near future (and who can blame them, frankly), so the key decision here surely, is what country do you want to live in? I wouldn’t be stressing to much about schools with a 4-month old. Confused

Having said this, I would move south like a shot - solely on the basis of warmer weather / more sunshine hours. That alone brings a different quality of life. Edinburgh is very austere, I find.

Guildford is Guildford. It’s a nice town yes, But quite a suburban feel. And, schools-wise (for a boy), you would be looking at the Royal Grammar which is fine but, I fear, not aspirational enough for your DH. Grin

If you really want to throw your hat into a tiger-parent-extraordinaire scenario, then please do join us here in SW London. But you will need to get him enrolled NOW into “the right” prep. Otherwise, how will he get into St Paul’s Shock He will be doomed!

I’m joking, it’s not really that bad (sometimes). But if you want access to the most selective independents, why are you thinking suburbia? Could I suggest Richmond, Barnes, Putney and thereabouts? Or Ealing, Parson’s Green, Fulham etc. Everything on your doorstep. Greenery and parks and the Thames is beautiful here. Some people move to Surrey and generally, they regret it or they just get too bored and come back. Both my neighbours did this and quite a few people I know actually.

Aspirational schools for the DH include - Kings Wimbledon, St Paul’s, Latymer Upper, Westminster, Hampton (super-selectives).

There are other schools which take the 98% that don’t get into the above. But do please bear in mind that even an “average” school will make somewhere like Fettes look like a holiday camp. Be prepared to bring your DS to an entrance exam and queue with 1,400 kids for 140 places in the school. Oh, and he will probably need to sit 5 separate 11 plus exams to get a place somewhere. And maybe sit 7+ or 8+ as well as 11plus.

Still keen.. ? Grin

No really - why Guildford particularly?

Janegrey333 · 10/12/2020 20:34

Re the Chris confusion. I reckon the Chris is Chris Hoy. He went to a private school - Watson’s I think. Go him!

Janegrey333 · 10/12/2020 20:31

@mellicauli

It's true Edinburgh is a world class city. But the sad fact is once you have a 4 month old you might as well be in Guildford for all the use you get of those world class facilities. I mean, where's the buggy ramp to those underground streets?
That is a good point, actually. Guildford is bound to have many super ramps. No contest. Forget the magnificent Castle, Holyrood Palace et al. What is the point of them when you need ramps?
SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 20:21

@AdelaideK

I'm strangely interested in the Chris Boardman comment Grin

He's from Merseyside and I think his mum was killed in Wales.

Anyway op stay in Edinburgh. It's a lovely city. You also may need to rein your DH a lot.

Funnily enough the poster that claimed that Edinburgh’s mean streets claimed Chris Boardman’s mum hasn’t actually backed that up with any, you know, facts.

Maybe their script mixed up Chris Boardman and Chris Hoy?

user1592512579 · 10/12/2020 20:11

I'd definitely stay where you are.

OoohTheStatsDontLie · 10/12/2020 20:02

I've lived in Scotland and England.

Costs of living are ridiculous around Guildford, literally some of the highest in the country, it's full of chain restaurants, and is full of rich people commuting to London. Some lovely little villages round about but b expensive. I think you would miss Edinburgh to be honest apart from it's a bit warmer...commuter towns to London are still mega busy, it's hard to feel like you're getting out to nature, as it's so populated, and yes you have to go a long way for a proper night out etc.

I'd say overall Edinburgh has an excellent standard of living compared to Guildford and similar, it's a nice sized city with access to amazing countryside.

I find it a bit odd that you're considering moving country as none of the schools in the whole of Edinburgh are good enough for your 4 month old child though!

mellicauli · 10/12/2020 19:57

It's true Edinburgh is a world class city. But the sad fact is once you have a 4 month old you might as well be in Guildford for all the use you get of those world class facilities. I mean, where's the buggy ramp to those underground streets?

tabulahrasa · 10/12/2020 19:53

Oh, oh, oh...

Underground streets!!!

Bet Guildford hasn’t got those...