Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel violated by a smear test?

238 replies

Jericoo · 27/10/2020 03:21

I had a smear test for the first time today. Although I understand the importance and had thoroughly researched the procedure, I cannot sleep at the moment as I feel so violated.

The doctor was wonderful, answered all of my questions and she took things slowly as she knew I was nervous. Does the feeling of being violated go away? It wasn't painful or even that embarrassing in the end, but the feeling of having something shoved in your hoo-ha by someone you've just met is not pleasant.

I am worried this will become a complex and I will avoid having it done again in 3 years as the way I feel now is so horrid, I am in tears. I know someone who had to have a hysterectomy at 30 because of cervical cancer, so it's very important to me to not develop a fear of this.

Does anyone have any tips on how to overcome the feeling of violation?

OP posts:
flaviaritt · 27/10/2020 10:14

Well, I was refused my pill prescription by one doctor as a young woman until I had a smear done and recently similar about my HRT as I was six months late getting it done.

With what medical basis?

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 27/10/2020 10:13

*flaviaritt Tue 27-Oct-20 09:50:25
I feel the pressure put on women to have smears does impact your freedom to choose.

It doesn’t. None of the procedures people imagine to be compulsory (vaccinations, smears, smoking tests/blood tests during pregnancy) are anything other than entirely at the patient’s discretion.*

Well, I was refused my pill prescription by one doctor as a young woman until I had a smear done and recently similar about my HRT as I was six months late getting it done.

groutingqueen · 27/10/2020 10:05

@TheYearOfSmallThings

A smear takes what, 2ish minutes? So maybe next time, focus on your breathing and close your eyes and count to 100 in your head. It will be over before you reach that. Promise ❤️

I really worry about this sort of advice. I went skipping in for my first smear test (many years ago) expecting it to be quick and no more painful or invasive than a dental procedure. Instead it took well over 2 minutes, was really quite painful, and if I were trying to count to 100 I would have been repeatedly interrupted by tutting and sighing from the nurse, because apparently my cervix was trying to escape up toward my left kidney, and I needed to contort sideways to let her at it.

I have never shirked a smear (yet) but for many of us they are VERY unpleasant, and focusing on our breathing really does not help much.

Sorry to hear you had a bad experience @TheYearOfSmallThings. However "worrying" about "this sort of advice" is IMO a bit of an overreaction. I get that for you, your experience meant that it lasted longer because clearly there was a reason, however, for most women it is over very quickly.

Advice isn't there to be tailored to every possible scenario. It's there for the majority of people.

flaviaritt · 27/10/2020 10:03

So for example, I'd reframe the smear test as an unpleasant and invasive procedure that I go through in order to avoid something much worse. I regard is as a necessary part of looking after myself and something that responsible adult women do. I think using the word 'violated' automatically sets off a set of feelings that aren't helpful in this situation. This is a procedure that thousands of women went through on the day you had your smear. It's normal, it's necessary.

Fair enough that this helps you. But I would reframe it as a very quick, slightly unpleasant procedure that I can choose to go through or not. I wouldn’t admit any coercive thoughts about it being necessary. It isn’t. We can either take the risk of getting cancer, or not.

NaughtipussMaximus · 27/10/2020 10:03

I've had five or 6 smears, as well as various other gynaecological examinations, and a baby with all that entails. Usually I feel fine afterward. Just once, when I had a colposcopy (not even my first colposcopy) and then a biopsy, I felt similar to how you're feeling, OP. The nurses and the gynaecologist were lovely, fully respectful of my boundaries and privacy, kind and gentle; and the procedure was less painful and unpleasant than other previous procedures - and yet I really did feel violated afterwards. No history of sexual assault either. I had a LLETZ procedure with the same nursing team a monht later, and felt fine (mentally at least) afterwards, so I relaly can't explain it at all.

The feeling did pass though - maybe after a week or ten days. Hopefully you'll be feeling ok again soon. Flowers

notalwaysalondoner · 27/10/2020 10:02

OP, it's normal to feel a bit uncomfortable or even a little traumatised by what happened. But I'd agree with other posters saying to try not to overthink it. In my experience after a D&C done with local anaesthetic (hahah didn't seem to anaesthetise anything) which was a million times worse, more painful, and much much longer than a smear, I only felt violated for a day or two, then it faded. But I remember literally using that language to my DH and DM to describe how I felt - 'violated'.

So try not to dwell on the feeling and just accept you've had a medical instrument shoved up your hoo-ha, of course you feel violated, it's normal. Have a cry if it helps. Then do something to distract yourself and move on.

CornflakeMum · 27/10/2020 10:01

Haven't read the full thread, but key for me was finding a practice nurse I trusted at the local surgery. She also lets me put the speculum thingie in myself!

ArabellaScott · 27/10/2020 09:59

They can't bring in urine testing fast enough, i.m.o. I believe it's possible, not sure why it's not widely used.

Shedbuilder · 27/10/2020 09:56

You asked for tips to help you overcome your feelings and here's mine.

I don't like having smear tests or any other invasive bodily treatments but I manage my feelings by the way I think about them and the language I frame them in. So for example, I'd reframe the smear test as an unpleasant and invasive procedure that I go through in order to avoid something much worse. I regard is as a necessary part of looking after myself and something that responsible adult women do. I think using the word 'violated' automatically sets off a set of feelings that aren't helpful in this situation. This is a procedure that thousands of women went through on the day you had your smear. It's normal, it's necessary. You've said the procedure was carried out sensitively, which is great. Things have improved a lot since I had my first smear.

Millions of European and American women go voluntarily to their gynaecologist every six months to have their reproductive/ sexual health routinely checked and are shocked at how rarely British women are tested or examined. They regard a visit to the gynaecologist office as being like a visit to the dentist. Maybe we have something to learn from them. Does that help put it into perspective?

flaviaritt · 27/10/2020 09:50

I feel the pressure put on women to have smears does impact your freedom to choose.

It doesn’t. None of the procedures people imagine to be compulsory (vaccinations, smears, smoking tests/blood tests during pregnancy) are anything other than entirely at the patient’s discretion.

BefuddledPerson · 27/10/2020 09:49

But there is nothing wrong with smear tests apart from for all the people for whom they are difficult, or painful, or upsetting.

Denying the reality for some people isn't helpful.

MotherOfCrocodiles · 27/10/2020 09:48

You could get a self sampling kit, they are about £50. They only test for HPV not abnormal cells, but I believe that is all the NHS smear tests for as well these days.

RoseTintedAtuin · 27/10/2020 09:48

I agree that you consent to the procedure and therefore it isn’t rape... it is still a violating experience and very invasive. The fact is if you are ill you are keen for treatment, for screening it’s not common people want a smear but choose to do it to catch problems early. This is a responsible approach to treatment but I feel the pressure put on women to have smears does impact your freedom to choose. If they could find a less invasive procedure uptake would be significantly higher. They have been talking about an alternative for years and if it were a male problem, this would have been developed and rolled out by now. I have chosen not to have smears for a while now and I hope that an alternative is brought out soon.

Soontobe60 · 27/10/2020 09:48

I think having any instrument placed in an orifice can be traumatic, and even more so when its in your genitals or rectum, as there are other associations with those body parts such as fear, embarrassment or even disgust.

I’ve had smears, internal examinations both vaginally and anally, and had a camera inserted into my stomach via my nose - all are invasive and uncomfortable to a certain degree. Looking back analytically, none have been especially painful apart from a biopsy of my uterus carried out at the same time as having an IUD fitted. The pain of that procedure, albeit very brief, was enough to cause me to faint, much to my embarrassment.

I personally haven’t felt violated with any of these procedures as I see violation to mean having something done without consent, and I think that’s what helps me deal with them. However, I do accept that others may well feel violated.

@Jericoo, I suggest you try to get an appointment with your practice nurse in order discuss your anxiety around such procedures. (I appreciate this may be a telephone appt at the moment). They may well be able to suggest things that could help with your anxiety and feelings of violation to enable you to prepare for any future examinations you may need. Also, do you have a friend who you can talk to who may be able to help you really I understand your responses to this procedure?

Having other women telling you they also feel the same way and saying how awful it is can make you feel better in that you’re not alone, but what you really would benefit from is having support in analysing why you felt that way in order to hopefully not feel quite so bad next time. Changing ones mindset from thinking that you’re having a procedure ‘done to you’ into ‘choosing to have a procedure’ is key here.

Ultimately, you know these procedures are important, as does your GP. It may well be that you’ll need a sedative before your next exam - I actually needed one when I had an MRI scan on my head! Don’t bottle up your fears, speak to someone now, before your feelings become worse.

I hope you find a good way to deal with.

movingonup20 · 27/10/2020 09:47

@Offtothedogs

But there is nothing wrong with smear tests. They are pretty unpleasant, a little embarrassing and yes invasive but are recommended for very good reason, to save lives. Because something isn't nice doesn't mean it's wrong. Nobody likes having one, end of, so gently asking if someone has something in their past which would make it worse than for the average person is normal. I'd rather have a smear than the camera I'm due to have down my throat to be honest!

RedHelenB · 27/10/2020 09:47

You dont have to have one. Presumably if you're on this board you've had a child so plenty of drs/midwives have looked at your nether regions I just think of it as any other part of my body, a smear is a very quick procedure.

TheSoapyFrog · 27/10/2020 09:46

For the first one I had, i felt similar. It wasn't like anything I'd experienced before and wasn't really prepared for the reality.
Unfortunately I've had many gynaecological issues for as long as I can remember and have had so many procedures, examinations etc that I don't give it a second thought anymore, but it has had lasting mental effects. My twin pregnancy was hard going as well - internal examinations, stretch and sweeps, waters broken, 4 hour examinations... I've had an ablation, the mirena coil put in 3 times, hysteroscopies, several more smear tests, sexual health examinations and then this year a termination which went wrong and I was rushed to hospital a couple of weeks later and had to put up with several internal examinations and surgery.
I don't like to have sex anymore because I hate the thought of anyone else messing about with me down there.
I don't think people always realise the toll these invasive procedures can take on a woman.
However, I will continue to have smear tests because as much as I hate the thought of it, I hate the thought of dying from cancer and leaving my sons motherless more.

Keha · 27/10/2020 09:44

Don't know if this has been covered, but I've heard you can say you want to insert the speculum yourself, this could make it feel less violating.

Toilenstripes · 27/10/2020 09:44

[quote Frenchsticks]@BefuddledPerson
It's not about minimising someone's feelings at all. It's about trying to help. How is it helpful to say, for this OP or any other young woman trying to research what their first smear is going to be like who happens upon this thread to say, yes it's awful, you do come away feeling violated. It's also not about saying there is something psychologically wrong with you because you feel this way but it is about acknowledging that you don't need to feel this way. Why is it so wrong to offer basic advice of proven techniques to help the OP process an unpleasant experience? She wasn't violated, she feels she was, but she wasn't. So we can offer advice as to how she can process those feelings so that she understands them better and hopefully doesn't let them overwhelm her by reassuring her that she is safe and she wasn't violated. Or we can just say 'yup, having a smear will always feel like that, nothing you can do about it, good luck for the next 40+ years getting them done.'
The OP asked for help. That's what I offered[/quote]
Completely agree with Frenchsticks who is offering a healthy and positive approach for dealing with the feelings.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 27/10/2020 09:43

A smear takes what, 2ish minutes? So maybe next time, focus on your breathing and close your eyes and count to 100 in your head. It will be over before you reach that. Promise ❤️

I really worry about this sort of advice. I went skipping in for my first smear test (many years ago) expecting it to be quick and no more painful or invasive than a dental procedure. Instead it took well over 2 minutes, was really quite painful, and if I were trying to count to 100 I would have been repeatedly interrupted by tutting and sighing from the nurse, because apparently my cervix was trying to escape up toward my left kidney, and I needed to contort sideways to let her at it.

I have never shirked a smear (yet) but for many of us they are VERY unpleasant, and focusing on our breathing really does not help much.

captainprincess · 27/10/2020 09:43

I hope you're feeling better OP. I had 3 smears last year, first 2 they couldn't read. The nurses were lovely and just got on with my day. However I got referred to a gynaecologist for a different issue who I saw this year, he had to perform an internal and whilst he was, what I would describe as, very kind I certainly felt a bit odd for a week or so afterwards. I couldn't quite put my finger on it.
Maybe it's because it was a male gynaecologist, maybe because I wasn't expecting an internal there and then. Anyway as time went on I have sort of forgotten about it. There is no right or wrong way to feel. For example I would rather visit the dentist than the hairdresser which others would find odd, everyone is different Smile

yossell · 27/10/2020 09:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

movingonup20 · 27/10/2020 09:41

They are not very pleasant but it's just a medical test. I would suggest not considering motherhood any time soon as that's a whole lot more invasive! Violated is a complete overreaction, I suggest speaking to your practice nurse sooner rather than later rather than letter the thoughts fester

goldenharvest · 27/10/2020 09:40

Maybe some counselling to understand the roots of your feelings? It's not normal to feel violated. It's Norman to hate them and loathe having them done. They're not pleasant, but most women do not associate it with violation.

You need to get to grips with these feelings because having a baby is a 100 times worse for vaginal examinations.

picklecustard · 27/10/2020 09:31

Op your feelings are completely valid and you’re not alone Flowers

I just wish there was more awareness that internal procedures like smears or having vaginal exams during labour can be very traumatic or triggering to women, and feel violating.

I also hate the phrase about ‘leaving your dignity at the door’ when it comes to childbirth. Sure, certain elements of the process can be undignified but that doesn’t mean women shouldn’t be treated with upmost respect and kindness and be given care that protects that their privacy and dignity as much as possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread