Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ivf. Doctor seemed overly negative.

209 replies

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 09:18

So husband and I have had 3 failed ivf cycles in the last 2 years. I am 41 and husband has had a vasectomy (previously married). Given the time constraints we decided that a testes biopsy was the best route to go instead of a vasectomy reversal which may not be successful and then still need to do a sperm extraction via biopsy at a later stage.

My last cycle failed completely whereas before I have had two early miscarriages. Without going into all the medical jargon I retrieved a fair amount of eggs for my age, they were reasonable quality, the embryos were not A grade but also not the worst. Everything seemed pretty average.

My appt with doc yesterday was terrible. I went in feeling so full of hope that we would be able to do another egg retrieval, ICSI and transfer before Christmas. But the doctor was so negative. He didn’t have anything hopeful to say. Basically I’m old my eggs have aged. My husbands sperm is less than great because it’s been extracted via biopsy and a vasectomy after 10 years rescues the quality. Our embryos are poor. The chances of genetic abnormalities are high. Our track record of 3 failed cycles leaves such a small percentage of success in the future. It’s costly.

We told him that money was not an issue (that sounds pretentious but we have enough to do another few cycles)

I’m just so disappointed in his atttitude. It’s like he doesn’t want me to do another cycle. I thought this whole process was about hope and that these doctors would be able to try and try. 3 cycles seems very little compared to what I’ve read and I’m surely not the only 41 year old who is seeking fertility help when there are 41 year olds falling pregnant naturally?

I don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
Mintychoc1 · 06/11/2020 12:55

OP when I was going through IVF I tried very hard to ignore what other people thought regarding my chances. As long as the clinic allowed me to have treatment, I disregarded the impressions the doctors gave of chances of success. I know that may sound ignorant, but I had my own personal turmoil to deal with, and I really didn’t have the energy to dwell on negative opinions. Like I say, until they actually refused me treatment, I worked to my own agenda. I’m not stupid, and I think I would have known when it was time to call a halt to it. So I went back time and again, for treatment after treatment. My consultant clearly thought I was a glutton for punishment ! He couldn’t believe that after each failed cycle I was straight back on the phone wanting to try again. In the end I lost count - I think I had 10 IUIs and maybe 5 full IVFs, and a couple of FETs. It cost me a fortune and took years but I now have 2 kids so I’m glad I stuck with it.
I guess what I’m saying is, whilst it’s important to keep your feet on the ground, you need to try not to take to heart the negative opinions. I think you’ll know yourself when enough is enough.

Tigger85 · 06/11/2020 12:54

Also I forgot to say that i don't believe embryo grading is particularly good, they are only looking at the cells not the DNA. My only living child is from a poor grade embryo that the clinic would have discarded if I had any higher grades. None of my A grades implanted, not even the hatching blastocyst. Both my b grades did implant in frozen cycles buy one ended in miscarriage and the other poor sweet very unwell little boy who was tfmr. We won't be wasting anymore c grade embryos in any further cycles. We are hoping to do a freeze all unless we have cs in which case they will be transferred and if they fail any higher grades will be a FET a cycle or two later.

Nottherealslimshady · 06/11/2020 12:52

I do think he was just being honest, there isn't really any positive evidence, such early miscarriages could most likely be due to serious abnormalities.
I think it actually shows him in better light that he told you it all how it is, its invasive and costly and it must be emotionally very difficult, he can't encourage you to do that again without understanding the chances.
I would do another cycle, and genetically test the embryos, and if they're no good I'd either use donors or just get DHs vasectomy reversed and see if you get a miracle but stop trying.

Ginfordinner · 06/11/2020 12:43

Does anybody think my doctor has given up too easily?

No. I can't really add anything different to what has been said, and I agree that the doctor is just being honest with you. He obviously does have a moral and ethical code, and isn't just taking your money for the hell of it. This is why I and most people have voted YABU.

You aren't unreasonable for being disappointed, but you are unreasonable for expecting the dcotor to give you good news when he clearly doen't have any.

I'm sorry you are going through this Flowers

Tigger85 · 06/11/2020 12:39

I am 35 and have low amh, we are looking to have another round now after our last cycle resulted in a baby boy who was very sadly tfmr for severe fetal abnormalities (not genetic). You can help your sperm and egg quality by making dietary changes and taking supplements. It starts with the egg is a good book and has a chapter for make fertility. We had a consultation yesterday and the doctor recommended the same supplements as it starts with the egg book. Ubiquinol 600mg for you, 200mg for him, vit d, folate for both, N acetyl cystine 600mg for you, r-alpha lipoic acid for both l carnitine for him, high quality high strength omega 3/DHA for both (I'm taking the Zita West ones). Medittereanian diet, no red meat, fish a few times per week.

bloomety · 06/11/2020 12:37

Also OP, I am a member of two facebook groups for women 40+ TTC. They have been a great support.

Bear2014 · 06/11/2020 12:36

Hi OP, sorry you are going through this. I do agree that after 40 the IVF success rates drop through the floor, yes over-40s do get pregnant but less so and they do have more miscarriages. I have been through several rounds of IVF and my eggs were found to be dreadful at the age of 36, thankfully as I'm in a same sex relationship we managed to conceive two DC using my partner's eggs, even though she is older than me. It really does vary so much.

If you won't consider an egg donor, you could definitely throw everything at it in terms of supplements, ubiquinol is something we tried and apparently does help many people. You would have to take them for a few months before you tried again. Also perhaps try endometrial scratch before the transfer. Choosing a clinic is a personal thing, if money is not an issue I would definitely go somewhere else and give it another shot.

Phoenix21 · 06/11/2020 12:23

OP I had 10 years of IVF (x8 cycles, x5 miscarriages).

My last cycle with PGS (abroad) was successful.

It might be worth having some counselling, we found that with the limbo grief anxiety hope and despair That we couldn’t think clearly.

Alternatively a second opinion might help you.

I wish you all the best.

bloomety · 06/11/2020 12:21

He also told me there is nothing you can do to improve egg quality... is this true?

No. DHEA can improve egg quality. You can only get it on prescription in the UK so I bought it from USA. After 9 weeks of being on it, I am now 12 weeks pregnant. I had previously had 2 early miscarriages. My AMH is low at 3.3 and I am 40.

from it starts with the egg

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 12:12

@52andblue

I think the IVF Dr was being brutally honest. As was mine, during my rounds of ICSI IVF. Better that than a Dr / clinic that will keep selling you hope (& tx) Its a big business industry after all. But that doesn't mean you cannot keep going if you wish. What does your heart tell you?
My heart is sad. Just been shopping and pushing a trolley and thinking about why I’m sad. This process itself is such a heart wrenching one. You most want the end result which is a healthy child but each step in the process is such a pain in the arse. I spend each drive to the clinic feeling angry that I have to pursue this route to motherhood and almost having to convince myself to walk into the clinic because it’s such a shitty way to have a child!
OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 06/11/2020 12:08

I just refer back to your post about your dhs “precious jewels”. Whatever procedure he has pails in comparison to anything, which happens to a woman actually doing ivf and the procedures, which can be performed on you. Not time for either of you to get precious about the pain / discomfort he may go through.

Hope your blood work comes back ok.

TableFlowerss · 06/11/2020 12:07

I can imagine it must be absolutely awful so you do have my sympathy OP. I would also say if you can afford it then keep going, it’s no ones business as such. You’re 41 not 51!

I suppose the doctor is being realistic though. I would say it’s better than a doctor promising the earth and taking your money when the reality is it’s Mother Nature that decides whether it’s going to end successfully.

The sad reality is some women will never fall pregnant through IVF and as we know, the quality of the eggs diminishes with age. That’s not to say it won’t work, hopefully it will for you, but I don’t think it’s unreasonable of him to be cautious.

I hope it works OP

Fusillage · 06/11/2020 12:03

I have been there. I am now early 40s and after 4 rounds of own egg IVF without a whiff of pregnancy the clinic were clear that they considered future success v unlikely with my own eggs. Horrible to hear but true. Am now on round two of DE (first ended in miscarriage). If this doesn’t work I know I’ll have tried everything possible (within your realm of comfort, you may have v good reasons for not using donor eggs but definitely don’t write it off without thinking about it). It feels like a massive hurdle to start on another process but it’s actually a lot more straightforward than traditional ivf. All the best.

Branleuse · 06/11/2020 12:01

I know quite a few doctors are of the opinion that IVF has such a low success rate overall that it shouldnt be pushed. Also a lot of people overestimate the success rate of vasectomy reversal. It is after all, a permanent sterilisation. You are likely peri-menopausal too.
I am not sure if your doctor was overly negative, or appropriately negative and trying to manage your expectations. After all, having a lot of money doesnt mean it will work

SoulofanAggron · 06/11/2020 11:59

Is this someone you're paying to see privately? In that case, I think it's very ethical of him to suggest that paying for it mightn't be worth your while, rather than just taking your money.

Also, saying it might mean a client is less likely to blame him/put it down to him if it doesn't work out.

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 11:58

@PurBal

If you want to have a few more cycles that's a valid decision, but cost aside is it something you can go through emotionally? Especially since it sounds like your odds are low. Sorry you're dealing with this OP.
I think I could do another cycle. I have heard all the comments about drawing a line as our limit and in my heart this next round would have been it. Just didn’t expect to get such a unenthusiastic response from the RE.
OP posts:
PurBal · 06/11/2020 11:56

If you want to have a few more cycles that's a valid decision, but cost aside is it something you can go through emotionally? Especially since it sounds like your odds are low. Sorry you're dealing with this OP.

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 11:55

@ClaireP20

Just to add OP, are you taking projesterone suppositories? After my miscarriages, i took these and the pregnancies stayed with me. The clinic should be giving these to you for at least 3 months x
Yup. Everytime. And even progesterone injections which are hellishly expensive compared to the suppositories. Obviously not taking them now.
OP posts:
pjani · 06/11/2020 11:54

I would get a second opinion. Ask for all your records and take them to another clinic.

ImMoana · 06/11/2020 11:52

OP I wouldn’t give up hope. I think the dr was just trying to manage your expectations.
I had a hell of a journey with ‘unexplained infertility’.
Tried ICI and it failed.
Tried IVF and didn’t have enough or big enough eggs.
Abandoned next round as they found fibroids on a scan.
Had an op to remove fibroids and during the op they couldn’t find any fibroids...!
This all in all took 3 yrs and cost £6000.
Had a break from the process and conceived naturally.

In your shoes I’d give it another go using what was remaining of your DH’s specimen.

52andblue · 06/11/2020 11:49

I think the IVF Dr was being brutally honest.
As was mine, during my rounds of ICSI IVF.
Better that than a Dr / clinic that will keep selling you hope (& tx)
Its a big business industry after all.
But that doesn't mean you cannot keep going if you wish.
What does your heart tell you?

Rubyroost · 06/11/2020 11:41

I'm 42 and I've not had IVF, I think at our age the chance of conceiving naturally or by IVF is lowish. And of course all your eggs won't be great and there will be some chromosomal issues.
I had a miscarriage and then conceived at 38 and had a baby at 39. Conceived at 39 and had termination at 40 due to poorly baby at 13.5 week (chromosomal) then conceived at age 40 (chemical) then again at 40 and had baby at 41.
So I guess doing it by IVF would lower your chances a bit too? I'm not sure how it works. I decided I would keep trying and we got there in the end, but I know my egg quality can't have been brilliant.

herecomesthsun · 06/11/2020 11:35

Hi, I have looked through the OP posts and wanted to say good luck.

We were in a similar position in a way- I went to see the IVF specialist after 3 miscarriages when I was 42. He said there was no point trying IVF, that I should "face it" and reconcile myself to not having any kids and offered me counselling, which I refused. I felt the game wasn't over yet.

He did offer to see me again, by which time I had fallen pregnant naturally Grin. That pregnancy and the next one went relatively and I have 2 healthy children now, doing well at school.

Just posting as people were discussing the importance of hope.

Medical science is wonderful in many ways, but doctors still don't know everything and do not always have the final say.

The consultant did prescribe us loads of vitamins (which we both took) as there was evidence they might help, I had also cut out caffeine, as there was some discussion in the literature that eliminating caffeine might help with recurrent miscarriages, and was drinking very little alcohol anyway. And I chose a less stressful workplace, partly because of the miscarriages.

We also got a very early scan when I was pregnant as there was evidence that this helped avoid a miscarriage (again possibly because of improved confidence). I hope it's ok to mention that, in case any of it is helpful Smile.

ClaireP20 · 06/11/2020 11:34

Just to add OP, are you taking projesterone suppositories? After my miscarriages, i took these and the pregnancies stayed with me. The clinic should be giving these to you for at least 3 months x

mistermagpie · 06/11/2020 11:30

It's really hard. I do think the Dr was being honest but if it was me, I wouldn't give up now.

You talk about being at a crossroads and a life without children vs a life with them. In my own head I would have to examine whether one of the other options is one I could live with - and that is to revisit the idea of having a child that isn't biologically yours or DHs.

I know that personally I would rather have a child with donor eggs and/or sperm than no child at all. So yes, I would revisit this option. You haven't really said why you won't consider this?

If money is no object and mentally you can handle it, I would give it one more go with your own sperm and eggs and if this doesn't work I'd give it one go with donor sperm/eggs.

Then you have explored everything and if it still hasn't worked there are no what ifs.

But this is me and it's not my decision, but I think discounting donor eggs/sperm at the outset and never reevaluating that decision could be a mistake.