Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to Think MNHQ needs to tackle the ageism on this site?

556 replies

LastGoldenDaysOfSummer · 15/10/2020 08:07

The venom and hate aimed at older people on some of the Covid threads is disgusting. If the same was aimed at disabled, TW or BAME people then the posts would be deleted immediately, and rightly so.

But because it's the elderly it's left to stand, even after being reported. This isn't new, MNHQ has always been a hotbed of ageism but it's usually dealt with when reported.

But not any more. Should they be doing more?

OP posts:
TheSeedsOfADream · 19/10/2020 10:24

@TheEmojiFormerlyKnownAsPrince, I do some social media moderating and almost all the clients have a "inflammatory" or "hate speech" button to escalate the post being assessed. MN obviously does its own moderation but there must be something that says forum owners be held to account for allowing hate speech to stand.
I'm NOT blaming HQ, and as I say, they do delete most of the posts. But it does need more close moderation.

TheSeedsOfADream · 19/10/2020 10:21

I've just revisited the "for some random 80 year old with dementia" thread. I hid it after the self-styled scientific expert tried to pick a fight with me on the thread after I said I was the one who had reported her. (Obviously she tried to rewrite history and say all she'd said was something about figures in carehomes) pleased to see the tide did turn on the thread after that and that was the last thread she posted on under that name. I'm sure if I could be arsed to cross match I'd find another hate speaker who started with the eugenics fangirling the same day though.

TheEmojiFormerlyKnownAsPrince · 19/10/2020 10:20

Has anyone else contacted them or reported anything? Or drawn their attention to this thread?

Could Ofcom help?

grumplass · 19/10/2020 10:10

The threads on Coronavirus are horrible and things that are said there are plain hate speech. Scotsnet is similar. I wish mumsnet would do something about it

TheEmojiFormerlyKnownAsPrince · 19/10/2020 10:02

They’re both insidious and nasty though. And come from the same place.

grumplass · 19/10/2020 10:00

Sorry I haven't read the entire thread... but wondering if there are 2 different things going on? There's one kind of ageism on here which is pure misogyny and comparable to racism .... the general feeling that anyone past menopause should just go to gransnet and stop moaning. Women hate themselves so much and don't even know it.
Then there is the general ageism in the Coronavirus topic. Old people ( over 50) should accept their lot and die

LiveintheNow · 19/10/2020 09:43

There is a lovely example on this thread, talking about 'old people smell'

To worry about DH's weird breath smell? http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4053789-To-worry-about-DHs-weird-breath-smell

TheSeedsOfADream · 19/10/2020 09:17

@RiotAndAlarum

... but AIBU and Relationships are a laboratory for case-by-case judgement and teasing out of prejudices and unconsidered ideas.
The eugenics is on Coronavirus topics though. And it's all over the shop.
TheSeedsOfADream · 19/10/2020 09:17

Again, I think it's to do more with the demographic of the average common or garden MNer these days. Definitely way younger, so probably have small children rather than teens or uni student children. So "the elderly" to them is their gran, not their mother, and students are still nearer to their own age than their children's if that makes any sense.

I defend teenagers to the hilt (I have 300 though only gave birth to one Grin) and likewise students. And there IS abuse directed towards them.

RiotAndAlarum · 19/10/2020 09:12

... but AIBU and Relationships are a laboratory for case-by-case judgement and teasing out of prejudices and unconsidered ideas.

RiotAndAlarum · 19/10/2020 09:11

@TheEmojiFormerlyKnownAsPrince

I hope you will also report posts that are on the same lines made about young people too. After all, been ageist is about age, not just older people.

FWIW, I found that the ‘older’ posters on MN tend to be very dismissive of the young (snowflakes anyone? Or any comment about been born with a silver spoon in their mouth, not knowing the value of money, having it EASY etc etcc)
And posters with teens/young adults can be protective of said young people and say that boomers (so NOT you or me!) should appreciate they had many advantages (which BOOMERS had tbf).

As long as people will carry on pitting people against each other and try to outdo each other on who had it worse, it will carry on.

I thinkl said the Millennialls had been shafted. I would never ever call them snowflakes. My Millennials are grafters. Ive never understood the term ‘snowflake’ and never use it. They’ve had a shit deal.

Yes l would report it. But no one amongst my similar aged friends use the term or think it’s applicable. Ugh, that Armu advert that referred to snowflakes. That was just appalling.

Yes, this is also a terrible form of inter-generational hatred, and especially shocking given that MNers are disproportionately mothers (or other carers), and so we really do interact with the interests of other age groups. That's not to say we have to think young people can never be selfish, or old people are terrible put-upon, but we shou
RiotAndAlarum · 19/10/2020 09:11

@TheEmojiFormerlyKnownAsPrince

I hope you will also report posts that are on the same lines made about young people too. After all, been ageist is about age, not just older people.

FWIW, I found that the ‘older’ posters on MN tend to be very dismissive of the young (snowflakes anyone? Or any comment about been born with a silver spoon in their mouth, not knowing the value of money, having it EASY etc etcc)
And posters with teens/young adults can be protective of said young people and say that boomers (so NOT you or me!) should appreciate they had many advantages (which BOOMERS had tbf).

As long as people will carry on pitting people against each other and try to outdo each other on who had it worse, it will carry on.

I thinkl said the Millennialls had been shafted. I would never ever call them snowflakes. My Millennials are grafters. Ive never understood the term ‘snowflake’ and never use it. They’ve had a shit deal.

Yes l would report it. But no one amongst my similar aged friends use the term or think it’s applicable. Ugh, that Armu advert that referred to snowflakes. That was just appalling.

Yes, this is also a terrible form of inter-generational hatred, and especially shocking given that MNers are disproportionately mothers (or other carers), and so we really do interact with the interests of other age groups. That's not to say we have to think young people can never be selfish, or old people are terrible put-upon, but we shou
TheEmojiFormerlyKnownAsPrince · 19/10/2020 09:00

I hope you will also report posts that are on the same lines made about young people too.
After all, been ageist is about age, not just older people.

FWIW, I found that the ‘older’ posters on MN tend to be very dismissive of the young (snowflakes anyone? Or any comment about been born with a silver spoon in their mouth, not knowing the value of money, having it EASY etc etcc)
And posters with teens/young adults can be protective of said young people and say that boomers (so NOT you or me!) should appreciate they had many advantages (which BOOMERS had tbf).

As long as people will carry on pitting people against each other and try to outdo each other on who had it worse, it will carry on.

I thinkl said the Millennialls had been shafted. I would never ever call them snowflakes. My Millennials are grafters. Ive never understood the term ‘snowflake’ and never use it. They’ve had a shit deal.

Yes l would report it. But no one amongst my similar aged friends use the term or think it’s applicable. Ugh, that Armu advert that referred to snowflakes. That was just appalling.

TheSeedsOfADream · 19/10/2020 08:52

Posted too soon.

Was saying, people are slagging students off, but not advocating euthanising them.

And the piece of shit (who has now namechanged but is immediately recognisable) talking about "dribbling dementees in their dirty nappies" wasn't challenged. But she would have been if it had been a disabled teenager.

TheSeedsOfADream · 19/10/2020 08:50

I haven't seen many posts in the Coronavirus section advocating eugenics on people because they're young tbh. Or talking about how someone they know (though I didn't believe that one) owned a carehome and told their staff in the event of a fire "not to bother with those on the top floor" (it wouldn't have been said by someone working with severely disabled teenagers I don't think)

Xenia · 19/10/2020 08:43

Ageism is against the young too., I remember when the first age discrimination legislation came out in the UK we had to hammer that home to people although age discrimination law is not the same as other discriminations. Eg if you need someone with 10 years of surgery experience and you don't pick someone who is 21 that is not illegally ageist.

RiotAndAlarum · 19/10/2020 08:15

I voted YABU because if Mumsnet does one thing well, it's to allow posters to be challenged, and that's only become more possible with the "quote" feature (no editing that!). The rise of the "Karen" insult, and its applicability to older women, should have made us all more sensitive to ageism and sexism: if we wield these weapons ourselves, they can be wielded against us, too. Therefore, arguing against ageism is, in most cases, a job for all of us, not just MNHQ.

TheSeedsOfADream · 19/10/2020 07:07

[quote MoiraRoseisupSchittCreek]@echt - did you get a reply from MNHQ about the thread we both reported (the one about age determining whether death was tragic)?

I asked them to respond via PM and didn't hear from them.[/quote]
I've sent them a list of "ones to watch" from that thread. Two particularly charming hate speakers.

Aridane · 19/10/2020 06:33

I hope you will also report posts that are on the same lines made about young people too.
After all, been ageist is about age, not just older people.

If you don’t get the difference between a poster describing a young person as entitled / whatever and a poster effectively saying that the lives of the elderly are not worth living let alone saving, you are part of the problem

MoiraRoseisupSchittCreek · 19/10/2020 04:37

I can tell you now its is entirely possible to say something is a personal attack when it's the argument being attacked and get the post deleted and the poster's knuckles rapped

I got suspended for the same reason!

anyginplease · 19/10/2020 04:04

Yanbu at alll

echt · 19/10/2020 04:03

@echt - did you get a reply from MNHQ about the thread we both reported (the one about age determining whether death was tragic)?

No. But I'm less and less surprised about the idiosyncratic methods of MNHQ. I had my account suspended a while ago, for troll hunting (yes)and personal attack. (no) I can tell you now its is entirely possible to say something is a personal attack when it's the argument being attacked and get the post deleted and the poster's knuckles rapped.

However you can call someone out on being troll in so many words, yet that is OK, not troll-hunting.

Rant over.

They really really don't get the ageism at all.

MoiraRoseisupSchittCreek · 19/10/2020 03:47

@echt - did you get a reply from MNHQ about the thread we both reported (the one about age determining whether death was tragic)?

I asked them to respond via PM and didn't hear from them.

echt · 19/10/2020 03:18

After all, been ageist is about age, not just older people

While strictly true, its most immediately understood application is about older people.

PhilSwagielka · 19/10/2020 03:10

I do have to agree. There’s a lot of threads about how the young are so entitled and a bunch of snowflakes and it wasn’t like that in WW2 when everyone was stoic and had no emotions and just got on with it. It’s tiresome.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread