Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are still having kids?

688 replies

Tobythecat · 20/09/2020 19:21

I understand that the urge to reproduce is very strong, but the future looks incredibly bleak (I'm not talking about just covid, but also climate change). I fear for the future and what sort of quality of life people will have, considering Automation/competition over jobs, climate change issues (food/water shortages, extreme weather). Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? Children today will face unimagineable suffering in the next 20-30 years, how can you justify it to them? I wanted children desperately but decided not to because of the above, plus genetic factors.

People mention the war and how people kept having kids, but the threats we face have never been faced before and are multifaceted. Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?

OP posts:
Bluemooninmyeyes1 · 21/09/2020 08:59

@AltheaThoon of course it makes a difference that more women now are choosing not to reproduce. If everyone thought like you and kept adding to the problem by having kids, the world would be more overpopulated and resources would be scarcer. It doesn’t take a genius to work that out.

Kazakaren · 21/09/2020 08:58

Sure, the Earth might be saved, but at what cost...?

The human race. Obviously.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:54

"Moral high ground" isn't quite right...I think I meant to say "you lose all credibility".

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:52

@KeepSmiling89

Wow, what a cheery thread to read first thing on a Monday morning OP. I think if everyone thought the same as you, the human race would be extinct in 20-30 years time. Sure, the Earth might be saved, but at what cost...?
Some people want this to happen; for the human race to die out and Gaia could return to "a beautiful paradise". Although anyone who knows much about nature knows it isn't all gorgeous, fair and beautiful. Some of it is just brutal, cruel and very unfair. But, I digress.

It's a cliche, but everyone thinks it when they hear this argument; you first then!

People who choose not to have babies, for any reason, good for you! But when you deliberately choose to come on to a parenting site and try to bully and coerce people into feeling exactly the same as you, you lose the moral high ground.

It's like me swooping in to that "thank you for not breeding" site and telling them all they're WRONG. I would never. Some people might, but those people are honestly a little unhinged. As are the people who do the reverse imo.

Thisbastardcomputer · 21/09/2020 08:45

Every generation has a crisis, wars, cold wars, missile crises, aids. Please calm it down, any new parent with anxiety will be distraught.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:43

*they are being

KeepSmiling89 · 21/09/2020 08:43

Wow, what a cheery thread to read first thing on a Monday morning OP. I think if everyone thought the same as you, the human race would be extinct in 20-30 years time. Sure, the Earth might be saved, but at what cost...?

AltheaThoon · 21/09/2020 08:39

If women chose to stop having children we'd soon find ourselves in a Gilead like state being forced to have them.

Yes the world is over populated and yes it's a problem. Good for you and your friends if you all chose not to have children in an attempt to save the planet (though I hate to tell you that you not having children won't make a blind bit of difference to that). No need to gleefully tell those of us who chose differently that our children's lives are damned.

Most people make small changes where they can in the hope of making a difference.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:37

wondering how we as parents plan on explaining to our kids how we justified parenthood to ourselves

I'd be more concerned about justifying our lifestyles. Before we start removing, (by coersion, as people are doing on here), womens reproductive rights, maybe we need to take a look at how we are living.

Both are important. I'm not disputing that at all, but when people say it's just about numbers and if you have a child you're doing worse than someone driving a huge diesel car every day, taking long and short haul flights many times a year for holidays, eating a lot of red meat and dairy etc etc, is being overly simplistic.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:32

Not the one I was thinking of, but this:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-15449959

It isn't just numbers; it's also wealth which is the problem. So lifestyle is a huge factor.

Marmitecrackers · 21/09/2020 08:31

To be honest OP if you are that anxious I would concur that you shouldn't have children as it's not fair to bring them up around heightened anxiety.

As for the rest of it the human race does need to continue...

Mimishimi · 21/09/2020 08:31

I had kids even though I an from a minority that gets hit pretty hard with the fasces when everything hits the fan. To be honest I do worry about it

squeekums · 21/09/2020 08:30

wondering how we as parents plan on explaining to our kids how we justified parenthood to ourselves
Parents don't need to justify it.
Just like non parents don't have to justify not having kids to the "your likes totes missing out #mumlife #blessed" crowd
As women our reproductive choices are just that, OUR choice and no one else's business. Even our kids. I mean I never wanted a brother but I didn't get to make that choice, nor did my mother have to justify it to me, she wanted a 2nd kid so that's that.

Enrico · 21/09/2020 08:28

@ChelseaDaggers agree with you. The worst of it is that the birthrate has already fallen and is falling throughout Africa anyway, so even that eugenicist target is not an accurate one.

A lot of this often boils down to "my solution is that everyone else needs to stop doing something that I, for complex personal reasons, feel ambivalent towards. This is preferable to considering how best to share finite resources".

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:22

I am also a bit grossed out by the response that "children born in the West will most likely be OK"

Completely agree with this. But also bear in mind that a lot of the antinatalist rhetoric as a response to climate change comes from privileged, post productive, white men. (I do have a source for this, if I could find the fucking thing).

The main area for 'concern' in terms of birth rate is projected to be in Africa.

So, let's think that through; the west likes holibobs in the sun, eating vast quantities of meat and aircon. Woopsy daisy, we've fucked the planet. How shall we combat this? Less babies! Oh we already are having what some people say is a concerning low number of babies in this country. It is not considered by all experts to be a good thing that we have been at below replacement level for years here. But ah yes, in Africa and parts of Asia, there's your trouble. Crack down on the babies.

Also, as I said, lifestyle comes into it in a significant way, otherwise carbon footprint wouldn't be so much bigger per person in the west than elsewhere.

Enrico · 21/09/2020 08:16
  1. People have children because all species that can reproduce do so in order to perpetuate their species.
  2. We are collectively, globally, and in each individual country, having fewer children than we did seventy years ago. This has been the case for several decades ie more than a generation.
  3. People have always continued to have children even in the face of large scale or global uncertainty. Through plague, pestilence, famine, they've done it. During my early years there were some who wrung their hands about those who had children despite the fact that they would doubtless perish in what seemed, for twenty years, imminent and likely nuclear war. Yet, here we all are.
YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 21/09/2020 08:13

It is not mean to have this conversation on a parenting website, Rosebel. Don't you think many parents are having this conversation in their own heads a lot of the time in one form or another, precisely because they are parents?
It is not antinatalist as a previous poster suggested, just a natural response to what is a growing concern, especially for parents.
On this thread, I am seeing a lot of subjective responses to a global, objective issue; lots of "Well, I am going to raise my kids to be the best they can be..." etc, which is not what the OP is really asking. OP is, it seems to me, wondering how we as parents plan on explaining to our kids how we justified parenthood to ourselves.
I am also seeing cited examples of other 'disasters' which have heaped suffering on sections of mankind over the millennia. It seems to me that none of these would really have threatened life on earth quite in the same way as we are currently seeing with the climate, so I think it is a false comparison.
I am also a bit grossed out by the response that "children born in the West will most likely be OK", which wilfully blanks what is happening to people (not to mention species) in cities and countries in other parts of the world, as a direct consequence of a heating climate, right now. Like that's somehow OK.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:11

That poster is still on here btw, although I haven't seen her whip out the "I'm childfree by choice unlike you selfish fuckers" line in a while.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:10

There was one poster btw, who used to go on the the conception boards, where people go when TTC, including those suffering with infertility. She would brag about how she was "childfree by choice" and how selfish the people TTC were. The thing is, that is someone who is not quite right. Like trolls on here who come on and write awful things about Meghan Markle or Jack Monroe. Those threads get deleted and repeat offenders get banned. But when someone says they deliberately come to snigger at parents who are struggling, because it makes them feel better about their own lives, that's ok according to HQ.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 08:05

@middleager

Why is this thread still going when OP clearly has issues? OP, I feel sorry for you on some level and hope you address your issues in a constructive way.
I have no idea. Honestly, it has no place on a parenting forum. Take it elsewhere please and thank you.
fairydustandpixies · 21/09/2020 08:05

Yes, you are definitely BU.

middleager · 21/09/2020 08:03

Why is this thread still going when OP clearly has issues? OP, I feel sorry for you on some level and hope you address your issues in a constructive way.

Kazakaren · 21/09/2020 07:59

I understand your point op, and to some level I agree with you. I have kids though, so my focus has to be on making the world a better place.

Danni290 · 21/09/2020 07:58

Your post is actually very insensitive and rather silly. I haven't RTFT but what if a child born today was a child that grows up to solves climate change? Or makes a big difference to the world in some other way?

So we should all stop having kids and then become extinct 150 years from now, you think that's a solution to the worlds problems? The world has had problems since its creation - you've just come on here to vent your frustration and bitterness it sounds like.