Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughter just told me she thinks she is a lesbian.

140 replies

DamnIvy · 25/09/2020 17:36

So, after school today, my 10 year old daughter asks me if it's ok to have a girlfriend when your 10. It took me a little off guard, and I told her that I think that 10 is too young for girlfriends or boyfriends. After a few minutes, she then tells me that she really likes a girl in her class, she said she 'like, likes her'. I asked if the girl was a close friend, thinking that she may be mixing up feelings. But it turns out to be a girl that she doesnt get on particularly well with. She then says that she thinks she is a lesbian.

I had no idea what to say. I basically told her that she is a little young to be thinking about girls or boys. But assured her that being happy is all that matters and that we love her no matter what.

Was I wrong for not talking more about it. I didnt want to lead her into conversation that she was happy talking about, it could be phase or mixed up feelings after all. I also have NO idea on how to talk about this with her.
It's not something I had ever thought about, I know some mums say that they have always known, I havnt. She only really plays with boys and isnt overly girlie. But that's just her. I was the same. But I'm reading things saying that that is a sign.

Either way, whatever path she takes in life, we will support her all the way. I'm just looking for anyone with experience with young children with this. So I can support her better in the future.

So aibu thinking that 10 is just too young to think, or know even, that you are gay?

OP posts:
catherinep80 · 25/09/2020 23:12

I definitely had crushes on boys at the age of 10, and as a young teenager who went to an all girl school I had what I thought were crushes on girls. I turned out to be completely straight and didn't actually have a sexual interest in girls at all - it was more of an admiration thing, just a strong attraction to them as people. Not something I would ever have acted on. Feelings are confusing at that age!

monkeymonkey2010 · 25/09/2020 22:56

SHE is already aware of her feelings and understands that what she feels for this girl is not the same as liking a 'friend'....she turned to you cos she was confused and probably feels a little scared/insecure about being in this situation - and you shut the door on her and told her to ignore her feelings.....and patronised her by telling her she wasn't 'old enough' to have a crush or fancy someone.

pallisers · 25/09/2020 22:44

@SarahAndQuack

Ugh, sorry, I tried to sit on my hands but I'm so bad at this. So. Please do ignore if you want.

There are a lot of posts in this thread saying it's probably 'just a phase' or that it is normal for straight children to have a phase of attraction to the same sex. There are mentions of 'crushes'. Someone's used the term 'pash'.

This is all true, but gay children also do the exact same thing - you get gay men and lesbians who thought they were attracted to the opposite sex. There's no need to trivialise what a child feels by telling them it must be part of 'normal' development and therefore temporary. If they feel it, they feel it.

There are also several posts saying either that it's a bit young, or suggesting that 'sexual' feelings come later. A lot of people are basically talking about humouring children, kindly, on the assumption those children simply have no idea about sex and sexual feelings.

This is really damaging and unkind.

Being gay or lesbian is not all about sex. Think about your heterosexual relationship with your partner. It's not just about sex, is it? A child who is beginning to suspect they're gay may have no sexual feelings at all - they might just feel, somehow, they are more comfortable and happy with members of their own sex. Or they might somehow realise that they always imagine themselves growing up and living with someone of the same sex.

All of the things said on this thread have a history. For centuries we've been saying that homosexuality is 'just a phase' and that it's essentially an immature emotion most people grow out of. There are generations of gay people who have said how hurtful and damaging this is (I really mean this, btw: you look at how painful early twentieth-century accounts of persecution for homosexuality are).

It's fine to be privately sceptical about something your child says; I get that. But I think you have to be really careful they don't pick up on the fact you're implying you hope they 'change their mind' or 'grow out of it'. That might be fine if they do - but if they don't, would you want to be responsible for implying you hoped they would?

This is such a great post. Thank you.
Whatisthisfuckery · 25/09/2020 22:36

I definitely knew I only liked girls at that age and it’s never changed. Liking boys just never crossed my mind until everybody put pressure on me to consider it. I made up boy crushes to fit in but I never actually fancied a boy. By my late teens I felt under so much pressure to be in a relationship with a man that I got married, which was an absolute disaster in every way imaginable.

I think it’s perfectly reasonable for a girl of that age to know, and even if she swears she’s a lesbian today then changes her mind tomorrow, who cares? She’s young, let her experiment with her feelings without pressure or expectation. I wish I’d been allowed to do that.

I definitely knew though, and from a lot younger than your DD’s age.

IamAporcupine · 25/09/2020 22:36

@SarahAndQuack

Ugh, sorry, I tried to sit on my hands but I'm so bad at this. So. Please do ignore if you want.

There are a lot of posts in this thread saying it's probably 'just a phase' or that it is normal for straight children to have a phase of attraction to the same sex. There are mentions of 'crushes'. Someone's used the term 'pash'.

This is all true, but gay children also do the exact same thing - you get gay men and lesbians who thought they were attracted to the opposite sex. There's no need to trivialise what a child feels by telling them it must be part of 'normal' development and therefore temporary. If they feel it, they feel it.

There are also several posts saying either that it's a bit young, or suggesting that 'sexual' feelings come later. A lot of people are basically talking about humouring children, kindly, on the assumption those children simply have no idea about sex and sexual feelings.

This is really damaging and unkind.

Being gay or lesbian is not all about sex. Think about your heterosexual relationship with your partner. It's not just about sex, is it? A child who is beginning to suspect they're gay may have no sexual feelings at all - they might just feel, somehow, they are more comfortable and happy with members of their own sex. Or they might somehow realise that they always imagine themselves growing up and living with someone of the same sex.

All of the things said on this thread have a history. For centuries we've been saying that homosexuality is 'just a phase' and that it's essentially an immature emotion most people grow out of. There are generations of gay people who have said how hurtful and damaging this is (I really mean this, btw: you look at how painful early twentieth-century accounts of persecution for homosexuality are).

It's fine to be privately sceptical about something your child says; I get that. But I think you have to be really careful they don't pick up on the fact you're implying you hope they 'change their mind' or 'grow out of it'. That might be fine if they do - but if they don't, would you want to be responsible for implying you hoped they would?

Really good post

I remember saying the same to my mum at about 10/11.
She said something along the lines of:
"You might be thinking this to hide your strong feelings for boys"

Confused

This has to be the most damaging thing a parent could ever say.
To this day, nearly 40 years later, I am confused about my sexuality

JaffaJaffJaffpussycatpuss · 25/09/2020 22:35

You did really well, OP.
I would have loved a mum like this... I grew up in a homophobic and sex shaming household.
Keep on being understanding and compassionate and she'll continually able to open up to you.

TheDuchessofMalfy · 25/09/2020 22:34

I’d be totally led by her in terms of how much or little you discuss.

I do think crushes at 10, whether on boys or girls, rarely mean very much. She does seem to have given this some thought, so I’d be as accepting as possible and there for her whilst not making a big deal of it either way.

malificent7 · 25/09/2020 22:29

No big deal i mean!

malificent7 · 25/09/2020 22:28

Meh...bo big deal. Crushes are normal and as long as you support her no matter what her sexuality is she will be fine...no need to worry.

maddiemookins16mum · 25/09/2020 22:27

I had a massive crush on a girl around that age, I was probably 11. I can still remember her name ☺️ even though it 1974/5 ish.

FunnysInLaJardin · 25/09/2020 22:27

OP, DS2 is 10. Half the kids in his class, boys and girls are saying they are gay atm. I really think it is just a thing they are going through, sort of fashionable if you like.

Give her some time and see if she still feels the same in a few years.

In the meantime, don't judge and give her your support and all will be fine, whether or not she is gay.

Incidentally DS2 told me he was probably a bit bi sexual! Although mostly straight!

ifiwasascent · 25/09/2020 22:26

This is strange because my 10 year old sister just told me that she's got a girlfriend. It happened at 4pm today- her answer when I asked how long they had been together. So happy she told us and I have no issue with who she goes out with as long as she's happy and I'm really really glad that her telling me wasn't a big deal.

Eckhart · 25/09/2020 22:18

Are we all dismissing the fact that children often have sexual feelings, and that that's normal?

BiBabbles · 25/09/2020 22:16

Much younger kids can have intense emotions of wanting to be close to someone (crushes aren't automatically sexual, or even romantic), but I agree with others that having that without someone one clashes a lot with would be my concern and between that and the age, I might want to start a conversation on what she thinks having a girlfriend means, maybe with a movie or show to help. Kids often have very different ideas of this to adults (hell, we adults often have different ideas of this from each other).

When my DD1 first started gushing about girls, I listened. When she started to tell her brother off about how he not have seen that girl with the...I admit I chuckled and then told her not to do that to him. When she said she thought she might be a lesbian, I told her it's a possibility and asked if she wanted to talk about it. We've discussed it a few times. Mainly, I try to discuss their sexuality as something that's theirs to figure out at their own pace, and not something they need to worry about or try to fix their sense of self on.

Eckhart · 25/09/2020 22:13

@ravenmum

That's poetic and really quite lovely Smile

(oh, and totally accurate)

ravenmum · 25/09/2020 22:03

Life is nothing but phases, like a beautiful patchwork bedspread :)

funtimefrank · 25/09/2020 22:02

@Spiderbaby8 - thanks for this, it's a more rational way of saying what have been trying to type!

Eckhart · 25/09/2020 22:00

@SarahAndQuack Excellent post, your long one.

@ravenmum Your experience is a good example of why a phase shouldn't just be dismissed or minimised. It can go on for a long time; it is part of you; the feelings are valid, even if your truth settles elsewhere in the end.

SarahAndQuack · 25/09/2020 21:59

YY, I think things are starting to get easier. I hope so! Smile

Spiderbaby8 · 25/09/2020 21:59

@SarahAndQuack yes agree that telling the child it's a phase is wrong. I guess I was thinking I wouldn't want to jump to validate her about being lesbian either. I would just be really casual whilst accepting at that age.

ravenmum · 25/09/2020 21:58

SarahAndQuack - No worries, I honestly thought I might have missed some key point and needed to be educated!

I get what you mean now. I do think that things are getting a bit easier, though, aren't they? My kids' friends were out in school. Though...my ds told me he's bi at age 14 or so, but I don't think he's as open about it with his mates as the girls seem to be.

Harriedharriet · 25/09/2020 21:57

Agreed that feelings at this age can be strong but I think the op did the child a favour by saying she is too young. She removed from the child the burden of doing something, becoming something, defining something, feeling weird around the friend and all the rest.She gave the child freedom and accepted her "confession" with "being happy is all that counts".
Well done op....

MulticolourMophead · 25/09/2020 21:47

@SarahAndQuack

Ugh, sorry, I tried to sit on my hands but I'm so bad at this. So. Please do ignore if you want.

There are a lot of posts in this thread saying it's probably 'just a phase' or that it is normal for straight children to have a phase of attraction to the same sex. There are mentions of 'crushes'. Someone's used the term 'pash'.

This is all true, but gay children also do the exact same thing - you get gay men and lesbians who thought they were attracted to the opposite sex. There's no need to trivialise what a child feels by telling them it must be part of 'normal' development and therefore temporary. If they feel it, they feel it.

There are also several posts saying either that it's a bit young, or suggesting that 'sexual' feelings come later. A lot of people are basically talking about humouring children, kindly, on the assumption those children simply have no idea about sex and sexual feelings.

This is really damaging and unkind.

Being gay or lesbian is not all about sex. Think about your heterosexual relationship with your partner. It's not just about sex, is it? A child who is beginning to suspect they're gay may have no sexual feelings at all - they might just feel, somehow, they are more comfortable and happy with members of their own sex. Or they might somehow realise that they always imagine themselves growing up and living with someone of the same sex.

All of the things said on this thread have a history. For centuries we've been saying that homosexuality is 'just a phase' and that it's essentially an immature emotion most people grow out of. There are generations of gay people who have said how hurtful and damaging this is (I really mean this, btw: you look at how painful early twentieth-century accounts of persecution for homosexuality are).

It's fine to be privately sceptical about something your child says; I get that. But I think you have to be really careful they don't pick up on the fact you're implying you hope they 'change their mind' or 'grow out of it'. That might be fine if they do - but if they don't, would you want to be responsible for implying you hoped they would?

@SarahAndQuack I think that was a good post. I've never even suggested to my own parents that I felt I was bi, so I never got this kind of comment or any suggeston of "it's just a phase".

But I did hear similar comments directed at a cousin of mine, who's now married to her wife, and I know her relationship with her dad was a bit rocky for a while, but things got miles better before he died. Her brother has never married or even had a girlfriend so far as I know. He's never actually come out, but I always see him with the same chap, so I think he, too, is gay. He's 61 now, and I suspect he'll never actually come out officially.

It probably has a lot to do with the times we grew up in, although I'm around 10 years younger than these cousins.

SarahAndQuack · 25/09/2020 21:43

@Spiderbaby8 - oh, yes, I think it's often role play, whether a child is/will be straight or not. But I did indicate I was talking specifically about those who had presented this as a phase.

SarahAndQuack · 25/09/2020 21:41

No, I wasn't at all meaning to imply you'd said your experience was difficult and (if you'll forgive me) I was more building on your good point with one of mine.

I think you're totally right some people know early and others know much later.

I just wanted to push that point, and observe that, if you don't know early on that you're straight, it's not so very tricky to have straight relationships in your late teens/early adult/adult years.

So, perhaps you are in less need of reassurance earlier on.

I really wasn't meaning to get at you! Sorry I judged the tone wrong - I thought we were coming from very much the same place and using our experiences to illustrate similar things.