Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are still having kids?

688 replies

Tobythecat · 20/09/2020 19:21

I understand that the urge to reproduce is very strong, but the future looks incredibly bleak (I'm not talking about just covid, but also climate change). I fear for the future and what sort of quality of life people will have, considering Automation/competition over jobs, climate change issues (food/water shortages, extreme weather). Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? Children today will face unimagineable suffering in the next 20-30 years, how can you justify it to them? I wanted children desperately but decided not to because of the above, plus genetic factors.

People mention the war and how people kept having kids, but the threats we face have never been faced before and are multifaceted. Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?

OP posts:
Reearry · 21/09/2020 14:07

www.npr.org/2016/08/18/479349760/should-we-be-having-kids-in-the-age-of-climate-change

Please read the article above. It discusses and refutes all the arguments by people who say we have lived through worse or are recycling etc
Some extracts from the article -

"cites a study from 2010 that looked at the impact of demographic change on global carbon emissions. It found that slowing population growth could eliminate one-fifth to one-quarter of all the carbon emissions that need to be cut by midcentury to avoid that potentially catastrophic tipping point."

"no amount of conservation gives you a pass. Oregon State University researchers have calculated the savings from all kinds of conservation measures: driving a hybrid, driving less, recycling, using energy-efficient appliances, windows and light bulbs.

For an American, the total metric tons of carbon dioxide saved by all of those measures over an entire lifetime of 80 years: 488. By contrast, the metric tons saved when a person chooses to have one fewer child: 9,441."

Another student asks: "What happens if that kid you decided not to have would have been the person who grew up and essentially cured this?"

Again, great question, says Rieder, but the answer is still no. First, the chances are slim. More to the point, he says, valuing children as a means to an end — be it to cure climate change or, say, provide soldiers for the state — is ethically problematic.

With all that's at stake, he says, we need to shift our cultural attitudes. "It's not the childless who must justify their lifestyle. It's the rest of us."

MarthasGinYard · 21/09/2020 14:06

'I must admit that I’ve found women planning to conceive in the middle of a pandemic hard to fathom.
I mean up to them but I wouldn’t want to be pregnant or labour in these circumstances - which are going to get much worse during the winter months.
And I definitely wouldn’t want to have a new born with no mixing in households.'

Couldn't agree more TBH

sharpeidiem · 21/09/2020 14:03

@HelloMissus

I must admit that I’ve found women planning to conceive in the middle of a pandemic hard to fathom. I mean up to them but I wouldn’t want to be pregnant or labour in these circumstances - which are going to get much worse during the winter months. And I definitely wouldn’t want to have a new born with no mixing in households.
It's not clear when the pandemic will end though - some people are on their last legs in terms of a biological time frame for having children. Plus, I guess there's an element of having more sex as for a long time nobody could leave the house (also possibly stopped people from buying birth control or similar). Maybe it also gives some people a sense of "you never know what's going to happen" which gives them a push to prioritise having children.
HelloMissus · 21/09/2020 14:00

I must admit that I’ve found women planning to conceive in the middle of a pandemic hard to fathom.
I mean up to them but I wouldn’t want to be pregnant or labour in these circumstances - which are going to get much worse during the winter months.
And I definitely wouldn’t want to have a new born with no mixing in households.

unmarkedbythat · 21/09/2020 13:56

But we're unlikely to see an apocalypse in the next 30 years. There are actually plenty of resources for everyone, we just need to be less wastefull and distribute them more fairly.

True, but so much as suggest on here that it is a poor use of resources to fly abroad for a holiday every year and see what reaction you get. People are unwilling to compromise. They like to talk about needing to take action on the environment, but ask them to give up their car, big house, foreign holidays, etc, and they balk. Suggest that as a planet we consume less meat and dairy and the response isn't great. They want action as long as they don't have to take it themselves. That is why other people feel so very bleak about the future.

Emmnooo · 21/09/2020 13:53

But I would never question a persons decision not to have them or criticize them as why would I?

Emmnooo · 21/09/2020 13:49

We live in a passive house , grow our own veg and fruit and try to live as self sufficiency as possible. We have planted hundreds of oak trees in the last few years on our land, our kids have done this with us. A drop in the ocean obviously but I have no doubt they’ll continue to do good work when we are gone.
There will always be adversity and challenges but I’m not in despair about the future for my children.

Having children and them being in our lives has been the most unbelievably rewarding experience of our lives. When they were born I had a glimpse of paradise , yes it might sound corny to someone else but that’s how it felt to me.

For now they wake up everyday happy and look forward to everything , being around that now is very uplifting
There’s also the concept of enjoying the now. Of course everything could get worse, of course bad things are happening all the time and we each have a part to mitigate that. This generalization of “people just have kids as that’s expected etc without thought etc” is just that , a generalization. Some people yes but lots like me and dh wanted a family , had children because we adore them and know we can give them a good life.
I know on my death bed my memories will be of my childhood and of my children and I don’t regret a moment with them. I have never felt love like the love I have with my children , a totally intangible thing and I wouldn’t have felt it without them. It’s not always a logical thing to have kids, there’s no one simple answer to why plp would have them in a less than ideal world.

sharpeidiem · 21/09/2020 13:43

@LadyH846 For me personally, the only times when I thought I wouldn't have kids was because I wouldn't let myself have them (rather than I didn't want them). For reasons similar, e.g. they are guaranteed to experience pain, they may have some genetic MH conditions, I'm worried about the cyclical hereditary abuse.

But as soon as my MH improved and I dealt with my trauma, I managed to actually experience joy in contrast with my pain. It made me realise that even through all the bollocks and horrible life events I experienced, I would still rather be alive. I guess I also benefit from some of the ego surrounding the theory of: "I'll be a better parent than my parents were."

I think being a parent is an individual choice. Those who don't want children, who can't support children or value other factors more (freedom, or the environment in this example, providing having less kids makes a big enough dent in our climate change issues) shouldn't have or feel pressured to have kids. It's a similar situation for those who DO want kids.

But honestly -- I think everyone here is overlooking the privilege of the choice. It is a million times harder to be a woman in a country without contraception or sex education to decide not to have kids. It is also a million times harder to be a woman who desperately wants children but cannot have them for health or other reasons. Those of us who are fortunate to have the choice should just respect other people's decisions and work to support those who are struggling in relation to fertility.

Sorry, big tangent.

LadyH846 · 21/09/2020 13:31

@sharpeidiem

To everyone here who is against having kids for environmental reasons, have you ever wanted children?

I'm not trying to be divisive, I'm just aware that when I was younger and more emotionally vulnerable from the things that happened to me, I too had the thought of; "bringing kids into the world can be cruel." Turns out I needed a bit of Sertraline in my system and then I was fine (now I actively would like kids in the near future, though that's unrelated).

Not insinuating that's anyone else's situation, but I would be curious to see if health reasons or anything other than environmental reasons comes into it.

That's interesting, for me it's the opposite.

I take an antidepressant which makes me feel pretty great.

I start thinking about having children when my mental health goes down the pan...I don't know why, but for me it's a sign I'm unwell. I don't want children when I'm feeling mentally well.

Every month I do feel a desire to have a baby for a few days when I'm ovulating but it passes.

My main reason for not wanting them is that I don't want the responsibility and also life hasn't been that rosy for many people I know so I can assume that my future kids (if I had them) would encounter challenges too. I don't want the potential heartbreak of what could go wrong. I'd rather just uncomplicate my own future. I was born into a family that has been hit by one tragedy after another over the years so it makes me wary.

oblada · 21/09/2020 13:27

Right now my kids have a pretty cool life and so do I, with them by my side. If we all die tomorrow we will still have had a fantastic time together and it makes it worth it. Of course I hope to have many years with them still.
If some are choosing not to have children for "environmental" reasons - great - more space for my family!

SallySeven · 21/09/2020 13:21

The posters here lobbying for women in the west to stop having children would appear to me like gnats pushing the oil tanker in the direction it's going already! Do you not follow demographic trends?

Sad people.

aSofaNearYou · 21/09/2020 13:19

I don't agree. We never got a choice to be born did we? Can most of us really say for sure that we'd definitely prefer to be alive as opposed to not alive? Life can be shit for a lot of people, and has been shit for most people historically.

I'm not sure what to say to that really. Life is shit for a lot of people yes and obviously some people are suicidal, but I do think that it is fairly safe to say that a majority of people, given the option of living in today's world or never having existed, would rather have lived. Especially if the only factors they take into consideration for why they might prefer to be dead are things that are specifically caused by being alive today rather than at a different time in history.

Itsabeautifuldayheyhey · 21/09/2020 13:18

MENU
@Tobythecat

"the urge to reproduce is very strong"
"the future looks incredibly bleak"
I fear for the future
"Children today will face unimagineable suffering"
"I wanted children desperately"
"Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?"

What's with all the superlatives? I think you might need some help for anxiety if you regularly think in such terms. It all sounds OTT to me.

sharpeidiem · 21/09/2020 13:13

To everyone here who is against having kids for environmental reasons, have you ever wanted children?

I'm not trying to be divisive, I'm just aware that when I was younger and more emotionally vulnerable from the things that happened to me, I too had the thought of; "bringing kids into the world can be cruel." Turns out I needed a bit of Sertraline in my system and then I was fine (now I actively would like kids in the near future, though that's unrelated).

Not insinuating that's anyone else's situation, but I would be curious to see if health reasons or anything other than environmental reasons comes into it.

Alabamawhirly1 · 21/09/2020 13:11

The way some people are talking you would think we were all living is Mao's China, or a village in the third world where we have no health care, education and have to walk 10 miles to a disease filled puddle for water every day.

Where I live, England, we have a pretty comfortable existence. To say kids are and will face unimaginable suffering and would rather not have been born - is more than a bit dramatic.

We don't know what the future will hold. But we're unlikely to see an apocalypse in the next 30 years. There are actually plenty of resources for everyone, we just need to be less wastefull and distribute them more fairly.

I don't think many people wish they hadn't been born because we've damaged the environment. If you do feel like that you've probably got some issues that need addressing. Most of us are generally happy. We had kids to share and extend that happiness and take great joy from our kids. And isn't that the point of life? Just to be happy and share that happiness. If that's by having kids, have them, if not, don't.

We can live in harmony with the planet. It's not like the only option is human race or happy natural world. Just because we are currently fucking up the planet doesn't mean we can't live without doing it.

Abouttimemum · 21/09/2020 13:04

Well it’s all just fucking pointless anyway though - we exist to continue existing.
We’re all just a tiny speck of dust in an infinite universe, in which the earth will implode one day.
Which is why I have no idea why people give so many fucks about what other people look like, or believe in, or what Sandra had for tea or why Brian’s all of sudden wearing skinny jeans and flip flops.

Utterly matterless. Focus on yourself and the ones you love.

Ref OP I do agree actually, and I often feel guilty about having DS, and what his future will be like, and how he’ll manage on his own. But it’s too late now, so I need to try to give him all the tools he needs to get by.

unmarkedbythat · 21/09/2020 13:04

@neversayalways

It’s not him (Trump) as a baby that was the problem, it’s the millions of idiots who voted for him as adults. (as it is with Johnson)

Neat illustration of exactly why people keep voting the way the left don't want them to.

What, because mean and nasty people say they are idiots? Just proving the meanies right then, aren't they, if they will vote against their own interests as part of a tantrum about being called an idiot Grin
ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 13:01

Oh god, I've just seen a username I refuse to converse with. I am out. Bye! Enjoy your apocalypse porn session everyone.

Cheekyfox · 21/09/2020 12:59

OP- your in the wrong forum sweety.... I think you might want to head over to the child free subreddit 😂

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 12:59

I don't agree. We never got a choice to be born did we? Can most of us really say for sure that we'd definitely prefer to be alive as opposed to not alive? Life can be shit for a lot of people, and has been very shit for most people historically.

Just a little aside re this; this is the original argument for antinatalism, which began at least as early as the ancient greeks. It is an ideology / philosophy, which has been around for thousands of years. It isn't something I agree with personally, but the argument has been around for a very long time. I find it very interesting, (even if nobody else does), how people come up with the same arguments for and against something, centuries apart.

I also find the threat of constant agony which is usually predicted by people on threads like these, (not usually by actual scientists), reminiscent of religious dogma in days gone by. Same threat, different reason.

lynsey91 · 21/09/2020 12:58

I guess a huge amount of women have children simply because they want children and never really think beyond that.

I know numerous couples who didn't even discuss if they wanted children or not but just had them because apparently "it is what you do"!

So with the numbers that just blindly have them regardless of what sort of life they can give them, whether they can afford them etc and the large number of "accidents" it's easy to see why so many have children.

Humans have totally fucked up the planet and, to be honest, I think we deserve to die out.

I don't have children by choice and I am so glad of that. It means I don't have to worry about their futures. Climate change is real and is going to get worse. It's probably too late to stop it or even change the outcome much.

Rising sea levels, food and water shortages. My what a great future to look forward to.

Mind you if we kill off all the bees as we have killed off so many species of animals, insects, plants etc we will die out anyway

MsTSwift · 21/09/2020 12:56

Agree with pigs. Life has been pretty bloody awful for the non aristocratic majority for hundreds of years - read your history. Only since the 1960s onwards have we had it this good. Imagine being an ordinary person in the 13th century or even Victorian times. Pretty bloody awful. What was the quote about the life of the average British person “nasty brutish and short”.

Emmnooo · 21/09/2020 12:55

@BiBabbles, really great post!

LadyH846 · 21/09/2020 12:47

@aSofaNearYou

Tbh besides issues like overpopulation (which is not yet widely regarded as something people have an individual responsibility to curb) I really don't understand why anyone would think this is the worst or bleakest time in history to live through. People have dealt with far worse and continued to have children. Would you rather they were married off at twelve to pop out ten kids and then die at 25 of dysentery? Or be brutally killed for a petty crime or during a religious rebellion?

The reality is people have always had children despite the hardships of the world because for most people, the world they live in is just how it is, and the majority of us would rather live through what we are currently living through than never have been born. People obviously think the same about potential children.

the majority of us would rather live through what we are currently living through than never have been born.

I don't agree. We never got a choice to be born did we? Can most of us really say for sure that we'd definitely prefer to be alive as opposed to not alive? Life can be shit for a lot of people, and has been very shit for most people historically.

The fact is, many pregnancies happen by accident and we just end up here through no choice of our own.

ChelseaDaggers · 21/09/2020 12:44

What anyone says if they don't agree with your opinion*