Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quality at Aldi and Lidl

392 replies

Marcelduchamp · 05/11/2020 13:40

I know Aldi and Lidl are really popular on mumsnet but I really am completely baffled as to how people can claim its good quality. I have relatives who shop there and I have eaten the food lots of times. Yes a few items are OK but on the whole its not good in my experience. I don't eat meat so can't comment on that. I do think veg is veg so is probably not vastly different. I also think the choice is poor with a very basic selection of stuff.

I know it's cheap and we all need that at times. I'm not knocking people who need to cut shopping costs. But are people really being honest when they say the can't tell the difference. What are you tasting? Examples are the strong cheddar cheese is just bland, the crisps don't have much flavour and the filled pasta is cloying inside.

I suppose my AIBU is AIBU to day these shops sell poor quality food.

OP posts:
RaspberryCoulis · 06/11/2020 08:51

I also think that a switched-on store manager makes a huge difference. Someone who is on top of issues like stock rotation - it's basic but can go a long way to explain why people are finding in a particular store things go off quickly - because a shop assistant has piled the new stuff in front of the old rather than behind, and the new stuff has sold.

Also the store environment affects your feelings hugely. The Lidl near us is an older store. Narrow, dark, feels cluttered and cramped and it's just not a nice place to be in. Same with the Sainsbury's, it's been there forever and it's really tired and old. Scruffy flooring, poor lighting, just really "1980s". In contrast we have an Aldi which only opened about 18 months ago and it's lovely - aisles twice the width of Lidl, very bright and airy, higher ceilings, huge windows, just makes for a much more comfortable place to be.

Jroseforever · 06/11/2020 08:47

Aldi sell the exact same premium steak as Waitrose do as well of much of their prepared veg.

Evidence? Source?

myhobbyisouting · 06/11/2020 08:45

And whilst I was typing @Jroseforever proved my point Hmm

myhobbyisouting · 06/11/2020 08:45

If you think that any food in this country could vary as wildly as a 1 star apartment in Benidorm vs 5 star in the Maldives then you're not thinking it through and are simply acting out of snobbery. In the process you are spending unnecessarily, sometimes on EXACTLY the same item.

We have a good standards agency and environmental health which ensures that it isn't possible to have a scale as you describe in our supermarkets. M&S sell dire wine, but Aldi are fantastic.

The reason it is cheaper is due to their systems, not their produce. If you'd allow yourself to see past the snobbery you might find that you were being a fool not to try it out.

Aldi sell the exact same premium steak as Waitrose do as well of much of their prepared veg.

Jroseforever · 06/11/2020 08:39

It depends what’s the main part of your diet.

Mine... organic fresh fruit and veg, flavoursome organic meat and fresh. Consequently... I love marks and Waitrose

If it was cheap crisps, fizzy drinks and cereals. Then it would be Aldi and Lidl

Sickofbroccoli · 06/11/2020 08:34

For veg, I think it depends on where you live for Lidl/Aldi. Where I used to love, Aldi’s veg was always on a par with Sainsbury’s, lasted well etc while Lidl’s was crap.

Where I live now, Sainsbury’s veg is still good, Lidl’s doesn’t last quite as long but is good while in Aldi half the stuff seems to be past it’s best even on the shelf.

Fruit is very unreliable in both for me, sometimes great and lasts as expected and sometimes awful. The same for meat. But I know others who say both are wonderful, or again that their lidl is great and aldi crap or vice versa.

The general unreliability and seemingly random stock issues (which when they have one option per product is problematic - at Sainsbury’s or Tesco if they don’t have the brand of X I wanted, I can almost always pick up other brand) means I struggle to do a full shop there.

Marcelduchamp · 06/11/2020 08:33

@Jroseforever

Aldi / Lidl vs M&S/ Waitrose

The equivalent of...

Benidorm 1 star vs high end Maldives resort

Incomparable in my view.

But many people on the thread are saying otherwise! So apperently were wrong.
OP posts:
Marcelduchamp · 06/11/2020 08:32

[quote PattyPan]@Facelikearustytractor I cook every meal from scratch but find Lidl doesn’t have the range I need. They have hardly any herbs & spices, the only dried pulses they sell are red lentils, they don’t sell bulgur wheat, spelt, barley, giant couscous, don’t regularly have tofu and so forth. Aldi and Lidl make the choice to have fewer items at cheaper prices but that’s less convenient for cooking from scratch because you have to go to bigger supermarkets to get the ingredients they don’t stock.[/quote]
Yep this I regularly buy the items mentioned. I was actually just thinking this yesterday as I opened my spice drawerwhen making lunch. There are loads of spices I can't get at Aldi and Lidl.

I am also massively enjoying how not cooking from scratch is used as an insult! 😂

OP posts:
Jroseforever · 06/11/2020 08:21

Aldi / Lidl vs M&S/ Waitrose

The equivalent of...

Benidorm 1 star vs high end Maldives resort

Incomparable in my view.

silentpool · 06/11/2020 08:08

I don't buy everything at Lidl. I do a combination of shopping between them and Waitrose. I've found their veg to be absolutely fine. I actually find it weird when vegetables last for ages, it does mean they've done something to them, like irradiate them. So if food doesn't last long, its probably better for you! But their basics are absolutely fine. I've found some lovely things there like smoked trout. But I don't rate their meat as it was tough as boots. I feel that overall Waitrose pays more attention to suppliers and the food chain.

Essoterical · 06/11/2020 08:06

I love both Lidl & Aldi for basics.
My elderly father is also a big fan, however for a change we did a big shop at Waitrose recently for him. He reported a couple of days later that 'his taste buds seem to have returned'.
Think this says it all really.
At least with somewhere like Waitrose you are assured the produce is ethically sourced and fair trade etc.
I think using a combination of supermarkets is best.

SoloMummy · 06/11/2020 07:16

I think that it does depend on what you are buying.

The fish is cheaper and no noticeable difference in quality from lidl or the main supermarkets.

Aldi veg, is variable quality in the same way that I have experienced similar in shops from Sainsbury's and morrisons. However never had an issue at other main supermarkets or lidl.

Lidl bakery is lovely, but sells out quickly.

I don't buy ready meals, so can not comment on these, but have had some of their prepared potato dishes and they're amazing and even though I love cooking their dauphinoise is way better than mine!

I save money if I shop at lidl. However, as with any supermarket, I can never get everything I need from one place, so always do sporadic shops elsewhere.

Defenbaker · 06/11/2020 00:23

I like Lidl but don't often do a big shop there. I like their fruit and veg, bakery products, select cheeses, crisps and chocolate. Some of their ready meals are good and I've also bought some great plants and cheap seeds in Lidl.

However, I recently shopped at a different Lidl store, and was disappointed because 2 packs of sliced fruit went mouldy in under 2 days (kept in fridge). One was on it's use by date, the other within it, but both were inedible. Due to Covid I didn't feel it was worth going back just to get a refund, but it has put me off going to that store again, as perhaps something is at fault in their chilled fruit section. No other problems with Lidl before though, in fact I've had some really tasty fruit from there.

WithIcePlease · 05/11/2020 23:45

Some of the stuff is definitely made in the same factory for both M and S and Aldi as said below. I knew someone who worked there. Can't remember all the brands made but often same mix but different shape
Also the newspaper story of couple who bought the Mediterranean veg in foil tray from Waitrose and it had Aldi instructions on the back
In my local Lidl/Aldi there was a bit of a commotion around the potatoes. An old chap had picked up potatoes that labelled as Sainsbury's and was worried he wouldn't be able to buy them.

I can't abide enormous supermarkets. 20 mins round the store is fab for me. Scratch cooking. Couldn't comment on anything preprepared

Dee1975 · 05/11/2020 23:15

I think with any supermarket there are good and bad lines.
I am a fan of their fresh fruit and veg and pasta sauces. Pizzas are great for the children’s and I actually prefer their hummus over tesco / Sainsburys. Great for children snacks. Not so keen on anything frozen. (Apart from ice cream). And they sell lacto free milk so much cheaper than others.
So some very good bits, but like all. Some not so good.

PurpleFlower1983 · 05/11/2020 23:06

We do Sainsbury’s online shopping but do sometimes shop in Aldi as my Nan likes to go every couple of weeks. Some of their stuff is great but on the whole I do prefer Sainsbury’s as I feel the quality is better.

Impatiens · 05/11/2020 23:01

I'm using Aldi a lot at the moment as it's definitely cheaper and there's quite a few things I like - butter, english mature cheddar, a couple of the ready meals and their chicken is good. Veg is always very poor quality to the point I've stopped buying as it's a false economy.

