Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel violated by a smear test?

238 replies

Jericoo · 27/10/2020 03:21

I had a smear test for the first time today. Although I understand the importance and had thoroughly researched the procedure, I cannot sleep at the moment as I feel so violated.

The doctor was wonderful, answered all of my questions and she took things slowly as she knew I was nervous. Does the feeling of being violated go away? It wasn't painful or even that embarrassing in the end, but the feeling of having something shoved in your hoo-ha by someone you've just met is not pleasant.

I am worried this will become a complex and I will avoid having it done again in 3 years as the way I feel now is so horrid, I am in tears. I know someone who had to have a hysterectomy at 30 because of cervical cancer, so it's very important to me to not develop a fear of this.

Does anyone have any tips on how to overcome the feeling of violation?

OP posts:
Lolalovesmarmite · 27/10/2020 08:37

I’m very sorry for all those out there who have had bad experiences. I’ve never had a bad smear but I didn’t feel able to book one for a long time as a result of PTSD after rape.

I spoke to the very kind practice nurse about it during an appointment for something else and she was incredible. She spoke to the doctor and they wrote me up for some diazepam, which I took beforehand, and then she did the smear herself and was as kind and gentle as possible. She talked me through the whole thing and checked I was ok to continue every step of the way. I was still in floods of tears and shaking like a leaf but it was actually a really positive experience because of her kindness and because I felt in control. That experience made me able to deal with examinations during labour and also subsequent smears.

These sorts of threads worry me because if they put off one person who may otherwise have booked their smear, then it could ultimately cost that one person their life.

Please, if you are frightened, consider phoning your GP practice and asking if you can speak to the nurse about it. If they’re kind and happy to take the time to allay your fears over the phone, then they’re probably going to be the same when it comes to the test. Alternatively, I’ve also had mine before in a local GUM clinic because I didn’t feel comfortable with the GP practice I was with at the time. You do have options.

PicsInRed · 27/10/2020 08:37

@GetOffYourHighHorse

'My understanding is that a prostate examination - which also involves an internal examination - is no fun at all but the method has stayed the same for at least a hundred years.'

'No, they've got a simple blood test for that now.'

Rectal examinations are still routinely carried out.

Nobody likes being intimately examined by strangers but you've got to remember the alternative, advanced disease, is much much worse.

But not routinely for screening. Smears are carried out on asymptomatic women to screen at a population level, rather than on a symptomatic women to ensure her health. Screening should be a noninvasive as possible to minimise the harm vs the benefit to the patient in front of you. That clearly is not the case with smear screening vs a urine test.
Christmasfairy2020 · 27/10/2020 08:36

I take my kids to mine as I'm.one for encouraging things etc. No issue

FlamingoQueen · 27/10/2020 08:36

I find smears extremely painful nowadays (post menopause- brought on by cancer treatment). However, on my last one the nurse tried a small speculum which helped enormously and she’s put a note on my records. Because I was so distressed, she felt awful so I ended up giving her a hug and saying I was okay (pre COVID)!
My ds recently had her first ever smear (aged over 40) and found out she had stage 1 cancer so it is really important they are done.
My suggestion would be to ask for a nurse that is used to doing the tests and to practise some breathing techniques. I think the right nurse would make you feel less violated. It is a horrible exam, but done right, it’s just a medical procedure.

BumbleFlump · 27/10/2020 08:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

pinkonions · 27/10/2020 08:35

We don't get to consent to smear tests. We are told we have to have them done. We don't have a choice in it tbh

It's interesting to compare these NHS pages. PSA page gives the pros and cons and makes it clear there is a choice, which the cervical screening page doesn't.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/prostate-cancer/should-i-have-psa-test/

www.nhs.uk/conditions/cervical-screening/

tomandmigg · 27/10/2020 08:34

My top tip is to replay the memory, let it be full colour, from your point of view and as detailed as possible. Then imagine the colour fades to black and white, and the perspective goes from first person to third, so watching outside of yourself. Then change from 3D to 2D and then imagine the memory getting smaller.

You need a nice quiet space to do this, and if you do it once a day for a week or so, you should find the memory stings a lot less.

Good luck.

GetOffYourHighHorse · 27/10/2020 08:34

'My understanding is that a prostate examination - which also involves an internal examination - is no fun at all but the method has stayed the same for at least a hundred years.'

'No, they've got a simple blood test for that now.'

Rectal examinations are still routinely carried out.

Nobody likes being intimately examined by strangers but you've got to remember the alternative, advanced disease, is much much worse.

Fightthebear · 27/10/2020 08:33

Of course you don’t have to have a smear test, there’s no obligation.

All screening programmes are a choice.

WomenAndVulvas · 27/10/2020 08:33

Smear tests are unpleasant, but this level of anxiety around them is exaggerated and it's not helpful to say "that's perfectly normal, you have to live with those feelings, you can't help the way you feel".
Yes, you can help the way you feel and you don't need to live with this level of anxiety. You can get help to relieve the stress and anxiety you feel about a medical procedure, there is no need to suffer. You will never enjoy smear tests, no one does, but you will be able to have them without feeling this way. Speak to a professional OP and get some help.

PicsInRed · 27/10/2020 08:32

@pinkonions

I really strongly believe that if men had to undergo something like this, an alternative, less invasive method would have been found decades ago.
Thankfully, a home urine test is coming. Another article quoted delivery in 3 years (from 2019).

And you're absoutely right. The ONLY reason they've done this is that 25% of women now refuse smears, they were perfectly happy with some women experiencing pain and re-trauma before and for women to be hurt by smear takers doing a bad job, and by "discomfort"
Hmm and "embarrassment". They were happy to bully and berate instead of doing what it turns out was entirely possible all along ... an HPV urine test. Still the narrative of the silly whiny women remains. Oh well. We got there in the end. Hmm

news.sky.com/story/home-urine-testing-kit-could-make-cervical-cancer-smear-test-obsolete-11854461

TreestumpsAndTrampolines · 27/10/2020 08:32

Pre-kids I found smear tests painful, but the nurses doing them were always so comforting, and practical, that I felt OK having them.

With my first child though, I went to the mid-wife close to term, and got one that I didn't really have a rapport with, and she announced I should have an internal to check my cervix. I thought it would be fine, but actually, even though it didn't hurt much, I had to go to the toilets for a cry afterwards, I don't even know why, I just felt so violated by it (I wasn't particularly emotional in pregnancy - it was definitely the internal). I didn't feel that way about the ones I had when I was actually in labour for some reason.

TLDR: Sometimes, something, that you can't even put your finger on can make something traumatic, even when you've done similar before and weren't expecting it to be a problem.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 27/10/2020 08:32

We don't get to consent to smear tests. We are told we have to have them done. We don't have a choice in it tbh.
You CAN refuse them. You do have to give consent. It's your choice. Anyone can refuse.

I have never felt violated after smear and I had them since 16. That doesn't mean I am saying OP shouldn't. It's your feelings, they are all valid, however, maybe not 100% rational? So I would look into why you are feeling violated after procedure you agreed to. There may bre something deep down.

pinkonions · 27/10/2020 08:29

Sorry, not sure what went wrong there! I think it's because reading this thread is making me feel a bit trembly.

pinkonions · 27/10/2020 08:27

@GetOffYourHighHorse

'really strongly believe that if men had to undergo something like this, an alternative, less invasive method would have been found decades ago.'

Men do have also intimate examinations like sigmoidoscopies and colonoscopies.

In decades to come they'll look back at our medical procedures with the same horror that we look back at practices in Victorian times.

MillieVanilla yes, that's very similar to my experience. Horrible. Flowers
MrsMarrio · 27/10/2020 08:27

I was always very worried about having a smear, and only went when I was 26 as I had bleeding in between a period. All was fine. However I lost a baby at 22 weeks they were not sure if it was cervical incompetence or an Infection and so in my next pregnancy I had more speculums and ultrasound probes up there than I dare to count! And I just blocked them all out. They don't get easier or more comfortable. And I defiantly concur with others that it makes a massive difference who does it. Some are more painful than others and made me bleed afterwards and others were much easier. You've done the hardest part and actually went to your first smear! So many woman don't! I convinced my friend to go the week after having mine and it turned out she had CIN3 cells and now she always says I probably saved her life as she had no intention of going. Maybe talk professionally to someone to get to the root cause of why you do feel so strongly about this? I felt very empowered after having my first smear as I had dreaded it, put it off and thought 'god I've actually gone and done it!' However I did feel stressed, panicked and quite emotional whilst waiting for my results. It's a tricky thing but so important

joanwinifred · 27/10/2020 08:25

@Frenchsticks

You weren't violated. You consented to a medical procedure and the medical professionals treated with completely appropriately and with respect. All of this is the exact opposite of violating you. So if you feel violated, that is a psychological issue, not a physical one. I doubt there are many women who can say they enjoy getting a smear and for many they are actually quite painful so I fully understand hating getting it done. But you were not violated and you do need to readjust your thinking to understand your feelings because if you convince yourself that you have been a victim of something then you're traumatising yourself further completely unnecessarily and the more you focus on that train of thought, the more you'll convince yourself that something along those line did happen and the less likely you'll be to go again. You say it's important to you to go again in future; you understand why they're important and you want the peace of mind that comes with having them done (which is why we all put ourselves through it). And the previous posts on here trying to suggest you simply don't need to go again are not particularly helpful given you've already acknowledged that you want to be able to go again and not give into these feelings. So calm down, think about what actually happened and point out to yourself exactly what you felt at what point and what you think contributed to that. Did it bring back memories of past abuse? Was it 'just' the feeling that felt so wrong? Did you have preconceptions before you went in? Was it the clinical environment? The fact that the nurse was wearing so much ppe which can make it feel very odd? Only you can know but do try to make some sense of your feelings and if you can't manage it on your own then yes, speaking to your GP for help with that is certainly a better alternative than spending the rest of your life potentially feeling like you were violated (which means abused). I'm not trying to minimise your feelings; I completely understand that people do feel very traumatised after a smear for various reasons; but you actually had, for all intents and purposes a positive experience physically so you need to address the psychological reasons as to why you now feel the way you do to not let those feelings overwhelm you. Good luck OP.
We don't get to consent to smear tests. We are told we have to have them done. We don't have a choice in it tbh.
Shmithecat2 · 27/10/2020 08:25

@OnceUponAnEnzyme

That's awful, how disgustingly unprofessional of the nurse. I have to say, I've never had a 'bad' smear experience. But they still leave me feeling terribly down. I feel a bit tearful now just thinking about how they make me feel 😳

joanwinifred · 27/10/2020 08:24

@SuzieQQQ

Honestly I’d get some counselling. Why do you feel violated? From what you have said you were fully informed and treated with respect by the Dr. not sure how that equates to violation
Because it is an invasive and violating experience. Many women have this experience. If men had to go through this they would have figured out a non-invasive method already.
MillieVanilla · 27/10/2020 08:23

I've only had 1, I was 26 and the male doctor who did it (I assumed it would be a female nurse but no, wasn't warned or given the option just walked in and there he was) was quite rude. I asked him if he would be doing it and said I had expected a female for him to get all defensive and ask did I not feel he was qualified. He was also my regular GP so it was so embarrassing.
His attitude was that I had had a child now so should be used to people looking down there and told me to stop being so precious.
He was rough as hell and I felt very much like I'd been assaulted. I've nothing to compare it to as I've never had one since and I know that is really, really dreadful as I'm nearly 40 now but I feel physically sick when the reminder letter comes through. I've got as far as to make the appointment but I can't do it.
I think with your experience, it will be less difficult to face it again as you had someone who sounds lovely and professional.
But no one has the right to say how you should or shouldn't feel, and one person's simple procedure is another's absolute nightmare

pinkonions · 27/10/2020 08:23

@GetOffYourHighHorse

'really strongly believe that if men had to undergo something like this, an alternative, less invasive method would have been found decades ago.'

Men do have also intimate examinations like sigmoidoscopies and colonoscopies.

In decades to come they'll look back at our medical procedures with the same horror that we look back at practices in Victorian times.

Yes, but they only have these when porblems are suspected, don't they?

Compare PSA testing to the cervical screening programme. Very different beasts.

OnceUponAnEnzyme · 27/10/2020 08:21

I don't feel violated at such, but I do feel terribly emotional and upset afterwards.

This resonated with me and like some others here, I have a shit story in which a nurse left me in the room with the speculum in/open when she realised she didn't have a scrap stick and left the troom to get one. Apparently, she thought she's do half her chores while out and didn't come back for about ten minutes. I was young then and didn't make a fuss. Now I'd scream bloody murder.

These days I try to get a mid morning appointment and keep the rest of the day relatively clear so I can just do what I like. Even if I am returning to work, I try to discourage tough meetings etc for the rest of the day. Early bath, pyjamas, movie and some fudge for me.

I also keep in mind that the procedure itself is just 5 mins (usually). That is all. Then it is done for 3 years.

cbt944 · 27/10/2020 08:20

My understanding is that a prostate examination - which also involves an internal examination - is no fun at all but the method has stayed the same for at least a hundred years.

No, they've got a simple blood test for that now.

DorisDaisyMay · 27/10/2020 08:20

No one likes it - it is something that has to be done.

I breathe deeply and have a day dream during it. I think there was one time I held a nurses hand during it.

It also helps me to think about it in terms of it’s their job and when you deal with bodies as part of a job - it’s different for them. It’s not personal- just another thing in a busy day for them. Thinking like that
de-personalises it for me and allows me to reduce it to just another thing in my day.

Over thinking about it will not help you. You will be strengthening the pathways in your brain that connect a smear with the violation feeling. You need to find some ways to reframe it and actively concentrate on what was positive about the experience to strengthen those neural pathways.

eeyore228 · 27/10/2020 08:17

Smears are horrible and I have never met someone happy to have one. I have had a few and they were as painful as, however one year it caught something and I had treatment. I use that to remind myself that despite the embarrassment and pain it helped me from long term issues and illness. That’s all I’ve got really.

Swipe left for the next trending thread