Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quality at Aldi and Lidl

392 replies

Marcelduchamp · 05/11/2020 13:40

I know Aldi and Lidl are really popular on mumsnet but I really am completely baffled as to how people can claim its good quality. I have relatives who shop there and I have eaten the food lots of times. Yes a few items are OK but on the whole its not good in my experience. I don't eat meat so can't comment on that. I do think veg is veg so is probably not vastly different. I also think the choice is poor with a very basic selection of stuff.

I know it's cheap and we all need that at times. I'm not knocking people who need to cut shopping costs. But are people really being honest when they say the can't tell the difference. What are you tasting? Examples are the strong cheddar cheese is just bland, the crisps don't have much flavour and the filled pasta is cloying inside.

I suppose my AIBU is AIBU to day these shops sell poor quality food.

OP posts:
ByGrabtharsHammerWhatASavings · 05/11/2020 16:26

We're feeling the pinch atm so I went to lidl instead of asda for some basics yesterday and honestly I barely even found it any cheaper. The selection was much worse, and I didn't even really felt like I saved money. Definitely won't be bothering again. And yes to whoever said its useless for vegan stuff. Mind you, I'm sure asda has got more expensive recently as well. Every week it feels like my shopping bill gets higher and higher and we really eat pretty frugally, own brand everything, cook from scratch, hardly ever buy alcohol or treat food etc. I'm really dreading a brexit price hike.

Unicorners · 05/11/2020 16:23

I don't find Aldi fruit and veg lasts well, but I really like their meat. The specially selected products are good too. Our closest big name supermarket is a Tesco and I find most of their own brand stuff absolutely awful!

JaJaDingDong · 05/11/2020 16:21

@PattyPan

I used to shop at Lidl because it's the closest supermarket to my house but stopped this year because the quality had really gone downhill on a lot of the stuff we buy regularly. The final straw was when I had to throw away a whole bag of onions I'd bought on special that week because they were all bad inside - even though they were only 29p that was 29p wasted.

We're currently eating up the value porridge oats I'd bought from Lidl and even cheapskate DP who is usually in favour of buying whatever is cheapest is complaining about them because there are loads of pieces of husk in there. I actually bought them because they're in a paper bag and I wanted to reduce our plastic waste but keep having to throw away inedible bowls of porridge instead!

I shop at Sainsburys now...

Make flapjack!!

PattyPan · 05/11/2020 16:17

Also I'm vegan and Lidl is utterly crap for vegans. I only go in there to buy the Linda McCartney sausages now.

PattyPan · 05/11/2020 16:16

I used to shop at Lidl because it's the closest supermarket to my house but stopped this year because the quality had really gone downhill on a lot of the stuff we buy regularly. The final straw was when I had to throw away a whole bag of onions I'd bought on special that week because they were all bad inside - even though they were only 29p that was 29p wasted.

We're currently eating up the value porridge oats I'd bought from Lidl and even cheapskate DP who is usually in favour of buying whatever is cheapest is complaining about them because there are loads of pieces of husk in there. I actually bought them because they're in a paper bag and I wanted to reduce our plastic waste but keep having to throw away inedible bowls of porridge instead!

I shop at Sainsburys now...

Frostedlantern · 05/11/2020 16:14

I used to think like this, but I tried a few more things and now can honestly say that a lot of Aldi's food is really good. A few things I wouldn't buy from there, but most really is excellent.

However I stopped shopping there during lockdown 1. It was just much easier to go to the big Sainsbury's.

teraculum29 · 05/11/2020 16:13

I am Aldi and Lidl shopper,mainly is a good quality of foods, but I can agree Lidl crisps have change, and they dont have much flavour, prefer Aldi's one.

Aldi is cheap because have less choice.

ChronicallyCurious · 05/11/2020 16:12

YANBU - vegan here so we do our ‘basics’ at Aldi eg veg, breads, stuff such as hummus, tinned stuff like chickpeas, lentils and kidney beans and chips and then I go over to Tesco and buy my soya milk, cheese and meat substitutes there.

CoffeeandCroissant · 05/11/2020 16:11

In Scotland the meat at both is decent (for a supermarket) and lots of their produce (including most if not all meat) is sourced from Scotland. Fruit and veg varies but mostly fine. Some good wine and beer selections particularly in Aldi. Scottish milk, including organic. Most cheese is decent, Feta, Manchego etc. Not had the cheddar for a while but the Scottish cheddar was fine from what I remember. Maybe not as good as some at Waitrose or M&S but God enough for most purposes. Own brand chocolate is good.

Have never tried this crisps or filled pasta at either. Probably depends a lot on what you buy and you do tend to stick with the stuff that you know from experience is decent.

I have been to Lidls in several countries and a lot of the produce is identical everywhere (e.g. things like nuts, which are also good quality and value) the main difference is the locally sourced stuff. Romania and Poland had carp for example, Lidl in Poland had a great selection of French cheese for some reason, was also much nicer than the Tesco in Poland which was like a 1980's time warp Tesco from the UK. Lidl in Barcelona had Iberico pork. Worst Lidls I have been to were in Paris and in Germany (surprisingly).

ButterflyOfFreedom · 05/11/2020 16:10

I will not hear a bad word against Aldi!! Ha, I love it!
I find it extremely good value for money and their items are good quality imo.
I'm saving at least a third compared to the big supermarkets and am not missing out on flavour, taste, quality at all.

Marcelduchamp · 05/11/2020 16:09

@YouKidsIsCrazy

I'm talking about overall quality which is objective. Something either tastes nice or it doesn't

I mean, look at this for stupidity. As if taste is objective! How ignorant and arrogant do you have to be to think that if you don't like the taste of something it is objectively not good?
Laughable

In terms of ignorance I'm not the one calling a stranger stupid on the Internet over their supermarket questions. Just reflect that for a moment.
OP posts:
movingonup20 · 05/11/2020 16:09

The veg shelf life is definitely compromised at Aldi (Lidl is fine and they sell loose veg) cheese etc is better at Aldi than Lidl in my opinion and is as good as supermarket own brand (not deli section) but you do get what you pay for, the local butchers meat is superior but twice the price

JanewaysBun · 05/11/2020 16:08

Yanbu!
The biscuit knock offs are not as good nor the mayo.
The fruit is ok
The meat varies (although the only place I think the meat is v tasty is Waitrose butcher)

I class it the same quality as asda, below sainsbos (which I like) and then wait rose is nicest.

However they do a lot of pickle type things I like so excited to get one on my high st next year!

BIWI · 05/11/2020 16:05

@EmpressoftheMundane

I quite like their fresh fruit and veg. I think their beef and sausages are good too. I will buy their free range chicken, but not their regular (same applies to Waitrose for me though.) I think their cheese and dairy are also good. Their nuts, crisps, dried fruit and sliced bread are all also good. I like their chocolate and tinned tomatoes too.

I don’t buy their wine, cider or spirits. I don’t buy their ready meals, I don’t like their frozen stuff with the exception of hallumi fries, skin on fries, and frozen fruit for smoothies.

Their is a lot of tempting crap in the middle aisle. Avoid! Their plastic trash sacks are good, and so is their loo roll, but a lot of their cleaning supplies are so-so. I just nip to Home Bargains for branded cleaning soaps.

I buy my fresh fish / seafood, pasta (it has to be DeCecco) organic yogurt, unpasteurised butter and eggs at Waitrose. Along with any alcohol and KP nuts (husband claims to notice a difference.)

You're missing a trick not buying your wine from Aldi - and I really doubt your husband would notice a difference! They have a lot of award-winning wines that are fantastic value for money. (And spirits for that matter too)
Marcelduchamp · 05/11/2020 16:04

@YouKidsIsCrazy

but I really am completely baffled as to how people can claim its good quality

It Is good quality. They win endless awards in blind taste tests by experts, who certainly know more than you.

Clearly you're one of those people who is easily swayed by branding and thinks things taste better if they cost more. That's sad, but don't do all the faux confusion and putting down people who have more taste and are savvy shoppers.

Wow people are really protective of their choices of supermarket. Why so aggressive? That's not normal to be this angry about a question regarding supermarkets.

Also I don't buy branded products really

OP posts:
MillieVanilla · 05/11/2020 16:03

I shop at Aldi majority of the time, although I do go once a fortnight to the Morrisons thats next door to it to have a look for yellow sticker items.
I find the veg doesn't last as long but I grow a lot of my own now anyway, but the meat is great.
I think perhaps it's how you cook with the bits you buy. I buy basics but I have a cupboard full of herbs, spices and other bits and bobs which change a very basic meal into something far nicer.
I also make my own cooking sauces too as I was horrified with what added salt and sugar is in even the posher brand cooking sauces.
But I think the quality is brilliant.

YouKidsIsCrazy · 05/11/2020 15:54

I'm talking about overall quality which is objective. Something either tastes nice or it doesn't

I mean, look at this for stupidity. As if taste is objective! How ignorant and arrogant do you have to be to think that if you don't like the taste of something it is objectively not good?
Laughable

YouKidsIsCrazy · 05/11/2020 15:52

but I really am completely baffled as to how people can claim its good quality

It Is good quality. They win endless awards in blind taste tests by experts, who certainly know more than you.

Clearly you're one of those people who is easily swayed by branding and thinks things taste better if they cost more. That's sad, but don't do all the faux confusion and putting down people who have more taste and are savvy shoppers.

MusicWithRocksIn1t · 05/11/2020 15:49

I use lidl weekly. I think a lot of their stuff is great and prefer their fruit and veg to tescos stuff. I don't eat meat and they sometimes have a good meat free range although normally I don't eat fake meat either.
I agree their crisps arent that great but you can get main brands there quite cheaply.
I cook almost all our meals from scratch so think they are great. My nearest lidl is in a retail park with an Iceland and a home bargains so between the 3 I can get most things I want. I love their olives and their humus.

That being said I've noticed huge quality variations between different lidl stores and I always check the fruit and veg thoroughly before buying it.

butterpuffed · 05/11/2020 15:46

I wouldn’t go near the Lidl bakery, in my local one I’ve seen flies on the doughnuts

It's their 'go to' supermarket, they never could get the hang of the Waitrose 'one in one out' procedure

Whoooootaminute · 05/11/2020 15:42

I think different stores have varying levels of quality. There are a few of each Lidl and Aldi within a short drive and the store cleanliness/stock availability varies. Maybe some managers are more on top of stock rotation and presentation etc.

I am a fussy bugger when it comes to food but find that I can get a great shop from (my favourite) Aldi and Lidl.

The greek style natural yogurt is delicious (and waaaay cheaper than Fage), meats have always been fine - as has the fresh fish. I buy frozen berries for our porridge - it's much cheaper than the main supermarkets and possibly better quality. The only thing I don't buy much of in there is booze as we only like certain beers and spirits. The wines are sometimes good though.

Despite prices rising over this past few months I still feel less unhappy with my shopping bill when I have been to Aldi .

OhDearMuriel · 05/11/2020 15:42

Hmm very damning for someone who doesn't even shop there.

I can't comment so much on Lidl, but Aldi is excellent.

I never buy steak anywhere else (the same goes for lots of things - but I haven't got time to list them on here).

Perhaps you should do your own research before commenting and not go by what your relatives feed you.

Compared to the average supermarket you'll save approximately 30% on costs - do that calculation over a year.

NannyGythaOgg · 05/11/2020 15:42

@Marcelduchamp
I'm talking about overall quality which is objective. Something either tastes nice or it doesn't.

Quality isn't totally objective as different people will have different criteria but I agree there is an element of objectivity
But
Taste is extremely almost totally subjective - no 2 people will totally agree on what tastes good and what doesn't.

LadyOfTheImprovisedBath · 05/11/2020 15:40

The fruit and veg always seems to go off quicker than other supermarkets.

Fruit and some veg - I agree. I think the Aldi we used to live close to was better for them than one we currently leave near. Not notice it with Lidi.

Lots of things I do like about Aldi - their chocolate is now some of the best out there. There cheese seems great to me.

I don't always liek everything in other supermarkets - I think pasta sauces in Asda ranges taste too artificially sweet for us. Since lockdown we occaionally used Morrisons and there been things there we haven't always though great other items we've prefered to our more usual Tesco and Sainsbury's.

EvilPea · 05/11/2020 15:37

Yeah I agree. Crisps are crap and bananas, what do they do with them? It’s like they’ve gone 40 rounds with mike Tyson