Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum says she wishes she never had children as 'life was better without them'

656 replies

toothfairy73 · 03/10/2020 17:31

I have just seen this headline in a Newspaper. A anonymous mum has written this letter stating the above.

apple.news/A7zR8oawtR6OFxqP2tijb6g

What are your thoughts? I'm sure we have all had moments where we miss our old lives. It sounds like it is written by someone deeply unhappy and in need of some support. AIBU to think this is someone who is desperate for a bit of time alone and some support?What do you think?

OP posts:
Mittens030869 · 04/10/2020 18:12

@BewilderedDoughnut

It probably does sound like it's cliche but in a way that is how it was for me. I wasn't particularly broody in my twenties, unlike my DSis, who always really wanted to be a mum. I never thought I didn't want DC, I just put it on the back burner until I met my DH. He did want DC and I realised that I did too.

I just didn't feel the ticking of the 'biological clock' until I was in a loving relationship.

It wasn't something I desperately wanted then, but when I couldn't, the pain was something I never expected to feel.

I'm not the most maternal person ever, but

Morgysmum · 04/10/2020 18:11

I get this, when my son was 4/5 months old, someone asked me if I missed my life before my son. I said yes, I had the blues. I was fat, (baby weight) didn't have much money and was sick, of everyone asking how my son was, but not bothering about me. I did miss my life before my son, I was thinner, had a job and a life. It seemed as all that had gone.
I eventually, got a part time job, which helped as, I got to talk to adults and was once again vicky, not just the person attached to my sons pram. Now 13 years later, I still have days in which I wished I was child free. I think, it does not help, I was with my partner long before I fell pregnant. So I think I feel trapped, to a partner, I aren't feeling attracted to anymore, but stuck with because of my son and lack of money to move out.

PerveenMistry · 04/10/2020 18:11

@SecretSpAD

I think the only thing you can truly say about motherhood is that you really have NO idea how it's going to impact you until you actually go and do it

Except a lot of women, like me, know that we don't find babies and children interesting, don't enjoy spending time with children and have no desire to find out whether we're wrong.

Same here. It just seems like a dreary existence. Excrement, porridge, crying and whining and expense punctuated by a few moments of happiness.

Sarahpaula · 04/10/2020 18:05

This thread is all about mothers regretting having children.

It would be interesting to look at it more from the child's point of view too.

People who had a mother that regretted having them: did you regret being alive?

Because my mother regretted having me,

And I regret being alive,

If I could go back and do my time over, I wouldn't choose to be born.

Mothers - if you are really, really not sure if you want a child - get an abortion.

Save the children from a lifetime that they don't want.

Because I can guarantee you this - if you regret having the child, the child regrets being alive.

PerveenMistry · 04/10/2020 18:03

@ohnonotyetplease

I have one daughter. She's eighteen months and I really have grown to love her. But it haunts me that I didn't really want to be a mum and I still have frequent moments of envy of people who haven't got kids.... The guilt is so awful. I look at posts about heartbroken people who are desperate for a family and I can't get my head round it....then I hate myself for having no instinctive connection with this seemingly absolutely natural and normal desire. Then the ingratitude of my situation - a beautiful healthy happy little girl and I still sometimes just wish I could go back and undo....

That must feel awful. One reason I refrained is the wholly irrevocable nature of parenthood.

Eatdrinkbemerry · 04/10/2020 18:03

I think the trend here is women who have not had partners support them. I only have one DD and she’s at a self sufficient age and if I’m honest I have never once regretted having her.

I was lucky that I had my parents support and also in laws support. DH was hands on, I went back to FT work when she was barely one and he was the parent doing the nursery drop offs and dinner.

We also were on the same page about her bedtime so we could have ‘us’ time and had babysitters in tap for when we wanted to go out.

DH wanted another but for various reasons I was unable to and if I’m honest I am glad I was unable to and he also now agrees. Our lives would have gone backwards. We are now living our lives the way we want and have a level of our independence back and there is no way I would change that.

I’m not saying I had perfect DH as we definitely had a few years adjusting to having a child and the fact we couldn’t just get up and do whatever we wanted was frustrating at times. Our relationship was tested, especially when he wanted another one and I didn’t but I decided to for him.

I guess for us just having one was best thing as I love being a mother but it doesn’t take over being an independent women and wife.

violetindigolilac · 04/10/2020 17:59

I did regret it. My son was unplanned and I've never been maternal. Now he's 17 the regret is a memory however I now have a lot of worry for him over what a covid infested near future holds, he isn't getting the education he would have done ordinarily.

As others have said, a big part of the problem was my son's father.

KylieKangaroo · 04/10/2020 17:58

@bewildereddoughnut my parents did that and one of my brothers followed them to their new smaller house Grin

YouJustDoYou · 04/10/2020 17:57

Children can utterly destroy what was otherwise an amazing relationship.not everyone can hack kids. And the sad part? The men just usually up and leave when the going gets tough, and it's the women left with the raising duties.

BewilderedDoughnut · 04/10/2020 17:54

@Sudoku88 I really love my kids and a huge part of my life has been totally devoted to them, but my god, I can’t wait for them to grow up and leave for university

There are no guarantees. My brothers are both still living at home at 35 and 40 years old. My parents have actually considered leaving the house they love and never coming back.

PerveenMistry · 04/10/2020 17:53

@GettingUntrapped

It sad, and it's sad for our children that we are in this situation where being a mother human is too hard for a mother human to bear. But we need to see it for what it is.
It's not sad on an overheated planet teeming with 8 billion humans.

Childfree is a viable, pleasant and socially beneficial life choice.

DonaPatrizia · 04/10/2020 17:52

I don’t have kids - I strongly felt I would have regretted it if I did - but there is definitely a lot of social pressure on people like me. I’m very happily married, have a great career, family and friends.
Despite this, I am sometimes openly criticised, pitied and patronised for my child free choice.
I have pat answers - when told I’ll end up old and alone I respond with: ‘You say that like it’s a bad thing’ and when asked if I have kids I reply ‘just a childish husband). Interestingly, no-one ever gives DH a hard time and the people having a go at me are, with only one exception, other women. It would be better if women felt able to choose to be child free without stigma.

Sudoku88 · 04/10/2020 17:51

I really love my kids and a huge part of my life has been totally devoted to them, but my god, I can’t wait for them to grow up and leave for university.

I can’t wait to have time on my own, not to have to share a home with them (and all their mess). For me to be able to go off and start living my life for myself and doing my own things.

I would feel terrible regret if I had not had kids, but now I feel I want to move on to the next phase of my life. I have largely had to bring them up on my own as my partner works abroad and I have had enough of the daily routine/ drudgery (so as to speak).

CharityRoyall · 04/10/2020 17:50

As someone who’s currently TTC I’m reading this thread with interest. I’ve always wanted children - not in a single minded “I was born to be a mummy” way, but it was something I knew I’d like to do. Partner and I are both 30 with big supportive families and financially secure.
I also think I have some of an idea of what raising children takes as I nannied 4 children for 3 years which was HARD work. I lived in and the parents worked away a lot so I was with them on my own for a hell of a lot of time, including weekends (fantastic money but draining).
I wouldn’t have 4 myself as it was very hard work but nothing I couldn’t handle. However I’m aware that’s probably very different when they’re your own children. I do wonder what some people expect when they have kids though.
I haven’t had the most adventurous life but I’ve travelled, sown some wild oats, had a brilliant time with friends. I really feel I’m ready for the next step now with more responsibility, and due to my previous nannying career I know a fair amount of what to expect.
My partner is also incredibly responsible, family orientated and hands on. My ex boyfriend was childish, lazy and reliant on me/his mum with occasional mental health issues. The older I got the more I began to realise I would never ever procreate with him as it would be miserable for me. That’s not to say my current partner would never change because who knows, but I really don’t think he would.
To echo some other posters I think the factors to consider are choice of partner, finances, family support, your own personality type/preferred lifestyle, and potential SEN/ASD/disabilities in your child. If you and your partner like being spontaneous, travelling loads and spending long boozy nights down the pub every weekend then you’ll probably struggle more than someone like me who is already a boring old cow at 30! SEN conditions worry me I must say, but I can’t control that.

BewilderedDoughnut · 04/10/2020 17:46

The ones that annoy me the most are the “I never wanted children until I met my husband and fell in love” stories. It’s all fun and games until you’ve lost your freedom, your career and haven’t had sex in two years and his life is otherwise normal.

So cliche but it happens over and over.

Harls1969 · 04/10/2020 17:44

I've loved being a mum since my daughter was born almost 23 years ago. I still loved it when her brother came along 4 years later. There have been some tough times but I've never ever regretted it and for me, having kids was the best thing I ever did. But it's ok to not want kids and it's ok to have them and regret it...as long as the kids never know

Busymum45 · 04/10/2020 17:43

To add, once they are older you can go out again on spur of the moment and do all those things again :)

Meuniere · 04/10/2020 17:43

FWIW all the studies show that people are happier wo children than with children until they get older and the order is reversed (when said dcs have left home?)

Busymum45 · 04/10/2020 17:42

Its good that people can be honest, I think its hard and tiring when children are little, its mentally hard when they are teenagers but the good should outweigh the bad hopefully for most ....

simiisme · 04/10/2020 17:36

It's a shame that people don't consider the consequences before they have children. Yet people who are childless by choice are often called 'selfish' - I find that weird.
Children are not for everyone, but you'd have to be really thick to think that your life wouldn't change once you have them. They're slightly more of a commitment than a kitten or a puppy.
I adore my two, struggled with fertility issues for years so every cell in their body is wanted and precious to me. Me and my husband did not spend a night without them until our 10th wedding anniversary, but that was fine, I didn't resent it.
Aged 18 and 16 they're increasingly independent and I love watching the marvellous, mature young men that they're becoming.

Saxineno · 04/10/2020 17:35

My mum used to tell me regularly if she had her time again, she wouldn’t have kids. Made me feel really shit!
I’ve never once, even for a second regretting having my kids. I’m really surprised so many parents have!

Meuniere · 04/10/2020 17:35

@GettingUntrapped

Perhaps we have to face up to the fact that it isn't us being 'bad mums'. Knowing that in itself is a lot to take in and absorb. Men take too much of us, especially when we have children. It entraps us, and doesn't need to.
That with bells on!!
Singlenotsingle · 04/10/2020 17:35

My DIL misses her old life, going out drinking, clubbing and generally enjoying herself. It wasn't so difficult when my DC were tiny, even though I had no help at all. The kids played out most of the time and we didn't have to entertain them 24/7.

GettingUntrapped · 04/10/2020 17:33

It sad, and it's sad for our children that we are in this situation where being a mother human is too hard for a mother human to bear. But we need to see it for what it is.

munchkinman · 04/10/2020 17:23

My mum always said that to me. It is sad. X