Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to Think MNHQ needs to tackle the ageism on this site?

556 replies

LastGoldenDaysOfSummer · 15/10/2020 08:07

The venom and hate aimed at older people on some of the Covid threads is disgusting. If the same was aimed at disabled, TW or BAME people then the posts would be deleted immediately, and rightly so.

But because it's the elderly it's left to stand, even after being reported. This isn't new, MNHQ has always been a hotbed of ageism but it's usually dealt with when reported.

But not any more. Should they be doing more?

OP posts:
Xenia · 17/10/2020 09:11

I think young and old can come together. Parent love their adult children and want to help them and vice versa.

Shakespeare put it well although I am sure someone will come along and say the sonnet is ageist.

Crabbed Age and Youth
Cannot live together:
Youth is full of pleasance,
Age is full of care;
Youth like summer morn,
Age like winter weather;
Youth like summer brave,
Age like winter bare:
Youth is full of sports,
Age's breath is short,
Youth is nimble, Age is lame:
Youth is hot and bold,
Age is weak and cold,
Youth is wild, and Age is tame:-
Age, I do abhor thee;
Youth, I do adore thee;
O! my Love, my Love is young!
Age, I do defy thee-
O sweet shepherd, hie thee,
For methinks thou stay'st too long.

RainingBatsAndFrogs · 17/10/2020 07:54

MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes and as I carry on working until I am 66 or 67, my taxes are paying towards the free childcare hours that I missed out on, the free meals in primary that we didn’t get.

It is absolutely clear though that housing is far harder for the new generations and the whole global situation is tougher. But the crash of 2008, recession, etc are hardly all down to upholding pensions.

Sertchgi123 · 17/10/2020 07:12

I hate the threads that say that all grandparents should step up and provide childcare. It would seem that many young adults today feel entitled and believe their parents shouldn’t have a life.

Northernsoulgirl45 · 17/10/2020 07:06

Yanbu op.
Some posts on this thread have proved your point very nicely.
Exactly like similar threads started about the disabled/vulnerable.
My parents are no longer alive but they worked hard all their lives and lived in council house squalor. The house I grew up in was damp and I now have asthma/bronchitis.
Like another poster my Irish immigrant father worked with asbestos and ended his life struggling to breathe.
They had no spare money to pay into a pension or a mortgage. Hell some weeks they ran out of food.
They never voted Tory and neither have I or my siblings.
My baby boomer WASPI sibling worked from age 16, never had dc and spend her last 5 years before receiving her state pension on JSA. It was a miserable existance. She still had to pay council tax but people with dc were exempt.
Really not sure how prople like this have ruined anyone's future.
Never voted for BREXIT either

mygrandchildrenrock · 17/10/2020 06:44

@RainingBatsAndFrogs

I can’t stand the ageist generalisations, usually the ‘older generation’ (when they are talking about 60 yo MIL) are racist / sexist etc.

It’s so stupid: your grandmother’s generation invented the Equal Pay Act, the Sex Discrimination Act, your Mum was probably Rocking Against Racism and wearing an Anti Nazi League badge.

Well said!
Hyperfish101 · 17/10/2020 06:42

As an older person I see it on here. The Covid threads have an undercurrent of ageism and ableism. And some of the discussions about conceiving after 40 can be unpleasant.

mrsswayze · 17/10/2020 06:36

I didn't realise I'd be banished to grans net at 50 my youngest will be 7 😂
I have noticed the ageism as well on her especially on COVID threads . If some posters had there way I'd be forced to isolated , how would I be able to do my job as a nurse though 🤔
Mumsnet need to sort this out as it's very obviousl

LiveintheNow · 17/10/2020 06:29

'Life is harder now'

Try watching Cathy Come Home,
www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-51100189

That is the world I was born into.

Aridane · 17/10/2020 06:18

Like racism can be a fear that non whites come into the uk and take our jobs?

Pixxie7 · 17/10/2020 06:12

It has become more noticeable over the past 6 months, but I think some of it is down to the current Covid and fear for the young.

Aridane · 17/10/2020 05:58

@HebeMumsnet. Thanks for clarifying. The point though is not the more egregious ageist posts - which are readily capable of deletion - but the strong ‘othering’ of the elderly and dismissal of the value of their lives and that permeates the covid threads and seems to be in the DNA of so many posters. Where the whole premise of the post (or thread) is ageist.

I guess some ‘isms’ shock us to the core - eg I don’t think I’ve ever seen posts complaining about BAME covid patients clogging up hospital beds unlike the complaints about the ‘oldies’ clogging up hospital beds.

Aridane · 17/10/2020 05:46

@DeeCeeCherryn- you really do t get it, do you. So racism’s is not ok in your book but ageism somehow is, which is why the substitution sticks in your craw.

The bbc series on Harold shipman is interesting and a premise of it in part is that shipman was only able to get away with what he did because they were elderly and attitudes to elderly

I now cannot help, when reading the ageist posts, substituting ‘jew’ for ‘elderly’ and goodness the post then become gasp worthy in their blatant ageism

echt · 17/10/2020 03:22

So many saying 'But if it were BAME'

Why not? Comparisons are helpful for clarifying the debate. The same goes for the way MNHQ jump all over the trans issue: it's holding MNHQ to account.

DeeCeeCherry · 17/10/2020 01:59

So many saying 'But if it were BAME'.

Racist af. If you think there's an issue with ageism then stick to that, nothing to do with BAME. Racism creeps in everywhere. Unable to stick to discussing an issue without bringing race into it. Ridiculous, and bigoted.

Unless you're thick enough to think Black women are somehow ageless and never reach 50, or 70, so ageism can never affect us too. The irony of being racist 'yeah but BAME's, yet complaining about ageism.

There was so much racism on here that a Black Mumsnetters section had to be created. Do the maths.

Pelleas · 17/10/2020 01:19

Live in unsafe lodgings with Rachman style landlords

Yes - my mum has stories about her lodgings in the 1960s that would make you shudder.

The area was eventually condemned as a slum and she was rehoused in a tower block, which she said was marvellous by comparison.

eaglejulesk · 17/10/2020 01:10

It's interesting how so many people judge how life was lived by previous generations by doing some research on the internet. Unless you were there you really haven't the faintest idea. People don't seem to learn the history of their country by listening to the stories told by older generations any more, but think they know better because they read a report. Reports don't reflect the actual feelings and struggles of those who were there.

SheepandCow · 17/10/2020 00:03

@MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes

I see that you are happy enough to generalise widely about strangers without one shred of evidence yourself. Yet you, as other baby boomers, do not like the generalisation that everyone can see for themselves. It does not wash. And it never will.
I'm not a baby boomer.
SheepandCow · 17/10/2020 00:02

Want to be like previous generations?
Don't go to university. Leave school at 14 or 15 and go straight into (often) manual work. No sick pay, no maternity pay (in fact, don't work if you're a woman).

Live in unsafe lodgings with Rachman style landlords who'll beat you (or your husband) up if they want you out, have your children taken off you if you become homeless or even just a single mum. Rent a shabby flat with no gas, fire, or electrical safety.

Oh - and smoke.

MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes · 16/10/2020 23:59

I see that you are happy enough to generalise widely about strangers without one shred of evidence yourself. Yet you, as other baby boomers, do not like the generalisation that everyone can see for themselves. It does not wash. And it never will.

SheepandCow · 16/10/2020 23:56

@MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes
You clearly fail to see the overlooked members of the middle-aged and older generations. I don't expect they exist in some people's narrow little middle-class havens (note, this is not a dig at the middle-class as a whole, just the narrow-minded who refuse to acknowledge the world outside their bubble).

There was a report published shortly before the pandemic detailing how the over 40s are the fastest growing group in private renting. Unlike younger people, they're in dire straits. No Help To Buy tax gifts for them.

Inequality and poverty exists amongst every generation.

The ones who profiteered from right to buy or buy to let are a minority of their generation. Who do you think rented off the buy to letters? Magic unicorns? It was other less fortunate people of the same generation.

Someone posted a link upthread. Data on the million plus pensioners living in poverty. These people exist. They're real.

MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes · 16/10/2020 23:36

And yet we have an ageing population. And yet the average age expectation has gone up with that generation. And yet buy-to-let happened, and now house ownership has fallen and the average age of first time buyers has gone up.

I am not just speaking from statistical generalisations. The statistical generalisations back up observation everywhere. Do you think we do not see our parents and grand parents? Do you think we don’t see all our neighbours? I do not know how many trolls there are making mischief or people who are seriously blinkered but irl most admit that life is harder now.

SheepandCow · 16/10/2020 23:23

Like I said yesterday. We have a simple solution. 🚬 and 🍰 Smoking and cake. Stress relief, higher tax revenue, shorter life expectancy so lower pension payouts (and no social or care home costs). Win win.

SheepandCow · 16/10/2020 23:21

@CayrolBaaaskin

I should clarify that of course people will contribute different amounts throughout their lives and that is to be expected. However there is a cohort of current pensioners who benefited from low state pension ages, high house price inflation (so cheap housing when they bought it but now worth a fortune due to no effort of theirs), free education and so on. I do think it’s unfair as my daughters generation will pay for the majority of this.
Yes. The affluent middle-class cohort. Then there's the rest of their generation. The majority. Who didn't go to university. They left school at 14, 15, or at a push 16. Straight into work. Lived in shabby lodgings and retired younger- but also died sooner. Because they smoked. Perhaps we should do the same. Higher pensions received for shorter periods, paid for through smoking taxes.
cbt944 · 16/10/2020 23:18

Goodness. Well, for those who have mysteriously missed the ageism that is threaded into a good 90% plus of all Covid-related threads (along with a level of casual eugenics about 'the vulnerable', in general, that would make a Nazi blush), there is enough on this page alone to show that it really is a problem here, and elsewhere.

gamerchick · 16/10/2020 23:17

[quote SheepandCow]@gamerchick
Yes I agree. Completely wrong.
I like think it comes from ignorance rather than malice. I definitely don't agree with much of what she says but she has the right to her views. Views she's honest about. She owns them.[/quote]
Right and so do the rest of us. There are few topics on here that are kind to ignorance. Are the elderly exempt? Considering the topic of this thread, there might be a bit of irony there..

Or maybe irony is the wrong word.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread