Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel violated by a smear test?

238 replies

Jericoo · 27/10/2020 03:21

I had a smear test for the first time today. Although I understand the importance and had thoroughly researched the procedure, I cannot sleep at the moment as I feel so violated.

The doctor was wonderful, answered all of my questions and she took things slowly as she knew I was nervous. Does the feeling of being violated go away? It wasn't painful or even that embarrassing in the end, but the feeling of having something shoved in your hoo-ha by someone you've just met is not pleasant.

I am worried this will become a complex and I will avoid having it done again in 3 years as the way I feel now is so horrid, I am in tears. I know someone who had to have a hysterectomy at 30 because of cervical cancer, so it's very important to me to not develop a fear of this.

Does anyone have any tips on how to overcome the feeling of violation?

OP posts:
MoonJelly · 27/10/2020 08:17

@pinkonions

I really strongly believe that if men had to undergo something like this, an alternative, less invasive method would have been found decades ago.
My understanding is that a prostate examination - which also involves an internal examination - is no fun at all but the method has stayed the same for at least a hundred years.
flaviaritt · 27/10/2020 08:15

So sorry you feel this way. This is not to say your feeling is in any way wrong, but try to remember that you asked them to do it and it was your free choice. That might help. They’re not fun, but they’re not compulsory either.

Branleuse · 27/10/2020 08:14

Ive had loads of smear tests and internals and tbh, I think this feeling of violation is worse the more times goes on. Last time I had to have internal scan, I was so upset. I cant think of any particularly traumatic experiences that would have meant it makes me feel so bad, but it just gets worse.
Yes i could probably do with some sort of therapeutic talking it over, but where the hell do you get that on the NHS now

Al1langdownthecleghole · 27/10/2020 08:12

I’m sorry that you feel like this. As you have recognised, It’s an important procedure but never an enjoyable one, and for some women its painful and traumatic.

I won’t post about the mechanics of the procedure, because I don’t want to feed people who read these boards for their particular enjoyment, but honestly OP, break the steps down of what actually happened to you and I promise you your feelings are not “off” at all.

So what to do? Firstly remember it is an optional procedure. As PP have said, there are alternatives but also do your own risk assessment. People who have had few sexual partners and whose partners have had few partners are at a lower risk of HPV, this doesn’t mean you can ignore screening opportunities, but you could choose a more dignified method.

Secondly, valid though your feeling are it would be OK to talk to an HCP or counsellor if it would help to reduce your negative feelings and gain a sense of control.

And it’s also OK to treat yourself. It’s not a nice procedure, so you are entitled to reward yourself afterwards.

GetOffYourHighHorse · 27/10/2020 08:12

'really strongly believe that if men had to undergo something like this, an alternative, less invasive method would have been found decades ago.'

Men do have also intimate examinations like sigmoidoscopies and colonoscopies.

In decades to come they'll look back at our medical procedures with the same horror that we look back at practices in Victorian times.

LittleTiger007 · 27/10/2020 08:12

@MaryShelley1818 I thought you were perfectly kind and reasonable with your comments.

PanamaPattie · 27/10/2020 08:11

You feel violated because you were. It’s not surprising when you are asked to remove your underwear in front of a stranger, who then cranks you open with a cold instrument, shoves a bottle brush up you and twirls it like they are cleaning a toilet. You may be left bleeding and in pain. If this rare cancer affected men, there would be a simple urine or blood test, as I’m sure many men wouldn’t agree to having cells scraped off from the end of their penis. Women are expected to put up with it.

Janaih · 27/10/2020 08:07

I've had a couple of upsetting ones, they do stick in your mind but the feelings of panic and shame do fade with time. Closing your eyes and practicing relaxing breathing can really help, as can having something nice planned for the following days.

It's always worth asking when you make the appointment for a sympathetic nurse. A friend of mine gets a valium on prescription to take for the procedure. Flowers

pinkonions · 27/10/2020 08:04

I really strongly believe that if men had to undergo something like this, an alternative, less invasive method would have been found decades ago.

Namechangeforthis88 · 27/10/2020 08:04

Tip for everyone who finds smear tests difficult

Ask to hold and insert the speculum ("crank") yourself.

I find them very difficult and a nurse offered me this option. Made a whole world of difference. She still does the swab. And she advised treat yourself to a sticky bun afterwards. It's almost clinically indicated to treat yourself afterwards.

pinkonions · 27/10/2020 08:03

Namechanged for this.

OP you are not alone. I had my first smear in my 20s. It was done by a male doctor and really hurt. A few weeks later I had to have it done again (by the same doctor). I felt traumatised and treated like a bit of meat.

I haven't had one since. My hands sweat just thinking about it. I did some research and decided that as I was very low risk and because of the issues with false positives that I would not have another. I am now almost 60.

I didn't know about the HPV postal test though and will look into that.

Nailgirl · 27/10/2020 08:02

I had a first smear 20 years ago as a virgin - I didn’t have sex until years later. My GP practice at the time insisted -so my first experience of something up my vagina was a light shining, being pulled apart with a cold metal implement and then the nurse was very uncaring - she scrapped and scrapped and told me it looked funny and was pointing the wrong way (!) and made out my cervix wasn’t normal - She even put her fingers in and said I had a tilted uterus and that would make it difficult to get pregnant etc, for me as a naive 20 year old it was damaging mentally and physically and yes I had counselling - people swing around the word counselling as a ‘cure’ for trauma - I still remember it - it affects me less as I get older but when I told my mum years later I remember how horrified she was that she had encouraged me. You are ok and justified in your feelings. It is a violating procedure. It is hideous. For me it is not pleasant. Don’t let anyone minimise how you feel.

Shiverywinterbottom · 27/10/2020 08:02

*and not particularly pleasant that should say

Shiverywinterbottom · 27/10/2020 08:01

My mother never had a smear. She died 3 months ago of cervical cancer. Watching her die of cancer was far more traumatic for me than any smear test has ever been.
Nobody forced you into it, you made an informed choice and did so knowing the benefits outweighed the negatives. The first one is always the worst and yes it’s invasive and not particularly unpleasant, but maybe you should try changing your thought process to empower yourself into realising that your procedure may just save your life one day.

MathsRocksMathsRocks · 27/10/2020 08:01

It really does make a difference who does them, too. The worst two I've ever had were by female GPs (we don't have practice nurses, and my surgery is a 2 minute walk away, so it's easier to go there). They were very much of the 'we're all girls, there's worse than this when you have a baby' kind of thought.

The best experiences I've ever had were with the lovely male GP who, quite by luck', ended up looking after me when I had a MC nearly 30 years ago. For some reason I trusted him to do my smears, and he did them fantastically. Never uncomfortable, never demeaning to me, never 'pull yourself together, you've had babies' or anything like that.

In fact, he thanked me at my final one (we grew old together!) for choosing him because he said it's sometimes hard for male GPs to get enough practice when women automatically often choose a female practitioner. And his wife was a midwife too, so maybe he had some understanding through her too. He said that many (sadly not all) male GPs are very aware that - precisely because they're NOT women - they need to be more gentle and less patronising. He was also very aware that women have to go through so much stuff that is invasive in their lives compared to men.

I hope you will go back next time, OP. Hopefully you can build up a relationship with the practitioner who did it the first time, and go from there. But you're perfectly entitled to feel as you feel. Good luck. Flowers

AuntieMarys · 27/10/2020 07:59

I had an internal examination at 9, and was given no clue by the doctor or my mother as to what would happen. I have dreaded my regular smear ever since, but always explain to the nurse why.
I felt violated when a consultant decided he would remove a polyp " while he was down there" without telling me. I went into actual shock.

Zeitgei5t · 27/10/2020 07:58

Hi OP, I also had a traumatic first smear, turns out I have a posterior cervix and both the nurse and the student nurse couldn't find it. The nurse had a good rummage around in there to the point I was nearly passing out before she went and got the doctor to do it.
Took me till I had kids before I went back, as i argued to myself that the responsibility to not get cancer outweighed the trauma.
Made sure I booked direct with the doctor (as the nurse had said the doctor has to do mine, though this involved a short argument with the receptionist).
Explained the situation to the doctor when I arrived, who was understanding. It was still unpleasant but I did the breathing techniques you do when in labour and got through it easier.
I made sure I'd booked the afternoon off work too so I could go home and sit wrapped in a blanket with a cup of tea and some chocolate before I picked the kids up.

Kamt · 27/10/2020 07:55

I think one can feel violated by anything. For me smears are a bit tricky but mostly i struggle with dental appointments. Theres no particular reason, no trauma or back story.
dental trigger warning
My last but one appointment was horrid (it gets better i promise!) It was simply for an xray, but the combination of people in my space, having to accept something when i wanted to shout "back off" meant that i had to be collected by my other half and couldnt talk for an hour, and later had flashbacks to sitting sobbing waiting for the people to tell me i could move. I may have also bit my dentist Blush. I like to think of my self as a calm collected person so i was absolutely horrified by the whole loss of control thing

However when i had a follow up appointment i did lots of things which really helped. The appointment itself required more work which should have been worse but honestly it was fine. The dental assistant didnt even realise i was the same biter from before. For me the key was to ask for more time (and breaks), better sleep the night before, proper food and fluid, listening to music, having my oh chat to me throughout, some breathing techniques and grounding techniques.

For me i need to feel in control, and proper preparation totally changed how i felt.

Shmithecat2 · 27/10/2020 07:55

I don't feel violated at such, but I do feel terribly emotional and upset afterwards. I know that they save lives (and indeed did save mine 20 years ago, CIN2 cells found in my womb), but it always feels so degrading. That may not sound rational, but that's how I feel. You're not alone OP.

Doingitaloneandproud · 27/10/2020 07:54

@Frenchsticks

You weren't violated. You consented to a medical procedure and the medical professionals treated with completely appropriately and with respect. All of this is the exact opposite of violating you. So if you feel violated, that is a psychological issue, not a physical one. I doubt there are many women who can say they enjoy getting a smear and for many they are actually quite painful so I fully understand hating getting it done. But you were not violated and you do need to readjust your thinking to understand your feelings because if you convince yourself that you have been a victim of something then you're traumatising yourself further completely unnecessarily and the more you focus on that train of thought, the more you'll convince yourself that something along those line did happen and the less likely you'll be to go again. You say it's important to you to go again in future; you understand why they're important and you want the peace of mind that comes with having them done (which is why we all put ourselves through it). And the previous posts on here trying to suggest you simply don't need to go again are not particularly helpful given you've already acknowledged that you want to be able to go again and not give into these feelings. So calm down, think about what actually happened and point out to yourself exactly what you felt at what point and what you think contributed to that. Did it bring back memories of past abuse? Was it 'just' the feeling that felt so wrong? Did you have preconceptions before you went in? Was it the clinical environment? The fact that the nurse was wearing so much ppe which can make it feel very odd? Only you can know but do try to make some sense of your feelings and if you can't manage it on your own then yes, speaking to your GP for help with that is certainly a better alternative than spending the rest of your life potentially feeling like you were violated (which means abused). I'm not trying to minimise your feelings; I completely understand that people do feel very traumatised after a smear for various reasons; but you actually had, for all intents and purposes a positive experience physically so you need to address the psychological reasons as to why you now feel the way you do to not let those feelings overwhelm you. Good luck OP.
This. It's a medical procedure, an invasive one of course - no one would ever say its not, but its not a violation. You choose to have smear tests done, if you don't want to that's your decision. I would always recommend you do though. I've had multiple colposcopy's and a LLETZ procedure, then had a hemorrhage after where I had to be packed to stop the bleeding, all due to having abnormal cells.

I would talk to the doctor about how you are feeling, do you think it may help to have someone else with you when you have them performed?

XEbonyrose1X · 27/10/2020 07:51

I had my first last week. I put it off for ages. But it's over now. It is embarrassing. O was worried because I spot alot at the moment. I thought oh no what if there's bloody discharge down there.

Every women will worry about something different. It's normal. We are taught to cover our bits up from being young. They are private etc.

I don't know what to say to help. But it's just medical and not sexual. I had swabs done too and they rang me yesterday to say the lab damaged them and I need them redoing. It's so hard being a women at times. But you've had it done. Don't worry about three years away. Confidence and anxiety changes all the time. It does in me anyway. Some days I think I can't do that. Others I think I can do it.

Just try and forget it now.

cologne4711 · 27/10/2020 07:50

@Gremlinsateit

Feeling violated IS psychological, and hardly surprising when you’re talking about lying down partially clad in front of a relative stranger, who then inserts a speculum into a body area you’ve been heavily socialised to think of as absolutely private since your earliest years. Add the pain factor, which is worse for some women than others, and there is nothing odd or extreme about this reaction.
I agree 100%.

It's not unreasonable to feel that way OP - it's a horrible procedure. I felt like it the first time I had it too and I'd not had any bad experiences sexually.

Diadora30 · 27/10/2020 07:48

I hate them. My heart is always pounding when it’s performed and I kind of leave my body if you know what I mean? Also, I find it incredibly painful. But I had to have a lletz procedure years ago, so had to have follow up smears regularly.

Kenworthington · 27/10/2020 07:47

Haven’t rtft sorry but I always feel the same too op. I had a very ‘violent’ and traumatic birth with my first baby and I think this takes me back to it. I had mine done last week and I dreaded it and ended up in tears and everything. The nurse was lovely end as gentle as she could be but yeah I feel violated every time too so you have my sympathies

dolphinpose · 27/10/2020 07:46

@TurkMama - thank you. I had no idea this existed. I will look it up.