Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is DH being unreasonable regarding career change

232 replies

Logiclady94 · 08/11/2020 09:28

Hi, I’m prepared to be told I am being unreasonable but I was only making a suggestion. DH and I had a massive argument this morning with regards to me suggesting a career change for him. He is a web developer/designer and has been doing it since we got together 4 years ago, when we met he’d lost his job and it took him about 6 months to get another.. he had enough savings to live on during that time. He had been in that job since 2017 until he got let go in June 2020 because his performance had dropped and he hadn’t progressed at all.

He has since got a new job but because he his progression hadn’t moved at his old job he got a new job at the same level he was on but for less money (£4000 less) he was told he would get a pay review in January 2021 when his probationary ended and if he met it he would potentially get the original job adverts salary (more than his last job)

So long story short I said to him this morning why didn’t he train to become a railway signaller like my dad? He could train as he has more qualifications than I do and he could freelance in his spare time if he still loved the web developer role and he blew up at all.

Saying that the only way I’d be happy is if we had more money.. it’s always about the more money. He told me I don’t respect him and that if I liked the money so much why I don’t study to become one like my dad. I told him I’m not smart enough, I don’t have any qualifications.. I earn more than him right now as I work in a good industry.

I only suggested it because my dads hours would work really nicely for the lifestyle he wants, he wants to do his hobby in his spare time (painting figures and playing war games) he also wants to do podcasts, paint other people’s figure for commission work, freelance web design and get married, move to a nicer area and so on and so on... it is a long extensive list which he would have more time to do all that as the job is 3 days on 4 days or 4 days on and 3 days off (I can’t remember what my dad said, he likes to work himself to death so he does a hell of a lot of overtime)

I feel awful for suggesting it now as I was just trying to be helpful as I don’t think the web developer role is working out for him. He has two lost two jobs and he hasn’t gained any progression in nearly 6 years. I feel like I lost a bit of respect for him when he lost that job because he didn’t even tell me he had been put on a warning or anything. He had been supporting me through two terrible pregnancies and one illness that required surgery. He told me his work understood and then during lockdown he had a meeting about it then when I asked him what was going on, he told me everything. He then got a call that afternoon to say he’d been let go. I didn’t know any of this and it made me have to return from maternity early which was stressful because with covid we didn’t have the childcare set up.

Was IBU to suggest it? And was DH being unreasonable for blowing up at me?

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 08/11/2020 10:20

And to Add, he’s consistently out earned the op for all their time together, and for a three month period, whilst on probation she will earn a couple of grand more than him, them he will go back to out earning her.

She’s lost respect for him because he’s lost two jobs in six years and hasn’t progressed to her liking. Even though she consistently earns less than him and isn’t progressing either.

Nice stuff.

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/11/2020 10:20

@sst1234
OP, concentrating on family too much is not a reason for being let go.

It can be. Happened to my uncle (see prior post of mine). It’s just a variation on the number of women let go because they’re pregnant or on maternity leave. It’s legally protected for women, but still happens a lot. With men, there is no legal protection and guess what? It happens a lot.

Bluntness100 · 08/11/2020 10:17

Some of these comments, 😂

The guy lost his job four years ago, got a other one, and he’s lost his job again, walked straight into another one and will likely be earning more in it. It’s hardly looser territory. Acting like he’s some kinda kid and he’s too flakey to be freelance is just so controlling.

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/11/2020 10:17

One of the reasons he got let go from the last role was that he was concentrating on family too much.

This can happen especially to men. When my aunt was in hospital with heart failure and having heart surgery. My uncle was by her bedside in hospital with a laptop trying to keep up with work. My aunt was in hospital for two months she came very close to dying. One month in, my uncle was called into the office and double demoted for taking too much family time. A month later, when my aunt was released home but needed another month of caring my uncle asked for flexible working hours and to be able to work from home some of the time. He was let go on the spot.

OPs DH was let go when she was in an out of hospital with pregnancy related illness. So I can see a similar pattern here. Employers are much more accepting of females doing caring and needing flexible work than they are of males.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 08/11/2020 10:15

I think I remember your last thread, wasn't he let go because he was missing so much work for childcare and appointments because of a risky pregnancy? And he didn't tell you because you didn't need the stress?

HoppingPavlova · 08/11/2020 10:15

No, he’s not being unreasonable. You are being odd.

