Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are still having kids?

688 replies

Tobythecat · 20/09/2020 19:21

I understand that the urge to reproduce is very strong, but the future looks incredibly bleak (I'm not talking about just covid, but also climate change). I fear for the future and what sort of quality of life people will have, considering Automation/competition over jobs, climate change issues (food/water shortages, extreme weather). Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? Children today will face unimagineable suffering in the next 20-30 years, how can you justify it to them? I wanted children desperately but decided not to because of the above, plus genetic factors.

People mention the war and how people kept having kids, but the threats we face have never been faced before and are multifaceted. Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?

OP posts:
Aerial2020 · 22/09/2020 17:15

Have you posted the same on dadsnet?

India999 · 22/09/2020 17:01

Bloody hell

Alabamawhirly1 · 22/09/2020 16:53

@lynsey91 - but you're admitting that climate change was just a factor and you woulndt have had them anyway. I was clearly referring to people who say climate change / the future of mankind is their only reason for not having children.

So a. Clearly you won't regret not having kids because you obviously don't want them regardless.
B. I would still rather be alive, even if things arnt as great as they were for the previouse post ww2 generations - then not exist. I'm pretty sure most sain people feel the same way.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/09/2020 10:27

@SerenDippitty

Is it so unrealistic to think that jobs are going to get scarce because of IT/AI and automation, and ever more skilled and specialised? Not in the current generation of children’s lifetimes, but their children and grandchildren.
So at what generation should we stop everyone having kids?
MsTSwift · 22/09/2020 09:49

Humans are very resilient. Dh family member fought on the Russian front in WW2 famously hellish. He died recently the most cheerful live life to the full person I’ve evet met. When asked what it was like he would just say “cold”.

aSofaNearYou · 22/09/2020 09:37

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators

Again, none of what you've said makes it seem in any way likely that children will be angry at their parents for having them, even if they broadly agree that decreasing the population is a good idea. I think people on this thread are expecting way too much in terms of people's selfless interest in the environment if they think that a majority of children would genuinely prefer to have never existed so that the environment could be that tiny bit better.

And in terms of the future being so bleak that they would all wish they had never been born, that is when it seems a bit ridiculous when you look back at what children have lived through in the past. This might be the worst time in history in terms of the environment but it certainly isn't in virtually every other way that contributed to quality of life. However bad the environment gets, most people would still rather live in the time they live in that not live at all. I just cannot understand why anyone would expect differently.

MsTSwift · 22/09/2020 09:34

Also you could drive yourself mad - and I speak as someone who is concerned environmentally (try to use train not plane had 2 kids not 3 refillables, reuseable nappies mooncup etc) but probably drop in ocean. But seeing humans as parasites I mean what is the end goal?! A perfect natural deserted planet with no humans?! What’s the point!

Hardbackwriter · 22/09/2020 09:23

ONE of the reasons we chose not to have children was climate change, another was overpopulation but there were a few reasons.

This is completely disingenuous. You post constantly all over MN (which is a separate issue in itself, and appears to be some sort of pathological compulsion) about how awful having children must be and how glad you are you didn't. Pretending that you made some sort of selfless sacrifice by not having children for the wider good of the climate is laughable.

SerenDippitty · 22/09/2020 09:21

Is it so unrealistic to think that jobs are going to get scarce because of IT/AI and automation, and ever more skilled and specialised? Not in the current generation of children’s lifetimes, but their children and grandchildren.

lynsey91 · 22/09/2020 09:16

@Alabamawhirly1 ONE of the reasons we chose not to have children was climate change, another was overpopulation but there were a few reasons.

I won't be kicking myself on my death bed if everything is fine because (a) things may not be that bad by the time I die (b) things are not going to be fine for ever (c) me and DH have no regrets whatsoever choosing not to have children

Quite likely all those who believe everything is going to be rosy will be the ones kicking themselves and possibly long before their deathbed

lynsey91 · 22/09/2020 09:12

@YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators sorry but I would say the majority of women are definitely NOT thinking about climate change when they get pregnant/have children.

In fact, as I said before, it seems many don't think anything other than "I want a baby" or "it's the normal thing to do". Add to that all the "accidents" and where exactly are all the concerned intelligent women actually thinking about the enormity of bringing a child into the world?

When people ask why we chose not to have children (because they are so rude and I have never asked anyone why they chose to have children) we have mentioned climate change and overpopulation as one of the reasons and, almost always, have been met with blank and/or puzzled looks

One neighbour who has 3 children (2 of whom she admits were "accidents") said she had never once thought about her childrens' futures other than seeing herself with grandchildren!

Alabamawhirly1 · 22/09/2020 08:04

All these people not having kids just because of climate change are gonna kick themselves of their death bed of everything turns out to be just fine.

After all, weren't we all gonna die from a hole in the ozone layer a few years ago, and ebola and aids. Wasn't the cotton mill, and the printing press and the automated plow gonna make jobs obsolete.

Call me nieve, but I honestly think we will change our ways if it means total destruction of the earth. We have the ability and the resources to live in harmony with the earth - we just need the will.

But I'm sceptical of anyone that says they're not having any kids purely for environmental reasons. Even op admits she can't have them for genetic reasons - she's just using fear of the future to try and make others feel bad and herself feel better.

squeekums · 22/09/2020 00:57

Those of you who mention people have always had kids even in hard times- women didn't have access to contraception like we do now and they also did not have the rights we do today- women were raped by their husbands etc.
I think today we know better and our reproductive choices should reflect that.
Why should women be told what they should do with their body for the environment? Its our body, our choice. Just like i dont subscribe to the one for mum, one for dad, one for country that the aus government has spouted before, i dont think climate should be used as a thing to tell women YET AGAIN what we should do with our body.
Its a personal CHOICE
Also head rural, access to contraception and abortion isnt as easy as youd think in some parts. Nor is it suitable for all women.
If your so set on women shouldnt have kids, lobby for FREE contraception AND abortion, support FULL sex education in schools.
Dont tell women what they should do with their body
Women are STILL raped by their husbands. So that point is irrelevant and just another one of your big hysterical claims to try sway women. Rape happens kids or not.

Children today will not have the quality of life that their parents had and face a very bleak future

Where is your proof, like actual evidence? My quality of life is better than my parents yet ive grown up through recession of the 90s in Aus, the same doom and gloom climate stuff has been spouted for years, 20 years ago we were as good as told we would be burning up by now, yet here we are

Life and technology evolve, how are you certain that its a bleak future? Your simply not and your just trying to get people to buy into your doom and gloom outlook of the world.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 22/09/2020 00:09

Sofa, OP was born, and since that event (although by no means because of it), the global environment has been in steady decline, chiefly on account of a warming climate. OP, through no fault of her own, will face the consequences of the climate emergency as an adult, and is perhaps generously thinking that her parents, however many decades ago, we're not as aware of pending environmental issues as today's parents are, and therefore does not hold them accountable. Facing said consequences of environmental degradation as an adult is, in OP's own words 'bleak'. But, when I read about crop failures, melting permafrost and civil unrest and all the rest of it, I worry loads more for my DC than I do for myself, because I'm an adult, and they are still kids, and will be kids for a good while longer. OP is asking why parents today continue to have children, and whether "they think that everything will be fine and work itself out", or whether they "just don't think about it"? The way I read it, OP is empathising with the children of the future.

aSofaNearYou · 21/09/2020 23:46

no of course not, I’m saying you obviously don’t think this threat of “unimaginable suffering” is that off-putting either, so why would anybody else?

This is what I'm struggling to get past. It just feels like a very odd argument to me to genuinely expect your children to begrudge you for choosing to have them, because of the impact it had on the environment. I just seriously doubt that very many children who are not suicidal for other reasons would think that way.

Shikamiri · 21/09/2020 23:40

00100001

Unimaginable suffering?? confused

Like what? confused

Dunno, maybe the OP can't imagine it grin

@worraliberty 😂😂😂😂😂😂

Aerial2020 · 21/09/2020 23:38

What are you doing for climate change then OP?
What are you doing for the planet apart from judging parents?
Did you blame your parents for being born?

whatthehellis · 21/09/2020 23:27

Maybe my son will save the world 🤷🏻‍♀️

ChristmasCarcass · 21/09/2020 23:24

Tobythecat no of course not, I’m saying you obviously don’t think this threat of “unimaginable suffering” is that off-putting either, so why would anybody else?

Leobynature · 21/09/2020 23:00

I do understand some if your thinking, life is hard and there are great concerns ahead.
When I think about my children I am hopeful they will have a good life and only the next generation can really make a decision about their suffering and willingness to change The world.

My ancestors were slaves, my grandparents didn’t go to school, my father grew up in great poverty, he experienced hunger and illness. He received a very poor education and struggles to read and write. All his children are degree educated and we do ok financially. We are happy and healthy. I believe my children will never experience this type of suffering and I am pleased each generation of my race excels the next. Thank goodness my ancestors did not stop reproducing.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 21/09/2020 22:59

Reese, I see from your contributions on this thread that you and I are focusing on different things in the OP; you are keen for someone to supply a current source for whether having a child in a western economy is as detrimental to the environment as we have been led to believe, and have repeatedly requested this.
What I see is this bit: "Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? ...how can you justify it to them?". I think OP is asking a much more personal question;
if current climate science is to be believed, kids born now will likely experience the effects of climate change while we, their parents, are still around to answer their questions about how we responded to the opportunity to do something about it. And if this is the question, and if parents and children are already experiencing the impact of climate change in many parts of the world, then the question of whether or not having another kid is detrimental to the environment becomes a moot point, as it is already happening to those of us who are already here, and that's bad enough, whether they're growing up in Bangladesh, Queensland, Chad or on the Norfolk coast.

On a different note, it seems to me that revision of the "one child less" argument relies on factoring in the effects of future government policy to reduce individual emissions. For this to be significant, it implies future restrictions on consumption, travel and use of resources in general, so hardly a 'as you were, crack on!' scenario. I can't decide whether I find this reliance on a change in global governmental policy refreshingly optimistic or touchingly naïve.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/09/2020 22:50

@MoaningMurlock

Excuse we might be birthing the geniuses that figure out how to fix the mess? Or the charismatic leader who takes us in to the new tomorrow?

Or in my case the Antichrist, who is going to make our suffering short.

I have twins, one will solve the needs from the lab and the other will use this solution to take us to a new tomorrow. Your antichrist shall repent and make a triumvirate of goodliness
PinkLegoBrick · 21/09/2020 22:33

The fertility rate is falling rapidly which will improve climate change.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/amp/health-53409521

ReeseWitherfork · 21/09/2020 22:17

That's how it's done these days. People don't know how to discuss and debate anymore.
I’ve really seen no debate. I’m yet to see anyone explain to my why having children is so terrible. Aside from one 10 year old outdated source.

The latest figures (2018) state that the fertility rate in the U.K. is 1.68. Which to note, is a downwards trend (it was 2.6 in 1968). So people are making the decision to have less children; we are not replacing like for like so the population will decrease.

For comparison, the 2018 figures were:
1.88 in France
1.73 in US
1.57 in Germany
1.29 in Italy

The global fertility rate is 2.415, down from 4.922 in 1968. So overall a drop over the 40 years. As the number is above 2, the global population will continue to increase. However, if we extrapolate the trend, this number will eventually fall below 2. And the big point with fertility rates is that they are generally higher in less economically development countries (and vice versa). So economic advancement results in less babies.

If OPs point was: “why does anyone ever have children?” then it comes across slightly hysterical. And as pointed out on the thread, humanity would cease to exist in about 50-80 years. I don’t know whether humanity should exist but a PP claiming to have studied the philosophy of it has suggested she thinks yes. It’s hard to debate as that’s just OPs personal opinion that humanity should end. Surely you can forgive posters for not easily agreeing to be so bleak? Highly emotive subject, hard to debate logically (happy for you to disagree if you can articulate why?)

If the OPs point was: “why don’t people have less children?” then this would be a relatively valid question to which the answer is “we are, see the data”.

And whether having a child is the worst thing you can do for the environment: I’m yet to see anyone mention government policy. The U.K. has a legal requirement to arrive at net zero admissions by 2050. If we succeed then the climate change factor in deciding whether to reproduce becomes null (as long as everyone stays in this country of course; big ask but many other wealthy countries have similar targets).

PablosHoney · 21/09/2020 22:14

So I have I, I don’t agree with the OP but that’s not right at all.