Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum says she wishes she never had children as 'life was better without them'

656 replies

toothfairy73 · 03/10/2020 17:31

I have just seen this headline in a Newspaper. A anonymous mum has written this letter stating the above.

apple.news/A7zR8oawtR6OFxqP2tijb6g

What are your thoughts? I'm sure we have all had moments where we miss our old lives. It sounds like it is written by someone deeply unhappy and in need of some support. AIBU to think this is someone who is desperate for a bit of time alone and some support?What do you think?

OP posts:
Hollowtree3 · 03/10/2020 21:02

@Sarahpaula My sister made it look so easy and warm and lovely with with having two, but she was a primary 1 teacher also..... I am very different though I now see I want to read philosophy, and about medicine and science and just keep learning. childcare is so dull and relentless. Never ever ever again and I dont hold back telling others how it is in reality so they can choose. I know that a lot of women should choose not to have kids.

lilfoxfur · 03/10/2020 21:01

I absolutely adore my ds10 and my biggest regret is that I never had a second child. However, I share care with my ex so I get plenty of time to myself. I might feel differently if I didn't. It also helps that me and ds are very similar so we really get eachother. I cant imagine my life without him.

PerveenMistry · 03/10/2020 21:00

@MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes

The trouble is financial cushions and marketable skills in an ever-changing market are harder and harder to come by. As someone with no wider family support who's watched their work sector be destroyed by politics, and had to watch the house prices quadruple in 2 years 20 years ago, I often wish I hadn't bothered. Kids are wonderful and all that, but they trap women, in what is a bad economic time. And it's going to get worse! Hurray, can hardly wait.

Yes, it is harder. There are billions more people on earth, all needing a livelihood. And clean air, water, food, fuel, housing. You think it's going to get easier as competition grows among more and more humans for those dwindling resources?

We need to change our notions of what makes up a "normal" life. Because sustaining an ever increasing number of nuclear families bent on self-replication is not a viable plan.

Wimbledon11 · 03/10/2020 21:00

@Sarahpaula so sorry to read you post Thanks

ClementineWoolysocks · 03/10/2020 21:00

@Justaboy

There was also a poll on Loose Women a few months ago, and I think it was around 30% who said if they could go back, they wouldn't have had them.

Well yes quite! they may say that, but were the OK with their mums having them?. If not then they ought exit this world!! harsh i know but..

Wut now? Did your mother consult with you before you were born to find out your opinion?
PyongyangKipperbang · 03/10/2020 20:59

I dont regret having them at all, but I do slightly hanker after the life I would have if I hadnt had them.

That said, my sister has that life. Expensive holidays, a beautiful large house, high disposable income.....and would give it all up to be able to have a baby. SHe doesnt have a romanticised ideal of motherhood as she has seen the reality of it with my family, and it breaks her heart that she will never get the chance to have it for herself.

So.....the grass isnt always greener and I have to remind myself of that.

Roowig2020 · 03/10/2020 20:58

I can understand why women might regret having children. I work in a field where I'm in constant dealings with parents who are struggling, whether it be mental health, addiction, poverty, DV, SEN or generally shitty non involved parents (mostly dads but not always) etc. I'm in awe of how most of these parents cope in such awful circumstances. I would probably regret kids if this was my life too tbh.

I feel extremely privileged that I've never had to deal with those situations though so for me parenting is an absolute joy. I only have one dc though, after fertility issues then eventually ivf. We wanted a second but it didn't happen. Now I have completely accepted that for us one child has worked fantastic.

I had dc at 28 but I personally achieved most of my non parenting achievements in my 30's (masters/ phd/ good job etc). Having one dc has not been a barrier but I don't think I could've achieved those with 2. I don't think I would've even applied for a doctorate with 2 small children. My dh couldn't have coped with doing the bulk of nursery/ school/ parenting duties with no family nearby for those tough few years.

I am still very close to my group of 8 school friends (all late 30's). several are child free. They've brought children up in conversations and they say they are very happy with their lives at the minute. They say they don't feel a pressure to conform. I don't know if that's because they're high flying professionals with options??

Wimbledon11 · 03/10/2020 20:58

Yes I think this. Would never admit it to anyone and certainly wouldn't tell them but if I could have my time again...

I love them so much now they are here but it hard work, expensive, and I am constantly worried about them and come to realise that I will worry about them for the rest of my life.

Vieve1325 · 03/10/2020 20:56

Thank you for this thread. Despite being fairly certain I don’t want children, I have been feeling the pressure lately. It’s helpful to know that it really doesn’t suit everyone.

I don’t want to risk the potential changes / damage to my body (it’s been through a lot in my life!) and also have a lovely, busy, and full life which I don’t want to compromise. Many call me selfish, but I just don’t think women HAVE to procreate?

Quietlyloud · 03/10/2020 20:56

Well yes quite! they may say that, but were the OK with their mums having them?. If not then they ought exit this world!! harsh i know but.. Confused

Sarahpaula · 03/10/2020 20:56

Women really need to think more before having children.

Think about the child.

Too many children are growing up in absolute hellholes.

My mother screamed at and abused me for 18 years. She verbally and physically abused my brother. She hated being a mother.

We said to her so many times "why did you have children!". It was her choice. She said "oh that is just what people do - have children"

it wasn't my choice to live in hell and a torture chamber for 18 years.

Both me and my brother have attempted suicide as adults numerous times. Only that I know that attempting suicide is very physically painful - stops me from trying again. If I could painlessly die, I would.

formerbabe · 03/10/2020 20:56

I also hear so often people calling babies a blessing or a miracle...fwiw, I absolutely adore babies but it's not a miracle...it's the result of unprotected sex...and whilst you will adore your child, children are a burden as much as they are a blessing.

BreathlessCommotion · 03/10/2020 20:54

@Sarahpaula I don't think my children have a clue. They are loved and well cared for. I would never tell them.

Sarahpaula · 03/10/2020 20:53

@Hollowtree3 so just to ask you, why did you have that child?

Hollowtree3 · 03/10/2020 20:52

It is me. I have one and would never ever have another. Maybe some ladies have great joy from it all, but I have yet to experience it.

Sarahpaula · 03/10/2020 20:51

I am another one that would really encourage women to think carefully before they have children.

I think hearing women saying "it is just what people do" and then go on and have children, does not cut it anymore.

You need to put serious thought into whether you would actually be able to care for a child or not. Before you have children.

Because if you have a child, and can't care for it, it is not one life you are ruining (yours), it is two lives that you will be ruining.

What upsets me is that I see so many threads on here about women who regret becoming mothers, and not one of those mothers talk about how hard it is for the child in that situation.

I see women on this thread saying that their mother regretted having them.

I am another person who grew up in the same situation. My mother regretted having me and my brother. To grow up with her for 18 years, with her screaming and shouting at us, and insulting us was sheer hell.

Think about it: a child in that situation has to live in an environment where some one much bigger than them, hates them, and screams and shouts at them for 18 years. It is like being in a torture chamber.

People get better human rights treatments in prisons.

All these posts on this thread saying "I regret being a mother", not one post is talking about how difficult it must be for the child. It makes me really annoyed.

why didn't you THINK more, before you had children.

Quietlyloud · 03/10/2020 20:51

Yipitsme Your comment is heartbreaking. My kid is disabled but not to the extent of many, I don’t know how people do it when their child is like that. I also feel bad for the kids living like this, it’s not good for either party, but what can we do?

Grapewrath · 03/10/2020 20:50

Also I am the child of parents who were bitterly disappointed they didn’t have a boy. They probably didn’t regret having kids as they just continued their usual lifestyle and I basically brought myself up.
As a child I felt hugely unimportant and unloved
I think really even if you do regret kids, but life and nurture them it’s ok. It’s sometimes the case that people who say ‘my kids are my world’ who aren’t doing a great job.

PerveenMistry · 03/10/2020 20:50

@imfatletsparty

"Well yes quite! they may say that, but were the OK with their mums having them?. If not then they ought exit this world!! harsh i know but.."

I didn't know people have a choice in being born or not?

Any time there's a suggestion that not everyone needs to reproduce, someone trots out that "good thing your parents didn't think that way" mindless gibberish. usually followed by the veiled suggestion that the non-breeder needs to off herself. Absurd and frankly a bit sicko.

MayYouLiveInInterestingTimes · 03/10/2020 20:48

The trouble is financial cushions and marketable skills in an ever-changing market are harder and harder to come by. As someone with no wider family support who's watched their work sector be destroyed by politics, and had to watch the house prices quadruple in 2 years 20 years ago, I often wish I hadn't bothered. Kids are wonderful and all that, but they trap women, in what is a bad economic time. And it's going to get worse! Hurray, can hardly wait.

PerveenMistry · 03/10/2020 20:46

@Whatshouldicallme

I am getting to an age where I really need to decide but feel totally ambivalent. I've always pictured myself having children "one day" but now I'm getting older and still feel it should be at least another 10 years away. I'm totally content carrying on with my life as it is. I still have lots of things I'd like to do before I have a child. I'm terrified I will feel this way, but also terrified I will later want a child and it will be too late.
Better to regret the absence of a child than the presence of one.

You can make a positive difference in the life of children not your own. And enjoy them.

I8toys · 03/10/2020 20:45

jellykat so sorry. My mum said she'd always wanted a boy but ended up with me! It's awful. I adore my children and can't imagine ever resenting or regretting their existence.

PerveenMistry · 03/10/2020 20:44

@Annabanana455

I’ve found being a mum much harder than expected, but don’t regret it.

However

  • I only have one
  • DC has been relatively easy, ok sleeper etc
  • I have a supportive DH
  • We have supportive grandparents, who are local and willing to help
  • I had a career I could return to part time that can be done flexibly
  • We are not short of money, so for example, I sometimes have a half day off work when DC at nursery / with grandma. No added stress of money worries and get time to myself
  • DH and I both in good health & fitness
  • We have a nice house, in a nice area with lots to do for kids and a nice garden

I imagine without those things it would be much much tougher

In other words you waited till you had an education, marketable skills, work experience, a financial cushion and a stable, time-tested relationship with a man of integrity. If everyone did all of the above there would be fewer miserable mums.

Jellykat · 03/10/2020 20:43

As a child of someone who wishes she'd never had children, i can tell you it's awful.. I'm now 57 and being 'blamed' for being alive has really impacted my life, and affected all my relationships.
My thinking is, i didn't ask to be born, it was her decision not mine.
As a lone parent to 2 now grown up boys, they have always been my no.1 priority, even when times were really really bad, i'd never ever blame them for being around or ruining my life. I know too well how it feels!

Grapewrath · 03/10/2020 20:42

I don’t regret my kids, they are amazing
However had I known the anxiety and exhaustion they brought beforehand I may have chosen not to have them. My situation is influenced by having a child with a disability and no family support whatsoever. It’s been really, really hard.
I am determined that if my kids choose to have kids I’ll support them 100% as the isolation of being unsupported is actually really traumatic.