Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum says she wishes she never had children as 'life was better without them'

656 replies

toothfairy73 · 03/10/2020 17:31

I have just seen this headline in a Newspaper. A anonymous mum has written this letter stating the above.

apple.news/A7zR8oawtR6OFxqP2tijb6g

What are your thoughts? I'm sure we have all had moments where we miss our old lives. It sounds like it is written by someone deeply unhappy and in need of some support. AIBU to think this is someone who is desperate for a bit of time alone and some support?What do you think?

OP posts:
corythatwas · 05/10/2020 15:46

Coming back to this thread and wondering what would I say if someone asked. What should I say?

I reckon it's as if someone said "should I do a walking tour through Siberia?" How should I know?????

For one thing I don't know what might or might not happen on your walking tour- the weather might stay lovely and you might meet some great people or you might get eaten by wolves or die in a blizzard. I wouldn't want to take the responsibility for your being devoured by wolves during a raging blizzard when you could have had a much safer holiday on the Isle of Wight.

But more than that, I cannot possibly know if walking tours through Siberia are your sort of thing. To me, it sounds rather enticing, but there are people who prefer lying on sun loungers, and other people who'd be up for the walking but would want a hotter climate. Or to be too busy with other aspects of their lives to take the time out to wander round Siberia.

What I would never do, under any circumstances is judge someone because they do not go on walking holidays in Siberia. That would be plain weird.

I might slightly judge someone who went without thinking it through or without preparation, but I'm also prepared to accept that even with the best of training there can be unforeseen wolves or blizzards.

TOFO1965 · 05/10/2020 15:39

@Yespresh

I haven’t read the article but I feel the same. Our 21 year old daughter is verbally abusive to us. Started when she was 15, she tells us she was abused. She has had a typical middle class upbringing with two parents in a comfortable home. She treats us like dirt. She has moved away now but moves from drama to crisis.

Our 25 year old son still lives at home in total squalor. We went in his room to clean today as he was working. The mess is indescribable. It’s mostly takeaway food packets. He is usually gaming so urinates in bottles rather than using the toilet. I must have emptied 25 plastic bottles of urine today. It is unbearable but what is the alternative? He doesn’t care about himself. Has been on tabs and had counselling in the past.

I am currently having cancer treatment and start chemo next week after a huge operation to remove the tumour. My DH is wonderful but I dearly wish it was just the two of us. There I said it. I want to live by the ocean just him, me and the dog.

I hope you both find the strength to give your son his marching orders and set some boundaries with them both. Sell your house and buy something lovely by the sea. Good luck to you.
TOFO1965 · 05/10/2020 15:23

@Atthecopacorona

I think it's really sad and I hope your children never find out how you really feel.
My mum didn't want children and had me because of societal pressure I guess, and then my sister so I wouldn't be lonely. This was OK whilst she was with my dad and wealthy enough to have a nanny. It all rather went to shit when I was 6 and they split... She was always straight about it, it was pretty obvious to me and sis though.
TOFO1965 · 05/10/2020 15:19

@sunshinesheila

I feel like this. Think a lot of it is worse when your with a useless manchild. I used to truly hate being a mum. Love them to bits but my god it is a effort at times. So I left him, my life is unrecognizable. I now get free time to do my own thing, he has them regularly and I feel much better with a bit of breathing space to be me.

I wonder if I am odd. When they are with their dad it dosent cross my mind about missing them or anything.

I don't think you're odd at all. I don't have children (and don't regret that decision, I dodged a bullet!) but my husband has 4 and we had them every weekend for years and also holidays. Their mum didn't miss them at all (she was very upfront about it). She'd have happily never done a Christmas either.
MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes · 05/10/2020 15:04

There is so much self sacrifice for women with children, yet we don't often say it out loud.

Yes what is coming through loud and clear on this thread is that there is huge loss of identity involved in parenting for women in a way that is just not the same for men.

It's potentially for 20 years. People tell you that you'll be freed up when kids go to school - you're not, there are school holidays to cover. If you have no support through family you're pretty much stuffed. There is less term time or part time employment around than ever before, ime, even before we get started on recession.

No other species on the planet requires this kind of input from females to raise the young.

Lightlysieved · 05/10/2020 15:00

There is so much self sacrifice for women with children, yet we don't often say it out loud.

Yes what is coming through loud and clear on this thread is that there is huge loss of identity involved in parenting for women in a way that is just not the same for men.

KylieKangaroo · 05/10/2020 14:59

See I would never recommend it and would probably put people off, even though I don't regret it which doesn't make sense. Point being if friends asked I would always be honest, but no one ever really asks me anyway!

GettingUntrapped · 05/10/2020 14:51

I think there is some truth in people recommending it to others because they want you to be miserable too.

What the heck?Why is it such a taboo for a woman to say she doesn't want children, doesn't want any more or regrets it.

There is so much self sacrifice for women with children, yet we don't often say it out loud.

Browncoat1 · 05/10/2020 14:17

@holliem91 exactly! I'm lucky in the fact that my husband knows I'm being serious and has said he's fine with it. But every other family member has been constantly asking when I'm having another since she was born. My dad even going as far to call me cruel if I don't give her a brother or sister.
Totally agree with you that people overlook how it would impact you mentally and the fact that if the only reason you're having another child is to keep the one you already have company then it's probably not a good idea 🙈

holliem91 · 05/10/2020 13:15

@Browncoat1 I have one DD and I don't want another either. Very adamant about it. I've told DH and also many others and all they say is "you'll change you're mind", "wait until she's a bit older" or "she needs a sibling!". It puts a lot of pressure on me. My DH does want another and says that we will but I know for a fact, I won't have another baby. I love my DD and I don't regret her. But, I only just about cope with her and I know that mentally more than anything, I would not cope with a second and for that reason I don't want one, but everyone just overlooks that

malificent7 · 05/10/2020 12:33

Whilst I don't regret dd, it's WAY harder than I thought. She is a feisy , willful child and I find it so hatd patenting her to the extent i let her go on her phone a lot and feel like a failure. Tbh she spends most of her time having group chats so at least she has friends.
I would not send her back but my life is hardernow.

AlexTheHalloweenCat · 05/10/2020 12:29

@Thinkingthinking

I don’t regret my child for a second, she is the best thing in my life. BUT, I do feel sad that my partner is so unsupportive (even though he wanted kids) that I’m lucky if I get an hour once a week to wash my hair. He’s not had one broken nights sleep in a year and basically does whatever he wants always yet he makes out that he has no free time. I feel physically, mentally and emotionally broken and resent him for making motherhood harder than it needs to be. There’s no way I would have another child, I don’t think I’d survive it and my marriage certainly wouldn’t.
I'm so sorry he is so unsupportive. I think this is one of the main reasons that women regret having children. Dads need to step up too. I was accidentally earwigging on some first time mums chatting this morning and they were talking about how would they manage doing the cleaning when they went back to work. I wanted to tell them that they needed to get their partners to do their part (I didn't of course).

I miss peace and quiet, a flat tummy, having a career and time with my OH but I don't regret having children (just some of the effects of having them!). I sometimes wonder if it was the right thing for them as since I've had them it has been like the four horsemen of the apocalypse with Brexit, Trump, Covid and climate change coming to the forefront, and the world feels so unstable now and I worry about their futures.

We need dads to step up and support their partners and children, much much better support for parents with SEN kids (there isn't anywhere near enough and it must be so hard - on the PPs said it was much better in Scandinavia), cheaper and better childcare (again, Scandinavia). We need lower expectations about constantly entertaining our kids and running ourselves ragged taking them activities. It wasn't like this we were children and it would be good to have a middle ground between being so full on and how things used to be (not the benign neglect of the 70s where parents would go to the pub and leave the kids in the car with a packet of crisps though Shock). Mums would have more time and head space for themselves and maybe they would enjoy it a lot more (All Joy and No Fun by Jennifer Senior is an interesting read on why parents are struggling, it's American but some of it applies in the UK).

PlonkItDownNOW · 05/10/2020 12:15

I know that however much I think now that if I'd known what being a parent was like I wouldn't have done it, it's a catch 22 because if I'd never done it I would 100% be sad that I hadn't. So.

Strangeways19 · 05/10/2020 12:12

thoughts are - gate, horse, bolted....
I think everyone looks back and the grass is greener, I do that with career choices, with life choices like having children, its natural.
We don't know really though whether life would be better or worse, whats to say that this mother wouldn't have regretted not having the experience of having children had she chosen not to?

Its easy to say that we would do it differently but its also irrelevant as we did it this was and therefore have to do life the best we can with what we have got, including errors or wise decisions.
I have said this to myself also - about having children - but reality is that you don't know what its like until you're doing it, risk is with parenthood that you can't go back on the decision! huge commitment

Frostiesfortea · 05/10/2020 12:10

@DickintheDob - it’s always a worry. My son is non verbal and has severe learning disabilities so it’s usually a call to says he’s kicked off or hurt someone and we need to go and get him. We stopped bothering to arrange anything For when he was in respite years ago 🙄. It’s worth it for the times he behaves and we get a couple of days off!

DickintheDob · 05/10/2020 12:00

@Frostiesfortea..
I know that feeling when the phone rings I don't know what I'm going to be dealing with when I answer. And on the flip side if she doesn't respond to my messages or pick up when I call I worry she's followed through with her thoughts. Don't regret having her but wish I could go back in time and change things for her.

Zaphodsotherhead · 05/10/2020 11:36

@VanillaChai20

I struggled enormously when my kids were younger. I regretted having had five, I regretted having had them with a man who decided after number two, (which was the point at which I gave up work, incidentally or maybe not) that I was 'mummy' and not an intellectual equal, and therefore should do ALL the housework, childcare etc, and I regretted the loss of my old life, partly occasioned by a move for his job 350 miles from all my family.

Now they are adult and I don't regret anything. Looking back my regrets came from overwork, tiredness, lack of support with ANYTHING and lack of any kind of life outside the children. I was desperately homesick, had PND (undiagnosed) when we moved DC4 was only three months old. We had DC5 and then split up.

But now they are among my best friends. They and their partners enliven and enrich my life no end. But if I had my time again, would I do it all over? I can't 'unthink' any of them, so I can't say 'yes, but I'd only have two, or three' (which ones would I 'send back'?). I regretted the way my life went back then, but now I am happy to have had them.

And I would have been happy to have had them when they were small had I had one ounce of help with them both before and after my husband and I split up.

Bugbabe1970 · 05/10/2020 11:07

I have never regretted having my kids ever
I had a good life before I had them and enjoyed my freedom before kids came along
Looking forward to grand children now
My kids are fab

Quietlyloud · 05/10/2020 10:34

Yespresh Thats so sad. He sounds like those incel types. Worst part is he’s probably part of some online groups encouraging his gross behaviour. I do t know to suggest but I’d want him out for sure.

VanillaChai20 · 05/10/2020 10:24

Very interesting thread for someone on the fence.

I'd be interested to know if there's regret when the kids are adults though as well?

Quietlyloud · 05/10/2020 10:20

It would be interesting to look at it more from the child's point of view too.

So go start a thread then.. why are you so determined to change what this one is about?

ConcernedAuntie · 05/10/2020 10:18

Many years ago I read an article about the pressure from friends and relatives to have children. The article concluded that these friends and relatives wanted you to be as miserable as they were.

Quietlyloud · 05/10/2020 10:02

I regret having children but I decided to have TWO.

Yes...ok....

Yes because in many cases it’s only after the second we find it tough or the second is born with extra needs that makes it harder. It’s not as black and white as you would like to think.

IcedPurple · 05/10/2020 09:29

I read that as meaning she didn't initially want children, not that she has not wanted children throughout.

So she didn't want children...until she did. Not really the same as 'never' wanting children, as she claimed.

FTMF30 · 05/10/2020 09:05

@IcedPurple

I find this so sad. Never wanted a child ended up with 3!!!

Unless you've had serious consecutive contraception failures, clearly you did want children.

@IcedPurple I read that as meaning she didn't initially want children, not that she has not wanted children throughout.