Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This MP should be sacked

263 replies

acerred · 24/10/2020 00:48

Disgusting comments. He should be sacked.

This MP should be sacked
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
scottturner37 · 21/08/2021 23:57

ben bradley should really be sacked full stop he is nothing but doing nothing about with problems at all he think he does but he doesn't and anyways he should not be telling people what to do its not his choice its ours and i think we need to oust him out compleatly

Sunflowergirl1 · 27/10/2020 08:08

@ViciousJackdaw

@Marieg10 Teachers, Head teachers and lecturers are all exempt from political restrictions and will not be regarded as holding “politically restricted posts” whatever their role or remuneration level. However I also don’t see what is partisan about reporting someone’s words - Ben Bradley said it in writing - if he doesn’t like it being reported he should have thought before he typed.

Perhaps lol, at the school code of conduct. I don't know if one that doesn't restrict school staff from making comments such as this when speaking on behalf of the school. Making pronouncements at a school staff union meeting may be different.

I am also a school governor and the template code of conduct for all schools in our area makes this clear. If the head of our school either published or sanctioned the publication of this I would insist on a disciplinary investigation.

As schools we should be focussed on educating the kids and helping in whatever way is reasonable and not publishing shit such as this that all it does it spark a conflict between schools and parents....last thing we need in such fractured times

TheWordWomanIsTaken · 26/10/2020 18:44

@Enterthewolves

The £600m they keep trumpeting about was given to authorities in June and was for community support across all groups - in my city a significant proportion was used for food for older people, people with disabilities & health needs and children. Some of it was used to house homeless people, to support additional support in the absence of day centres/respite. There isn’t any left
Yes and comes after a decade of cuts to local authority budgets. Decimated them in many cases.
StandWitch · 26/10/2020 17:58

Well at the moment it's suspended during covid, but essentially you are supposed to spend 35 hours a week either working or looking for work or be sanctioned.

So if you had 9-12 and 3-6 then I think they'd expect you to find a job that provided 35 hours instead.

I imagine that could be the subject of discussion.

www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/679371/response/1622379/attach/4/Expected%20hours.pdf?cookie_passthrough=1

acerred · 26/10/2020 12:36

35 hours per week if your child is 13 or over. These aren't hard limits in that you are supposed to 'look for work'.

My mistake, I thought it was 21 hours.

What do they do if your employer can't offer you 35 hours? Say for example you work for an employer from 9am-12 noon daily and then again from 3pm-6pm so can't fit another job in with your split hifts.

OP posts:
StandWitch · 26/10/2020 09:47

A PP said about the 30 hours, it's 21 if you are a lone parent. I took on a 2nd job to help.

That's not correct. For a joint tax credit claim there must be 24 hours work done between the claimants. For a lone parent it's 16 hours.

The 30 hours is something else, this is a bonus introduced in about 1998 to encourage people to do more hours. Essentially tax credits are withdrawn at 41%, on top of NI & tax, which can work out as a marginal rate of about 73% for some people, but if you work 30 hours, then a £825 bonus is paid, which offsets some of that.

For Universal Credit you are expected to work 25 hours per week if your child is 5-12, and 35 hours per week if your child is 13 or over. These aren't hard limits in that you are supposed to 'look for work'.

There is no 30 hour element for UC because the government's idea with Universal Credit is that you should work more hours whether it's financially worthwhile or not.

The UC withdrawal rate is post-tax, and is 63%, which given a legal minimum 5% pension contribution, works out at (1-5%)-((((1-5%)(1-20%))-(12%))(1-63%)) = 71.32% 'tax', compared to tax credits which are (1-5%)-((((1-5%)*(1-20%-42%))-(12%))) = 70.9%, on income over the personal allowance of £12,500

SteppedOnBloodyLego · 26/10/2020 02:05

@StandWitch

Tax credits were increased by £1045

www.gov.uk/government/news/increase-to-working-tax-credits-what-this-means

There is a 30-hour element to tax credits of £825

Yeah, you forgot to add “temporarily”

“... plans to reduce the headline generosity of benefits by £1,040 for millions of households in April 2021”
www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/death-by-1000-cuts/

ancientgran · 25/10/2020 18:37

Acerred you must have had to budget hard to make that up. I've got a niece who is a lone parent and she seems to cope but I think she probably has a tough time, ex went abroad and she doesn't get anything from him. I always send her some cash for Christmas as it must be a tough time for lone parents, maybe I should review what I send. She's lost her 2nd job because of Covid.

acerred · 25/10/2020 17:52

@ancientgran

Acerred Tax credits weren't increased. My income dropped by 50% and my tax credits went down by £30 a week. I work for over the 21 required hours. That's a massive drop, have you managed OK? Obviously you don't have to say if it is something you want to keep private. I hope you have managed though, good luck.
I'm good at extreme budgeting. A PP said about the 30 hours, it's 21 if you are a lone parent. I took on a 2nd job to help.
OP posts:
acerred · 25/10/2020 17:50

Mine weren't, as I said they went down.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 25/10/2020 15:55

Acerred Tax credits weren't increased. My income dropped by 50% and my tax credits went down by £30 a week. I work for over the 21 required hours. That's a massive drop, have you managed OK? Obviously you don't have to say if it is something you want to keep private. I hope you have managed though, good luck.

ancientgran · 25/10/2020 15:53

During the past summer holiday supermarket vouchers were made available. And so were food parcels, by the way they weren't all Sainsbury's vouchers so you got that wrong as well. There would have been uproar from other supermarkets if that was the case and I can't imagine why my local Co-op and Iceland had signs up about them if they were for Sainsburys.

StandWitch · 25/10/2020 08:12

Tax credits were increased by £1045

www.gov.uk/government/news/increase-to-working-tax-credits-what-this-means

There is a 30-hour element to tax credits of £825

StandWitch · 25/10/2020 08:12

Tax credits were increased by £1045

www.gov.uk/government/news/increase-to-working-tax-credits-what-this-means

There is a 30-hour element to tax credits of £825

acerred · 25/10/2020 01:57

@WrongKindOfFace

Not all benefits were increased though? I don’t think income support or jobseekers were increased, just uc and possibly tax credits?
Tax credits weren't increased. My income dropped by 50% and my tax credits went down by £30 a week. I work for over the 21 required hours.
OP posts:
Lineofconcepcion · 24/10/2020 23:26

I feel so ashamed that children in the UK are more impoverished now than 10 years ago. That the situation was so bad under May's austerity agenda that the UN special rapporteur Philip Alston published a report that was damning of child poverty here, and yet nothing happens in 2 years.

Those people on here suggesting benefits have increased. They are lower now in real figures than 10 years ago, particularly if you are disabled. Don't forget the 'bedroom tax', 'the bottom tier of DLA abolished by introducing PiP which the Appeal Courts later deemed unlawful, the abolition of HB for anything other than a single room for the under 35s, massive increases in homelessness since 2010, and the waste of space Tory MPs vote against* ensuring children have enough to eat during holiday times . . ..

This country is shameful.

StandWitch · 24/10/2020 20:56

There are 5.69 million people on Universal Credit, of which just over 2 million are in work.

dwp-stats.maps.arcgis.com/apps/MapSeries/index.html?appid=f90fb305d8da4eb3970812b3199cf489

In February (latest date) there were 33,000 JSA claimants with dependent children, and 228,000 Income Support claimants with dependent children

stat-xplore.dwp.gov.uk/webapi/jsf/dataCatalogueExplorer.xhtml

Probably more have moved to UC since then.

JamieLeeCurtains · 24/10/2020 20:08

Clearly.

StandWitch · 24/10/2020 19:52

yes possibly if you don't work or something you might not be entitled to UC with kids? I'm not totally au fait with that.

WrongKindOfFace · 24/10/2020 19:35

Not all benefits were increased though? I don’t think income support or jobseekers were increased, just uc and possibly tax credits?

