Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to Think MNHQ needs to tackle the ageism on this site?

556 replies

LastGoldenDaysOfSummer · 15/10/2020 08:07

The venom and hate aimed at older people on some of the Covid threads is disgusting. If the same was aimed at disabled, TW or BAME people then the posts would be deleted immediately, and rightly so.

But because it's the elderly it's left to stand, even after being reported. This isn't new, MNHQ has always been a hotbed of ageism but it's usually dealt with when reported.

But not any more. Should they be doing more?

OP posts:
gamerchick · 16/10/2020 09:13

@Quaagars

I haven't seen any ageism personally Racism and transphobia on the other hand, yes
Coming from you I find this post properly funny. Grin oh dear.
Janevaljane · 16/10/2020 09:04

Dh and I have been very fortunate. We'll pass it all down the line to our kids though and end up living in a shed somewhere.

MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes · 16/10/2020 09:01

I am fully aware of the intersection of prejudices and that not every boat was floated through the post war years. Nevertheless it was a period of stability the like of which we’ve never seen before or since. I really do not know what people were thinking when they sold off and cashed in - as a group, no not everyone etc etc - on the mechanisms which had permitted the period to exist when it can be very clearly compared with the rampant unchecked commercialism of the pre-war and post-Thatcherism periods. I really don’t know how anyone can deny that people living in that period did better than those before or since. Or that the burden of an ageing population is one that we’ve never had to face before and we urgently need honest conversations about it.

There’s outright nastiness on one side, and then there’s refusal to accept reality on the other.

Janevaljane · 16/10/2020 09:01

@Xenia

I would like to see a lot less deletion of anyone as we can all cope with it and can look away if we don't. I am over 50 and can take the heat as I am sure women can when men are nasty to us too and vice versa. Let freedom prevail.

However it is true that generalisations about groups of people whether gay, white, female, old and young tend to be a bit unfair as you do have people in those groups who are not the same Eg I have no pension other than state pension at 67 as I have given it ti HMRC (hundreds of thousands of pounds) when I turned 55 as a gift to the nation (well kind of ,...) and to the children for housing so my children have had more than I had but that is not the narrative the young like to hear.

I don't think the CV19 issue is particularly ageist. I am against the lockdown laws on freedom and human rights grounds even though being over 50 I would be likely to die and younger people would not. To that extent I am fighting the corner of the young.

Let us see if we can delete many fewer posts and let freedom prevail -then people can see the views of others, avoid echo chambers and perhaps even be converted to the views of others.

If only Xenia.
Janevaljane · 16/10/2020 08:58

(I'm 54 and not past it, btw)

Janevaljane · 16/10/2020 08:58

@LeaveMyDamnJam

Those who have an issue with older people need to remember that it will be them one day who are over 50 and past it 😉. Time passes bloody quickly.
Hilarious. I hadn't noticed ageism before I read this post 🤪
TheSeedsOfADream · 16/10/2020 08:57

Other examples: the thread a couple of weeks ago about fatcat boomers (a word which is only ever used abusively) should be MADE by law to give up their nice mortgage free houses to young people who can't afford one. It was as if entire swathes of MN couldn't grasp that those "boomers" hadn't just had that house handed to them (like they were wanting) but had worked, saved, and bought.

Xenia- treading a fine line though. Are you in favour of threads using the N word abusively, or calling the disabled S's? I presume not. Yet you think abuse of the elderly is OK?

I was musing on this, and it's definitely been over the last few years on here that the ageism has taken hold so aggressively. We go from "old bags" tutting at us in Asda, to the thread a couple of weeks ago where an elderly man stopped to exchange a few words with the MNer whose daughter was running round barefoot on the lawn. The exchange was something like "haven't you put your shoes on this morning" to little girl which had the OP wanting to call the police because he was a sicko/paedo/stalker and the OP's husband saying he'd beat him to a pulp if he ever spoke to them again. With the fangirlz cheering. The OP came back to say that through her curtains she'd seen him WALKING UP THE STREET AGAIN so obviously staking the joint. Or going to buy his paper...

CaptainMyCaptain · 16/10/2020 08:55

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@SheepandCow - how about less tax after pension age? That’s what we currently have. Despite the fact that care for the elderly and universal state pensions are a huge cost to the state.[/quote]
Only because of lower income. I pay tax on my Teacher's Pension which is less than half of what I earned. As a WASPI I still haven't got my State Pension but when I do it will be taxed.

chickenyhead · 16/10/2020 08:47

OMG this thread hit the skids

The reason for the pension shortfall wasn't old people fgs, it was dodgy investment by dodgy rich people.

My father was that daemon generation and to choose to pretend that what they went through was privileged is absolutely disgusting.

He was an Irish immigrant builder who worked for a well known building company his whole life. They removed asbestos by hand, there was no health and safety, his pension was a pittance. But thats ok, I guess, because he owned his house.

Ridiculous

Xenia · 16/10/2020 08:47

I would like to see a lot less deletion of anyone as we can all cope with it and can look away if we don't. I am over 50 and can take the heat as I am sure women can when men are nasty to us too and vice versa. Let freedom prevail.

However it is true that generalisations about groups of people whether gay, white, female, old and young tend to be a bit unfair as you do have people in those groups who are not the same Eg I have no pension other than state pension at 67 as I have given it ti HMRC (hundreds of thousands of pounds) when I turned 55 as a gift to the nation (well kind of ,...) and to the children for housing so my children have had more than I had but that is not the narrative the young like to hear.

I don't think the CV19 issue is particularly ageist. I am against the lockdown laws on freedom and human rights grounds even though being over 50 I would be likely to die and younger people would not. To that extent I am fighting the corner of the young.

Let us see if we can delete many fewer posts and let freedom prevail -then people can see the views of others, avoid echo chambers and perhaps even be converted to the views of others.

TheSeedsOfADream · 16/10/2020 08:43

X post serendipitously.

And that one is mild beyond belief compared to the Covid section ones.

TheSeedsOfADream · 16/10/2020 08:42

There's one right now heading that way in AIBU. Cunningly placed there rather than Coronavirus but it's getting there
Examples recently that I've reported (and which have subsequently been deleted) "I'm not going to sacrifice my family for some random 80 year old with dementia" and a doozy yesterday about the absurdity of protecting "dribbling dementia patients sitting in soiled underwear" over the young people of today.

The ageist posts DO get deleted, but there is a hardcore of astroturfers who, if you look at what they post apart from their ageist bile, seems to indicate the new alt right anti state intervention for the vulnerable it's all about the money tendency. There's a handful of names, that whatever thread you see them on, you know, they're going to trot out the 80 year olds should be dead anyway soon trope.

Ablist posts, racist posts, ageist posts. They all need to be dealt with. It's not a competition.

MoiraRoseisupSchittCreek · 16/10/2020 08:42

Here's a thread for those of you demanding examples of ageism on MN.

BIWI · 16/10/2020 08:42

@DimityDeNimes

The thread was started to discuss ageism against older people on MN not argue about student infection rates. It's irrelevant
Not according to the title of the thread it wasn't.

The OP is an example of ageism - there's plenty more examples of ageism on this site, against younger and older people.

And yes, I call it out/report it when I see it, before you ask!

MoiraRoseisupSchittCreek · 16/10/2020 08:33

The Style & Beauty board often has ageist threads "are these old lady shoes?" "help! I look like an old hag!" "can I wear my hair long now I'm 50?"

I'm pleased to say they are being robustly challenged more and more.

Madhairday · 16/10/2020 08:27

YANBU op. The covid threads are raging with ageism and ableism too and it is left there generally by mnhq. It's not that we perceive a discussion about whether the elderly and vulnerable should be sheilded as ageism, but the kind of language used to 'other' them:

They only have months to live anyway.
They're only sat round in soiled nappies all day, what's the point in keeping them alive?
The vulnerable take enough off the state already and now they're ruining the lives of the young and fit.
They all voted Tory so bought it on themselves.

Etc.

Huge generalisations and sweeping language used to minimise and dehumanise. And I see it over and over and over. I am weary with it, as one of those pesky ECV people. Weary.

DynamoKev · 16/10/2020 08:05

@Quaagars

I haven't seen any ageism personally Racism and transphobia on the other hand, yes
Read the thread - there is plenty
MagpieSong · 16/10/2020 07:29

@ChasedByFox

And please do not conflate ageism with racism. People that are now old were once young. People that.are non-white we're not previously white. They've never had white privilege in a way that older people now once had youth.

Two separate issues, both need addressing.

I agree and also not all racist comments have been dealt with. Some posts went unreported and therefore stayed up, those reported were dealt with. There have been a number of nationalist, racist comments when people have sought their own board for the black community, or the Asian community - many of the responses to that were vile. It’s a different issue and one which many never understand because they’ll never change their heritage.

As for ageism, yes there has been some undeniably. The ‘lock up over 50s and don’t let them ruin our kids lives’. I find that annoying as these people won’t feel that way if we have a pandemic and they’re 50+, equally 50+ isn’t old - most people are in good roles at work, have experience and many still have youngish children at that age. There are also plenty of kinship or foster carers in that age range with kids. Are the offensive posts being reported as I expect it’s difficult to police them without notice being drawn?

VinylDetective · 16/10/2020 07:17

@tillytown

They’re not whining. That’s the prerogative of the generations behind them. Implying that all younger people are whiny is ageist, do better VinylDetective
Check the context, honey. It’s not me who needs to do better.
Aridane · 16/10/2020 04:04

I agree, OP - the ageism is disgusting. Read any covid thread and substitute ‘Jew’ or ‘black’ for ‘elderly’ and one sees the the last tolerable ‘ism’ on Mumsnet

echt · 16/10/2020 03:52

There are loads of pensioners who paid minimal amounts in during their working lives but are living on very comfortable pensions for 30 years or more

Any evidence for this?

Loads who had nice jobs for life and retired on the dot of 60 or 65

Not so sure about nice jobs for life but why should anyone work after pension age? Also, where's your evidence for this?

CLUE: "Loads" is not not a statistic.

Many companies have nightmare pension liabilities because of these people

Who? Evidence?

Oh, and this:

www.theguardian.com/money/2004/jul/10/pensions.jobsandmoney

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/pension-payments-holiday-to-ease-pressure-on-firms-wjddcv3gn

theconversation.com/britains-great-pension-robbery-why-the-defined-benefits-gold-standard-is-a-luxury-of-the-past-100844

www.ft.com/content/c4217e98-6926-11ea-800d-da70cff6e4d3

The only people getting fucked over here are the pensioners, present and future.

tillytown · 16/10/2020 01:44

They’re not whining. That’s the prerogative of the generations behind them.
Implying that all younger people are whiny is ageist, do better VinylDetective

eaglejulesk · 16/10/2020 00:19

Stop putting millions of people into tiny little boxes, based on your own narrow life experiences.

In the real world, no one generation is a homogeneous group.

There are huge variations within every generation - income and attitude included.

Well said.

SheepandCow · 16/10/2020 00:12

Right anyhow. It's all sorted now.

Problem solved.

From now onwards we encourage young people to smoke and eat lots of cake and crisps.

Never again will we need this argument. No-one lives to pension age. No pension or care costs, and lots of tax revenue to spend on the needs of the present. No need to worry about the future. Win win.

SheepandCow · 16/10/2020 00:08

@VinylDetective

Zero sympathy for their whining

They’re not whining. That’s the prerogative of the generations behind them.

Grin
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.