Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum says she wishes she never had children as 'life was better without them'

656 replies

toothfairy73 · 03/10/2020 17:31

I have just seen this headline in a Newspaper. A anonymous mum has written this letter stating the above.

apple.news/A7zR8oawtR6OFxqP2tijb6g

What are your thoughts? I'm sure we have all had moments where we miss our old lives. It sounds like it is written by someone deeply unhappy and in need of some support. AIBU to think this is someone who is desperate for a bit of time alone and some support?What do you think?

OP posts:
VeniceQueen2004 · 03/10/2020 20:04

I think a lot of it is about whether you made a conscious decision to have kids or not, and what you had them for.

I was always determined I wouldn't have kids. Got overcome with the biological urge in my late twenties, but waited and considered and went back and forth - had my first child at 32. Now pregnant with no 2 at 35.

In the end I decided I had to do it, because I wanted so badly to love someone completely. I didn't want anything "out of it". I knew it would be hard work. But I had do much love in me and I wanted to give it to someone who deserved it rather than keep wasting it on people I kept elevating on my mind to make them "worthy" of it and it kept on turning out to be a disappointment.

And I do. I love her completely and it is WONDERFUL. Just what I had wanted.

I hadn't banked on the effect of her total refusal to sleep as a baby, her high needs, and how much I'd be anxious about whether I was a good enough mother. That was all bloody hard. Didn't anticipate how hard it would be for my partner either, and I know he has had moments he has regretted becoming a father.

But I never ever have. Because I only had a child because I really, really couldn't not (as opposed to feeling like it was just "what you do"), and I didn't expect anything other than what I got.

Looking forward to doing it all again with more experience and more confidence.

However I do think SN would have s massive role. Not that I assume all SN parents wish they hadn't had their kids - I knoe enough of them to know that isn't so. But if I'm having s tough day with my daughter, I can remind myself it's s phase, it will pass, she will learn and grow and change. For parents who have no realistic hope of this for their children, and whose anticipated 20 some years of heavy responsibility has instead become a lifetime of self-sacrifice and care... I have nothing but total respect for those parents, and they can feel any way they feel about it they damn well please. They have been dealt a really really difficult and unexpected hand.

BooseysMom · 03/10/2020 20:01

I’m child free by choice. I’ve always known I never wanted children. I felt no pressure to have any nor has anyone ever queried my choice either, luckily I found a man who felt the same! We chose sleep, money, holidays, weekend breaks.....freedom basically and we have no regrets whatsoever. We are middle aged now and thankfully, able to enjoy a full and happy retirement.

I felt this way for years and then after pressure I had DS at 41 and he changed my life. I knew if I didn't try to have a child I'd lose my OH. After 2 miscarriages it happened and I never looked back. My life was shit before him and yes it's really tough as we have zero support but I'd never ever regret having him.

Atadaddicted · 03/10/2020 20:01

@AwaAnBileYerHeid

*I’m curious. The mother’s that regret. What do you envisage you’d be doing?

I went to university, 3 years of professional Exams, good job, high pay, fantastic life in central London.

In my twenties.*

And that obviously suited you at that time in your life. However some women still enjoy travelling, exploring their own hobbies, changing careers etc, completely unburdened at any age. Personally I can't imagine my me years just being in my twenties and that that's me done.

Different strokes for different folks.

I didn’t regard the change as “that’s me done”

Rather a new chapter that I feel in my thirties and forties more happier and suited to than central London, young and highly ambitious corporate work, very social group spending vast pints of socialising, weekend verity treatments, long boozy lunches most weekends etc

It was fabulous. Absolutely fab, 10 years in zone 1 , flat sharing with friends and earning a very decent salary.

Now, moved out, much more countryside walks, long boozy lunches are a lovely treat rather than just routine, pottering, making a nice home, interior design etc.

So it isn’t the end. Start of new chapter, one is which with my children.

I have loved both experiences.

KenDodd · 03/10/2020 19:59

Oh my mum has always said she wishes she'd never had children. She used to say she could have been this, she could have done that, if she hadn't had children. It's bollocks, she wouldn't have done anything.

I would never say such things to my own children.

nevermorelenore · 03/10/2020 19:56

The article comes across like the writer has a lot of nostalgia for being in her 20s, but I don't think things would necessarily be as rosy as she thinks if she'd stayed childfree. It gets harder to keep in touch with people, you get tireder and do less, and generally, life becomes more sensible and predictable. There's no guarantee her marriage would still be like a rom com.

I do sympathise with her, because it sounds like she doesn't get time to go out and be herself. She should definitely try to make some friends who have more in common than just mumhood. Also, the career thing. Yeah, I'm going through that myself and planning to retrain because current career is just dead right now. But things could be very different in a few years.

Allusernamesalreadyused · 03/10/2020 19:56

It seems to be the lack of support that's an issue ie partners/husband

formerbabe · 03/10/2020 19:55

Oh and I will say I'm so happy that my children are growing up..they're 10 and 12...I hear other mums say how devastated they are that their children are growing up quickly. Typical crap on Facebook..."slow down time". Well I bloody love them getting older...in fact I can't wait until they're old enough for me and dh to go out for the evening without needing a babysitter

willieversleep · 03/10/2020 19:54

For those saying life was so much better before is it not a case of the grass being greener? Had you not made the choices you did you may not have had the carefree lifestyle you had prior to children now either.

toothfairy73 · 03/10/2020 19:53

Wow so many comments. I'm losing track of who said what.

Whoever said
*
I find that woman's feelings on motherhood far more understandable than your view that she's "in need of some support". What sort of support? What if she neither needs nor wants "support"?*

I speak from my experience. Whenever I have felt like this, I have usually been depressed and feeling overwhelmed. I sufferer from depression and CPTSD. Despite years of therapy so that my childhood didn't impact on the rest of my life I can see how my trauma impacts my children even though I do everything I can do mitigate it. I'm not suggesting for one minute the person that wrote this has the same issues as me, but for me it's a red flag for depression.

OP posts:
mikkyr · 03/10/2020 19:53

@Yipitsme

I definitely wish I hadn't had them.i have one child who is so severely disabled that its ruined all our lives,we are so limited and restricted in every aspect of what we do.the constant guilt of a life defined by this for my other children eats me up every day. The nonstop never ending work involved in looking after my disabled child will never end and they will never leave home.its a very difficult pill to swallow. My body is literally battered and aching every single day and my mental health is in shreds. I was desperate, desperate to be a mother.turns out I just wasnt lucky . I constantly dream of my past, I dont recognize myself anymore.
Gosh this is my biggest fear about having children. How do people accept this risk?
Yipitsme · 03/10/2020 19:51

I definitely wish I hadn't had them.i have one child who is so severely disabled that its ruined all our lives,we are so limited and restricted in every aspect of what we do.the constant guilt of a life defined by this for my other children eats me up every day.
The nonstop never ending work involved in looking after my disabled child will never end and they will never leave home.its a very difficult pill to swallow.
My body is literally battered and aching every single day and my mental health is in shreds.
I was desperate, desperate to be a mother.turns out I just wasnt lucky .
I constantly dream of my past, I dont recognize myself anymore.

TheFormidableMrsC · 03/10/2020 19:51

I didn't want children, had absolutely no yearning to be a mother. Somehow ended up with two. Love the bones of the pair of them, wouldn't be without them now. However, at 51 I find myself a very much single parent to a 9 yo autistic DS and I know that any hope of eventual freedom is gone. I have nearly finished treatment for a reasonably risky breast cancer and quite honestly if things were different I'd be living my bucket list. Not happening. My DD doesn't want children and I am glad.

Notanotherwooname · 03/10/2020 19:50

And DH isn’t the backward bastard - we share childcare responsibilities 50/50 - it’s men in the workplace!

formerbabe · 03/10/2020 19:50

I adore my dc and don't regret them. If there's such a thing as reincarnation though, I'll be advising my future self to not have kids...it's a mugs game

Notanotherwooname · 03/10/2020 19:49

I’ve had 4 kids - not due to any societal pressure, but because I wanted them. And you can probably guess based on the fact I have four, I’ve enjoyed it. They give me the greatest joy of my life!

Sometimes me and DH dream of a week’s holiday (or frankly a night away) on our own, but it’ll happen again and neither of us would change having the kids. I get frustrated about the impact being a woman has on my work - because it’s not having children that does that, there is no negative impact on DH’s work! But that doesn’t make me regret my kids, it makes me regret the existence of backward bastards! And I try to find a way round it.

oldmapie · 03/10/2020 19:49

I think plenty of parents probably feel like that this year. I suspect if you asked that parent last year the answer may have been different. Juggling jobs with home education, then closure of childcare venues over the holidays. Many schools in our area have no breakfast or after school clubs. Many extracurricular activities have been cancelled. People have lost child care, or even a precious morning of 'freedom' if a grandparent previously did it.
I love my children, but bloody hell I could do with a few hours to myself to get on and do the chores I need to do without endless interruptions!
I think the pressures on parents particularly mothers, have really ramped up this year.

LemonPeonies · 03/10/2020 19:48

Of course life is different after children, I always try to step in other people's shoes but I honestly can't understand people not getting how life will be different after having kids unless they have a very low IQ. I'm of the opinion that having children is a privilege not a right and some people just don't suit/ deserve them TBH. I feel sorry for her kids, they will grow up feeling unloved and unwanted and they will pick up on it. Why she went on to have another after feeling like her life was ruined by the first is beyond me.

Nicolastuffedone · 03/10/2020 19:48

I’m child free by choice. I’ve always known I never wanted children. I felt no pressure to have any nor has anyone ever queried my choice either, luckily I found a man who felt the same! We chose sleep, money, holidays, weekend breaks.....freedom basically and we have no regrets whatsoever. We are middle aged now and thankfully, able to enjoy a full and happy retirement.

eaglejulesk · 03/10/2020 19:48

Do women still feel that societal pressure or expectation that they should have kids?

That's an interesting question. I'm 61 and never really wanted children, and I can't remember anyone ever asking me about having them, and I was never under any pressure to have them from anyone (and yes, I was married).

LilOldMe · 03/10/2020 19:44

@Krankie

..but how do people know that their lives would be happier without kids? People are looking back through rose tinted glasses and assuming their childless carefree 20s/30s would continue forever.

Truth being the older you get, things will change regardless of whether you have children. Those nights out/holidays/social events might dry up because your friends have all settled down. That relationship you spent 20 years in might fall apart. Your career could be destroyed by a pandemic/redundancy/ill health. Children might make these things harder, but could also keep you going through harder times.

I don’t think having kids = happiness, definitely not in all scenarios. But I also wonder if people are too quick to blame their unhappiness on the fact they had children.

@Krankie - thanks for this. It’s a good way of looking at things, and I found it helpful.
Parkingt111 · 03/10/2020 19:42

having my second child only two years apart from my first was difficult for the first year but now they are 4 and 2 and Its much easier and more enjoyable and as hard as it was in those early days I don't think I ever felt regret
I do feel there is alot of pressure on women to have children, my mil is always asking one of my sil's when she is planning on having a baby even though she has made it clear she does not want to yet

Plmoknijb123 · 03/10/2020 19:40

How can someone also say this when their children are young? Maybe they’ll get older and 20 or 30 their mum will think...wow it’s great I had kids I don’t regret it at all.

Chewbecca · 03/10/2020 19:39

I LOVE the earlier comment - I would have children again, but next time, I would be a Dad.

I'm unusual it seems, I definitely have no regrets, but I do only have one (he's 17) and whilst he can be a bugger at times, on the whole, he's great & the whole journey has been fascinating and enjoyable.
I also have a decent husband and a very good job. The job would likely have been even better without the DC but it has meant we have a very comfortable lifestyle which actually seems to be the biggest regretful consequence of children & IMO that's what we need to change - the situation where having children means no meaningful or lucrative job for the mother again.

JellyNellie · 03/10/2020 19:35

I don't regret my children what's so ever,if I had my time again I'd definitely have all 4!! But I've know nothing different I had my first child at 17 still with DP and the children are our world,it isn't always easy we have 4 children under 6 I still get time my self as DP dose to,we also make the for each other when Children go to bed,we also have a date night once a week where either one of is cooks a meal and we talk about everything that's going on around us 🥰

Krankie · 03/10/2020 19:34

..but how do people know that their lives would be happier without kids? People are looking back through rose tinted glasses and assuming their childless carefree 20s/30s would continue forever.

Truth being the older you get, things will change regardless of whether you have children. Those nights out/holidays/social events might dry up because your friends have all settled down. That relationship you spent 20 years in might fall apart. Your career could be destroyed by a pandemic/redundancy/ill health. Children might make these things harder, but could also keep you going through harder times.

I don’t think having kids = happiness, definitely not in all scenarios. But I also wonder if people are too quick to blame their unhappiness on the fact they had children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread