Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are still having kids?

688 replies

Tobythecat · 20/09/2020 19:21

I understand that the urge to reproduce is very strong, but the future looks incredibly bleak (I'm not talking about just covid, but also climate change). I fear for the future and what sort of quality of life people will have, considering Automation/competition over jobs, climate change issues (food/water shortages, extreme weather). Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? Children today will face unimagineable suffering in the next 20-30 years, how can you justify it to them? I wanted children desperately but decided not to because of the above, plus genetic factors.

People mention the war and how people kept having kids, but the threats we face have never been faced before and are multifaceted. Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?

OP posts:
UnshakenNeedsStirring · 20/09/2020 20:31

You are right OP. The future is grim :(
If I was deciding now, I wouldnt have any kids. No point bringing them in such a hostile world.

thecognoscenti · 20/09/2020 20:30

I don't think there's much to be gained from pretending that the ecological situation isn't absolutely dire.
Yeah it's upsetting and not nice - doesn't mean it's not true.
People throwing their toys out of the pram about how the OP is saying things which aren't all sunshine and positivity are burying their heads, unfortunately.

IHateCoronavirus · 20/09/2020 20:30

The love I share with my family is amazing. My eldest, so far, has had 5497 days of pure love and support, laughter, happiness, new experiences.
Yes, one day life might be tough, and he may suffer, the thought terrifies me, but the idea that I would have deprived him of what he has had, based on what might be, I find very sad.

WellThisWentWell · 20/09/2020 20:29

YANBU.
I agree with you.
In my 30’s childfree by choice.

SomewhereEast · 20/09/2020 20:29

@OhCaptain

I remember 20 years ago people saying by 2020 the world would be over

Have you been awake for this year? Grin

Joking aside, isn't it something like 100 corporations who produce 71% of emissions? Those are the changes we need to focus on. Not people reproducing.

Oohhh and just in case anyone mentions Covid, I'm going to put my history PhD hat on and say that Covid isn't even in the top ten thousand Bad Things Which Have Happened To Humanity.
Hardbackwriter · 20/09/2020 20:28

@DilloDaf

Why did people in the 17th century have kids when the life expectancy was 35, and disease was rife?

Because 17c women didn't have the luxury of choosing whether or not to have children.
Some posters seem to think reliable contraception has existed for hundreds of years Grin.

Contraception as reliable as we have now hasn't always existed but the concept of contraception always has. The average American woman had 7 children in 1800 but 2.5 in 1900 - do you really think that people weren't doing anything to influence that? Contraception and abortion were both known about and practised in the 1700s, not with modern levels of efficacy (and with a lot more danger, for the abortions) but people have always known that there are things you can do to make having a baby much less likely.
tempnamechange98765 · 20/09/2020 20:26

@Bunkumum actually laughing out loud at your answer!

In answer to the OP, um because no one has a crystal ball? The world could end tomorrow or it could end up being AMAZING in 10, 20 or 30 years time. What a ridiculously negative thread.

SomewhereEast · 20/09/2020 20:26

I'm genuinely fascinated how anyone who views humans, including presumably themselves, as "parasites" gets by on a day to day basis? Like, do you have friends? Does your SO know you fundamentally think they're a parasite and the world would be a better place without them / you? That must be a bit of a romance killer, no? If someone shares a pic of their new baby on Facebook does a little voice in your head bellow "Not another planet-destroying parasite doomed to live in a world aflame!!!"

Thenneverendingstorohree · 20/09/2020 20:23

I don't think my children will face unimaginable suffering or I wouldn't have had them, obviously. I presume the majority of people, who do have children, feel the same (and those who would have children if they were able to).

Your position, from my experience, is an extreme minority one.

Choosingmyring · 20/09/2020 20:23

I bet you’re fun at parties OP! Grin

x2boys · 20/09/2020 20:23

Because there have always been risks ,you mention the war ,I can't imagine my grandparents thought it was a great time to have kids during WW2 yet they did and my mum was born in 1942 ,it's life

Nottherealslimshady · 20/09/2020 20:22

Otherwise only people who didnt care would have children and their children wouldn't help the planet. We need to improve our species and we do this through our children. I hope my child will have a positive impact on our planet.

Puffalicious · 20/09/2020 20:21

Puffaliciousyou've come onto the OP's thread... to tell the OP to go away? Interesting choice.

Yes, I have, because the OP has come onto a parenting site to goad parents about becoming parents based on their own prejudices and personal issues. I have the right to express my opinion and my opinion is that the OP remove their sanctimonious self before others are upset. That okay with you, thread police?

newnameforthis123 · 20/09/2020 20:20

Part biological urge, part societal expectation.

As an adopted child (well, adult now) I do wish more people would consider adoption of children who already exist but don't have a safe, forever home. But I appreciate I'm biased on that and it's a difficult journey that isn't for everyone.

OhCaptain · 20/09/2020 20:20

*though over population is a problem, too. No denying it.

OhCaptain · 20/09/2020 20:19

I remember 20 years ago people saying by 2020 the world would be over

Have you been awake for this year? Grin

Joking aside, isn't it something like 100 corporations who produce 71% of emissions? Those are the changes we need to focus on. Not people reproducing.

Aloethere · 20/09/2020 20:17

Your posts are really sad OP. I'm sorry you feel this way. I hope you can find some support to help you realise that life can be great.

OhCaptain · 20/09/2020 20:17

The thing is, there are plenty of children in the world already living in unimaginable suffering.

And you're absolutely right that the effect of climate change will be catastrophic. Sadly, the countries that will feel this the most don't tend to have access to sex education and healthcare that we do.

In short, your western children should predominantly be ok.

You're not wrong though about it not being a bad thing for the human race to die out. We are parasitical and have destroyed the planet.

But I think even knowing that it's not something people would ordinarily take into consideration for day to day life, if you see what I mean.

Jemima down the road isn't going to decide not to sprog because the planet is on fire, for example.

I'm sure the best thing for the earth would be if every person living on it decided to stop breeding. But that's never going to happen. So we'll adapt as lots of parasites do.

ScarMatty · 20/09/2020 20:16

What a depressing thread.

Alabamawhirly1 · 20/09/2020 20:16

Wow, I bet you're fun at a dinner party.

Some of us arnt all doom and gloom and just live in the now.

There is a chance there won't be "unimaginable suffering" and actually things will just work out OK.

majesticallyawkward · 20/09/2020 20:16

Climate change, pandemics, recessions are not new. New generations bring change, who are you to declare we're all doomed? Perhaps Covid will be catalyst for a period of rapid change (the period post- Black Death did) and these things will become more of a priority globally. I'm pretty sure during all other the other big events there were people screaming hysterically about the end of the world just like the OP and here we all are.

We just don't know what will happen, climate change can still be pulled back. The children born now could do amazing things for humans, our planet and the animals on it. They could even be the generation to start colonies on other planets.

However all that said, I do think more people should stop and think about the consequences of their actions before choosing to have larger families.

JumpingJamboree · 20/09/2020 20:16

It is a concern about the future but I just see it as things will have to change if we want to avoid extinction by climate change etc and I am pretty sure no leaders in this world want that to happen, even Trump, so they are taking/will take the necessary steps to stop it from happening by banning plastics, more electric cars, more eco friendly electricity, clean air initiatives etc.

However, I think it is very weird for people to judge others based on the fact they have decided to have/not have children. If no one reproduced for fear of the future, we would all go extinct anyway!

SomewhereEast · 20/09/2020 20:16

I'm a historian by training (left academia a while back as the workload is crazy), who specialized in early 20th century Europe. I'm honestly a bit baffled by this weird secular End Times narrative so many of us are buying into right now. If you really want to pick a time & place when people should've thought twice about reproducing, then I give you continental Europe in the 1890s, particularly Central & Eastern Europe, which is ironic, in that the 1890s themselves probably felt like a pretty good decade to have children. Yet that generation lived through / died in two vicious World Wars, Spanish Flu, the Holocaust & other assorted campaigns of ethnic cleansing, communist dictatorships, fascist dictatorships etc etc. Some lucky countries got a bit of extra misery for good measure - the Ukrainians really lucked out with a Famine and Chernobyl on top of everything else (tangent but if you really want to read about all this, than Timothy Snyder's Bloodlands is a good start). And that's just Europe....Cambodia, China, Korea, Vietnam & most of Africa had pretty 'fun' 20th centuries too. On the other hand, when I was born in Ireland at the end of the 70s we had a shattered economy, mass emigration, huge unemployment, a savage civil war raging in part of our island and the whole specter-of-nuclear-war thing, yet the 90s brought unimagined change and we ended up being probably the most fortunate generation in the entire history of our country. We don't really know quite what the future holds, but humanity has muddled through all sorts of horrors and somehow kept creating art and falling in love and raising children and celebrating milestones and all the rest. Yes I know people will say "but Climate Change could wipe half us out", but then so could nuclear war, and everyone born between the 50s and the 80s lived under that shadow. Even Chernobyl could have actually been much much worse.

Wakemeupwhenthisisover · 20/09/2020 20:15

@Tobythecat

Calm down OP no one knows what’s going to happen, I remember 20 years ago people saying by 2020 the world would be over ect due to go along warming, I reckon in 30 years things will worse than now (to what extent we can’t know) but not apocalyptic.

Ishihtzuknot · 20/09/2020 20:15

Who are you to judge what other people do. At the end of the day we have to carry on. The next generation could fix so much that the past generations caused I think it’s important to keep having children. Where would we be if we stopped producing? Let humans die out because you don’t agree with it? I have two elder children before you presume I’m a baby making machine.
I understand where you are coming from, but as you said yourself people carried on during the war and most of us wouldn’t exist if they hadn’t. It doesn’t make you superior because you chose not to have children, I’m sure your carbon footprint could be lowered.
I’m a ‘glass is half full’ person and live with positivity that the world can improve, that we can’t just stop living our lives on the chance the world will crash, try it you might enjoy it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread