Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel violated by a smear test?

238 replies

Jericoo · 27/10/2020 03:21

I had a smear test for the first time today. Although I understand the importance and had thoroughly researched the procedure, I cannot sleep at the moment as I feel so violated.

The doctor was wonderful, answered all of my questions and she took things slowly as she knew I was nervous. Does the feeling of being violated go away? It wasn't painful or even that embarrassing in the end, but the feeling of having something shoved in your hoo-ha by someone you've just met is not pleasant.

I am worried this will become a complex and I will avoid having it done again in 3 years as the way I feel now is so horrid, I am in tears. I know someone who had to have a hysterectomy at 30 because of cervical cancer, so it's very important to me to not develop a fear of this.

Does anyone have any tips on how to overcome the feeling of violation?

OP posts:
Melroses · 27/10/2020 12:04

I've never heard of there being a self sampling prostate exam?

I've never heard of men being summoned for a prostate exam every 3 years as a matter of routine, whether or not there is any risk or symptoms of an illness.

My DF has had one, in a hospital appointment, after suffering bleeding from a prostate infection.

MintyMabel · 27/10/2020 12:03

if you find a smear traumatic there must be something deeply wrong and abnormal with you

I don't think most have been quite so blunt and insensitive.

But just like women who are led to believe it is entirely normal to live with incredibly painful and heavy periods, or that sleep deprivation is just an accepted part of parenting, it is unhelpful to suggest this reaction is something they just need to live with.

It isn't minimising it to say that perhaps some kind of counselling, or therapy will help.

Binswangers · 27/10/2020 11:50

I completely understand how you would feel violated. Having said that it is not very common to have such an awful reaction to it, especially when it is done gently. I think the poster who suggested counselling probably meant something like NLP, perhaps to change your associations around the examination in order to make it easier to deal with.

Elsewyre · 27/10/2020 11:45

@rainkeepsfallingdown

It's interesting how many posters keep implying that if you find a smear traumatic there must be something deeply wrong and abnormal with you, yet there are plenty of us saying we had a traumatic experience.

Nothing like women minimising other women...

I agree, if men had to put up with this, self-sampling would be widespread by now and not just one pilot trial in North London.

Just because some women have had children and been poked and prodded doesn't mean all women should feel comfortable at having things shoved inside them. We should be aiming for everyone to have a better medical experience not an equally shit one. Also... not all women have children. So all this talk of 'it only gets worse!' isn't relevant and/or helpful.

As for did I complain? No. I can't say it even occurred to me at the time. I was younger, less assertive, and caught up in my own pain. On some level, I knew that the nurse didn't want to make me feel violated, she just hadn't given me the due dignity and respect she should have done.

People saying to think of how common the procedure is for nurses aren't helping - it's because it's common that it's terrible. I think some of them find them so routine they forget that it can be a big deal for the patients being examined, and they need to be kinder, more gentle and reinforce that consent comes from the patient rather than bulldozing along.

The colposcopy was worse. The pain was intense and I didn't stop sobbing before, during or after.

Not one medical professional stopped to reassure me. And there were plenty in that room.

I'd like to think these days I would complain to ensure that the nurses and doctors involved were reminded to empathise more with their patients, but I didn't have it in me at the time. That's the trouble with shitty patient experiences - rarely does anyone have the strength to complain. Complaints tend to happen if a family member or close friend is aware of the struggle and advocates on your behalf.

This is the sort of experience you box up in your head and don't talk about until many years after the fact.

"I agree, if men had to put up with this, self-sampling would be widespread by now and not just one pilot trial in North London."

I've never heard of there being a self sampling prostate exam?

rainkeepsfallingdown · 27/10/2020 11:36

@MrsBonnie

I had the exact same feeling with my first. I was actually a virgin so needn’t have had it done really, and she used the large speculum thing. I had tears streaming down my face because it just Didn’t. Fit. In. Begged her to use the smaller one but she said that was for shorter girls and I was very tall. After about five mins it really wasn’t going in, I was clamping up and crying in pain. She simply lubed it up more, rammed it in and did her stuff. I had blood in my knickers after. It really did feel like I’d been raped. That’s SO dramatic isn’t it? But I went home and cried and lay in bed all day.

The good news is that my second smear was world’s apart! Lovely nurse who made me feel so relaxed. No pain in any way shape or form. I promise they’re not all as bad as that one. Sorry you had a horrendous experience. Sad

I don't think you're being dramatic at all.

Mine also went for the large speculum when it was the wrong size for my body. I'm so sorry you went through that as well.

Well done for managing to go back, you're so much braver than I am.

Bbq1 · 27/10/2020 11:36

Violated? No. Way Ott. Unless you have related history, that's a massive over reaction to a standard medical procedure. In 2015, I had an massive non cancerous ovarian cyst which was pushing my uterus to one side. I had to have a smear prior to being operated on and I went to my local clinic who couldn't do it. Three different male Dr's tried but couldn't do it properly due to the misalignment. It hurt and I cried at one point. In the end they sent me to a walk in centre and the medical professionals there could do it either. It was painful (normal smears aren't), embarrassing and upsetting but not once did I feel anythingapproaching "violation".

MrsBonnie · 27/10/2020 11:30

I had the exact same feeling with my first. I was actually a virgin so needn’t have had it done really, and she used the large speculum thing. I had tears streaming down my face because it just Didn’t. Fit. In. Begged her to use the smaller one but she said that was for shorter girls and I was very tall. After about five mins it really wasn’t going in, I was clamping up and crying in pain. She simply lubed it up more, rammed it in and did her stuff. I had blood in my knickers after. It really did feel like I’d been raped. That’s SO dramatic isn’t it? But I went home and cried and lay in bed all day.

The good news is that my second smear was world’s apart! Lovely nurse who made me feel so relaxed. No pain in any way shape or form. I promise they’re not all as bad as that one. Sorry you had a horrendous experience. Sad

PicsInRed · 27/10/2020 11:23

You might consider buying a speculum and trying it as a sex toy - how would it feel for you if you were using one with a partner?

What the fuck?

rainkeepsfallingdown · 27/10/2020 11:21

It's interesting how many posters keep implying that if you find a smear traumatic there must be something deeply wrong and abnormal with you, yet there are plenty of us saying we had a traumatic experience.

Nothing like women minimising other women...

I agree, if men had to put up with this, self-sampling would be widespread by now and not just one pilot trial in North London.

Just because some women have had children and been poked and prodded doesn't mean all women should feel comfortable at having things shoved inside them. We should be aiming for everyone to have a better medical experience not an equally shit one. Also... not all women have children. So all this talk of 'it only gets worse!' isn't relevant and/or helpful.

As for did I complain? No. I can't say it even occurred to me at the time. I was younger, less assertive, and caught up in my own pain. On some level, I knew that the nurse didn't want to make me feel violated, she just hadn't given me the due dignity and respect she should have done.

People saying to think of how common the procedure is for nurses aren't helping - it's because it's common that it's terrible. I think some of them find them so routine they forget that it can be a big deal for the patients being examined, and they need to be kinder, more gentle and reinforce that consent comes from the patient rather than bulldozing along.

The colposcopy was worse. The pain was intense and I didn't stop sobbing before, during or after.

Not one medical professional stopped to reassure me. And there were plenty in that room.

I'd like to think these days I would complain to ensure that the nurses and doctors involved were reminded to empathise more with their patients, but I didn't have it in me at the time. That's the trouble with shitty patient experiences - rarely does anyone have the strength to complain. Complaints tend to happen if a family member or close friend is aware of the struggle and advocates on your behalf.

This is the sort of experience you box up in your head and don't talk about until many years after the fact.

MintyMabel · 27/10/2020 11:14

Because it is an invasive and violating experience. Many women have this experience.

I think we have to be careful with language, and understand there is a big element of individual referencing.

If the message we are sending out to young women is that the procedure is very likely to leave you feeling so violated you can't sleep, that is a worry. I hate them and find them incredibly painful, but I wouldn't want anyone to think that was a normal experience.

I would be very surprised if the vast majority of women feel so violated they can't sleep and still think about it days after.