StandWitch · 24/10/2020 18:58

As I mentioned, the government have increased benefits over and beyond the amount of this proposed scheme, without being prompted to by footballers on Twitter. And if it's true that food stamp-type schemes create inefficiencies, why would we introduce them in the UK?

You have already admitted that the replacement for those FSM was either a £90 voucher or a food parcel.

no.

It is not a replacement because free school meals have existed for decades, and it was clear that if you were entitled to FSM, you would get lunch provided 180 days a year or whatever it is, and provide their lunch on weekends, school holidays, and so on.

Food parcels were created because schools were abruptly shutdown meaning that that food was no longer available. They still exist for children who have to stay at home due to covid. www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-free-school-meals-guidance/covid-19-free-school-meals-guidance-for-schools

During the past summer holiday supermarket vouchers were made available. www.gov.uk/guidance/covid-summer-food-fund This was the 'free school meal'. Anything else was an 'alternative'.

Going forward the options are either supermarket vouchers or no supermarket vouchers. There is no way to efficiently provide meals for millions of children when schools are closed, and that has not been proposed. Food parcels are also not a good use of government funds, in that not everyone wants a box of Heinz beans & Napoli spaghetti.

Regardless of any of what you want to make out he said he actually admitted it was a very small minority who were trading food parcels for drugs so why should the majority of children go without?

the government pays parents thousands of pounds in the form of universal credit child allowance, personal allowance, and also child benefit. It also funds housing costs via Universal Credit.

Some councils such as Birmingham, K&C, Liverpool, and others are providing 'free school meals' during half-term. This is a £15 voucher the same as the one administered during the summer holiday.

There is no way to 'feed children' efficiently. All you can do is hand out cash or vouchers. For some reason everyone has now decided that vouchers are the way forward, even though £15 food vouchers don't actually mean any children will be fed.

ancientgran · 24/10/2020 18:36

Well you were quite clear in this statement "There were no 'food parcels' as they put in their headline, one of many similarly misleading things they put out." There were food parcels, you've seen the link and admitted it so you got that wrong.

"It was a £90 electronic debit card valid in supermarkets for food similar to American food stamps," or as you have conceded a food parcel

"As far as Jenkinson's comments go, the point he was making seems to be that if people already trade food bank parcels for cash/drugs, then they will certainly trade £90 supermarket vouchers for drugs." He doesn't say anything about £90 vouchers.

"Selling stolen meat for drugs is well-documented" So now parents with children on FSM are the same as thieves?

"This was a £90 supermarket voucher valid for food
this does not appear to be a reference to FSM, given that FSM is nothing to do with food parcels, but rather to the fact that people obtain non-perishable food from food banks, and sell it for drugs."
You know perfectly well what they were talking about was children who are entitled to FSMs getting support for food in holidays. You have already admitted that the replacement for those FSM was either a £90 voucher or a food parcel. Why the back tracking?

Regardless of any of what you want to make out he said he actually admitted it was a very small minority who were trading food parcels for drugs so why should the majority of children go without?

StandWitch · 24/10/2020 18:21

I'm not sure if any food parcels were distributed by Workington schools in the summer; they did in March when school was abruptly shut down. www.newsandstar.co.uk/news/18322239.covid-19-school-helps-food-wellbeing/

but by summer there was a voucher scheme in place, so it would have made less sense to do so.

StandWitch · 24/10/2020 18:20

The thing is all he said was 'people trade food parcels for drugs'. The overwhelming majority of food parcels come from food banks. Some food parcels might have been distributed by schools as well, but in terms of the most recent scheme, that was an alternative, not the primary offering.

Whether or not the food parcels he's referring to are food parcels from schools or food parcels from food banks doesn't seem to be particularly significant to the conversation.

ancientgran · 24/10/2020 18:13

Schools did provide parcels, I actually saw a head teacher on local news during lockdown, he was taking parcels to children's homes.

So there were food parcels and as the conversations weren't about food banks it is reasonable to assume he was referring to the parcels children entitled to FSMs got during the summer.

So did you just assume he was talking about food banks or is there any actual evidence that was what he was talking about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread