Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This MP should be sacked

263 replies

acerred · 24/10/2020 00:48

Disgusting comments. He should be sacked.

This MP should be sacked
OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
StandWitch · 24/10/2020 18:03

I'm not really sure what your point is here.

There are food parcels from food banks, there were food parcels for people sheltering from covid.

I found some on Twitter

twitter.com/BennyMorts/status/1245621592089956353/photo/1
twitter.com/GothicCard/status/1245288526905839616/photo/1

As for whether schools, as per your quote 'claim through the exceptional costs fund if they are arranging food parcels (rather than vouchers) for benefits-related free school meal pupils over the summer holidays.' then that doesn't seem like it was very common - clearly a £90 supermarket voucher would be preferred by the overwhelming majority of parents, rather than a box of Heinz baked beans or what have you.

Regardless, if the schools did provide such parcels, then it is obviously possible that they were sold.

chomalungma · 24/10/2020 17:56

Phillip Davies you say?

His reputation precedes him.

ancientgran · 24/10/2020 17:54

MagicoRomantico just when you think they can't sink any lower they go and prove you wrong.

MagicoRomantico · 24/10/2020 17:53

More disdain from politicians
twitter.com/Glitter_brawl/status/1319738398505111555?s=19

ancientgran · 24/10/2020 17:53

So Mark Jenkinson was talking about food parcels nothing to do with replacing FSM during the holidays, Ben Bradley was talking about vouchers.

From the gov.uk site re summer food fund

"Schools can also claim through the exceptional costs fund if they are arranging food parcels (rather than vouchers) for benefits-related free school meal pupils over the summer holidays. If schools arrange food parcels, these can only be ordered for children in receipt of free school meals before the summer holidays begin."

So are you right or is the govt?

MagicoRomantico · 24/10/2020 17:51

Philip Davies MP replying to a 16 year old constituent who wrote to him concerned about his vote against extending free school meals.

This MP should be sacked
StandWitch · 24/10/2020 17:45

StandWitch so a big post and you haven't shown us where Mark Jenkinson is talking about £90 vouchers. It is clear on twitter that he did say people were trading food parcels for drugs so are you just interpreting for him or did he actually say anything about the vouchers? I mean did he clarify that when he said food parcels he actually meant £90 vouchers.

Sorry we might have been talking at cross purposes

  • Ben Bradley indicated that £90 vouchers were sold for drugs
  • Mark Jenkinson said, effectively of course they are - 'I know in my constituency that, as tiny as a minority it might be, food parcels are sold or traded for drugs.'

this does not appear to be a reference to FSM, given that FSM is nothing to do with food parcels, but rather to the fact that people obtain non-perishable food from food banks, and sell it for drugs.

both comments are poorly judged, but that people will trade £90 supermarket vouchers for drugs, and that people sell food bank parcels for drugs, are true.

ancientgran · 24/10/2020 17:09

StandWitch so a big post and you haven't shown us where Mark Jenkinson is talking about £90 vouchers. It is clear on twitter that he did say people were trading food parcels for drugs so are you just interpreting for him or did he actually say anything about the vouchers? I mean did he clarify that when he said food parcels he actually meant £90 vouchers.

This "I know in my constituency that, as tiny as a minority it might be, food parcels are sold or traded for drugs." is copied from twitter, what he actually posted on there.

pollyannaperspective · 24/10/2020 17:05

Correction - not 'UK' but 'England'.

pollyannaperspective · 24/10/2020 16:52

Ben Bradley quoted the support of a Headteacher of a school in his constituency to the views he was expressing, without actually checking he had their permission. A Governor of that school checked with the HT and confirmed that no such support for Ben Bradley's view had been given by the HT.
Ben Bradley also disclosed information he says is correct about the pupils and parents of a school. If he knows that information to be true, he also knows that it is confidential and should not be placed in the public domain.
Ben Bradley then deleted his tweet. If he is so certain his views are correct at least have the courage of his convictions, or perhaps he has seen that the optics of his argument are not playing well. He also offers no solution to the fact that there are hungry children in the UK in 2020.

My view, as a School Governor, is that there are children going hungry. Yes, a very few in receipt of the summer holiday voucher/food parcel support may not have used it for the benefit of their child/ren, but let's not make the majority pay for that minimal abuse. There needs to be a better solution but that will take time and meanwhile there needs to be a continuance of the 'good enough' system from the summer holiday until the Government sorts something permanent. Children should not be hungry in the UK in 2020.

CinnamonSquare · 24/10/2020 16:46

@Clavinova

Where is he getting the idea that schools and teachers are supposed to be apolitical? Teachers standards don't say that anywhere (there's a bit about not undermining democracy, which is not what the school has done anyway).

Here;
"the guidance stipulates that “all staff have a responsibility to ensure that they act appropriately in terms of their behaviour, the views they express (in particular political views)”.

"It goes on to say that staff must also be appropriate in their use of school resources, and “should not use school resources for party political purposes”.

That's not the same as being apolitical though.

What is inappropriate about drawing attention to the views an elected official has expressed publicly about parents?

Where has the school used school resources for party political purposes?

LittleRa · 24/10/2020 16:46

[quote tenlittlecygnets]**@LittleRa* - did your MP say that: some local Tory MPs justified their vote against the school holiday meals by saying they had “been told” that the vouchers had been used for cigarettes, alcohol and “unhealthy food”.*

Because that exactly what mine said when I emailed him this week!!

Some families, although certainly not all, have used vouchers to buy alcohol and cigarettes and there have been quite a lot of complaints about this by supermarket staff who did not think this was a good use of taxpayers’ money

His whole email was probably a cut and paste job... 🙄[/quote]
It wasn’t my own local MP because luckily for me I live in an area that still has a labour MP, but I read these quotes from local Tory MPs in nearby constituencies. Looks like it a party line being used then.

tenlittlecygnets · 24/10/2020 16:43

@LittleRa - did your MP say that: some local Tory MPs justified their vote against the school holiday meals by saying they had “been told” that the vouchers had been used for cigarettes, alcohol and “unhealthy food”.

Because that exactly what mine said when I emailed him this week!!

Some families, although certainly not all, have used vouchers to buy alcohol and cigarettes and there have been quite a lot of complaints about this by supermarket staff who did not think this was a good use of taxpayers’ money

His whole email was probably a cut and paste job... 🙄

tenlittlecygnets · 24/10/2020 16:36

Actually, if his facts are correct, why should he be sacked? He is saying we need to help kids who live with parents who are not looking after them or prioritising them.

The school's interpretation of good words is not very accurate.

But it is horrendous for MPs to vote against free school meals, and I wrote to my MP this week to say so.

StandWitch · 24/10/2020 16:20

Can you give us a link to where he has mentioned £90 supermarket vouchers, I couldn't so would like to read them. Thanks.

for context, there are no actual 'free school meals in holidays', this is just a political slogan.

there ARE free school meals at school.

And there was a 'free school meals in school holidays' scheme over the summer. This was a £90 supermarket voucher valid for food

www.thesun.co.uk/money/11960389/parents-deadline-apply-free-school-meals-summer/

Rashford was calling for this to continue. It's misrepresentation in that it should be called 'food stamps' or similar.

If you look at the tweet by Angela Rayner quoting Bradley

twitter.com/AngelaRayner/status/1319698900069076994

he says 'extending FSM doesn't reach this kids'

'Extending FSM' means handing out supermarket gift cards. It doesn't mean handing out meals.

There IS something called the Holiday Activities and Food program

www.gov.uk/government/news/thousands-of-children-to-benefit-from-free-meals-and-activities

however it's only available in certain areas, and this is NOT what the so-called 'holiday FSM' refers to at all.

The call is for £15/week in supermarket gift cards during school holidays. That is fine, but food stamps (which are common in the US) have been criticised for being demeaning & inefficient, when compared to cash payments.

Here it can be noted that there have been large rises in cash benefits this year - the government increased Universal Credit by £20/week in April, and has re-linked housing benefit/UC LHA to local rents, after having frozen them for many years; this is an increase of in some cases several hundreds pounds a month.

There is no 'extending FSM' literally, there is only giving out £15 gift cards or not giving out £15 gift cards.

I don't think anyone was talking about foodbanks, it was about FSMs, some people got vouchers, some got food parcels and some kids had lunches provided (well people on here have quoted that.) Maybe there is some confusion and he wasn't talking about FSM or swapping food parcels but that is what he seems to have said.

No, the scheme was extremely clear - £15/week over the summer holidays in lieu of FSM. This was separate to and in addition to the 'food & activities programme', which has not been referred to as such.

There seems to be a bit of an irony in that people are talking abut 'FSM in holidays' referring to a scheme that doesn't involve either meals nor in school, and not the scheme which did actually involve meals.

I don't think that tweet was to be taken literally about Dairylea sandwiches. I think it was supposed to refer to all dairy products.

? dairy products are nothing to do with this at all not even a little bit. The main thing being discussed was a supermarket voucher for £90 in lieu of FSM, and second to that that foodbank parcels are resold for drugs. Neither of these are really anything to do with dairy products.

WrongKindOfFace · 24/10/2020 16:13

Or that you could even sell it to earn enough to purchase drugs?

WrongKindOfFace · 24/10/2020 16:13

What exactly do MPs think is in the average food parcel that it’s actually tradable for drugs?

Coralista · 24/10/2020 16:04

And tbh I would bet that there is much more drug taking amongst high earners than those who are eligible for FSM how about that for making assumptions but I bet I’m right

JamieLeeCurtains · 24/10/2020 16:01

I don't think that tweet was to be taken literally about Dairylea sandwiches. I think it was supposed to refer to all dairy products.

acerred · 24/10/2020 15:59

Selling stolen meat for drugs is well-documented

That's not disputed but it doesn't mean that school staff know that most families are doing this. It's impossible to know what individual families are doing unless you actually see them doing it.

OP posts:
Coralista · 24/10/2020 15:57

Seriously how many families would actully somehow swap these vouchers for drugs or not use them as intended? A TINY percentage
And because of that possibility it would be better for ALL the other eligible children to go without ?

ancientgran · 24/10/2020 15:54

As far as Jenkinson's comments go, the point he was making seems to be that if people already trade food bank parcels for cash/drugs, then they will certainly trade £90 supermarket vouchers for drugs. Can you give us a link to where he has mentioned £90 supermarket vouchers, I couldn't so would like to read them. Thanks.

I'm quite certain that food banks don't hand out Dairylea sandwiches - it's non-perishable stuff. I don't think anyone was talking about foodbanks, it was about FSMs, some people got vouchers, some got food parcels and some kids had lunches provided (well people on here have quoted that.) Maybe there is some confusion and he wasn't talking about FSM or swapping food parcels but that is what he seems to have said.

JamieLeeCurtains · 24/10/2020 15:51

The government whips really aren't reading the room.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/boris-johnson-tory-neo-nazi-anti-islam-hitler-conservative-party-b1254794.html

Apparently they told a concerned Tory peer to back off when he objected to the Tories being in bed with full-on lunatic fascists in the Council of Europe. The whips said, the Prime Minister can't be on top of everything.

I think cocooning Johnson like this is proving to be a disaster, from schools to poverty to European allegiances.

Boris Johnson is not Trump or Nero. Ben Bradley is not Jared Kushner or Sporus. This is the UK.