Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Losing faith in Mumsnet?

220 replies

TheWho67 · 26/09/2020 01:08

People post for validation or genuine comprehension over an issue.
Replies go either way, agree or disagree, sometimes quite strongly. I've seen a lot of posts were OP has been flamed and wished they had never posted. I've been there, under a different name. I've asked Mumsnet to have more moderators, to keep things on track but I guess that wont happen. I've seen a few posts get mentioned on DM recently and think, thank god that wasn't me! Some posts get quite out of hand and once one negative post starts, other pile on.
YANBU - to think people should stick to the question asked and not unpick every single thing.
YABU - people will naturally be critical because it's on-line and not face to face and why post on a public forum if you can't handle it.

OP posts:
SuitedandBooted · 26/09/2020 09:21

I'm not losing faith in Mumsnet.

I AM losing faith in people's ability to use critical thinking, and realise what is going on in the wider world. MN is known as a place where women speak freely, - Can't have that, oh no.

There have been widely reported posts on Twitter/Facebook/reddit urging members to complain to MN advertisers, come on here and basically wreck it, and put women off. Those people aren't going to start a post with "Hi, I'm here, you bitches had better listen to me....".
This is an anonymous forum. People can assume any persona.

BiBabbles · 26/09/2020 09:21

As pps have said, I'm not sure why one would have faith in an internet forum.

Especially not when regularly there are goady threads that call most women naïve if they believe their male partners, that the UK's education system has low standards, or similar and then posts in say shite about how everyone is being too defensive and they just wanted to have an interesting conversation/ask a question on whatever topic. And then there is the convenient dripfeeding or just outright fakes, but people can only respond to what's written and their own experiences of similar posts they've seen.

There are overly harsh responses, but whether the person actually believes what they're saying is also up for debate (same with the regrets). This can be true in person, though rarely against the amount of people as in an internet forum.

DarkmilkAddict · 26/09/2020 09:18

I think people are starting to treat every area of MN as if it’s AIBU. Really sad

C8H10N4O2 · 26/09/2020 09:17

You have to sit in a reversed pentagram while emailing. It helps to invoke other symbols of sheer demonic evil...for best results, do it on a day when you've been for Botox, held a cake smash photoshoot and bought a toilet brush

Damn - I forgot the pentagram.

OlympicProcrastinator · 26/09/2020 09:17

There's also a strong anti-intellectual aspect to that which is pretty representative of the country generally

This isn’t a bad thing imo. Too many people consider that people who do not have much of a formal education or are of a lower class to themselves have nothing valuable to contribute. Shutting people out of conversations because you feel as though you have some special insight due to your education or class is a dangerous game.

When people pile on the ‘thick, underclass, ignorant’ etc etc I believe they fail to see the irony. That very way of thinking and behaving has created political exclusion which has resulted in the very things people on here complain about.

AlexisCarringtonColbyDexter · 26/09/2020 09:14

I find the Style and beauty, property, telly and health boards completely supportive and fun

Thats not been my experience. I posted on beauty that I wanted to try a new face serum, it was only just out and looked really good and I asked if anyone had tried it.
I got told I needed to "get a life/get out more" - all during lockdown which made it especially ironic. I was posting about a beauty product on a BEAUTY THREAD. Not sure how wanting a new face cream means I "have no life"? I also got told I was sad for having beauty as a "hobby"- firstly, I never said it was my hobby and secondly, it was like only the 2nd post I ever posted on beauty. I dont get the need for all the nastiness. If you dont like beauty then why the fck are on the beauty thread in the first place? Its like me disliking cats and then going on a cat thread telling everyone they are dumb for liking cats. Some people are really pathetic if thats their only entertainment in life.

Roussette · 26/09/2020 09:14

@ClinkyMonkey

Totally agree. I sometimes think...god you're daft, dense, uninformed, stupid or whatever but no way would I go and post anything off that nature!
I just don't post and ignore the thread or post.
Why people can't be kinder to each other I do not know.
I posted on a covid thread for the first time last week. One polite post
This poster tore me to shreds for considering covid was a bit of a problem! She was unbelievably vile and sarcastic I told her she was rude and walked away.

What is up with people it's beyond me
Just be kind to your fellow human beings

EarringsandLipstick · 26/09/2020 09:11

@BIWI

Comments only get evaluated if they're reported. It's not about an editorial decision - it's about whether or not posts break Talk Guidelines.

Yes, but when they are reported, MN can be v subjective about what they delete or not.

I had a particular situation where a poster was persistently directly mocking me & a particular ethnic group linked to my country & MN would not delete the posts, despite multiple reports, not just from me.

ClinkyMonkey · 26/09/2020 09:05

I think it depends very much on where you post and what you are posting about. There can be a very toxic vibe sometimes, where someone asks for advice and is dismissed with one line 'smart' remarks from various posters. You can almost hear the sighing and see the eye rolling as they batter their keyboards in disgust at the OP's naivety/stupidity/ignorance (delete as appropriate). Why bother to post if that's all you have to contribute? If you think a poster is asking a question to which there is an obvious answer, help them out. It can be done politely, without the whole 'are you dense?' attitude. I can't stand the attitude of people who say that they just say it like it is - as far as I'm concerned that's code for 'I don't give a shit about anyone else's feelings'.

TheSeedsOfADream · 26/09/2020 09:05

I do agree with Xenia's last sentence about an echo chamber on the "quiche" threads at times. There's one in particular running at the moment with one poster who praises their lord (to keep in with the metaphors) on that thread, yet on other threads on the same topic is the opposite. Quite an interesting sociological study really. (I just read to report their ageism which, given the argument, is rife)

ShebaShimmyShake · 26/09/2020 09:03

As yet I've had no mail from HQ to say I should burn incense, light candles and chant prayers to them.

You have to sit in a reversed pentagram while emailing. It helps to invoke other symbols of sheer demonic evil...for best results, do it on a day when you've been for Botox, held a cake smash photoshoot and bought a toilet brush.

BIWI · 26/09/2020 09:00

@TheClaws

I've been on MN a number of years, primarily on the excellent Trump threads. I dipped and out of AIBU and Chat. However, the lack of moderation of the COVID boards has bothered me. I don't expect them to be filtered down to one viewpoint only - that's ridiculous, but the level of hostility from certain posters is consistently high. Even if what they say goes against medical advice, nothing is deleted. I don't understand this obvious editorial decision of MN.
Mumsnet isn't a pre-moderated site, though. Comments only get evaluated if they're reported. It's not about an editorial decision - it's about whether or not posts break Talk Guidelines.
RobertaTheGreat · 26/09/2020 09:00

When I was new on here, under a different name, I posted in AIBU, quite an innocuous thread. It was an awful pile on, with some viscious comments, although there were sensible comments too and voting was 50/50. It really upset me that people could be so hurtful - like it was a sport to them. I was a liar, I was wierd , I had a chip on my shoulder. A poster supporting me was accused of being me with a different name! I don't start threads anymore.

Those who say it's just disagreement are wrong. I see lots of threads where posters just hurl insults, often misrepresenting what the OP said. I think there are many very bitter posters and it gives them a thrill to deliberately hurt others.

Xenia · 26/09/2020 09:00

.. not that it matters Sunday Times (not Sunday Telegraph) for my late father......

emilyfrost · 26/09/2020 09:00

YABU. If anyone is upset by words on a screen from a stranger they need to look at their own resilience and build it up.

Seventybillionnamechanges · 26/09/2020 08:59

I think that this year it had been particularly vicious. However you now see the same on things like Facebook groups and even Nextdoor. I never used to see the huge rows that break in say, my local fb group until this year.

DrBlackbird · 26/09/2020 08:59

Sometimes I've seen OPs asking for advice and getting roasted always in AIBU and usually in the first replies, but then someone comes along to offer a more reasoned or calm response. In terms of any anonymous online forum, MN is pretty good and the moderators are really very active.

Otherwise, there are many threads on here that are full of intelligent, knowledgeable, witty, and supportive women (and men), who provide more substantive and nuanced analysis than found in the media. I hugely appreciate them - and MN - in these dark and uncertain times.

Xenia · 26/09/2020 08:59

There are a lot of supportive posts for people in all kinds of difficult situations and a good balance between free expression and censorship. I think they do pretty well particularly on the trans and other feminism issues where in other places women are censored ad made to shut up. Freedom of speech is very important. I read the Guardian and the Telegraph as well as the FT every day just as my father always took the Sunday Telegraph and Observer because I like to see all view points.

When people only surround themselves with people with the same views they are not open to other ideas or do not know what they are up against as it just becomes an everyone agrees echo chamber.

BIWI · 26/09/2020 08:58

@JustFrigginNameChange

Where is all this racism people keep mentioning? I have not seen any outright racism on here and I visit every day. Is it on certain boards?
Really?! Clearly you haven't been reading any of the BLM threads, or the more recent ones asking for a Black MNetters board.

Same goes for you @ivfbeenbusy.

The amount of racism recently on those threads has been actually quite shocking. It's inevitable with a site the size of MN that some members will hold racist views, but the extent of those who were prepared to express them quite openly, and defend themselves was awful.

C8H10N4O2 · 26/09/2020 08:58

Losing faith

As yet I've had no mail from HQ to say I should burn incense, light candles and chant prayers to them.

As @AuntieStella says, I do see a great many threads which are variations on the "nasty women" trope and frankly they can fuck off.

PapsofJura · 26/09/2020 08:55

I very rarely post and nowadays stay away from AIBU as there is less funny stuff and much more shoutiness, showboating and vitriol.

However this is a large platform and there are lots of sections which are lovely and very helpful.

Also, a lot people have had some really good advice over the years which has really helped them in difficult times.

Livelovebehappy · 26/09/2020 08:54

You just pick out comments that are helpful to you. Obviously there’s going to be very different opinions, and some people feel passionately about their own opinion. Why post on Aibu, and then slate anyone who says you are?

ShebaShimmyShake · 26/09/2020 08:52

@JustFrigginNameChange

Where is all this racism people keep mentioning? I have not seen any outright racism on here and I visit every day. Is it on certain boards?
There was a lot on the thread about the Diversity performance. One poster said that people who protest the murder of black people were "arsey", plus plenty of people who wanted to dictate how and when black people should reveal their treatment and experiences.

Nobody actually comes out and says overtly hateful things, that's not how it works these days. They all say they're not racist and I think they believe it. But if you first complain that protest should be peaceful, and then call for sanctions over a dance performance, you might like to look at what's really bothering you. If there's something wrong with literally every way black people protest their abuse, and that bothers you more than the abuse itself...

EarringsandLipstick · 26/09/2020 08:51

Myimaginarycathadfleas

There are plenty of wise, funny and interesting posters around but they no longer have the loudest voice here. Bullying seems to thrive and the moderation is inconsistent and often irrational.

I couldn't agree more 👏👏👏👏👏

I still really enjoy the excellent, articulate advice of many. I learnt so much & understood so much about my abusive relationship from MN. M
I got support in the Bereavement forum when by dad died.

I do think the bullying is awful & the gratuitous nastiness is truly awful.

TheClaws · 26/09/2020 08:46

Ah, just read Seeds post.