Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think London commute towns are no better than Edinburgh for raising a family?

583 replies

JenXG · 10/12/2020 09:38

So basically DH and I are having a debate on whether to leave Edinburgh and move to a commute town outside London. (we have to stick with Edinburgh / London as working in financial sector but both of us would avoid London because of traffic/pollution/crowded streets).

The main reason for DH favouring those commute towns is that they seem to have loads of good schools for DS (4mo) to choose from compared to Edinburgh where there are only a few (or hardly any if his standard). He has high hope for DS. Also the A-level system is widely recognised across different countries (so potential for studying overseas) but the same cant be said for the Scotland system.

My worry is that we are giving up preferred lifestyle for a very small difference in schooling. I grew up in a big city and always need busy streets nearby. I understand some places such as Guildford will have its own town centre but there are still fewer things going on compared to Edinburgh. For example, there are a wide range of fine restuarants, several theatres & cinemas, pubs, etc in Edinburgh but living in Guildford we'd still have to go to London for a night out? I'd assume activities for young kids are more available in Edinburgh than in Guildford? E.g. Edinburgh has a zoo, lots of museums, and a coastline where you can do kayaking. Also Guildford is one of the busier towns as I understand. Some other commute towns are even quieter. So we'd highly likely end up travelling to London a lot which is not fun (I'm far more used to walking or driving a little bit to favourite places than hours of trains/tubes).

What do people think? I haven't been to many places in the southern area. Maybe I have misunderstood what life would be like there? Would you relocate if you were us?

OP posts:
HeelsHandbagPerfumeCoffee · 10/12/2020 23:44

Your husband is financially illiterate it seems,what provision are you both making for school fees?

tabulahrasa · 10/12/2020 23:43

@longcoffeebreak

Just how shit is the weather in Edinburgh? I currently live much further south in the Channel Islands and am considering a move.
Not that bad compared to further inland or further up.

Can be a bit windy and damp...which makes it cold. But I’m in West Lothian and work in Edinburgh, it doesn’t freeze the same as out here, and rarely gets deep snow, and I’m from up north on the west coast, it’s a lot drier in Edinburgh than it is there.

hopingforonlychild · 10/12/2020 23:40

@JenXG Its ok, he is not quite as bonkers as my DH who believes his unborn child must go to St Paul's or City of London school (but even he is ok with us moving to Edinburgh for now..he hasn't looked at the schools yet). My DH also thinks home ownership is stupid and financially illiterate and you should just rent a nice flat in Kensington (and invest your money into something sensible that generates passive income) until the house prices crash and you can buy that luxurious Central london pad. I arm wrestled him into buying our zone 3 london flat and he is still moaning about it a year on. Not because of the flat, he thinks the flat and location is great, but being a home owner in london at 29 is apparently a waste of money .

longcoffeebreak · 10/12/2020 23:38

Just how shit is the weather in Edinburgh? I currently live much further south in the Channel Islands and am considering a move.

Skysblue · 10/12/2020 23:27

I’m in a nice commuter village and I’ve lived in Guildford and it was ok but no culture to speak of, mostly bankers wives doing yoga and law students getting drunk. Edinburgh would be way more fun for a teenager.

Also what about university isn’t it still free in Scotland? That would make me stay!

In general Edinburgh is better except for weather / access to mainland Europe. But - don’t you have family and friends? Aging parents maybe? Faily and friends would be the biggest deciding factor for me with such a big move.

LonnyVonnyWilsonFrickett · 10/12/2020 23:25

This thread is almost as bonkers as the OP's husband - I mean, it really has everything from red pandas to magical mystery bus tours to fucking batshit craziness!

OP, your husband is not particularly well-informed about Scottish education, that's OK - that's why 25% of Edinburgh's children are in private schools, their dads are all afraid they'll catch stupid and common too. Alternatively, give your husband's head a wobble before he sets your baby up for a lifetime of not being quite good enough for daddy's standards.

SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 23:24

Don’t big yourself up @GreenlandTheMovie, you have an obvious agenda fuelled by bollocks and misinformation, so why shouldn’t people be curious?

I really don’t care who you are, nor (on the basis of your posts) are you anyone I’d want me or any of my family to have anything to do with, so I think you’re quite safe on that front.

Some of your comments on this thread were pertinent, many weren’t and some were just plain old crapola. The best bit was you berating other posters about their research skills. Smile

MaryLennoxsScowl · 10/12/2020 23:21

From some of the comments here, students in Scotland are parochial because they are more likely to go to a Scottish university. So a kid from the Northern Highlands who went 5 hours south to Edinburgh (and was undoubtedly shy and quiet when they got there) is parochial, but a Londoner who went to Edinburgh (5 hours north) is adventurous? Why? Because they’re louder? Bearing in mind too the huge expense of getting home on public transport to a part of the country not well served by said transport (you’d probably need to get buses rather than trains) and therefore with no discounted tickets, and the likely lower incomes of the family, and you’ve written them off. I had a vivid memory of a lecturer moaning about how some students didn’t get university and just turned up to classes and never spoke - of course we didn’t. We had never been anywhere like it. We didn’t have regular visits or find it was just like being at home, or come from an environment in which you spoke up at school at all - at my school anyone talking to a teacher outside of classes was doing so because they had problems either academically or personally. And who do you think should have helped us fit in and learn the ropes, and who didn’t bother?

1000umbrellas · 10/12/2020 23:10

OK the chat has moved waaaay on from the OP but

Also the A-level system is widely recognised across different countries (so potential for studying overseas) but the same cant be said for the Scotland system. Some, if not most of Edinburgh's private schools offer GCSEs and A-levels

GreenlandTheMovie · 10/12/2020 23:07

Sabrina I think the stalking comment was to me - since this poster has cropped up on other threads in the last few days with contradictory statements.

Actually, you are creeping me out. You are really trying to work out how to identify me in real life, aren't you? You do realise this is the internet, and there are all sorts of weirdos out there that a person might want to avoid "meeting"? Do you have any idea how creepy and sinister you are sounding?

Don't you have anything better to do with your time? You have completely derailed this this thread. At least my comments were about the actual thread topic.

Teenagetrials · 10/12/2020 23:04

We moved from Edinburgh to Surrey - came to Surrey for two years and that was 18 years ago. One over-riding reason we would never go back - the weather!!!! It allows for a completely different, outdoorsy lifestyle in the south

SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 23:02

I think the stalking comment was to me - since this poster has cropped up on other threads in the last few days with contradictory statements.

Always happy to oblige Smile

ImNotMeImSomeoneElse · 10/12/2020 22:59

That's funny. You come here and complain about everything Scotland other than rural and North, and then accuse me off being intolerant?

I've not made any personal attacks, or stalked or ridiculed anyone.

Where have I told people what to think? The only thing I said about 'we' is that we know Scotland isn't perfect! How on earth are you finding that in any way controversial when you have spend the evening saying exactly that!

SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 22:56

So be sceptical indeed but don't unduly try to make a fool out of people because they aren't a fan of the SNP. Or is this what awaits Scotland?

I am pretty ambivalent about the SNP, so I don’t much care what you think of them either.

If you think you’re being made to look a fool, then you might want to consider (and own) your comments.

Frestba · 10/12/2020 22:55

If you can find work, a home and a reasonable school, stay in Edinburgh. It's not easier living in the S E.

Wbeezer · 10/12/2020 22:55

Lots of reasons Greenland, some probably worth challenging others perfectly valid. I don't exactly think its a bad thing for a country to keep bright students to educate at home, lots of positives to that.

MissMarks · 10/12/2020 22:55

Haven’t read all the posts, but if your husband is concerned about schools- Northern Ireland gets the best academic results consistently in the UK. Minimal private schools but fantastic grammars.
My children were at a private Edinburgh school deemed one of the best- but it is no where near at the level of the school they moved to here.