My main problem with Aldi is that it's such a depressing 'experience' - ours was closed for a fortnight for refurbishment but it still looks a mess with horrible lighting and items put in odd places. There's no self-service or even 10 item tills, everyone has to queue together and you have to put up with the till announcements every few seconds - as soon as I set foot in there I just can't wait to get out again, which seems to be their intention.

cakewench · 05/11/2020 23:01

I suppose I’m a food snob.

Aldi and Lidl are both excellent for cupboard staples. I do a lot of cooking from scratch and their ingredients are superb (oils, passata, olives etc).

Pre made items are very hit or miss. I find both shops have very decent frozen pizzas, but I’m not a fan of their dip selections (just as an example!)

I guess I’m saying, the cupboard staples, plus the meat and veg, are what keeps me shopping there, and I’ve discovered other things along the way. We do the vast majority of our shopping at Lidl now.

popcorndiva · 05/11/2020 22:34

Aldi's Roast Chicken in a bag is the best. I have tried all supermarket versions and still make a special trip to get it

Sydneylover1 · 05/11/2020 22:31

I haven’t read all the posts so forgive me if I’m repeating anything already said.

I’ve worked in the food industry for 20 years. I can’t comment on Lidl but I can say that certain fresh produce items (root veg) are exactly the same in Tesco, Waitrose & Aldi.

I can also say that certain baked items (think croissants & pain au chocolat) are actually better in Aldi than M&S due to the higher butter content. Aldi often team up with an M&S supplier as they know their technical standards are high but Aldi can demand a better product (at a cheaper price) as they ride on the back of M&S by not paying for the higher technical standards (it’s a considerable cost to be a M&S supplier).

The bottom line is try the products without pre-conceived ideas - you may be pleasantly surprised.

And, no, I don’t work for Aldi or any other supermarket or supermarket supplier now (currently in branded bakery) - this is just my personal opinion based on experience in this industry.

myhobbyisouting · 05/11/2020 22:19

I like Aldi but ours is a refurbished one too, their meat is good. Some things are absolutely shocking (tomato ketchup), I don't eat cereal and don't know what filled pasta is...

Lidl I like too, but the best place for veg is Morrison's around here

Timeforredwine · 05/11/2020 22:17

Cant complain, I've shopped Aldi & Lidl, always have good quality food and some great bargains, get so much more for your money too. Used to shop other supermarkets but dont bother anymore.

AliceMcK · 05/11/2020 22:09

I do my bulk shop at Aldi, the meat is better than my other local supermarket, Morrison’s. Definitely better than asda, I haven’t shopped at Sainsbury’s for a couple of years as everything I got was disappointing. I do shop at tescos too because I like some of their products. On the meat front tescos definitely have a better selection and better quality but a lot more expensive.

I find Aldi veg is fresher, again more selection at tescos but again more expensive. I’ve also found the fruit far nicer than some other supermarkets.

A lot of Aldi home branded stuff is definitely very good quality, but not everything. I was always sceptical as I like my branded food, but after giving Aldi stuff a go I’ve definitely converted with some things, I still like buying certain brands for some things though.

The only negative with Aldi is it can be limited in choice, but dose some good special buys.

PattyPan · 05/11/2020 22:02

@Facelikearustytractor I cook every meal from scratch but find Lidl doesn’t have the range I need. They have hardly any herbs & spices, the only dried pulses they sell are red lentils, they don’t sell bulgur wheat, spelt, barley, giant couscous, don’t regularly have tofu and so forth. Aldi and Lidl make the choice to have fewer items at cheaper prices but that’s less convenient for cooking from scratch because you have to go to bigger supermarkets to get the ingredients they don’t stock.

Marcelduchamp · 05/11/2020 21:51

I'm enjoying the digs a few posters are making implying I don't cook. Which would make me a terrible person obviously. However disappointingly we cook most of our meals from scratch. The day we tend not to is when we do a shop and are knackered. So then get pizza or gnocchi or similar. We don't use sauces and have loads of ready meals, I still find there's not the choice as a vegetarian although in the past year it has got way better as veganism has become more popular.

We do buy things like crackers, humus, crisps and cereal. Which are fairly ordinary purchases. It's those tyoe of things which I notice the difference on. They are obviously more prepared than ingredients. But are posters honestly telling me you're baking your own crackers for cheese and making your own cereal?

I am vegetarian / vegan so I do think if you eat any meat alternatives. Like quorn or oomph then there's a certain amount of processing involved in these foods. So sorry for not being a good non meat eater and only eating pulses.

OP posts: