Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quality at Aldi and Lidl

392 replies

Marcelduchamp · 05/11/2020 13:40

I know Aldi and Lidl are really popular on mumsnet but I really am completely baffled as to how people can claim its good quality. I have relatives who shop there and I have eaten the food lots of times. Yes a few items are OK but on the whole its not good in my experience. I don't eat meat so can't comment on that. I do think veg is veg so is probably not vastly different. I also think the choice is poor with a very basic selection of stuff.

I know it's cheap and we all need that at times. I'm not knocking people who need to cut shopping costs. But are people really being honest when they say the can't tell the difference. What are you tasting? Examples are the strong cheddar cheese is just bland, the crisps don't have much flavour and the filled pasta is cloying inside.

I suppose my AIBU is AIBU to day these shops sell poor quality food.

OP posts:
Chameleon72 · 05/11/2020 14:38

OP you mentioned bland crisps at Lidl, well I beg to differ on that particular point as there the most delicious, crunchiest and bang on flavour salt and vinegar crisps at Lidl. Do try the green bag ridged salt and vinegar natural crisps. At 85p for a big bag, they're a steal and far better than anything else IMHO

Charlottejade89 · 05/11/2020 14:37

I've shopped at aldi for almost 3 years now and I find the quality good. Even my partner cant taste the difference and he's way more of a food snob than I am. I usually freeze meatbif km not using it within the next 2 days anyway so it doesn't go off, love their baby range, the nappies and wipes are fab and I saved a fortune using their own brand formula when my dd was a baby. I can easily get a full weeks shopping for 3 if us for £50 or less, I wouldnt be able to afford to do anything else if I shopped at sainsburys as their prices are extortionate

Burnthurst187 · 05/11/2020 14:37

If something is cheap, it's for a reason

Saying that there are a few gems at Lidl. The freshly baked croissants are very nice and there's sausage rolls in a four pack (£1:89) which are just as good as Tesco's at a £1 more plus the coleslaw (89p) is the same as Tesco Finest

We also buy nappies and wipes from Lidl, can't fault them

Zilla1 · 05/11/2020 14:37

IMO, on the whole, the quality of the produce is much better than the Tesco equivalent even without taking in the price difference. I don't buy ready meals so am not commenting on them. I would tend to rate 'German' supermarket meat quality over UK-equivalent. Taking into account the price difference, the value proposition of Lidl/Aldi significantly exceeds Tesco. Someone can pick an individual item or try and compare a Lidl/Aldi 'value' line with a Tesco 'luxury' line but, to me, the value proposition so significantly exceeds Tesco that I suspect some of the threads are driven by paid marketing activity or by people who don't cook though I'm not accusing you here, OP. If it is paid marketing activity then I suspect it's ill-judged as most threads usually lead to positive comments.

EatTheHamTina · 05/11/2020 14:36

@Sexnotgender

You started being rude and judgemental about what I was eating.

Sorry what now?

I said filled pasta wasn’t my thing, and that’s rude and judgemental? What a weird leap you made there. It’s not my personal taste, I don’t give a fuck if you eat it morning noon and night I was just saying that I couldn’t comment on the quality as it’s not something I eat.

Fucking hell love, I’m out. Enjoy your filled pastaConfused

😂😂😂
Lovemusic33 · 05/11/2020 14:35

Different shops are good for different things.

Aldi...
Rump steak is great and good price.
Love their Christmas food.
Fruit and veg are reasonable
Pizza

Lidl..
Fish
Cheese (good selection)
Bakery items really good and cheap, something Aldi doesn’t have.

I do my main shop in Tesco’s (online) and then pop into Aldi or lidl mid week, I don’t think I could do a full shop in either because there’s some items I just can’t buy and there’s not as much choice. I do like the middle isles especially Aldi for craft items.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 05/11/2020 14:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

EatTheHamTina · 05/11/2020 14:33

I hate Aldi meat it's just so gross all the time. Taste disgusting.
I tried going there again the other week and once I had cooked a meal instantly regretted it.
Other stuff is okay like their own versions of Oreos, some cereals etc.

somelemons · 05/11/2020 14:33

@Whatwouldscullydo

I personally agree .

I'm.not fussy by a long shot, not loyal to many brands at all ,.just the standard Branston beans and heinz ketchup, other than that I'm not that fussed.

But I just don't get on with aldi or lidl. There r a few nice surprises yes and I certainly don't like everything all the time from the other supermarkets, but the fruit beg akd meat is the worst. Doesnt last at all. Tastes weird. Strange tatse/texture.

Their stock rotation in ours is awful its frequently mouldy on the shelf.

Do not get the hype. At all.

That must be your branch then, because the produce in our local Aldi is a fresh as a daisy, cheaper and better quality than either Tesco or Morrisons.
Slightlyunhinged · 05/11/2020 14:32

Sorry, fat fingers on my phone! I was going to say that would be the same anyway. The range of wooden toys they have in the middle are really good too.

HokeyWokey · 05/11/2020 14:31

I love Lidl bakery. I'm always disappointed by most of the other Aldi and Lidl products though.

Slightlyunhinged · 05/11/2020 14:30

I shop in Lidl and really like the quality. There's the odd thing I don't like, butt

andyoldlabour · 05/11/2020 14:30

We first used Lidl and Aldi in France and Germany about 20 years ago and they are brilliant quality. The quality in the UK is not as high, but still VGVFM. We prefer Aldi because of the quality of the meat, vegetables, fruit and wine, also cheese and cooked meats. The Aldi Cotes du Rhone Villages is £5.49 and IMO is the best wine from that region under a tenner.

LJC1234 · 05/11/2020 14:30

I'm a food snob to and I adore Lidl and Aldi food!

KitKatastrophe · 05/11/2020 14:30

@Duemarch2021

I agree... much prefer asda, sainsburys.. morrisons and tesco.. I'm not being a snob.. ive tried the stuff and its just not the same, fake versions of branded and they smell/taste chemically i think.. xx
All of them? All aldi versions of branded products taste chemically, but the asda versions dont? Half of them are probably made in the same factory 😂
OoohTheStatsDontLie · 05/11/2020 14:29

YABU I think.

There isnt much choice but that's kind of the whole point - I think most people have moved away from wanting large supermarkets with 20 choices of extra virgin olive oil and 15 types of mayo.

I wouldn't say quality is amazing but I wouldn't say quality is amazing in most supermarkets so I don't think there is actually much difference in taste but price is so much better that I think overall value is excellent.

I don't do a big shop on there as I am a keen cook and use a lot of specialist ingredients (that most supermarkets don't have, thinks like preserved lemons, beef ribs, brisket, French cheeses etc) but I do regularly go there for top ups and certain products are great. I really like the specially selected range which is comparable to most supermarket prices for their normal rage. I usually stock up on -
SS crackers, very rich and buttery
SS almond thins, my favourite biscuit
Chocolate, not high quality but better than Cadbury etc so a good every day chocolate
Coconut milk, much more creamy than normal brands
SS extra virgin olive oil
Fruit - I find the quality fine
SS cheese especially the aged parmesan and manchego, best I've had from all supermarkets including m and s and waitrose
SS Truffle salami
Yoghurts, cream, creme fraiche - quality is very good eg cream doesn't go too thick once open like m and s
SS pizzas - they regularly win pizza retailer of the year and I think they are decent and similar to the top supermarkets versions
Kids snacks. Mine don't complain that their wotsits etc arent the branded ones
Breaded KFC style chicken thighs and drumsticks- better than most supermarkets who keep the skin on which then goes rubbery under the crispy coating.
Smoked haddock which is always moist, skinless, no bones, and better than I've had from waitrose and sainsburys as thicker so easier to cook
Booze. I'll be honest I mainly go for the booze. It's so cheap and I like it. It regularly comes out fine in taste tests and individual items eg gin wins blind tasting awards.
Baking stuff. I am not sure most people will be able to tell the difference between different brands of sugar and flour etc.
SS granola - got a lot of nuts and berries and better than brands like jordans etc
Tonic - I cant tell the difference between branded tonic

I do agree their own brand crisps are a bit greasy though

I think it's like any supermarket - some things are a bit hit and miss and you have to go a few times before actually finding out what you like and what you don't

KitKatastrophe · 05/11/2020 14:29

@Sexnotgender

Any supermarket filled pasta is horrible, so YABU to use that an example.

Careful now, apparently it’s rude and judgmental not to like filled pasta😂

Oops. In that case, I would have thought the OP saying the one she had was cloying and bad quality was pretty rude and judgemental to people who do like aldi filled pasta
Duemarch2021 · 05/11/2020 14:29

I agree... much prefer asda, sainsburys.. morrisons and tesco.. I'm not being a snob.. ive tried the stuff and its just not the same, fake versions of branded and they smell/taste chemically i think.. xx

emmathedilemma · 05/11/2020 14:28

I've bought filled pasta from a number of places and always found it tasteless. I like Aldi for the fruit and veg and staples like oats, tinned tomatoes, tinned beans and pulses, rice, that type of thing. I don't buy a lot of ready made things so can't comment on how they compare but for fresh things and "store cupboard" essentials I think they match up to any of the big supermarkets. The only thing i refuse to buy from Aldi is bagels which are pretty terrible compared to the New York Bagel Co ones!

Gobbledygook20 · 05/11/2020 14:28

It is also freezing in Aldi. I like some of their Lacura skincare range though.

BIWI · 05/11/2020 14:27

I would happily do all my shopping in Aldi if I could get everything I want there - so I do my big shop there, then go to Sainsbury's, which is just up the road, to pick up anything I can't find in Aldi. Sadly our cats won't eat Aldi's cat food so I have to go to Sainsbury's for that.

I haven't had a problem with anything I've bought from Aldi, and their Specially Selected range in particular is very good. They have fantastic cheeses as well as their wine and spirits range.

TheDogsMother · 05/11/2020 14:27

I tried several cheeses from Lidl yesterday. They were from their Deluxe range and I was very impressed. Roquefort and Somerset cheddar were excellent. I only buy very specific things from Lidl and Aldi though and wouldn't bother with most meats or ready meal type things. They are great for olives, roasted peppers in jars, cornichons etc.

lazylinguist · 05/11/2020 14:27

Can you give any other examples of food you thought was bad quality, OP? So, you said not meat, not fruit and veg? Are you talking about mostly processed stuff then? Tbh I think all supermarket filled pasta is pretty meh. Aldi do a number of different Cheddars. There's a mature one in a black packet that is pretty strong and very good. You just have to find the things you like, as you would in any shop that's new to you.

My DM has the same opinion about Aldi as you do. But when she eats at our house, she will often say "Ooh that's nice, where's it from?!" and it's invariably Aldi. She says their coffee is ' so disgusting that I threw it away', but she only tried buying one of their types of coffee, and she likes the one we buy there. Hmm

Dh and I are very keen cooks and appreciate good food. There are a few things we can't or prefer not to get in Aldi, but luckily there's a Booths next door. Doing the vast majority of the shop in Aldi saves us a fortune!

RaspberryCoulis · 05/11/2020 14:27

I am "completely baffled" as to how people can neatly put every single item sold by any particular supermarket into neat little categories. It's wrong to say every single product which Aldi sells is cheap crap. It's similarly wrong to say every single item in Sainsbury's s much better quality.

There's lots we like in Aldi. I love the oak smoked cheddar, the Moser Roth chocolate, pasta, noodles. DH likes their cooked meats like chorizo and parma ham. Kids like their crisps and "magnum" style chocolate ice creams. We weren't too keen on the yoghurts we tried, the tea bags, or the cereal.

Some people - as that Eat Well for Less programme shows - are very loyal to brands/shops and have such preconceptions about certain products that they convince themselves that they will absolutely be able to tell a cheaper substitute. It's only when they put stuff in plain packaging and the people are forced to judge each product on its merits without any pre-conceived notions about brands and shops that you see it's not so easy to tell.

ilovemydogandMrObama · 05/11/2020 14:27

Depends - Aldi is great for some items such as free range chicken, cheeses, chocolate, tinned tomatoes, wines, but you can't do a complete shop there, so you have to pick and choose.

Swipe left for the next trending thread