GreenlandTheMovie · 10/12/2020 22:53

Well then ImnotMelmSomeoneElse that sounds lovely. I'd rather be somewhere a bit more tolerant where there isn't this sinister "we" about who police people's opinions and crack down on them for not towing the party line.

'we' are people in Scotland. We know about homelessness and drug abuse and religious divide and crime etc etc etc.

You enjoy your Friday night. I'm not going to spend it making personal attacks on posters and stalking them to try and ridicule them.

I hope OP finds a decision to suit.

ImNotMeImSomeoneElse · 10/12/2020 22:50

You really think there is something wrong with people holding viewpoints? Only state-sanctioned viewpoints should be allowed?

Where did I say that?

ImNotMeImSomeoneElse · 10/12/2020 22:49

Who is "we" and is it a special club people with the "right" views have to be invited to, or does it extend to the whole of society?

'we' are people in Scotland. We know about homelessness and drug abuse and religious divide and crime etc etc etc.

Basically 'we' are the people that you are accusing if having the attitude that everything is perfect.

2020inhouse · 10/12/2020 22:47

OP I’m sure you already know this but post Brexit your 4.5month old will be classified as an overseas student if studying abroad, so fees will be eye watering. But hey, sovereignty.

GreenlandTheMovie · 10/12/2020 22:45

"we"? ImNotMelmSomeoneElse

Who is "we" and is it a special club people with the "right" views have to be invited to, or does it extend to the whole of society?

You really think there is something wrong with people holding viewpoints? Only state-sanctioned viewpoints should be allowed?

Its just becoming too controlled a country for my liking.

SabrinaThwaite · 10/12/2020 22:44

But I really don't like Scotland that much and I hope to get another job and move away relatively soon. This sort of attitude (of pouring scorn on anyone who criticises it) is one of the reasons I don't like it.

Good. Don’t let the door smack you on your arse as you go.

Your comments about Scottish students being parochial and not wanting to leave home to attend university and not speaking up in classes tells me a lot more about you than about them. If your attitude in tutorials is the same as the way you write about Scotland / your students / your family, then there’s no way I’d be opening my mouth in your classes either.

BTW, my DC’s (very state) academy sent kids to LSE, Imperial, Oxford, Queen’s, Trinity, UCL and US universities amongst many others. The ones that stayed at home were because they couldn’t afford to stay away (because loans and bursaries don’t cover costs, and yes that is a consideration if your income is fuck all) or because the specific course they wanted to do was available at the ancient university on their doorstep.

HTH

ImNotMeImSomeoneElse · 10/12/2020 22:42

Also the attitude that everything here is perfect

Oh we are very aware everything isn't perfect. But we are working on it 😁

But there's no way I would live somewhere that I could see no positives in. I feel that if someone can't see anything positive in an amazing city like Edinburgh, that's entirely a reflection on them rather than on the city itself. If all someone can talk about is what isn't perfect, then that's all they are looking for. And I, and most people on this thread to be fair, choose to see the good. I find it makes for a more enjoyable life, personally.

Oh and really, saying Scots students aren't interested in Oxbridge is ridiculous

Interesting. Weren't you saying the exact opposite, a few pages back?

mangoandraspberries · 10/12/2020 22:33

Currently live in London and have visited Edinburgh often (family there). Have also been to some of the commuter towns every now and then. Also work in financial services (banking).

Very different lifestyles imo. I wouldn’t move just for the schools - yes, they are very good, but I find it hard to believe there aren’t also v good ones in Edinburgh, esp if you can pay?

The only reason I would move (and what keeps me where I am), is if you or your DH could get a decent pay rise and/or much greater career potential by being within commuting distance to London AND you felt that would allow you to pay for better schooling or otherwise advantage your kids. We have looked at moving elsewhere in the UK and it’s always the pay cut we’d have to take and the more limited career options that stop us.

But also remember London life is more expensive, so the pay difference needs to be significant.