Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ivf. Doctor seemed overly negative.

209 replies

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 09:18

So husband and I have had 3 failed ivf cycles in the last 2 years. I am 41 and husband has had a vasectomy (previously married). Given the time constraints we decided that a testes biopsy was the best route to go instead of a vasectomy reversal which may not be successful and then still need to do a sperm extraction via biopsy at a later stage.

My last cycle failed completely whereas before I have had two early miscarriages. Without going into all the medical jargon I retrieved a fair amount of eggs for my age, they were reasonable quality, the embryos were not A grade but also not the worst. Everything seemed pretty average.

My appt with doc yesterday was terrible. I went in feeling so full of hope that we would be able to do another egg retrieval, ICSI and transfer before Christmas. But the doctor was so negative. He didn’t have anything hopeful to say. Basically I’m old my eggs have aged. My husbands sperm is less than great because it’s been extracted via biopsy and a vasectomy after 10 years rescues the quality. Our embryos are poor. The chances of genetic abnormalities are high. Our track record of 3 failed cycles leaves such a small percentage of success in the future. It’s costly.

We told him that money was not an issue (that sounds pretentious but we have enough to do another few cycles)

I’m just so disappointed in his atttitude. It’s like he doesn’t want me to do another cycle. I thought this whole process was about hope and that these doctors would be able to try and try. 3 cycles seems very little compared to what I’ve read and I’m surely not the only 41 year old who is seeking fertility help when there are 41 year olds falling pregnant naturally?

I don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
MrsPeacockDidIt · 06/11/2020 15:24

I’m sorry you’re going through this OP. I was very glad to have a straight taking Dr when we were doing our IVF. She was very clear after round 3 that it was very unlikely that using my own eggs was going to work. Like you, DH and I had discussed before the first round what we would do if things didn’t go well and decided that what was important to us was having a family, however that was to be achieved. We looked into adoption and spoke to a few local authorities but it didn’t look good where we lived and also they wouldn’t see us so soon after failed IVFs so we went the donor egg route which resulted in our son.

I don’t think it’s an IVF specialists job to give false hope. They need to be the ones without emotion as it’s impossible for the patients to do that.

Going into our first round of IVF we were filled with hope as sometimes a problem can’t be anticipated until they see how a cycle goes. It was heartbreaking for us when it failed. I really hope you get to have your family.

Misty999 · 06/11/2020 15:14

Change clinics OP nothing worse than cycling with all that negativity I didn't use my free nhs cycles because I couldn't take the negativity. Id say your doing pretty well to get three transfers out of one round of ivf. The odds were really against us and we knew it but we're still happy to throw everything we had at it our consultant was honest 10% chance of success over a three cycle package but at no time was he ever negative. We were successful after 6 rounds of ivf. I would also go for the vasectomy reversal at the same time so you get to try naturally as well x

Trixie18 · 06/11/2020 15:12

I'm so sorry you're going through this. Do you think the doctor was trying to (in their view, not necessarily mine) be realistic about your chances and thought they were being kind by preparing you for it not working?
You should maybe ask to have someone else handling your care tbh. I've been through this process and it's much harder when you don't really trust the person trying to help you. We had to change consultants and while our second was brutally realistic (we were given something like a 10% chance of IVF working) he always used to say things like 'where there's life there's hope' and 'the thing about statistics is you always have your outliers, those that beat all the odds'. I found it strangely comforting. Anyway at 41, after 2 failed pregnancies, we conceived twins via IVF, they're now 2 and they're great. Good luck, it's a hard journey and not everyone gets a baby at the end but you'll give it all you've got any try your best regardless of the chances. I'll be thinking of you xx

YouKidsIsCrazy · 06/11/2020 15:02

I would also say if you can afford it then keep going, it’s no ones business as such

It's very much the drs business.

In the UK 40-42 would expect 19% success rate per cycle

That's very much an average. For an individual, it could be 5%. Or 0%

AlternativePerspective · 06/11/2020 15:00

They have to be realistic.

Even if you were young your chances of success are still very low (around 30%), add your age and your DH’s sperm into that equation and you’re looking at very unlikely odds. And then if you factor birth defects in as well which might mean you would terminate a pregnancy the chances of you having a baby now are very slim.

The clinic isn’t just about giving hope. It should never be hope at all costs, and tbh there does have to come a point where you call a halt. There’s no point trying cycle after cycle after cycle with no chance of success. This is just going to make things even harder for you.

If adoption and donor eggs/sperm aren’t something you want to pursue (I wouldn’t have either) might it be worth seeking some counselling to help you come to terms with things.

Westnorwood · 06/11/2020 15:00

@Hardbackwriter

In the UK 40-42 would expect 19% success rate per cycle.

Isn't that the pregnancy rate, not the live birth rate? Not many people would consider a miscarriage at 12 weeks a success, but it would be under those statistics.

This is true, my mistake. Live birth is the better metric.

14% per cycle
16% per egg collection
18% per embryo transfer (42% of those being blastocysts)

Marmitecrackers · 06/11/2020 14:57

When we did ICSI my consultant told me she would always be honest on my chances and that she wouldn't ethically be doing her job if she didn't lay out what she felt our chances were.

Bathroom12345 · 06/11/2020 14:51

Have you had a child before?

I was 39 when I tried for my second one. It took 18 months and we looked at IVF. We even started a cycle and then I found I was pregnant but they said that as I was proven to be able to take a child to term that made the stats much better.

Like you I wouldnt consider donor eggs. We had one child already and that would have been fine but I agree with PP. They wouldnt be doing the right thing inflating your hopes. Your age isnt in your favour, you DH's situation isnt either and the cycles that didnt work is telling everyone something but please dont think you can go to 10 cycles or even 20 plus. What does your DH think?

Hardbackwriter · 06/11/2020 14:50

In the UK 40-42 would expect 19% success rate per cycle.

Isn't that the pregnancy rate, not the live birth rate? Not many people would consider a miscarriage at 12 weeks a success, but it would be under those statistics.

SoloMummy · 06/11/2020 14:44

It’s just something my DH and I agreed on from the start. No adoption and no donors. It’s probably a bit of an immature unexplored mindset but it was one of the limitations we set ourselves beforehand and probably why I’m so devastated that this may be the end of the road.

I don't think that navy people, in an ideal world, think that donor gametes is in their game plan.

However, for many and now you, there comes that crossroads, where you have to move on with your thinking. Do you want to potentially be a parent or forever more live with that gaping hole that you could have explored other options, be that donor gametes, surrogacy, adoption, fostering etc.

There are literally thousands of couples with a child, as a result of a donor. Be that donor egg, sperm or both.

It is, ultimately, a cell, given by another that you grow, nurture, love and birth.

Are you really, at 41,when you know your options are already reduced, going to not consider this now you've reached this point because when you made a decision you were still in the fertility treatment honeymoon bubble?

Surely you owe it to yourself, especially, as you have no biological children, to at least research and look into the other options now you're at this point before you rule it out?

Can I ask your concerns?
Not being related by blood? Child tracing donor? Not wanting to tell the child or others? Honestly, whatever it is, I promise you there are millions of couples who have thought this through before too...There are websites and forums that specifically deal with these situations and offer non judgemental advice. Do message me if you want further information.

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 14:38

@Westnorwood

If you can say which country you are from people might be able to suggest alternative clinics.
I’m in the KZN Midlands in South Africa. Clinic is in Durban
OP posts:
Westnorwood · 06/11/2020 14:36

If you can say which country you are from people might be able to suggest alternative clinics.

Westnorwood · 06/11/2020 14:35

That doesn’t sound standard. Usually they observe until day 3 and if enough were progressing normally leave until day 5.

I would double check they are using vitrification to freeze them. If they are using older techniques this may affect the outcome.

In the UK 40-42 would expect 19% success rate per cycle.

Circusoflove · 06/11/2020 14:25

No. They were frozen at 1 day and then thawed and transferred at 3 days.
The one embryo that actually resulted in a miscarriage was transferred at 1 day as part of a fresh cycle.

I really don’t think this is done in the U.K. anymore. Embryology advances mean that there is no benefit transferring at such an early stage.

Onadifferentuniverse · 06/11/2020 14:16

I know you and your husband have decided against sperm donation already- but would this be something you can speak about again if it would increase the chances of success?

Did he have a vasectomy due to having children?

Trousersareoverrated · 06/11/2020 14:02

OP I guess the doctor was trying not to give you false hope but have you asked what kind of odds you are dealing with? A 10% chance may still be worth taking to you but the doctor might see it as not worth your while. Don’t let one doctors pessimism get you down.

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 14:00

@Circusoflove

You said that your embryos were frozen at 3 days. That isn’t usually done as basically if they don’t make it to blastocyst (5 days) they are not going to be successful anyway. So I think you’ve been a misled up until now. They didn’t wait to see if your embryos developed into healthy blastocysts as they knew there was a good chance they would not do so.
No. They were frozen at 1 day and then thawed and transferred at 3 days. The one embryo that actually resulted in a miscarriage was transferred at 1 day as part of a fresh cycle.

The option going forward would be to leave them to get to blastocyst at day 5, genetic test and freeze pending the result.

OP posts:
Circusoflove · 06/11/2020 13:57

You said that your embryos were frozen at 3 days. That isn’t usually done as basically if they don’t make it to blastocyst (5 days) they are not going to be successful anyway. So I think you’ve been a misled up until now. They didn’t wait to see if your embryos developed into healthy blastocysts as they knew there was a good chance they would not do so.

CatsMother66 · 06/11/2020 13:49

I’m so sorry, I have been where you have and it was a very dark time for me. I felt that there was no point to my life. I had 3 rounds of IVF from the age of 40/41. We paid for it and I would never have given up if I had had the choice. The desire to have a child was so strong.
After the third failed attempt, the consultant told us more or less what yours has said, however he also added that we were bringing the clinic’s success rate down and I feel that was a big factor in his decision.
You have been pregnant twice and that would have given me the encouragement to continue. As a previous poster said, progesterone suppositories are very important to support a healthy womb in the first few months. I would find another clinic and keep trying.

diddl · 06/11/2020 13:49

Were you given too much hope in the first place, Op?

Were you told that your eggs might not be "good quality" & the same for your husband's sperm due to him having had a vasectomy?

RattleOfBars · 06/11/2020 13:47

I’m so sorry you’re going through this. But the doctor has a duty of care to be realistic.

The combination of your age, poor quality sperm, poor quality embryos and several failed cycles makes the chance of ICSI working quite slim. It’s a very expensive procedure so if your doctor acted optimistically about it working, would you not be concerned he was just trying to extract more money from you?

He’s likely seen many couples in your situation and is trying to be realistic.

Have you explored other options like egg and/or sperm donation?

thanksgivingchi · 06/11/2020 13:17

OP it is a very difficult way to have a dc.
It is stressful and uncertain.
I also read Zita West's book and found it useful although it was over ten years ago now.

Doctors are quite blunt about your chances after our successful births aged 32 I was told if I wanted more dc I needed to come back before I was 35 and my age became an issue.

That doesn't mean that older woman don't have success stories just that the odds are more stacked against them.

I remember looking at everyone else seemingly having dc without problems and it really hurt. I hope you find a good way forward.

Onadifferentuniverse · 06/11/2020 13:15

I’m sorry you’re going through this x

CounsellorTroi · 06/11/2020 13:07

My heart is sad. Just been shopping and pushing a trolley and thinking about why I’m sad. This process itself is such a heart wrenching one. You most want the end result which is a healthy child but each step in the process is such a pain in the arse. I spend each drive to the clinic feeling angry that I have to pursue this route to motherhood and almost having to convince myself to walk into the clinic because it’s such a shitty way to have a child!

I felt the same. I was so angry that other people could make babies in a fun, free and private way, just by going to bed with their nice warm partner and having a nice time and I was having to go through endless injections and invasive internal scans. I was a poor responder to the drugs, it took me three weeks to get to egg harvesting stage and then very few eggs.

mikkyr · 06/11/2020 13:01

Thank you so much for each and every reasonable opinion.

OP posts: