Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be annoyed at McCains advert

216 replies

Shouldputcheeseonit · 10/11/2020 22:06

Not just McCains doing it but theirs is particularly annoying. Companies now are really going for the adverts with mixed race families, L and G families (have any tried BT or Q?), and families with someone with a disability. I am an outspoken ambassador for inclusion and equality (and proud to say my family contains some of these elements) but I feel annoyed at how these companies are using this to advertise and make money. Car adverts, supermarkets, all sorts. It’s only this year they’ve started, it’s like they are using BLM and other areas of heightened awareness for their own gains, and it bothers me.
Rant over. Anyone else noticed?

OP posts:
Flaxmeadow · 11/11/2020 20:04

Are they? Are you sure?
And if so, why is that a problem?

Because, as I said, it does not represent the demographic of the whole country. Thats the problem.

These adds are dreamed up in London or a large city like Birmingham, that's OK and the ads are probably representative for a few UK city's, but it excludes most of the rest of the population of the UK. It isn't inclusive. Its the opposite of inclusive when it only portrays a London ethnic demographic

As I said earlier in reply to a pp who mentioned a minority ethnic child watching TV

"Away from the trendy multi ethnic buzz of the London metro bubble and from its advertising office blocks...maybe there's some white working class kid in a former mining or steel town like Rotherham, who sits gazing at the TV thinking "this says nothing to me about my life"

SinkGirl · 11/11/2020 19:13

@Leflic

It’s tokenism when every minority group is pointedly portrayed in a single advert - thereby setting them out as “ different”. Nothing wrong with a black family with or without a differently abled person . A gay couple ( why are they always female). But a whole advert flashing between every minority group is utterly twatish.
I’ve just watched it, the majority of people in it are white, straight and able bodied. It shows a range of families, who on earth could be offended by this honestly? It’s so depressing to see these reactions.
SkedaddIe · 11/11/2020 19:10

btw @Shouldputcheeseonit the McCain inclusion advert has been a running theme for a few years now so it's definitely not a 2020 bandwagon thing.

This ad is from 2017

And @SimonJT after a long hard day McCains sweet potato fries are a 20minute lifesaver. Trust me! Chuck some basa fillets under the grill or in the pan to seal the deal.

Leflic · 11/11/2020 18:33

It’s tokenism when every minority group is pointedly portrayed in a single advert - thereby setting them out as “ different”.
Nothing wrong with a black family with or without a differently abled person . A gay couple ( why are they always female). But a whole advert flashing between every minority group is utterly twatish.

PawsAndPhytoncides · 11/11/2020 18:24

Conversely, I'm very very suspicious of anti BLM and anti 'virtue signalling' because I feel it comes from a closeted bigoted place.

Yup, agree with this.

SimonJT · 11/11/2020 17:41

We’re having chips tonight, not crappy McCain ones of course.

viques · 11/11/2020 16:10

@ineedsun

As someone else has said, I really like the fact that different types of families are shown. Normalising single parents, step families, foster families, adoption is all good in my mind. Seeing families who represent ours is lovely and I imagine that anyone seeing people who represent them are also pleased about this.

(Every time I see the bit on avengers endgame with all the female characters I start crying - kids and husband think I'm mad but I try to explain to them that as a nearly 50 year old woman, all we've really seen on TV is women being rescued and to see them being strong and together is really powerful. They don't get it)

I agree , however I would also like it if sometimes they showed happy contented single person households, with or without cats or cute dogs. Any time they do show a single person house hold they are sad , lonely people staring out at life passing them by who need a happy “proper” family coming into their lives , offering lunch, a gift wrapped box, chocolate or advice about funerals to make them smile again.

Advertisers, that ain’t necessarily so.

33goingon64 · 11/11/2020 15:55

Representation matters.

dottiedodah · 11/11/2020 15:30

Shouldputcheeseonit I see where you are coming from .However if we stick to nice white MC families ,nothing will ever change ! Sadly most advertising consists of certain demographics ,and using white MC families the idea is that these people will have more money to spare in order to buy their products .By opening up to mixed race families ,disabled and LGBT they are wanting to fleece them ! So good that other families are getting a piece of the action,(even though they are being expected to part with their hard earned too! Also worth remembering that not all BAME families are poorer ,some are well off ! (And rightly so)

SkedaddIe · 11/11/2020 15:25

@flirtygirl

Many people on this thread not getting the point that diversity and jnclusivity is good but being used as a token is not good. Talk about missing the point.
We get your point... but I don't think you feel ours.

We have literally been across the Sahara desert and I don't care if the person offering water and shelter is doing for a photo op because it is something we need and it is welcome.

Like I said before I'm not naive, most black people can't afford to be. The real challenge will come when BLM and the other movements go out of fashion.

SinkGirl · 11/11/2020 15:22

How would supermarkets and shops and other business increase the diversity of their advertising without being accused of tokenism?

SillyCow6 · 11/11/2020 15:17

If it is a step towards true equality, then ultimately it's a good thing

SVRT19674 · 11/11/2020 15:15

They can´t win, poor guys. All adverts and films are too whitewashed, some take heed, and are labelled bastards because they are making changes...so it must be for money...bastards

SinkGirl · 11/11/2020 15:12

God the voting is depressing. Representation matters.

Doesn’t matter to you because most people on TV look like you. So many deny that representation matters until they suddenly don’t feel represented any more. Funny that. And it’s still a tiny minority of people on TV who are not white, straight and not disabled.

For most of my life, you haven’t seen non-white, non-straight or disabled people on TV unless there’s a reason in the plot. Thank goodness we are moving away from that. Some people won’t like it of course. I couldn’t give less of a crap.

GoJoe2020 · 11/11/2020 15:09

Getting the point, thanks. Disagreeing with the point Hmm

flirtygirl · 11/11/2020 15:07

Many people on this thread not getting the point that diversity and jnclusivity is good but being used as a token is not good. Talk about missing the point.

flirtygirl · 11/11/2020 15:04

These companies are just jumping on the bandwagon. It pure tokenism and its sickening for bame when they are just seen as a token, a trend, a moment.

Yes of course diversity is good but not when it's used in a token nature.

switswooo · 11/11/2020 14:54

Conversely, I'm very very suspicious of anti BLM and anti 'virtue signalling' because I feel it comes from a closeted bigoted place.

💯 we all see through it!

SkedaddIe · 11/11/2020 14:50

Personally I'm not against tokenism and I'm not against virtue signalling either. There's been a lot of real progress this year because racism and bigotry has been spotlighted and I'm not so naive that i don't see that it also lines up with commercial interests.

But what is wrong with that?

Conversely, I'm very very suspicious of anti BLM and anti 'virtue signalling' because I feel it comes from a closeted bigoted place.

Nicknamegoeshere · 11/11/2020 14:44

I'm loving the fact that there is more inclusivity on on televisions. I had my middle son ten years ago and have just had a baby daughter. CBeebies, for example, is definitely more inclusive than it used to be, even a decade ago.
There was a brilliant episode of Waffle The Wonder Dog recently. A blended family is featured. Woman and man both white and there are two kids from previous relationships. The lad is mixed race, the girl is white. The episode shows nan and Grandad visiting. They are both black and the little girl asks "Are you my real grandparents?" They explain who the lad's bio parents are and who the girl's bio parents are. But that they all family and nothing changes that.
Further on the little girl then asks mum about her "real" dad and mum talks very openly with her about getting in touch with him.
I thought it was awesome.

Shouldputcheeseonit · 11/11/2020 14:14

Thanks MNHQ, and everyone who has commented. It is really interesting to hear opinions.

If it helps to explicitly state - I am not white or straight myself, and there is disability within my family. I didn’t express myself very well initially and apologise for that, but I never intended my point to read that I don’t want to see diversity.

Anyway I’ll be quiet now. But I really like hearing everyone’s views on the subject, thanks to all that took the time.

OP posts:
D4rwin · 11/11/2020 14:10

"Some of these elements" jog the fuck on.

switswooo · 11/11/2020 13:58

As ever, we would suggest giving the thread a read before responding.

Is AEWWSGTTARBR the new RTFT? Grin

GoJoe2020 · 11/11/2020 13:54

But the adverts are not representative. They are overly representative for the demographic of this country

Are they? Are you sure?
And if so, why is that a problem?

slipperywhensparticus · 11/11/2020 13:49

Yes I've noticed im watching carefully to see how long it lasts