Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum says she wishes she never had children as 'life was better without them'

656 replies

toothfairy73 · 03/10/2020 17:31

I have just seen this headline in a Newspaper. A anonymous mum has written this letter stating the above.

apple.news/A7zR8oawtR6OFxqP2tijb6g

What are your thoughts? I'm sure we have all had moments where we miss our old lives. It sounds like it is written by someone deeply unhappy and in need of some support. AIBU to think this is someone who is desperate for a bit of time alone and some support?What do you think?

OP posts:
Cauterize · 03/10/2020 18:35

Up to the age of about 4, yes I often felt a deep regret.

Age 4 onwards, it's been pretty great actually. No regrets at all. However, I won't be having any more as that would affect my life in a way that would probably plunge me back into regret and I don't need any of that crap any more.

One child is manageable and still enables me to have a life away from constant child rearing.

Toffieefee · 03/10/2020 18:35

It's so complicated life isn't it. I love my kids. I am so glad I had them. I wanted them and I get so much joy out of them. But I can relate to feeling loss over other areas.

I think it depends on the support we have. I know many people with kids, my age who still go out. They go on nights out. They go out with their partners for meals, shows, weekends away etc. They go to the cinema. They work part time. They do all this because they have parents who are prepared to babysit and help them out. I thought we would get abit of occasional babysitting. I'm talking 3-4 times a year. We have two sets of parents. We both have sisters. But it turned out nobody wanted to help. So we have lost our realtionship massively. It's so easy to say cook a meal at home. Do this and that. But our kids interrupt. Or we are exhausted by the time bedtime comes. Or one of the kids will have a rough night. It's hard. Because we don't get those times at the cinema to giggle and eat popcorn we don't feel the closeness we had before the kids.

I don't regret them at all. But I am having to acknowledge the loneliness myself at the moment. I have a couple of friends. But they are also in the same boat. It's definitely tough.

It's extremely hard to get the balance and I think we all get selfish occasionally and think of what we want and need. We are only human.

She feels how she feels I guess. She loves her boys.

HoboSexualOnslow · 03/10/2020 18:35

@garlictwist

I am childfree by choice and I totally disagree that there is societal pressure - I haven't felt any (I am 39 if that makes a difference). No one has pressured me or queried my choices and I don't feel that not having children is that outlandish or weird.
I'm glad you haven't. I'm 37 and it didn't occur to me until a few years ago that children were a choice as I felt it was just what you did. I get asked a lot about why i don't want any, and sad faces. Infuriating.
ReallySpicyCurry · 03/10/2020 18:33

I also think having (with the age gap I have) essentially two only children has been a big part of why I've found it ok, so yy to those who say sticking to one or two can be a better option for some. I sometimes feel broody for another, but I know it would tip the overall balance in the long term and that would probably be where I'd struggle to cope

HoboSexualOnslow · 03/10/2020 18:33

The comments are interesting- "Maybe if more people were honest and transparent about their true feelings of parenthood then there would not be so many people having kids just for the sake of it, because that's just what you are supposed do. People feel pressured by society into parenthood and it is often feels like the right and expected path that we should automatically take. Social media portrays parenthood as such a fluffy world to live in. Why wouldn't anybody be tipped over the edge to take the leap if they were unsure? Maybe if people could discuss it honestly and freely (flaws and all) without being judged then people would think more carefully about the commitment before taking the leap. If you are a duck to water parent then good for you but dont judge those who aren't."

weebarra · 03/10/2020 18:32

I love my three, and I absolutely had them with the right man. I feel so drained by then though. DS1 has ADHD and other health issues, DS2 is on the list for ASD assessment and DD fights to be heard over the other two. They fight constantly and our home is not happy at the moment.
However, I was one of three, DH was one of four and neither of us ever considered not having children. Maybe we should have done!

garlictwist · 03/10/2020 18:32

I am childfree by choice and I totally disagree that there is societal pressure - I haven't felt any (I am 39 if that makes a difference). No one has pressured me or queried my choices and I don't feel that not having children is that outlandish or weird.

Worstyear2020 · 03/10/2020 18:31

Not all children are joy. Admitting life is better without them doesn't mean you are going to abandon / neglect or stop loving them.

thecognoscenti · 03/10/2020 18:31

@AliasGrape

I have a newborn and am probably not qualified to comment as I’ve been a parent for about 5 minutes (for what it’s worth it’s tough and knackering at times but also amazing so no regrets here so far).

But I don’t understand why people who feel this way always seem to have more than one child. The article says this woman thought it would change things? Really? What did she imagine it would change? That sounds snotty but it’s honestly a genuine question. I have a dog, if it turned out after I’d had him a while that I hated having a dog I wouldn’t go and get another. I get that accidents happen but often the second child is planned.

I often think this. Many of the people who express regret have two or three children, and I'm never sure why they had more after the first one. I'm curious rather than judging - I totally understand why people (women especially) might regret having children.
TheMandalorian · 03/10/2020 18:31

I think a lot of women are fed a romanticised and pure fantasy view of having children. Tv shows don't help where a woman gives birth and then the kid just shows up looking cute occasionally.
There's also a pressure on women from certain quarters, often family, to settle down, get married, have a baby.
Having been forced to babysit various children when I was a young girl (I was never interested in this), I had a big clue that being a parent was a huge responsibility.
Upon approaching 30 me and dh decided we had had a lot of fun and freedom and we were ready for the next stage to have kids. It was still a massive life change for us. We were used to late nights in the pub, going out all the time together and meeting friends, etc.
That all just stopped overnight. However, most of our friends also had kids at the same ages so actually life would have changed anyway.
I don't regret it, but I went in with eyes wide open.

IdkickJilliansass · 03/10/2020 18:30

I’d definitely be a parent given the choice again but this time I’d be a dad 😂

ReallySpicyCurry · 03/10/2020 18:29

I've been a parent most of my adult life and I've never regretted it. However. Having a child with an utter twat is 100% worse than being a single mum and 1000% times worse than having a child with a partner who actually pulls their weight. Having my first child (with the twat) meant giving up my entire life because all the work fell to me. As a single mum with an older child, I started to gain back what I'd lost. Now, married to a wonderful man who is just as capable as I am, the arrival of our child together created barely a ripple, because it isn't all down to me. Don't get me wrong, of course we still have to put things like big holidays on pause for a few years and can't do whatever we want when we want , but I still see friends regularly, I still work, wear nice clothes, study for fun, read books and enjoy my hobbies, just with slightly more negotiation and checking of the calendar. Even when DD2 doesn't sleep and we're both knackered and grumpy, I know it's not forever, as my eldest is a teen and it seems like five minutes ago that she was a toddler.

Basically, apart from children with unusual or complex needs, I reckon many of these women wouldn't regret having children if their partners pulled their weight. Having kids with someone who doesn't do their equal share is absolutely brutal and a million miles away from having a child with a man who treats the mother of his children like a multi faceted human and not a womb with a mop attachment

BreathlessCommotion · 03/10/2020 18:29

@Atthecopacorona

I think it's really sad and I hope your children never find out how you really feel.
I would never tell them. And it isn't about them personally. I really wanted children, how was I supposed to know how I would feel afterwards.
QueenofmyPrinces · 03/10/2020 18:29

I have two wonderful children who I love very much.
They are both NT and have no health problems.
I have an amazing husband who is an amazing father and all the grandparents are heavily involved and supportive. My husband has got a good job and I still get to work part time in a job that I love alongside doing a foundation degree in a topic I love.

The children cause the usual stresses but in general we all have a very nice, comfortable life as a family.

However, I still wouldn’t have children if I could go back in time.

Me and my husband often like to fantasise about how our life would be if we didn’t have children.....and it’s a nice thought.

WhatWouldYouDoWhatWouldJesusDo · 03/10/2020 18:29

I always say if people had kids in reverse (( starting with teens )) ala Benjamin Button no one would have them because a lot of it is shit.

Let's face it having kids is a selfish choice,the fact they're cute and good fun at times is a major factor. But the reality is very different and not always what we signed up for

Mammylamb · 03/10/2020 18:28

I absolutely adore my son, and love spending time with him. But at the same time, I can see where she is coming from. Children are absolutely relentless and a massive strain on all your resources (mental, emotional, financial and time)

arethereanyleftatall · 03/10/2020 18:28

@Procrastination4
Sad yes for anyone who's already pregnant, though hopefully they're not reading it.
But actually, desperately desperately important to talk about more.
So so many people in their twenties believe that children are the be all and end all because there are no discussions like this around. We need more honesty, not less.

YoYoYumYum · 03/10/2020 18:26

If I had my life again, I would have dogs rather than children. Dogs don't talk back, are loyal and appreciative.

In fact, that was the original plan if we couldn't conceive.

I gave up my IT career for my kids and now I have no career, no financial independence and no husband. I do have a dog though Smile

Atthecopacorona · 03/10/2020 18:26

I think it's really sad and I hope your children never find out how you really feel.

spottybitch · 03/10/2020 18:26

It's not unheard of. My mam never wanted children and aborted each pregnancy after me.

RedToothBrush · 03/10/2020 18:25

I never wanted children.

Then I decided I wanted one.

Just one. Stuck to one. Don't want more than one. One is enough.

I look at other parents with more than one and don't envy them and see many of them struggling.

Tbh, I've found having DS better than I expected and I am really glad I changed my mind and had him. I think its actually opened doors - different doors in my life. I think its definitely added something to our lives rather than taken away.

We tend to do everything with DS (including things I don't think every parent would). Only having one makes it possible to do that (stuff like holidays etc).

So I do wonder if its having a child or having multiple children that ultimately is the problem. (Afterall theres a lot of women who had a second so the first can't have been that awful).

TableFlowerss · 03/10/2020 18:25

There was a thread a couple of days ago (still running tonight) about where people realise the ‘risk’ of having children or do they know the pitfalls etc.... it was an interesting read.

Not read the linked article but I’d say there’s a good reason most people don’t go on to have 4,5,6,7 etc.

Having children is all consuming and whilst it’s the best thing in the world on so many levels, it’s hard going emotionally and physically.

I also think having a good support network would be the difference between how hard you found motherhood.

imfatletsparty · 03/10/2020 18:24

"Absolute don’t regret

I’m curious. The mother’s that regret. What do you envisage you’d be doing?

I went to university, 3 years of professional Exams, good job, high pay, fantastic life in central London.

In my twenties.

The idea of living that life now... at 40? Well, I love fact I’ve just had dinner with my two and we’re about to settle down to watch Marley and Me on a Saturday night!"

Why do they have to be "doing" anything? Why is it that women who don't have children have to justify it by having a high flying career, or devoting themselves to charity, or climbing Mt Everest, or some other "worthy" pursuit?

BreathlessCommotion · 03/10/2020 18:24

@Atadaddicted

Absolute don’t regret

I’m curious. The mother’s that regret. What do you envisage you’d be doing?

I went to university, 3 years of professional Exams, good job, high pay, fantastic life in central London.

In my twenties.

The idea of living that life now... at 40? Well, I love fact I’ve just had dinner with my two and we’re about to settle down to watch Marley and Me on a Saturday night!

Focusing on my job, which I love and gives me genuine satisfaction, but often has to take a back seat due to dc's needs.

Travelling, or even just going on holiday would be nice. Lack of money in the early years and now an ASD cold who can't manage more than 3 days away from home.

Going out for walks in the countryside or bike rides,climbing mountains. ASD child won't/can't walk so we can't go.

Going for nice coffee in cafes, long lunches and meals in nice restaurants.

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 03/10/2020 18:23

I think people feel like this more and more now because there is so much competitive parenting. Social media, this idea that children have to be constantly entertained and taught. I also (working with children) notice more and more that children are allowed to get away with shitty behaviour and their parents seem to think there is nothing they can do but put on the gentle nice voice and ask them to "please not do that". Everyone is expected to keep their temper all the time and be the best parent in the world. It's draining.