Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour asked us not to do fireworks?

785 replies

lockdownqueen · 05/11/2020 16:57

I'm in a group chat with girls on our new build estate I've sent out a pre warning as hubby has gone and bought some. Everyone was fine and said they will be in there gardens to watch then one of the girls asked us not too as her dog has severe panic attacks.

don't know what to do? Kids have been looking forward to them.

aibu to go ahead and do them?

OP posts:
Smallsteps88 · 06/11/2020 16:50

But we don't have a massive campaign to ban motorbikes.

We do insist people have a license to drive them though. Which requires taking a test to prove they can do that safely.

freddosfrogs · 06/11/2020 16:49

@Willyoujustbequiet

Its so entitled of people to think their pet trumps the enjoyment of others and I say that as a dog owner.

Im against home displays in normal circumstances but this year is different. I feel children are having a really hard time and they come first. Dogs arent stressed by Covid kids are.

A responsible pet owner should take steps to mitigate any distress their pet suffers on bonfire night. Not expect others to

Its so entitled of people to think that their right to set off dangerous incendiary devices trumps the right of farmers not to have their animals killed/scared by fireworks, by horse owners not to have their horses spooked/injured, of people not to have a house fire as a result.

Many animals are terrified by fireworks not just dogs. My rabbits are terrified by fireworks and they don't do anything to annoy my neighbours, they quietly go about their business and cause no irritation or harm to others. Fireworks can and do kill rabbits through fear.

Bookworming · 06/11/2020 16:38

Definitely ban thunderstorms @Turgha!

Bookworming · 06/11/2020 16:38

@MrsJunglelow I've already said about dogs being dangerous, they're not necessary (aside from assistance dogs), ban them?

Are any pets necessary? Not needed for transport, not needed for providing anything necessary.

They are dangerous, children have been blinded by their excrement.

Turgha · 06/11/2020 16:37

I am guessing thunderstorms are just as bad?

MrsJunglelow · 06/11/2020 16:32

Ban cars, they get driven by drunk people, they get driven by drugged people, they get driven to fast, they terrify people by being driven badly. People kill people with cars all the time, cars kill cyclists, horses, dogs, cars, wildlife. Ban them!
Just not comparable.

People are reliant on cars; they are needed to get to and from work, for transporting children to school etc.

There are measures in place to try and reduce accidents and work is being done to reduce their negative impact on the environment.
Without cars many people would be unable to continue their day to life as they wouldn’t be able to work for example.

How are fireworks necessary for modern day life exactly..?
And unlike cars absolutely nothing has been put in place whatsoever to reduce the damage they do and make them safer.

Bookworming · 06/11/2020 16:25

Yes my opinion and many many many many many more peoples' opinion.

And many many saying don't ban them!

put down? Horses going into premature labour because of their fear and the foal dying? Old people being terrified? People with ptsd being terrified? People having fireworks thrown at them, people having them pushed through their letterbox, people on a bus having one thrown on the bus?

Ban cars, they get driven by drunk people, they get driven by drugged people, they get driven to fast, they terrify people by being driven badly. People kill people with cars all the time, cars kill cyclists, horses, dogs, cars, wildlife. Ban them!

PurBal · 06/11/2020 16:05

As someone with a serious fear of fireworks complete with panic attacks I usually go away to a cottage in the middle of nowhere at this time of year (not joking). Last night was really difficult for me. But I wouldn't dream of telling people they couldn't have a good time. I hope you set off loads.

lynsey91 · 06/11/2020 16:00

@Bookworming

Your opinion is they should be banned *@lynsey91* and it's said year after year, but they're not and people can still enjoy them.

I've just read in another thread about an out of control dog jumping up on a mother wearing her baby in a sling, very dangerous, could've hurt the baby, mum could've lost her balance and fallen.

Should dogs be banned?

We here about them killing people, babies, young children. Police are attacked by them, time taken up going to seize them, just ban them, why not?

Yes my opinion and many many many many many more peoples' opinion.

Every year the momentum to have them banned grows and as each year they seem to get even louder that it just going to carry on.

Why is your argument about dogs? What about wildlife being terrified and/or injured? Horses burned so badly by them they have to put down? Horses going into premature labour because of their fear and the foal dying? Old people being terrified? People with ptsd being terrified? People having fireworks thrown at them, people having them pushed through their letterbox, people on a bus having one thrown on the bus?

Do you not care about any of them?

lynsey91 · 06/11/2020 15:54

@Willyoujustbequiet

Its so entitled of people to think their pet trumps the enjoyment of others and I say that as a dog owner.

Im against home displays in normal circumstances but this year is different. I feel children are having a really hard time and they come first. Dogs arent stressed by Covid kids are.

A responsible pet owner should take steps to mitigate any distress their pet suffers on bonfire night. Not expect others to

I don't think my dogs trump the enjoyment of others but I do think the wellbeing of pets, horses, wildlife, old people, people suffering from ptsd do.

If people want fireworks why are the pretty ones not enough? What enjoyment can there possibly be from the ones that honestly sound like a bomb going off and, yes, I have heard a bomb going off. Have silent ones or the quieter ones ON THE CORRECT NIGHT and far more people would be unhappy

I am a responsible dog owner and I took steps to ensure my dog would not be scared by playing cd's when he was a puppy. If you have actually read the thread you will see all that went out of the window when an arsehole let off a loud firework in DAYLIGHT on the 14th November as I was walking my dog past their garden. He was terrified and I am lucky I could hold onto his lead or he would probably have run into the road and got hit by a car.

I have tried everything since but he is scared of any loud noise including idiot next door crashing their wheely bin lid about 100 time a day.

Also I wish people would stop saying it is just bonfire night because it bloody well isn't. It is weeks of them going off from early (still light) until often pretty late.

Selfish twats.

lynsey91 · 06/11/2020 15:47

@Winterterrace

HibbleDibble have you asked your vet about diazepam? Just for Bonfire night and New Year’s Eve?
So what are they meant to do on all the other nights that idiots let fireworks off?

My friend has a dog that is terrified and has to be sedated. So far this year she has been sedated for 2 weeks with no let up in sight. That's ok is it?

Bookworming · 06/11/2020 15:46

Hear not here!

Bookworming · 06/11/2020 15:46

Your opinion is they should be banned @lynsey91 and it's said year after year, but they're not and people can still enjoy them.

I've just read in another thread about an out of control dog jumping up on a mother wearing her baby in a sling, very dangerous, could've hurt the baby, mum could've lost her balance and fallen.

Should dogs be banned?

We here about them killing people, babies, young children. Police are attacked by them, time taken up going to seize them, just ban them, why not?

lynsey91 · 06/11/2020 15:42

@Bookworming

What does eventually mean *@lynsey91*, in the next millennium?

I don't think this year is worse than any other year.

Well as I don't have a crystal ball I can't tell you but I do think they will be banned at some stage.

Every year there are more and more stories about animals being injured or even dying, fireworks being thrown at emergency service people, on to buses etc and more and more people think they should be banned.

stillsomewhatsheldonesque · 06/11/2020 15:26

Stdg and schade

Thank you for last night. Flowers

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 06/11/2020 15:19

@dkdkfhfkdsl - I don’t think there is any way to predict whether a dog will react badly to fireworks before they first encounter them.

Our first dog was utterly unconcerned by them, until recent years - as I said in my earlier post, our second dog (a rescue) was neurotic from the word Go, and hated fireworks and thunder, and I think some of her unease rubbed off on the first one.

I don’t see how we could have known that the first dog would develop a nervousness about fireworks in her later years, and the rescue we got the second dog from had no indication that she was going to be scared of loud noises - she was only in the shelter for a month, and presumably didn’t encounter either fireworks or thunder whilst there, and I don’t think her previous homes were particularly good owners so may well not have bothered to tell the shelter the relevant info. I know that they didn’t know many details about either of her previous homes, so I don’t think it is a stretch to assume they didn’t bother to hand on relevant info.

safariboot · 06/11/2020 15:14

I think motorbikes are a good analogy actually. Nobody needs to zoom around at 70 miles an hour balanced on two wheels just for fun. Hundreds of bikers are killed every year and thousands more seriously injured. There's a lot of antisocial behaviour and crime associated with them in both urban and rural areas.

But we don't have a massive campaign to ban motorbikes.

dkdkfhfkdsl · 06/11/2020 15:00

This really pisses me off. When people get a dog, they know full well there'll be fireworks every single year, and they know how dogs react. Their choice.

I hate dogs barking, but have to put up with that every single day of the year, something dog owners seem to think everyone else should have to put up with too. They're just being selfish - don't let them spoil your fun.

stillsomewhatsheldonesque · 06/11/2020 14:57

Not what I was saying but on you go.

Remember and apply it to children, cars, motorbikes, risky sports etc. Equally ridiculous.

But it wasn’t a dog letting off fireworks last night was it?

I have put why I don’t like them. Im sorry if you think noises like bombs are entertaining and setting off explosives are a fun thing to do. I don’t.

On that we will have to differ.

DynamoKev · 06/11/2020 14:51

For the first time I can remember in my 58 years we didn't have any fireworks last night. DD was disappointed but not devastated. I have a small box we didn't use last year so we will keep it in case we are allowed next year. I really think some of vitriol on here about fireworks is OTT.

Bookworming · 06/11/2020 14:51

*And an not insignificant number of dogs kill people each year but we don't apply that situation to every single dog do we and prattle on about "look at those owners just letting their dogs kill people, must be so much fun for them".

Because that would be ridiculous.*

100% this!

GlummyMcGlummerson · 06/11/2020 14:44

@stillsomewhatsheldonesque

They might not intend to set houses on fire but the fact is someone’s fireworks did just that last night.

A reasonable risk of that in a built up area and it is totally avoidable.

I’m sure the family involved will be delighted that they added the spectacle of a burning house to the proceedings.

Loads of oohing and aahing at that.

And weeping and wailing.

Such fun.

And an not insignificant number of dogs kill people each year but we don't apply that situation to every single dog do we and prattle on about "look at those owners just letting their dogs kill people, must be so much fun for them".

Because that would be ridiculous.

Winterterrace · 06/11/2020 14:36

HibbleDibble have you asked your vet about diazepam? Just for Bonfire night and New Year’s Eve?

stillsomewhatsheldonesque · 06/11/2020 14:20

They might not intend to set houses on fire but the fact is someone’s fireworks did just that last night.

A reasonable risk of that in a built up area and it is totally avoidable.

I’m sure the family involved will be delighted that they added the spectacle of a burning house to the proceedings.

Loads of oohing and aahing at that.

And weeping and wailing.

Such fun.

slipperywhensparticus · 06/11/2020 14:08

I love how everyone trots out children/bad year/need enjoyment on these threads
My children

A,loved this year because no school and mum 24/7

B,are terrified of fireworks

my three cats enjoy them more than my sons one was welded to the windows all night when the back neighbours finished he ran to the front of the house to see the other neighbours fireworks...my bloody cat