Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are still having kids?

688 replies

Tobythecat · 20/09/2020 19:21

I understand that the urge to reproduce is very strong, but the future looks incredibly bleak (I'm not talking about just covid, but also climate change). I fear for the future and what sort of quality of life people will have, considering Automation/competition over jobs, climate change issues (food/water shortages, extreme weather). Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? Children today will face unimagineable suffering in the next 20-30 years, how can you justify it to them? I wanted children desperately but decided not to because of the above, plus genetic factors.

People mention the war and how people kept having kids, but the threats we face have never been faced before and are multifaceted. Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?

OP posts:
pigsDOfly · 21/09/2020 12:40

Children today will face unimaginable suffering in the next 20-30 years

Goodness, what on earth is going to happen to them.

Can you clarify that statement?

And where exactly are you getting that information from.

Disasters come and go. Times get bad, improve, get bad again; it's the human condition.

No one knows what the future holds.

I imagine people thought things where pretty bad after the war but things improved.

Thousands of people who had lived through hell in concentration camps survived to rebuild their lives, some of them to start success businesses, get married, have children.

We are driven by instinct as human being to keep moving forward, to have children, to keep trying and striving.

Of course people go on having children it's what we're programmed to do.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 12:39

Super. Glad you know all about it with your one and a half degrees. It wasn't clear you knew anything at all about it by your previous posts. Glad you cleared that up by providing your academic qualifications 😉

Confused I was trying to clarify for you, as you wrongly assumed that I "don't like having difficult" conversations. But, since you're so convinced you're right that you just brush off what anyone who doesn't agree with your opinion, then I can't really help you 🤷‍♀️.

And it'll soon be two and a half thank you very much 😜.

Have a nice life.

BiBabbles · 21/09/2020 12:21

Life contains suffering for any species, that doesn't mean suffering is the purpose. It's just a consequence of it, like getting wet from standing in the rain. While people have debated the purpose for decades, and I'm generally under the 'the purpose is to choose and carry out purpose,, some of the current research on what most people think makes a good life includes: choosing and having meaning in life, mentally rich and interesting, and pleasure alongside (preferably greater than) the pain. For some, children are part of all of these, some - with and without children - work towards those in other ways.

I don't see the benefit in being angry at my parents for my existing or wishing I hadn't been born. Part of coping with trauma is accepting reality and move past wishing it away. I grew up knowing I was a daughter unwanted by my mother, told from my earliest days that I only exist because abortion wasn't accessible or acceptable. Generally I take the neutral idea that there is nothing I can ever do to make up to my mother what was done to her, and there is nothing she can do to make up what was done to me. Non-existence isn't automatically worse than existence, but people who go on that we shouldn't exist because 'humans are bad' and that to think anything good can come from us is 'fantasy' just remind me of my mother who used to say I should kill myself to unburden everyone and to not do so just proved I didn't have real feelings. I learned to tune out such extreme views young.

Humans will eventually go extinct, but I don't get saying 'what makes our species so special' and then listing off special-if-terrible things some humans have done as if cruelty and destruction for destruction sake exists in no other species. Just because they're less capable of it doesn't make us special. We can go on about how terrible we are, self-flagellating dramatically, or we can get on with our unchosen existence by choosing to use our capabilities until the end.

On a objective-ish access to resources level, I have not yet reached the quality of life my parents had at my age, and I likely never will be able to have the quality of life my father has now working in finance and tech. This is partially by circumstances and partially by choice. My mother doesn't have the quality of life her parents had, partially by circumstances and partially by choice and this was true of far more of her generation than I think is commonly talked about. My grandparents were mostly okay for their time, but the relatives I know beyond them were all born subsistence farmers, many of them traveling thousands of miles just as I did but under far worse conditions.

My quality of life is better than theirs, and likely so will my children's which was my great-grandmother's desire when she got out. I'm not trying to compete with my parents, I do not view them as a standard, but looking at my family line, quality of life has meant a lot of different things for my great-grandmother, it was never having to grow her own food or kill a chicken with her own hands again, some people today think that's the height of a quality life and the wider socially incentivized ideas of what a quality life is are going to continue to change. I don't think any one person's kid is going to save the world, but we'll have to go through the population bulge one way or the other and far more of our overpopulation issues are in increased longevity rather than birth end which is already below replacement in the UK and several others parts of the world and heading that way for the Earth as a whole in 30-40 years.

aSofaNearYou · 21/09/2020 11:47

Tbh besides issues like overpopulation (which is not yet widely regarded as something people have an individual responsibility to curb) I really don't understand why anyone would think this is the worst or bleakest time in history to live through. People have dealt with far worse and continued to have children. Would you rather they were married off at twelve to pop out ten kids and then die at 25 of dysentery? Or be brutally killed for a petty crime or during a religious rebellion?

The reality is people have always had children despite the hardships of the world because for most people, the world they live in is just how it is, and the majority of us would rather live through what we are currently living through than never have been born. People obviously think the same about potential children.

OliviaBenson · 21/09/2020 11:45

[quote Emmnooo]@Tobythecat The reason why you posted this thread isn’t really to find out why people are having children in the face of adversity. The reason you have posted it is to make people who have children or considering them feel bad because clearly you aren’t happy with your situation . Your post is a projection , it isn’t a real question.
Why do you think people still have children or want a family with their loved one
@Tobythecat
? Even in the face of war, pandemics, climate change? Are you very happy you don’t have children given the situation @Tobythecat?[/quote]
I'm not sure it's the op who is projecting here to be honest.....

GreatMindsThinkAlike · 21/09/2020 11:42

@Everyonesmama Thanks for wishing me luck. What a lovely gesture 😉

Kazakaren · 21/09/2020 11:39

Also do you really think everyone deciding to not have children tomorrow is going to solve all of the worlds problems ?

From an environmental point of view, it would go a long way towards it.

One of the key things for humanity to survive and to evolve is the concept of hope and continuity

Why does humanity need to survive and evolve?

Maybe you want all humanity to die out then what’s the point of you continuing to live with your strain on the earth ,the universe?

The op is not having children. So her strain won't be continuing.

Emmnooo · 21/09/2020 11:31

Also do you really think everyone deciding to not have children tomorrow is going to solve all of the worlds problems ?
One of the key things for humanity to survive and to evolve is the concept of hope and continuity .
Maybe you want all humanity to die out then what’s the point of you continuing to live with your strain on the earth ,the universe?
Do you honestly not get why people continue to have children @Tobythecat?

Emmnooo · 21/09/2020 11:28

@Tobythecat The reason why you posted this thread isn’t really to find out why people are having children in the face of adversity. The reason you have posted it is to make people who have children or considering them feel bad because clearly you aren’t happy with your situation . Your post is a projection , it isn’t a real question.
Why do you think people still have children or want a family with their loved one @Tobythecat? Even in the face of war, pandemics, climate change? Are you very happy you don’t have children given the situation @Tobythecat?

everyonesmama · 21/09/2020 10:37

@GreatMindsThinkAlike

If I have children, I've decided I'll adopt. There are so many children who need a good home and then I can't be blamed for bringing them into this shitty world.
Wishing you luck with that! If you think becoming an adoptive parent is simply your decision or an easy journey you are sdaly mistaken.

There are lots of children needing homes - True
There are also lots of people who could provide good homes who cannot jump every hurdle!

Enrico · 21/09/2020 10:34

So much of this 'argument' is based on false equivalencies. Having children isn't a leisure or consumer activity so equating it to either betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of the boundaries of your own argument.

LadyH846 · 21/09/2020 10:33

@neversayalways

You can't deny that in becoming the top species

Top species? I dunno, grass is doing pretty well.

Well we don't have too many predators. That's what I mean by top species.
Kazakaren · 21/09/2020 10:32

if we don't all fall all over the place catastrophising and wishing we'd never been born or had children yada yada, we must not know anything about the subject confused. Nope, sorry.

Super. Glad you know all about it with your one and a half degrees. It wasn't clear you knew anything at all about it by your previous posts. Glad you cleared that up by providing your academic qualifications 😉

NotBehindTheRadiatorPlease · 21/09/2020 10:31

Every generation has faced some kind of hardship/looming crisis. Yes, more jobs will be automated in the future, but that doesn't mean more jobs won't be created. 20/30 years isn't that far away, most of us posting will likely still be around. So were our parents wrong to have us?

You cannot predict what will happen in the future. I think you're being more than a little hysterical, and it was very poor form to post this on a forum that is overwhelmingly made up of people who are already parents.

neversayalways · 21/09/2020 10:31

You can't deny that in becoming the top species

Top species? I dunno, grass is doing pretty well.

neversayalways · 21/09/2020 10:30

It’s not him (Trump) as a baby that was the problem, it’s the millions of idiots who voted for him as adults. (as it is with Johnson)

Neat illustration of exactly why people keep voting the way the left don't want them to.

neversayalways · 21/09/2020 10:27

Well I do think it's true, this planet would be better off without us
But, we're here. A mass suicide pact isn't really the way forward

Grin
walking · 21/09/2020 10:27

[quote SleepingStandingUp]@walking did you actually just say people with Down Syndrome don't think? And that having Downs Syndrome is kinda an enviable position to be in??[/quote]
The poster I responded to said that people with Downs syndrome can have great lives. I agree. My putting 'think' in '', and the rest of the sentence, should indicate the meaning of what I wrote: that few people who have lesser 'comprehension' (not sure of the correct clinical word) have the mental capacity to think about/act on/worry about/be frightened about the state of the world and its development over the next 10-20-30-40 years.

neversayalways · 21/09/2020 10:26

The baby boom after WW2 is often attributed to parents holding off having babies during the depression and then the war

I thought it was because so many young men were not physically around to be procreating as they were fighting in the war? Then they came back and started shagging again.

LadyH846 · 21/09/2020 10:24

@ReeseWitherfork

I don't mean stop having children. You may not but that is quite clearly what OP means.

And you did say this: I still think it would be a better place without the human race. Confused

Well I do think it's true, this planet would be better off without us.

But, we're here. A mass suicide pact isn't really the way forward.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 10:23

[quote ChelseaDaggers]@Kazakaren Confused, what about my responses makes you think I have not given this serious thought? I am arguably better educated on this subject than your average person. I have one degree relating to it and...ok only half of another degree relating to it, because I switched courses.

Also, should have said experts agree is unlikely to happen in my previous post. Obviously nobody knows what will happen to an individual throughout the course of their life.[/quote]
Sorry, in case I wasn't clear here; I have given it considerable thought and I disagree with you and the op.

This is why this thread has irked me somewhat. Everyone assumes if we don't all fall all over the place catastrophising and wishing we'd never been born or had children yada yada, we must not know anything about the subject Confused. Nope, sorry.

unmarkedbythat · 21/09/2020 10:23

I have three children and I know this is the worst possible thing I could have done for the environment. I do, fairly often, think about why on earth I brought children into a world facing the issues we are. I do recognise that by having three, I have wiped out the years and years of refusing to engage in unnecessary air travel, not eating meat, recycling, not driving, etc. My carbon footprint is unforgivable large and that is entirely due to having three dc.

When I had my first, I was 24, I had a lot more optimism and less dread. I had a second because I didn't want an only. I had my third because he was totally unplanned and as soon as I knew I was pregnant I knew I couldn't abort. I have aborted in the past, I definitely would abort if I ever became pregnant again, if you look at it with any logic at all I should have aborted then. But I didn't. I had him and I can't regret him at all.

To be honest, as time passes and things seem worse and worse and I have less and less hope for humanity's future, I have started to be glad I had three- if life gets as atrociously hard for humans as I fear, at least they have each other. That's not logical or sensible at all, is it? But it's how I feel.

StoneofDestiny · 21/09/2020 10:22

Can you imagine? Someone once thought it was a good idea to bring Trump into the world. Maybe he was cute as a baby

It’s not him as a baby that was the problem, it’s the millions of idiots who voted for him as adults. (as it is with Johnson)

SleepingStandingUp · 21/09/2020 10:22

@walking did you actually just say people with Down Syndrome don't think? And that having Downs Syndrome is kinda an enviable position to be in??

LadyH846 · 21/09/2020 10:21

@RegularHumanBartender

We've done a lot of shitty things to this planet though. I still think it would be a better place without the human race

I agree. I never understand why it is said with such horror "What if humans die out". So what if we do? We aren't special, just because we like to think that we are! We are the species that have utterly ruined the planet for all the thousands of others that call it home.

We definitely aren't special. Unless you mean especially destructive