Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to Think MNHQ needs to tackle the ageism on this site?

556 replies

LastGoldenDaysOfSummer · 15/10/2020 08:07

The venom and hate aimed at older people on some of the Covid threads is disgusting. If the same was aimed at disabled, TW or BAME people then the posts would be deleted immediately, and rightly so.

But because it's the elderly it's left to stand, even after being reported. This isn't new, MNHQ has always been a hotbed of ageism but it's usually dealt with when reported.

But not any more. Should they be doing more?

OP posts:
Mintjulia · 15/10/2020 10:33

There's an example on the first page of this thread......."Some people have teenagers in their 50s".

Err, I had a 5yo in my 50s. There are plenty of us with primary age children. People just don't think. Grin

But it exists in every sort of media. According to the tabloids, anyone over 50 has a gold plated pension Hmm, we all own houses outright, had free university and now while away our time pottering. Rather than the reality of working full time, doing the school run and running a house like anyone else.

Ignorant, lazy reporting and frankly dim.

In covid terms, the country would grind to a halt if every over-50 flung up their hands and isolated. Most head teachers, hospital consultants, senior govt officials and senior police officers are in their fifties. But also thousands of carers, train drivers, nurses, supermarket staff, childminders, psychiatrists, water engineers etc. Without us society wouldn't survive.

In my last work place there was a discussion about whether we needed a tampon dispenser in the loo because there were only 3 women in the building and I was told I was too old to need one. By a 30yo woman. Grin Grin Grin. If only.

So mumsnet is no better and no worse than everywhere else. It would be nice if it were better.

eaglejulesk · 15/10/2020 10:32

The inequalities between the lives of the baby boomers - the wealth and opportunities they had and have and have been steadily removing from those behind them - and those of us who have to work to support their luxury, is appalling.

And here we go again - would you please tell me where this luxury of mine is, because I seem to have mislaid it somewhere! If I were to make a sweeping generalization about a generation of young people I would be shot down in flames., but it's okay to take pot shots at the older generation.

Belladonna12 · 15/10/2020 10:27

The mental health of a generation who can’t mix and socialise and make and build relationships is not a easy thing to deal with. It’s big ask to expect them to put their lives on hold.

It's a bit of an exaggeration to say that they can't mix and socialise. I have teenage children and whilst they have been a bit restricted it would be very untrue to say they haven't been able to socialise at all. They have certainly been less restricted than the elderly or shielding.

SonjaMorgan · 15/10/2020 10:26

I haven't read the threads being discussed but this does work both ways. There are posts about "idiot" students and "millennials". There are so many issues bubbling under the surface and the age divide isn't going away anytime soon.

TableFlowerss · 15/10/2020 10:24

It breaks my heart to think of what the younger generation and children have lost this last year. I hope their mental health can recover

@Nanny0gg

Me to. The irony in some of the posts that just think of it from their perspective. They couldn’t card less about the young one, and get pissed off when someone explains that actually, yours chucking one generation under the bus....

Cadent · 15/10/2020 10:23

You do see the opposite too. I see many older regular posters try to tie up younger posters in knots.

I’m somewhere in between Grin

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/10/2020 10:20

It breaks my heart to think of what the younger generation and children have lost this last year. I hope their mental health can recover

I think everyone has had to sacrifice in their own way - no greater or less, I don’t know anyone who hasn’t suffered some form of loss or disappointment. What those losses are will differ but be no less meaningful, why does it need to be a case of which matters more, or causes more impact on mental health.

TableFlowerss · 15/10/2020 10:20

There is a thread in the Coronavirus topic on how we're "sacrificing the young" to save the old, as if students not being allowed to party and older and sick people dying are equivalent things. That gives a pretty good idea of the value placed on older people by some posters on here. Posters are not saying that older people should shield, but that they have had their lives and big houses and pensions and should shuffle off and let the young enjoy themselves

@GCAcademic

But the very example you use is one that makes it sound like all the younger generation are losing out simply on is getting pissed up. It’s such a negative example and bias.

It’s such a narrow minded view that focuses solely on one age group and their needs and completely sidelines the other.

The mental health of a generation who can’t mix and socialise and make and build relationships is not a easy thing to deal with. It’s big ask to expect them to put their lives on hold.

The younger generations mental is a concern of mine but some people couldn’t card less!!!

eaglejulesk · 15/10/2020 10:19

According to quite a few posters it is now time for me, as a scummy boomer to have my assets and my future plundered as I have been selfishly keeping the young down.

Yes, good luck with that! I have no assets and I'm unemployed - but I should be feeling sorry for the the young because I must be wealthy and, as you said, selfishly keeping them down. From what I read on MN many young people are far more wealthy than I ever could have been - but because I am a "boomer" that can't be right, and I've had everything handed to me on a plate. Not sure where that plate got to!

Nanny0gg · 15/10/2020 10:12

@TableFlowerss

The same argument could be had about the disregard of the younger generation. Plenty people think it’s fine to not give two sh!ts about the youngsters or to acknowledge how it affects them and how they’re having to sacrifice a lot, but that’s allowed?!
It breaks my heart to think of what the younger generation and children have lost this last year. I hope their mental health can recover
Nanny0gg · 15/10/2020 10:10

@saraclara

People over 60 were being blamed for even going to the shops during lockdown! It was absolutely ridiculous. I think that was the period when I saw the most blatant generalisation and ageism going on here. It was infuriating. Every second post seemed to be about some bewildered or casual old person in the supermarket.
It's a miracle any of the 'older generation ' was allowed out at all as most of us are clearly not capable of making our own decisions anymore and have to be protected at all costs from ourselves
GCAcademic · 15/10/2020 10:08

@turnitonagain

OP can you give a specific example? Because I’m not sure saying the vulnerable should shield is ageism worth of deletion.
There is a thread in the Coronavirus topic on how we're "sacrificing the young" to save the old, as if students not being allowed to party and older and sick people dying are equivalent things. That gives a pretty good idea of the value placed on older people by some posters on here. Posters are not saying that older people should shield, but that they have had their lives and big houses and pensions and should shuffle off and let the young enjoy themselves.
earthycarrots · 15/10/2020 10:07

The generation that has welcomed huge levels of immigration from everywhere, which reduces wages and increases our population and pressure on the infrastructure they have dismantled.

So you want the immigrants all to go 'home' then Hmm

BoulangerieBabs · 15/10/2020 10:05

I dunno I’m torn on this. The older generation have prospered whilst younger generations have a shit time of it picking up the pieces with no opportunities. Then the older generation predominantly voted brexit and conservative which has and will make it harder still for the younger generations who are struggling and now there’s a virus that is only really affecting them and the younger generations are losing everything to protect them

What do you class as the older generation? I'm mid 50's as is my husband so you can guess the age of our parents.

We both work full time and are extremely invested in the economy, we have no choice because we still have a 15 year old child to raise. Neither us nor our parents voted for Brexit either, in fact I know very few people from my generation and above that did vote for it.

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/10/2020 10:05

The generation that has welcomed huge levels of immigration from everywhere, which reduces wages and increases our population and pressure on the infrastructure they have dismantled.

The generation which welcomed immigration from everywhere, creating diverse and culturally rich communities while paying people a pittance to do jobs the indigenous population wouldn’t do for any price.

There, I fixed the inherent racism in your post, you’re welcome.

DynamoKev · 15/10/2020 10:05

Then the older generation predominantly voted brexit and conservative which has and will make it harder still for the younger generations who are struggling
This level of ignorance is staggering and is certainly very ageist

TableFlowerss · 15/10/2020 10:05

The same argument could be had about the disregard of the younger generation. Plenty people think it’s fine to not give two sh!ts about the youngsters or to acknowledge how it affects them and how they’re having to sacrifice a lot, but that’s allowed?!

Nanny0gg · 15/10/2020 10:03

@FTMF30

Why are people getting so offended by the Gransnet section? It's useful to organise forums so that you can easily get the help you need and/or talk to like minded people. I don't see hardcore feminists complaining that they are being 'othered' because their is a feminism board, or the same with black mums complaining there's a black section, or parents with kids who have special needs complaining that there is a special needs section. It is designed to be a space where you can talk about things specific to you. Use it if you think it's useful and don't if you don't. No one is forcing any of you to do either.

Also, Gransnet will obviously be linked somewhat to age, but it's basically for anyone who is a Gran (i.e. a Grandparent). Some of you are so entitled, you've got to a point you're doing yourselves a disservice.

So let's have a Gransden topic on here. I can't be bothered to go to a whole separate forum
SecretSpAD · 15/10/2020 10:00

*I am talking about that group as a generation. Let's see. That generation would have been the people steadily dismantling the public sector since the 80s. Steadily dismantling employment rights. Cashing in on Right to Buy and privatisations of publicly-owned utilities. The generation that oversaw the great leap back into private renting and buy-to-let that had been dismantled by the earlier generations, which is causing widespread poverty everywhere. The generation that has welcomed huge levels of immigration from everywhere, which reduces wages and increases our population and pressure on the infrastructure they have dismantled.

And finally, that is the generation that have taken us out of the EU and removed our EU citizenship rights. So much to thank you for.*

I think you are mistaking age for Tory supporter.

DimityDeNimes · 15/10/2020 09:58

you have to consistently remind yourself that women are a vast range. There are many, many different stereotypes that fit our gender, so there is no stereotypical woman. But our sex we share ~
Dame Jenni Murray (aged 70 years 5 months)

Copying and pasting this quote from another thread on ageism. We are all in this together and we mustn't let this virus and the misogynist PM and his cronies divide us.

Jojoanna · 15/10/2020 09:58

Talking negatively about an entire group or generation is ageist! How can you not understand that?

I'm over 60 and didn't do any of those things, thank you very much

Agreed

CounsellorTroi · 15/10/2020 09:58

*I am talking about that group as a generation. Let's see. That generation would have been the people steadily dismantling the public sector since the 80s. Steadily dismantling employment rights. Cashing in on Right to Buy and privatisations of publicly-owned utilities. The generation that oversaw the great leap back into private renting and buy-to-let that had been dismantled by the earlier generations, which is causing widespread poverty everywhere. The generation that has welcomed huge levels of immigration from everywhere, which reduces wages and increases our population and pressure on the infrastructure they have dismantled.

And finally, that is the generation that have taken us out of the EU and removed our EU citizenship rights. So much to thank you for.*

I’m a remainer and lifelong Labour voter. As are most of my friends. Dismantling employment rights and privatising public utilities are not what I voted for. Likewise right to buy. Yet it seems you still hold me responsible for those things because of my age. And you think you’re not ageist?

saraclara · 15/10/2020 09:58

People over 60 were being blamed for even going to the shops during lockdown! It was absolutely ridiculous. I think that was the period when I saw the most blatant generalisation and ageism going on here. It was infuriating. Every second post seemed to be about some bewildered or casual old person in the supermarket.

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/10/2020 09:57

That generation would have been the people steadily dismantling the public sector since the 80s. Steadily dismantling employment rights. Cashing in on Right to Buy and privatisations of publicly-owned utilities. The generation that oversaw the great leap back into private renting and buy-to-let that had been dismantled by the earlier generations, which is causing widespread poverty everywhere. The generation that has welcomed huge levels of immigration from everywhere, which reduces wages and increases our population and pressure on the infrastructure they have dismantled.

The generation who have lived through three significant recessions, were coming to a housing market with 15% interest rates, the generation who saw an improvement in employment rights right across the board (which are now being dismantled by a Tory government via Brexit).

It’s in this governments interest to divide and conquer - issues around immigration, economy, Brexit, are all driven by the idea that others cause austerity and hardship which nearly removes responsibility from the shit show that is our government (which a sizeable proportion of under 50s voted for too). If they can get generations blaming each other too, all the better.

diplodocusinermine · 15/10/2020 09:56

[[https://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/coronavirus/4051199-Are-we-sacrificing-the-young-to-save-the-elderly[[

Plenty on this thread.

I'm at the lower end of the age group, still be working for 15 years at least, mortgage, bills, support family. We've been following the rules. My business, built up successfully over the last 13 years has gone down the pan. Luckily for us DH still has a job. We don't have the time to financially rebuild if this goes on much longer but I still won't be going to house parties, crowded pubs, street parties, not wear a mask etc because I understand that this is a virus, anyone can catch it, and importantly, pass it on to someone far more vulnerable. We're both pretty fit and healthy, so hopefully won't succomb if we catch the virus, but I have caring responsibilities for older relatives and I'm sorry, but I will not shorten their time on this earth by risking bringing Covid into their homes.

I have no idea how younger, vulnerable people must feel. I'm guessing written off (more so than usual).

One thing this whole situation has brought home to me is there is a real lack of humanity among certain people. Clap for the NHS, but don't give a damn about the vulnerable on our society.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread