Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are still having kids?

688 replies

Tobythecat · 20/09/2020 19:21

I understand that the urge to reproduce is very strong, but the future looks incredibly bleak (I'm not talking about just covid, but also climate change). I fear for the future and what sort of quality of life people will have, considering Automation/competition over jobs, climate change issues (food/water shortages, extreme weather). Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? Children today will face unimagineable suffering in the next 20-30 years, how can you justify it to them? I wanted children desperately but decided not to because of the above, plus genetic factors.

People mention the war and how people kept having kids, but the threats we face have never been faced before and are multifaceted. Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 21/09/2020 10:02

@ReeseWitherfork

SleepingStandingUp some good numbers there. You’ve forgotten that by the year 2100 humanity would be wiped out completely. We don’t get to find out if the planet survived, that’s it. Humanity done. Because we all just quit.
Probably line before that tbh. Generation last in 2060 would be facing the protect of failing health and the only work force would be their age or older. Yep, am the doctors and caregivers would be "pensioners". The death rate sure to cancers and other serious health issues would increase because they're would be a lack of young people coming into the workforce. Even fairly minor ailments that could be treated would be exacerbated.
Kazakaren · 21/09/2020 10:02

Mumsnet is more than a parenting site now and the environmental issues with having children are well documented. It is complicated but the truth is all there. But these threads always go this way because it's the last taboo.

The hysteria. Because someone dared ask a simple question, and that very question has offended, disturbed and upset people in equal parts. So the post must be removed in case it's disturbing content upsets anyone else. 🙄This is the monster that social media has created. Now that's far more depressing than the ops original post.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 10:00

@OliviaBenson

Oh my op, you had some aggressive responses? Now, I wonder why that might be? Perhaps because you started this goady thread, airing your poorly educated, revolting views on parents of babies and young children, on a PARENTING forum. Did you think we'd role over and take it? NOPE! If you don't like the responses, you know where the proverbial door is.

Wow, it's really hit a nerve with you hasn't it @ChelseaDaggers?

Mumsnet is more than a parenting site now and the environmental issues with having children are well documented. It is complicated but the truth is all there. But these threads always go this way because it's the last taboo.

People spouting inflammatory bollocks on a subject I am reasonably educated in, is something I will always challenge, tenaciously if needs be.

Do not attempt to minimise my perfectly logical and fairly well researched arguments with "pooh touched a nerve have we"? It makes you sound like a playground bully. Wow indeed.

ReeseWitherfork · 21/09/2020 09:56

Mumsnet is more than a parenting site now and the environmental issues with having children are well documented.
Tell me more about the well documented environmental issues with having children please.

OliviaBenson · 21/09/2020 09:55

Oh my op, you had some aggressive responses? Now, I wonder why that might be? Perhaps because you started this goady thread, airing your poorly educated, revolting views on parents of babies and young children, on a PARENTING forum. Did you think we'd role over and take it? NOPE! If you don't like the responses, you know where the proverbial door is.

Wow, it's really hit a nerve with you hasn't it @ChelseaDaggers?

Mumsnet is more than a parenting site now and the environmental issues with having children are well documented. It is complicated but the truth is all there. But these threads always go this way because it's the last taboo.

ReeseWitherfork · 21/09/2020 09:55

SleepingStandingUp some good numbers there. You’ve forgotten that by the year 2100 humanity would be wiped out completely. We don’t get to find out if the planet survived, that’s it. Humanity done. Because we all just quit.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/09/2020 09:53

So if op gets her wish and everyone ceases having babies as of now...

By 2021 the NICU / maternity would be obsolete. That's a load of nurses that need new jobs.

36000 midwives, 5000 NICU nurses and that's without the thousands of people around them

By 2024 most childcare settings would be inserious trouble. Yes they could expand to after school care but that isn't where the biggest trade is.

40000 registered childminders alone

We'd also not need Health Visitors although i guess they could be kept on till kids were say 11.

They're a mere 7000 of those.

By 2027 that's the infant and nursery teachers or of a job school and primary schools in their entirety by 2031.

That's 216,500 primary school teachers in ENGLAND plus an the dinner ladies, 121s, TAs, catering staff, cleaners.

Not to mention the businesses that supply them with food etc and those who come in to do specialist sessions.

So within a decade that's 300,000 job losses as a low ballpark figure.

So 2031 would see a huge increase in unemployment, something like 23000 school buildings left empty.

Some of those people would retain of course, but there's only a finite number of other jobs.

By 2038 all the secondary schools would be done, 210000 secondary school teachers, 61000 in independent schools, 17000 in specialist schools.

The college's would diversify into adult education but would lose the majority of their students.

Within 20 years we'd have no need for childcare providers, health visitors, midwives, paediatric buses, paediatric nurses, paediatric specialists like SALT, OT etc. No teachers or support staff. Thousands of buildings would become monoliths.
No children's clothes suppliers, no toy makers, no toy shops or children's books.

Meanwhile any arguement to do more to protect our children's world would be pointless.

for my son's generation, what would be the reason to consume less? They literally know they'll be the last ones left.

They're would be no kids taking their jobs so unemployment would eventually settle, but by 2040 it would just be about the hedonism, taking whatever you can whilst you're here.

I think part of what keeps people in check is the thought of future generations. We're bad enough as it is, without they natural check, we'd ruin far more

ReeseWitherfork · 21/09/2020 09:52

So I think my conclusion is that, as ChelseaDaggers has pointed out. It’s batshit crazy that this thread is still here. It makes hysterical discussion the norm and is surely only creating unnecessary anxiety. Hardly a well reasoned, thought provoking thread is it.

KeepSmiling89 · 21/09/2020 09:51

OP, you're looking for an intelligent discussion on why women should stop having children on a forum called 'Mumsnet'.
Yes, you do have some valid points but, c'mon! You're not being very intelligent in where you're actually posting your argument.

Regardless of what kind of future our children will have, it's our duty to educate our children, and show them how to respond to said situations. Yes, the situation is crap now, there were crap situations in the past and there will be crap situations in the future. I'm sure there's a word for that...oh yeah, its called LIFE! I, for one, am going to make the most of it instead of worrying about what MIGHT happen in the future.

ReeseWitherfork · 21/09/2020 09:50

The trouble with such open discussion is that a lot of what is being spouted here (by OP) is hysteria IMO. And there appears to be a lot of people claiming that having a child is the single worse thing you can do for the environment. But I don’t see that backed up by anything. It’s become almost ingrained in the way some people think. Why is it the worse thing we can do? Did I miss all those discussions were everyone agreed to it?

A few people here have said they’ve chosen not to have children for environmental reasons. I hope their decisions are backed up by some actual science and they’re not just being swayed by the hysteria. I fear that isn’t the case as I’m yet to see the science that tells you not to reproduce.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 09:45

Roll*
There*

Whatever else. Scuse typos, I'm on my phone.

Also stunned that the pro eugenics comments have been left up Angry🤢.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 09:44

If I held the view that dog ownership, especially overbreeding of dogs, was cruel (which I sort of do) and an unnecessary luxury in times when we should be being more careful about carbon footprint and meat consumption, and I then got myself registered on PugWorld . Com or something (I made that up btw. Don't think it's a real site) and went on ther going on about how wrong it was to have these dogs, how it is cruel, the UNIMAGINABLE suffering etc etc, I would get banned. Why is it acceptable for the op and her ilk to do it here?

If I hated old people and their carers and I did the same thing on a site for carers for the elderly, I would also be shown the door.

Oh my op, you had some aggressive responses? Now, I wonder why that might be? Perhaps because you started this goady thread, airing your poorly educated, revolting views on parents of babies and young children, on a PARENTING forum. Did you think we'd role over and take it? NOPE! If you don't like the responses, you know where the proverbial door is.

Alabamawhirly1 · 21/09/2020 09:42

Christ, I'm only on page 16 but I'd just like to point out that eugenics doesn't work because illness and disability can be caused by spontaneous mutations.

No one, NO ONE is a perfect 50/50 copy of their parents. At conception when the genetic material is copied there can be 100 or more mistakes. This can lead to no notible difference, small physical changes, health problems or in extreme cases like my sons a debilitating syndrome which would cause other fans of eugenics to pop him in a gas chamber.

So you can only breed "perfect" specimens all you want, but spontaneous mutations will still cause "imperfect" humans.

Enrico · 21/09/2020 09:36

Life is a sexually transmitted disease!

Ok, moonpig.

Tobythecat · 21/09/2020 09:36

A lot of very defensive and agressive replies to what I thought would be an interesting discussion. I guess a lot of it is guilt, but I was hoping for a more intelligent discussion.

Those of you who mention people have always had kids even in hard times- women didn't have access to contraception like we do now and they also did not have the rights we do today- women were raped by their husbands etc.

I think today we know better and our reproductive choices should reflect that. Children today will not have the quality of life that their parents had and face a very bleak future- why am I such a terrible person to even suggest that- this is reality. I feel like a lot of you just want to live in some fantasy that your kids will solve climate change and everything will be fine in the end. Why is it the next generations responsibility to deal with the shit we left them?

As much as I wish that we could come up with a solution- I fear it will be too late- we have done so much damage to the environment I don't believe it can be reversed in our lifetime.

OP posts:
AltheaThoon · 21/09/2020 09:31

[quote Bluemooninmyeyes1]@AltheaThoon of course it makes a difference that more women now are choosing not to reproduce. If everyone thought like you and kept adding to the problem by having kids, the world would be more overpopulated and resources would be scarcer. It doesn’t take a genius to work that out.[/quote]
Fair enough. Probably a stupid thing to say. However, both ideas in the extreme are damaging. If everyone was like the op and decided not to have children we'd be in complete dire straits for completely different reasons in a few years.

Choose not to have children for completely altruistic reasons? Good for you. But you have no right berating and trying to scare other for making different choices.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 09:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

redlockscelt · 21/09/2020 09:24

@GreatMindsThinkAlike

If I have children, I've decided I'll adopt. There are so many children who need a good home and then I can't be blamed for bringing them into this shitty world.
That's not a good reason to adopt a child.
LadyH846 · 21/09/2020 09:19

I agree OP.

However having children or not having children usually tends to be a selfish decision.

Life is a sexually transmitted disease!

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 09:12

@stoptheworldiwant2getoff

Its a bit of a cruel thing to write on a MUMS FORUM where a lot of us are about to give birth! Just go away, applaud yourself for saving the world but leave us alone you nasty piece of work!
This...yeah^^. Sums it up nicely. It'll probably get deleted, as will this because I've quoted it, but tbh, you're right.
ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 09:11

The baby boom after WW2 is often attributed to parents holding off having babies during the depression and then the war.

Also the notion that soldiers coming back from war had had enough of "adventure" and wanted to settle down.

This sort of contradicts what I just said re war zones, because people had fewer babies during those wars. But the UK and the US were never really war zones. Elsewhere in Europe yes, but although this actually used to be my field, I embarrassingly don't know that the baby boom was as pronounced in the rest of Europe as it was in the UK.

stoptheworldiwant2getoff · 21/09/2020 09:07

Its a bit of a cruel thing to write on a MUMS FORUM where a lot of us are about to give birth! Just go away, applaud yourself for saving the world but leave us alone you nasty piece of work!

netsybetsy · 21/09/2020 09:06

@ChelseaDaggers

I don't know if someone has stats on this but isn't it the case that disasters and war cause the birth rate to go UP rather than down?

Birth rates are higher in areas where women and children have less access to education and healthcare, so yes, this would be the case in war zones. Infant mortality is a big factor too. Mothers have more babies if there is less chance of them surviving to adulthood.

That makes sense, but wasn't it also the case after the two world wars in Europe and the USA?
ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 09:03

I don't know if someone has stats on this but isn't it the case that disasters and war cause the birth rate to go UP rather than down?

Birth rates are higher in areas where women and children have less access to education and healthcare, so yes, this would be the case in war zones. Infant mortality is a big factor too. Mothers have more babies if there is less chance of them surviving to adulthood.

netsybetsy · 21/09/2020 09:01

I think this could be an interesting discussion. I don't have kids (choice) so maybe less triggered, I don't know.

For my part, I have no business telling other women how many kids they should have at all and wouldn't presume to.

I imagine most parents have thought about all sorts of ramifications before they have kids. Even if they haven't, why should they when it's such a strong biological urge?

I have my own personal reasons for not believing it would be worth having kids.

I don't know if someone has stats on this but isn't it the case that disasters and war cause the birth rate to go UP rather than down?

Swipe left for the next trending thread