Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ivf. Doctor seemed overly negative.

209 replies

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 09:18

So husband and I have had 3 failed ivf cycles in the last 2 years. I am 41 and husband has had a vasectomy (previously married). Given the time constraints we decided that a testes biopsy was the best route to go instead of a vasectomy reversal which may not be successful and then still need to do a sperm extraction via biopsy at a later stage.

My last cycle failed completely whereas before I have had two early miscarriages. Without going into all the medical jargon I retrieved a fair amount of eggs for my age, they were reasonable quality, the embryos were not A grade but also not the worst. Everything seemed pretty average.

My appt with doc yesterday was terrible. I went in feeling so full of hope that we would be able to do another egg retrieval, ICSI and transfer before Christmas. But the doctor was so negative. He didn’t have anything hopeful to say. Basically I’m old my eggs have aged. My husbands sperm is less than great because it’s been extracted via biopsy and a vasectomy after 10 years rescues the quality. Our embryos are poor. The chances of genetic abnormalities are high. Our track record of 3 failed cycles leaves such a small percentage of success in the future. It’s costly.

We told him that money was not an issue (that sounds pretentious but we have enough to do another few cycles)

I’m just so disappointed in his atttitude. It’s like he doesn’t want me to do another cycle. I thought this whole process was about hope and that these doctors would be able to try and try. 3 cycles seems very little compared to what I’ve read and I’m surely not the only 41 year old who is seeking fertility help when there are 41 year olds falling pregnant naturally?

I don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
Brioelephant · 06/11/2020 09:55

So sorry you've had negative news. I think the doctor is giving you the hard facts so you can be realistic about your choices.

Would you consider getting your eggs frozen so using donor sperm in the future may be an option? Having friends who've done the years and years of IVF they all wish that they'd done this. Also everyone I know who has used donor egg/ egg/ embryo have no regrets at all.

Couchbettato · 06/11/2020 09:54

I'm very sorry, that's obviously not the nicest thing to hear, but ethically I think they have to manage your expectations, for your sake and the sake of the embryos.

If one did take, it would mean the chances of having a life with abnormalities or disabilities which could be painful to live with, and may mean a life of caring for you.

If it didn't take then you would be absolutely heartbroken after being filled with hope. You might even have misplaced anger and grief.

ClementineWoolysocks · 06/11/2020 09:53

I'm sorry you didn't hear what you were hoping for, however, wouldn't you rather a medical professional was honest with you rather than filling your head with unicorns and rainbows?

MrsSpringfield · 06/11/2020 09:53

"Our embryos are poor. The chances of genetic abnormalities are high. Our track record of 3 failed cycles"

It doesn't sound like there is anything much to be positive about. This is risky and a lot of strain to be putting yourselves under.

ChocoholicMama · 06/11/2020 09:52

@mikkyr

It’s crazy. For anybody who has been through ivf will know that hope is what gets you through this. I just always thought your doctor would be the one providing it through confidence. Possibly even give us some good news stories. But honestly I feel like he was trying to tell me not to do it anymore. Surely there are these women that do 10 cycles? Do they do it on their own will in the face of adversity from the very person you are hoping is going to make it happen for you? I’m devastated.
Sorry, OP, hope is important, but the docs have to be realistic. With your age, known issues, and three failed ivfs, your chances are very slim for a successful round and it would be unethical of them to boost your hope with the rare success stories in your circumstances. They need to make sure if you decide to go forward with more rounds, you're doing so fully informed that your chances are low. I'm sorry, it's such a hard thing to digest. For the few stories you see online of successful ivfs after 3+ failed ones, you're not seeing the many who weren't successful. Most of those who are eventually successful will likely be younger, which inherently gives a better chance (sorry, I'm just being honest, but I know that's hard to hear). It's not giving you a fair representation of your chances. Again, that's not to say you shouldn't try again, but I would recommend deciding on a final point where you can draw a line under IVF if any further cycles aren't successful. Flowers
Haenow · 06/11/2020 09:50

I’m so sorry. Flowers I think he was being objective and realistic, trying to manage your expectations. It’s going to be different for you because of the huge emotions. Gentle unMN hugs.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 06/11/2020 09:49

They were so optimistic in the beginning.

IVF is one of those things where you gain information from each cycle. In some cases everything looks hopeful, but then every part of the process fails to have a great outcome, and the odds change greatly.

My main concern with private IVF is that it is a license to print money by carrying out expensive and invasive treatment with a very low chance of success. In many cases honesty would be better, if hard to hear.

Having said that, medical opinions differ. If you feel that he was unduly negative or was casually brushing you off without really focusing on the options available, you might get a second opinion.

dontdisturbmenow · 06/11/2020 09:47

They are optimistic or pessimistic based on facts. First time, your statistic were probably good. Sadly, it didn't result in the expected good outcome and that means that the chances of it is much lower thus time taking into consideration these facts and adding the 2 years which can make a huge difference.

I had a scan at 39 that showed my ovaries to still have a decent amount of eggs. Blood tests confirmed this and reasonable quality. Yet I started the perimenopause only 3 years later.

Saying all that, my friend was told she was in the peri stage yet got pregnant and had a healthy child at 43, so again, statistics are one thing, miracles an another.

CrotchetyQuaver · 06/11/2020 09:44

I fear he was giving you the brutal honest truth that in his opinion, he doesn't believe there's much chance of there being a successful outcome (a healthy baby born more or less at term) for you both Thanks

helloxhristmas · 06/11/2020 09:44

Unfortunately your doctor is being realistic.

Circusoflove · 06/11/2020 09:41

If you look up the stats for people of your age they’re really poor. Then you have the sperm issue putting the odds even less in your favour. Your doctor is being realistic. I’ve been there too and it’s hard to accept.

hibbledibble · 06/11/2020 09:41

Unfortunately, objectively, the chance if success is low for you, unless you use donated eggs. The doctor is just trying to manage your expectations.

olympicsrock · 06/11/2020 09:40

I think he was just being realistic. Sorry that it was bad news

ChocoholicMama · 06/11/2020 09:38

So sorry, OP, but I do think the doc is just trying to be realistic rather than provide any false hope. Even with no other known problems, chances of successful IVF drop after about 3 cycles, and the chances of successful IVF at all are not overly high (I did one, unsuccessful, cycle years ago and was surprised that success rates are quite low per cycle... It's often talked about as the answer to infertility). That's not to say you shouldn't do more cycles or that it won't work, but better to have realistic expectations.

TheRuleofStix · 06/11/2020 09:38

And those people I knew who did repeated cycles were in their early 30s so a very different scenario.

SoloMummy · 06/11/2020 09:37

Fwiw you can also abroad run tandem cycles where you have your own embryos put back along with the de.

TheRuleofStix · 06/11/2020 09:37

I’m so sorry it wasn’t what you wanted to hear - there are lots of women who fall pregnant naturally in their 40s but you won’t know about the many thousands who try and never manage to Sad.

Ultimately it’s your decision but he’s being realistic (I had IVF and I know how brutal it is to hear this stuff).

SoloMummy · 06/11/2020 09:36

@mikkyr
I sadly think he's being realistic with you. That's a double whammy of issues at play.

It may be worth considering and looking into either one or both of donor sperm and eggs. If costs are not an issue, then there are many clinics in the UK. Equally, Europe has many clinics that have great success. Some with 50% plus success.

Chouxbuncity · 06/11/2020 09:36

Unfortunately it would be ethically wrong for a doctor to encourage people to keep going with the health and financial risks of IVF if it’s very likely to fail. It’s right that you know where you stand before you take on further treatment.

You can still have further treatment though? I would ask for a second opinion before deciding- just to get peace of mind.

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 09:35

It’s crazy. For anybody who has been through ivf will know that hope is what gets you through this. I just always thought your doctor would be the one providing it through confidence. Possibly even give us some good news stories. But honestly I feel like he was trying to tell me not to do it anymore. Surely there are these women that do 10 cycles? Do they do it on their own will in the face of adversity from the very person you are hoping is going to make it happen for you?
I’m devastated.

OP posts:
Washimal · 06/11/2020 09:33

It sounds like the Doctor was trying to manage your expectations and not give you false hope. But I can see that it must all be very disheartening and not what you would want to hear. Sorry you're going through this Flowers

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 09:31

We have decided that donor eggs or sperm is not an option for us.
They were so optimistic in the beginning. Basically that I was a fit healthy relatively ‘young’ women and that the only obstacle was my DH vasectomy which on biopsy had ‘lots of good moving sperm’!

OP posts:
dontdisturbmenow · 06/11/2020 09:31

I can't imagine what you must going through OP but can understand how desperate you must have been for encouraging news.

Your consultant gave you realistic clinical facts. Sadly, the reality is that your chances of carrying a pregnancy to term are very low. He just doesn't want to give you false hope and for you to turn around and accuse him if it, for the purpose of money making in the future.

But remember that in the end, it's your body, money and destiny, not his. You are in control, you can do what you want. It's in your hands to manage the odds.

If you both are mentally, phydically and financially ready to try again, then go ahead.

Sirzy · 06/11/2020 09:27

As horrible a situation as it is for you I think it’s much better he sets a realistic picture rather than you optimistically going ahead and spending more and more money for the result to sadly be the same each time.

SaskiaRembrandt · 06/11/2020 09:27

It sounds like he's trying to make sure you are continuing with a full awareness of the obstacles you face. It would be unethical of him to give you false hope and just keeping trying.

I know that must have been very hard to hear though Flowers