He’s obviously not that into his job as it is, so rather than try and force your fathers career into him (Confused) , which is something completely random and different to what he does, his background and quals and likely something that holds absolutely no interest for him - maybe your ‘support’ would be better placed trying to get him to work out what he really would be enthused in that would also provide the financial support required.

What you have done is like going up to a nurse and suggesting they become a buyer for a hardware chain instead - just really odd.

wellthatsunusual · 08/11/2020 10:15

I think you sound like you have had an awful lot of upheaval if you have only been together for four years. Getting to know each other, wo children and an illness inside 4 years is an awful lot. I think your suggestion maybe sounded a bit patronising, but that's not to say that the idea of both of you having a talk about where you would like to go career wise would be a bad idea. My husband has a job he loves and gets paid reasonably well for but he has been in it for 17 years and whilst his earnings have obviously increased over time, he hasn't become more senior or anything and whilst I find it frustrating, because I am much more ambitious, it's not my place to demand that he apply for new jobs any more than it is up to him to ask me to change jobs.

IndecentFeminist · 08/11/2020 10:15

You're angry he didn't tell you he was having issues at work, when you were having real struggles at home? Issues he was having at work because he was being there for you at home? Curious. 😕

Why don't you focus on quals and your career? If he is happy and secure doing what he does and you're coping financially at the moment?

ShandlersWig · 08/11/2020 10:14

I get it OP.

I think referencing your dad's job was with the best intentions but wouldn't have gone down well.

I can understand your concerns that your husband may have picked a career that he's not very good at, which will limit his earning potential. I think the time for the carear change ( of his choosing) would be if he fails to get the pay increase.

It does seem he likes to focus on hobbies and children which is great, but not if by doing so he looses or underperforms at work. There's loads of people who'd like to not work and chase their hobbies but if that was my DH I'd insist he continued to work as you won't earn enough for the luxury of a SAHD.

Can he continue to work in the job, but do the figure painting in spare time and set up a small business? At least he then gets to chase a dream and you never know, there might be a small demand. It could build up to something or not.

sst1234 · 08/11/2020 10:14

This freelance nonsense sounds a bad idea to be honest. The guy seems too flaky. OP’s comment about him being let because he likes spending too much time with the family days a lot. That says he doesn’t put enough effort into his work, he goes freelance and he’ll be doing even less work.

MummaGiles · 08/11/2020 10:14

Maybe he didn’t tell you about his job because you were, according to your OP, going through a horrible pregnancy.

Maybe he didn’t appreciate you suggesting he be more like your Dad?

Maybe you have a skewed idea of how well that job pays if your dad was constantly doing all the overtime he could get?

EveryDayIsADuvetDay · 08/11/2020 10:13

have to return from maternity early which was stressful because with covid we didn’t have the childcare set up.

You had to return from maternity leave early because your husband had lost his job? Why couldn't non working husband do the childcare? (while thinking all the while about how much he doesn't want to be a signal engineer)

Daydreamsinglorioustechnicolor · 08/11/2020 10:10

He could freelance but I worry if he gave up a set job and income than he would start being distracted by his hobby and by being around the kids sad*

So his plan for achieving work life balance is to be freelance, but you think he would not earn enough to achieve your other aims of nicer house etc. Have you tried to discuss this with him? What does he say?

Neitherupnordown · 08/11/2020 10:10

I don't think what he is suggesting is that crazy to be honest, freelancing in his friend can lucrative, and also flexible hours wise. Most will just require the work to be completed by X date with no real mandate on exactly what times you work, or some require people to work later to tie in with different time zones, he would need a clear plan though and to have boundaries so he isn't just doing his hobby or stuff with the children and he also falls behind on that work. It can take some confidence to secure work as well, he could maybe go with an agency but not if his performance isn't great. Are your children in childcare?

2pinkginsplease · 08/11/2020 10:10

His job, his decisions regarding his job. As long as he is working is the important thing.

My dhs job is a bit dead end with no progression but he loves it and gets every weekend at home, that’s his choice same as my job is my choice.

Gooseybby · 08/11/2020 10:08

He's probably still feeling shitty about the ignominious way he lost his job, and i know from experience how grating it is to constantly get silly off the cuff job suggestions from people who are only trying to help but simply dont know the whole story, havent thought it through and wont have to live with the consequences! Instead of saying 'why dont you X?' try 'what would you like to do?' maybe.

Bluntness100 · 08/11/2020 10:08

Just because your salary is more than his at the moment doesn't mean he needs to change

It’s less than four grand more, they are basically earning the same 😂

frewer · 08/11/2020 10:08

I'm another one who burst out laughing reading the op.

If this isn't a reverse, then you are a bit quirky OP, from web designer to railway signaller is quite a shift.

sst1234 · 08/11/2020 10:08

@Logiclady94

One of the reasons he got let go from the last role was that he was concentrating on family too much. He loves being around the children. He has even said a couple of times that if this job doesn’t work out he will give up web work and stay at home with the kids...

That is another reason I suggested it (not because my dad does it at all) he sounds and acts exactly like my dad when I was younger. He wants to be there for the little things with our two children and my dad was always around for the school run etc so I thought it might be exactly the right kind of home and work life balance he is looking for.

He could freelance but I worry if he gave up a set job and income than he would start being distracted by his hobby and by being around the kids Sad

OP, concentrating on family too much is not a reason for being let go. The problem is he wasn’t on concentrating on his job enough. Changing jobs won’t fix this, even if the work is less involved than web design, because it sounds like he has poor absence at work too. I think pushing him into different work is a sticking plaster, especially when his current work is so much in demand. Web design is a lucrative career, but if he isn’t committed, no job will ever be well paid enough. At best he is not career, at worst he has a poor work ethic. Could you maybe agree between yourselves for you to take steps to accelerate your career while he takes on the role of homemaking with some part time web design or other employment.
Bluntness100 · 08/11/2020 10:07

Me too, @Bluntness100. I'm still laughing now

I know, right..? 😂

Itsorange · 08/11/2020 10:07

I think you are being unreasonable, yes. Are you sure he was let go for the reason he gave and not 'because of Covid' like has happened to so many? Though it would be odd to make that up. Unless he's suffering from low self esteem (I wonder why 🤔).

You should not have suggested he do what your Dad does, no matter how good the salary or hours. You basically said to him 'You are not as good a father, husband or man as my Dad', no wonder he's furious!

You do sound money focused, and disappointed in him. If that is even partially true, or you feel you need more, then why don't you do something to earn more? Just because your salary is more than his at the moment doesn't mean he needs to change. If you're capable of getting a better paying job than him with very little in the way of qualifications, then maybe you should be the one to reach for more.

Some people aren't as bothered about high earnings, and provided they can support themselves or contribute to supporting their family that is fine if they're happy.

My H has never been career driven, but I am (less so now with kids, but I'm where I want to be). I earn the most by far, but he does his bit. He wasn't one to push himself but when a close family member died years ago he re-evaluated his life and went back to college to get some qualifications, then used those to get jobs that led on to better jobs. The only thing I have ever 'pushed' him to do was to apply for a team leader role when it came up, as he was more than capable, but would not have thought he would get. And of course he got it.

That's how you should act as a partner. Be supportive and encouraging, don't be negative, put down his choices and compare him to your Dad! It sounds like he lacks in self belief but at least he is working, and he got another job this year when so many are newly unemployed. He can and will do well if he puts his mind to it, and even if he's content as he is, so be it.

HollowTalk · 08/11/2020 10:06

Having a party is not the same as getting married again. And if you have a renewal of vows everyone will think one of you has had an affair.

Thesheerrelief · 08/11/2020 10:06

I think there are underlying issues that you both need to discuss but suggesting he changes career direction completely to do your Dad's job is ridiculous. I can see how that annoyed him

Bluntness100 · 08/11/2020 10:06

If his pay rise will only be four grand I think you’re nit picking to say you earn more than him then him you, it’s marginal and you’re both on about the same amount

Look it’s ok to idolise your father, but suggesting your husband is like him ans should be more like him is really a bit creepy.

He’s shown no desire to be a railway signal man, or I’m guessing aspire to be your father, I think you need to apologise to him.

HollowTalk · 08/11/2020 10:05

@Bluntness100

So long story short I said to him this morning why didn’t he train to become a railway signaller like my dad

I’m sorry but that made me laugh out loud. I can see why he wasn’t delighted

Did he ask dor your suggestion on a career change for him? Or has he ever suggested he wishes to emulate your father?

Me too, @Bluntness100. I'm still laughing now. My daughter's in a dither about careers right now and plan to suggest it to her when I see her - can't wait to see her reaction.