Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Losing faith in Mumsnet?

220 replies

TheWho67 · 26/09/2020 01:08

People post for validation or genuine comprehension over an issue.
Replies go either way, agree or disagree, sometimes quite strongly. I've seen a lot of posts were OP has been flamed and wished they had never posted. I've been there, under a different name. I've asked Mumsnet to have more moderators, to keep things on track but I guess that wont happen. I've seen a few posts get mentioned on DM recently and think, thank god that wasn't me! Some posts get quite out of hand and once one negative post starts, other pile on.
YANBU - to think people should stick to the question asked and not unpick every single thing.
YABU - people will naturally be critical because it's on-line and not face to face and why post on a public forum if you can't handle it.

OP posts:
Rumbledstitlskin · 26/09/2020 10:59

@MintyMabel

“Whine whine the free thing I’m under no obligation to use isn’t doing what I want it to do”

And stop talking about “Mumsnet” as if it is one homogeneous thing. There are thousands of people who post, there are many different views. If you don’t like what they say, find another site, or start one yourself.

As we always say here, don’t let the door hit you on the way out.

You see this is typical of these sorts of threads where nastiness is called out. Someone comes along to tell the people complaining or voicing their opinion to more or less 'well fuck off then'.

And stop talking about “Mumsnet” as if it is one homogeneous thing.
Then you say "As we always say here". If it's not homogenous, how can you speak for the "many different views".

TheSeedsOfADream · 26/09/2020 10:54

@MintyMabel

“Whine whine the free thing I’m under no obligation to use isn’t doing what I want it to do”

And stop talking about “Mumsnet” as if it is one homogeneous thing. There are thousands of people who post, there are many different views. If you don’t like what they say, find another site, or start one yourself.

As we always say here, don’t let the door hit you on the way out.

Don't include me in your "we" ta. I've been here since 2004 and never felt the need to claim ownership either of the site or of people's behaviour. That kind of comment used to be common among the famous "mean girls" though.
Rumbledstitlskin · 26/09/2020 10:53

The thing that I've noticed is that there is a lot of ganging up on some threads. Reporting doesn't work as MN seem to only take posts in isolation, they don't seem capable of reading a thread and its posts in context where there is collective school girl type sneering and goading.

Examples such as
'what she said',
'haha, you win the thread for wittiest post' and
'i agree with AnnaBubbles' following a pretty nasty or sneering attack on the OP.

That way posters get away with not breaking the guidelines and it means that threads can be pile-ons and I don't think the OPs come out of it feeling well at all. Then they're goaded for not coming back to the thread and stuff. Bitchiness I guess you'd call it.

WorraLiberty · 26/09/2020 10:51

I do think the moderation over the last year or so has become a bit like pin the tail on the donkey.

The sketchiness started with the whole trans issue and then went on to the issue of the new Black Mumsnetters topic.

There just seems to be no rhyme or reason to why some posts are deleted while others that are far worse, are left to stand. Reporting of late just seems to be met with 'Thanks, we'll look into it' and you're left none the wiser.

barskits · 26/09/2020 10:37

The humour and the wit has gone out of the place, certainly. I can't remember the last time there was a genuinely funny thread on here.

It is also really frustrating to start reading a thread from someone asking for support, and to see fairly near the beginning, the start of a bitch-fest pile-on. It's almost as if as soon as one person starts, loads of others think it is all right to give the OP a kicking as well. Nasty.

Roussette · 26/09/2020 10:35

Agree... the ageism is pretty bad.

Roussette · 26/09/2020 10:30

I love kissing a chip meself... too much Grin

LastGoldenDaysOfSummer · 26/09/2020 10:29

The ageism that MN allows is just awful.

Try saying what is regularly said about older people about BAME or Trans community and it's deleted before you can draw breath.

Seventybillionnamechanges · 26/09/2020 10:24

@wigglerose even on the most lighthearted of threads some grouch usually comes along to say “I don’t see what’s so funny about x, or y”
It’s like they rush to kiss on everyone’s chips.

wigglerose · 26/09/2020 10:20

It sometimes feels like there's no sense of humour any more. Some posters are just gratuitously nasty. I think there's a difference between saying, "Come on OP, don't you think you're being a lil bit precious here" and "Wow. You sound hard work."
The frequent refusal to see nuance also annoys me.

MintyMabel · 26/09/2020 10:18

“Whine whine the free thing I’m under no obligation to use isn’t doing what I want it to do”

And stop talking about “Mumsnet” as if it is one homogeneous thing. There are thousands of people who post, there are many different views. If you don’t like what they say, find another site, or start one yourself.

As we always say here, don’t let the door hit you on the way out.

Jaxsbum · 26/09/2020 10:17

@MashedSweetSpud

There’s another site online (which if I mention the name of it my comment will be removed) and quite a few people here are mocked/laughed at, some are mentioned regularly.

When you post online it goes a lot further than here and DM.

So true. They seem to mainly target posters that disagree with them. Then they call them bullies and act the victim.
Beamur · 26/09/2020 10:12

I've been on MN on and off for ages. It has always been thus!
The threads about how mean everyone has become are also not a new thing I'm afraid.
The different boards have different tones for sure, but it's a public forum, you sign away your rights to content when you sign up, like it or lump it really.
I think the site is well moderated. If you think it isn't then perhaps you haven't experienced some other internet forums!

Mumtumwobble · 26/09/2020 10:07

I’ve been on here for years now with various usernames, but regularly take breaks because it gets so toxic. I genuinely think some people just like an argument. They put out posts that they know are mean or controversial just to get someone to bite. I’ve no idea why they do this and I imagine most people wouldn’t say some of these things in real life. Online forums like this just bring out the worst in some people.

Greydove28 · 26/09/2020 10:04

Ive seen a lot of threads started slagging off other current threads on the board. Like "to be sick of im having another boy threads". I find those threads particularly nasty and seeing it a lot on here lately.

BIWI · 26/09/2020 10:03

For me, it was bringing out the begging bowl during lockdown when people were scared about losing their jobs and on a reduced income or unemployed that made me question MN. It really was a shit thing to do

Did you not read the thread at the time though? The reason for bringing forward the Premium membership is because MN - like a lot of other businesses - were losing a massive amount of revenue because of Covid/lockdown. Without the money they wouldn't be able to keep it going.

It wasn't just begging for money for the sake of it.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 26/09/2020 10:02

Over the years I've been here I've had to regularly take breaks for my sanity, as sometimes it's so toxic and the lack of reading ability and empathy so lacking it gets to me.

I recently started a post in Site Stuff with a suggestion about deleting inactive accounts. Reason being is that I'm unable to log into a couple of my old email addresses so for a few years have been unable to use my beloved old usernames (which took me ages to think up). Can't log in here and can't reset my login as can't login to my registered email. If my old account was deleted then my usernames would become available again and I reregister them. OK, many replies pointed out what a bad idea that was, but one poster just had to tell me I should've taken more responsibility to ensure I didn't lose my log in details (as though people never have the same issue!Hmm) As though I was an idiot and shouldn't expect MN to sort out my stupid mistakes. I just felt there was no need for that attitude, it wasn't AIBU. So generally, I only come on MN, even just to read threads, when I'm feeling mentally resilient as it can so easily make me feel shit.

Roussette · 26/09/2020 09:59

I know where you mean, only a few posters have been mentioned and they are the worst offenders in terms of hectoring and bullying others so in a sense they set the tone themselves

That is outright lies because I am one of the chosen 'few'.

I wrote a far longer post but in the interests of harmony I will refrain from saying what I really think.
Bullying is a sport for some people as they try and outdo each other in nastiness.

Yes, most of the time you can ignore it, and I do. But it is still upsetting. How cowardly and easy to bully and ridicule from the comfort of another forum. .

ShebaShimmyShake · 26/09/2020 09:45

For me, it was bringing out the begging bowl during lockdown when people were scared about losing their jobs and on a reduced income or unemployed that made me question MN. It really was a shit thing to do.

Presumably the staff at MNHQ had the same fears in case the situation should cause the site to collapse? I don't see the problem, nobody had to pay money if they didn't want to.

Galacticat · 26/09/2020 09:39

For me, it was bringing out the begging bowl during lockdown when people were scared about losing their jobs and on a reduced income or unemployed that made me question MN. It really was a shit thing to do.

There has been an upturn in nastiness across the boards recently. It used to be a safe space for help and information for women but when you have a male moderator telling women what they can or can't say, then I'm out.

I still nip on for a long standing support thread as I've made real life friends here but thats about it now.

Its a shame as there used to be so many funny, informative and helpful posters on here.

Myimaginarycathadfleas · 26/09/2020 09:28

@MashedSweetSpud

There’s another site online (which if I mention the name of it my comment will be removed) and quite a few people here are mocked/laughed at, some are mentioned regularly.

When you post online it goes a lot further than here and DM.

I know where you mean, only a few posters have been mentioned and they are the worst offenders in terms of hectoring and bullying others so in a sense they set the tone themselves. However I do agree that in an online forum you have to accept that the universality of the community means you don't get to choose your company.
AlexisCarringtonColbyDexter · 26/09/2020 09:27

As pps have said, I'm not sure why one would have faith in an internet forum

I agree with this. MN is no different to any other public internet forum. Yes, sometimes the vitriol and hatred towards innocuous, meaningless stuff is quite puzzling and I cant imagine how those people function in real life with such high levels of pent up rage about such insignificant things. You have to accept that on a public forum, you will get unpleasant people commenting, you'll have lovely people and you'll have shit people. Thats the internet for you. There is nothing to have "faith" in- its just life. When the nastiness gets too much I just log off- thats the beauty of the internet, you do not have to engage in it nor let it affect you.
When its clear people are unable to talk about something without throwing attacks and personal insults I just leave that thread. I'm not going to let a stranger bring my mood down. Thats my responsibility to protect my own feelings, not theirs.

TheSeedsOfADream · 26/09/2020 09:24

@OlympicProcrastinator

There's also a strong anti-intellectual aspect to that which is pretty representative of the country generally

This isn’t a bad thing imo. Too many people consider that people who do not have much of a formal education or are of a lower class to themselves have nothing valuable to contribute. Shutting people out of conversations because you feel as though you have some special insight due to your education or class is a dangerous game.

When people pile on the ‘thick, underclass, ignorant’ etc etc I believe they fail to see the irony. That very way of thinking and behaving has created political exclusion which has resulted in the very things people on here complain about.

That's very true. The people who pile on to a poster for a grammar error (or worse, then go on to justify humiliating somebody on a public forum by saying "if I were that thick I didn't know how to use "should have," I'd say thank you if someone pointed it out") don't tend to be so grateful when you then point theirs out (in the interests of what they want you to do) Funny that.

Because they always do make mistakes, often far worse than any misplaced "of".

Pedants' Corner went from being a slightly geeky zone where we'd all discuss random language and linguistics stuff to having its own "quiche" of nasty fuckers who would run over there with their "just seen this on a thread mwahahaha".

Bakeachocolatecaketoday · 26/09/2020 09:23

tldr; I think it's been the same for years, my example was from 5 years ago!

Bakeachocolatecaketoday · 26/09/2020 09:22

Sometimes people pile in with the weirdest comments too. Many years ago I posted about a whole class detention, a child had done something to the teacher, like water in her handbag or something and they were trying to find out who it was. My Ds was incensed as he got a detention - basically no one knew who had done it and no one confessed so they put the whole class in detention. My DS (who had never had a detention in his life) thought it grossly unfair and I posted asking whether I should complain to the school.

Well... I got told a) it was obviously my child who had done it and b) I was laughing at the teacher Confused Confused. There were 300+ posts like this, when I just wanted to spark some debate about inappropriate punishments, and get some affirmation I wasn't being "that parent".

BTW I did complain and got an apology from the school, they said it wouldn't happen again, they said they had gone down the wrong route to find the culprit and had had to follow through.