It is a real worry if that is the case.

campista · 27/10/2020 11:12

I hated all mine - all painful - am too old to be called for them now, but sympathies with all women having them.A couple of times I had the dreaded call back to go again as they hadn't got enough cells. I always went and later learned to have paracetamol beforehand - don't know that it helped, but I felt that I had 'armed' myself.

independentfriend · 27/10/2020 11:01

Maybe try to find something you find physically comforting - a warm bath/shower, hug someone you're allowed to hug (per COVID), warm comforting food, a hot drink etc.

Or consider when/how you might next do something sexual - either alone or with a partner. So you can feel pleasant-to-you touch in that area as a more recent memory than the clinical experience.

You might consider buying a speculum and trying it as a sex toy - how would it feel for you if you were using one with a partner?

Shedbuilder · 27/10/2020 10:58

That sounds horrible, toasforthissooner, but it's a million miles away from someone describing feeling violated by a sensitively and caringly carried-out smear test.

toaskforthissooner · 27/10/2020 10:35

And I completely agree, it does feel violating . I had an internal scan years ago on a gynae ward . Man walked in halfway through, took the probe from the female doctors hand, whilst the probe was still in my vagina, and carried on scanning , he didn’t even tell me his name or ask if he could take over . I did consent to the scan, but I felt like a piece of meat who clearly didn’t matter to them . I remember feeling absolutely horrendous after and violated describes it exactly .

flaviaritt · 27/10/2020 10:34

Ophelia2020

But you don’t have to comply with any of it. Just get up and leave.

flaviaritt · 27/10/2020 10:34

When you come to give birth, to be honest you won’t really care who’s down there, you just want your baby out!

I cared. I wasn’t ultra upset about it but I was very aware of it and I wanted to be treated like a person.

flaviaritt · 27/10/2020 10:32

JustHereWithMyPopcorn

Then hopefully my posts help make people more aware.

toaskforthissooner · 27/10/2020 10:32

Haven’t read full thread but I’m sedated for internal examinations (due to PTSD caused by years and years of gynae problems, hundreds of internals and scans and being mistreated), would that help?

It’s usually just a couple of diazepam and strong painkillers so I end up dozing through the procedure - maybe that would help . I cope better if I’m not totally aware of what’s going on . Have been offered a full GA but don’t feel that’s necessary !

I’ve also got a note on my records explaining the situation and that any internal is only to be done by specific GP/nurse. which helps a lot as they both know me very well .

BefuddledPerson · 27/10/2020 10:30

When you come to give birth, to be honest you won’t really care who’s down there, you just want your baby out!

This is not true for many women. Many women experience birth trauma resulting from the behaviour/attitude of HCPs involved in the birth.

There are a lot of bulldozer attitudes on this thread.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 27/10/2020 10:29

@flaviaritt that may be the case but unless you are aware of that at the time it's not much help.

Ori3 · 27/10/2020 10:28

Sorry but it’s really not a violation, even though you may feel unnerved by it. Presumably you agreed to the procedure beforehand, so you knew to expect a certain level of invasive involvement.

When you have kids everyone has a good old rummage. You get used to it! I really don’t mean to minimise what you’re feeling by joking like this but it is the truth that you will undergo more physical examinations if you decide to have children. And generally, more smear tests in your life; which are always carried out by trained health professionals. I agree that smears are undignified, but us women do have to suffer a lot of indignity I’m afraid in that area! It’s just what it is.

When you come to give birth, to be honest you won’t really care who’s down there, you just want your baby out!

Ophelia2020 · 27/10/2020 10:24

I have definitely been pressured. A simple No at the family planning clinic results in the nurse going to get the doctor to apply further pressure. Every gp visit is dominated by smear test lectures.

Trying to get taken off the screening programme is a nightmare, phone calls, letters and appointments being made for you to discuss why.

flaviaritt · 27/10/2020 10:23

JustHereWithMyPopcorn

Then that is malpractice. It doesn’t affect your actual rights.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 27/10/2020 10:17

These are 30 years apart but still.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 27/10/2020 10:16

None! the first time was a hideous male doctor (who was also trying to insist that I had a student in present on my first smear). The last time was about 9 months ago. I have no genetic risks or any risk factor higher than anyone else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread