Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are still having kids?

688 replies

Tobythecat · 20/09/2020 19:21

I understand that the urge to reproduce is very strong, but the future looks incredibly bleak (I'm not talking about just covid, but also climate change). I fear for the future and what sort of quality of life people will have, considering Automation/competition over jobs, climate change issues (food/water shortages, extreme weather). Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? Children today will face unimagineable suffering in the next 20-30 years, how can you justify it to them? I wanted children desperately but decided not to because of the above, plus genetic factors.

People mention the war and how people kept having kids, but the threats we face have never been faced before and are multifaceted. Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?

OP posts:
VinylDetective · 20/09/2020 21:55

@CorianderLord

I mean if you think of it this way then all the people who are passionate about climate survival etc won't have kids and pass on their passion to them. So the only adults we'll have will be those born to parents who don't believe it or don't care.

That sounds like a worse future to me.

Except over population is the biggest contributor to climate change. And kids learn from people other than their parents (thank goodness).
MagpieSong · 20/09/2020 21:54

Personally, I wonder if the genetic factors mentioned in the OP weren’t there if the decision would be different? Perhaps not. I made my choices for my reasons and because nothing is certain. The world could end before I type this or in a given period of time. We can estimate, but we cannot know. I do find it very weird how many people want to preach about not having children though. I’ve come across it a lot recently. Partly I think I feel that because as someone who was adopted and has worked with traumatised children (and adults), I find it is almost never those people asking and querying who are actively attempting to improve things in the world. For example, most say ‘I wanted kids but didn’t have them because It’s too bad for the environment/too hard for kids to go through this life when global warming is... etc etc’, but few seem to have considered becoming a parent through adoption (often very tough, but very eco friendly) or a foster carer. I also find they often aren’t making any huge effort to be super eco friendly. Obviously those things are blanket statements, there will always be exceptions, so OP forgive me if you’re someone who does, but it is something I’ve noted. I find it strange that it’s difficult to comprehend why someone would generally want children. Firstly, we are a social species based on interacting with each other. That’s our strength as a mammal and one we have continued to grow with as a species to the point we have these wonderfully complex languages and can describe things we’ve never even seen in real life. We thrive on relationships and the parent child relationship is one of those. Secondly, considering how much of the world don’t appreciate climate change etc. its hardly surprising that lots of people have children without it crossing their minds.

Thirdly, it’s quite a westernised question. There are many terrible things that face the human race and in the western world, we are lucky to not have to face some of these and for a majority of us to have to face few of the horrors that others face. Again, there are exceptions, but the majority of the UK is not threatened by starvation with our children dying, we can usually formula feed without too much issue if our breast milk dries up, we can go to town without our children witnessing a Neighbour being stoned etc. Even in very difficult situations, some of us as a race tend to keep having children (Not everyone at all, some make huge efforts to get hold of medication and attempt to prevent or end pregnancy), but the lack of direct threat in places like the UK etc. does not pressurise us to stop.

Anyway, one of things I think is that we never know when we’ll go through trauma. We also do not, by not having children, protect ourselves or others from trauma. It would be traumatic watching the human race die out, because someone somewhere would be ‘the last’. The world ending due to climate change may change people’s minds as it gets closer and very obvious, but the reality is that whether lots of people are dying together or one person close to you dies, that’s traumatic. Most of the time, trauma therapy tries to remind you that you cannot go through life avoiding everything that makes life worth living to attempt to avoid experiencing more trauma. You can take sensible precautions to avoid it, but you can’t stop following what you long for in your life and for some people who’ve longed for children, it’s traumatic not to experience parenthood.

I’ll be quiet now. This post ended up being crazily long.

ChelseaDaggers · 20/09/2020 21:53

@WombOfOnesOwn

Apocalyptic climate predictions are BS. Even environmentalists, dedicated ones, know this. Recently read a fantastic book by a man whose environmentalist qualifications are beyond reproach called Apocalypse Never, that explores how pernicious these myths are.

If you're considering getting out of the reproduction game because of climate guilt, I recommend reading that book. The money behind this particular game comes from oil and gas companies, and the "environmental solutions" proposed as properly progressive are often more for their benefit than to prevent any apocalyptic outcome.

It's also always white, overprivileged, post reproductive men who say we must stop having babies. Because population growth...oh where is that actually happening again? Not in the UK where we are already at below replacement birth levels, but in the developing world.
AfolMummy · 20/09/2020 21:53

WorraLiberty

She was also absolutely desperate for children and she too decided against it for genetic factors.

Sadly she too has now convinced herself her decision was due to a woman crusade to help the planet and can often be heard finger wagging at parents who made different decisions.

I know someone EXACTLY like this except that they couldn't have the kids they very much wanted as their DH didn't want any.

Dee1975 · 20/09/2020 21:53

So you think everyone in the world should stop reproducing now?
How have we coped the last 2000 years 🤣🤣

CorianderLord · 20/09/2020 21:52

I mean if you think of it this way then all the people who are passionate about climate survival etc won't have kids and pass on their passion to them. So the only adults we'll have will be those born to parents who don't believe it or don't care.

That sounds like a worse future to me.

WombOfOnesOwn · 20/09/2020 21:52

Apocalyptic climate predictions are BS. Even environmentalists, dedicated ones, know this. Recently read a fantastic book by a man whose environmentalist qualifications are beyond reproach called Apocalypse Never, that explores how pernicious these myths are.

If you're considering getting out of the reproduction game because of climate guilt, I recommend reading that book. The money behind this particular game comes from oil and gas companies, and the "environmental solutions" proposed as properly progressive are often more for their benefit than to prevent any apocalyptic outcome.

ChelseaDaggers · 20/09/2020 21:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ReeseWitherfork · 20/09/2020 21:50

Hysterical post.*

ChelseaDaggers · 20/09/2020 21:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ReeseWitherfork · 20/09/2020 21:50

And the whole “people have been going on about climate change and there have been no ill effects” person can go discuss that with the Pacific Islanders or those who are losing everything in the worst bushfires in a number of countries. Just because it hasn’t affected YOU doesn’t mean it hasn’t killed anyone.

In 1931, 3.7 million people died from natural disasters. In 2018, just 11,000 did. That’s a 99.7% decline. And that decline occurred over a period when the global population quadrupled. All because of economic advancement.

I’m not necessarily arguing with you but offering some context from your rather hysterics posts

TikkaBoo · 20/09/2020 21:50

12frogsincoats

I agree with you, and I repeat what I said earlier - it's because
They. Do. Not. Care.

StoneofDestiny · 20/09/2020 21:49

12frogsincoats No, I'm pretty sure it's the hypocrisy on this thread and the amount of people who seem to be void of empathy and kindness that's upsetting me. That, and my apparent inability to conceive a child after years of trying, and then reading horrible threads like this

Always odd that those who try to put people off having children, still hang around themselves to breathe and feed off the planets resources! Why do they think they take precedence?

Ihatefish · 20/09/2020 21:47

I think the urge to reproduce is stronger than almost any other thought/feeling for a lot of people. I do really wonder why people feel
The need to have more than replacements (ie. more than two) with the world as it is

sharpeidiem · 20/09/2020 21:47

@12frogsincoats I'm aware there is a risk for them getting anxiety yes - however it has passed over members of my family, and my DH's family has absolutely none so it's a shot in the dark. You don't know what your kids are going to turn out like, but you still decide to support them.

If the doctor said, "Hi, would you like a kid with or without anxiety?" and I asked for them to have it, then it would be correct to condemn me for making a shit choice.

12frogsincoats · 20/09/2020 21:47

@sharpeidiem People with Down's Syndrome and autism often live very happy, fulfilled lives. They are not conditions that automatically cause suffering. Anxiety and depression are.

ReeseWitherfork · 20/09/2020 21:47

Do you prefer the Earth or humanity? I am not quite sure where I sit in this argument, so I am not venturing a judgement. Earth without humanity would be a paradise, but if there's no intelligent being to value and appreciate it, then it's worth nothing in an indifferent universe.

This is beautiful. So poetic. I love it.

Napqueen1234 · 20/09/2020 21:47

I have two small children and have huge worries about the future but they bring so much joy to my world and to those around them. They are happy despite the stresses of the moment and I have no doubt they will face challenges and need resilience but life continues and the human race (like all animals) will adapt and evolve their practices to the world they live in. Everyone’s life is unique so I don’t want my children to relive my exact experience- they will have their own. Not having babies on principle seems like something people could deeply regret particularly if they miss their window of opportunity and (hopefully!) in 5 years the world will look brighter and more optomistic.

mayflowerapplepie · 20/09/2020 21:46

I’m with you OP. Extremely happy with my life and chose to have no children for a number of reasons but right now am very happy I made that decision because of the impact on the planet.
Not many people who had children are going to admit that they made a decision that while possibly right for them (and in most cases in the western world for their children) was probably a shit one for the world in general and possibly their grandchildren.
I don’t really care if the human race becomes extinct in the next few hundred years. It would be the best thing for every other fucking species on the planet and I am not selfish enough to think we are the “keepers” of the planet or some special creatures. The thought of this happening makes me sad for the people who will Experience it.
And the whole “people have been going on about climate change and there have been no ill effects” person can go discuss that with the Pacific Islanders or those who are losing everything in the worst bushfires in a number of countries. Just because it hasn’t affected YOU doesn’t mean it hasn’t killed anyone.
This thread makes me realise why so many people have children without thinking about the consequences. Some people have an overwhelming urge. Some are just dicks

catpoooffender · 20/09/2020 21:46

What a ridiculous OP. If you don't want to have children for whatever reason, that's fine. Don't come on a forum targeted at parents and tell people their children will face 'unimaginable suffering' in the future. I'm not going to take that to heart, but what an unnecessary thing to say. Had I read that in a recent post-partum frame of mind I would have been in bits.

You don't know anything about what the future holds. Make your own choices in life but don't judge others, and don't go around forecasting doom and gloom like it's the writing on the wall when this is a shit year for a lot of people anyway.

XingMing · 20/09/2020 21:45

Unimaginable suffering.... after all of whole human history? Please, don't descend into wetness, and read something about history. All of it is human suffering, wars, plagues, famines, poverty and damned hard labour for almost every individual on the planet. Read about times, as late as the early 20th century, when most families lost half their children to disease before clean water, proper sanitation, vaccinations and antibiotics. And reflect on how soft and easy life is today. Even in LDCs. The population has exploded, not because humans have learned how to breed, but because we now breed and survive to a degree that would have been unimaginable 100 years ago, and it is our success that is killing or at least abusing Earth's resources.

Do you prefer the Earth or humanity? I am not quite sure where I sit in this argument, so I am not venturing a judgement. Earth without humanity would be a paradise, but if there's no intelligent being to value and appreciate it, then it's worth nothing in an indifferent universe.

12frogsincoats · 20/09/2020 21:45

@PablosHoney

How could she possibly know that
Read the posts I'm replying to in which @sharpeidiem states she has debilitating mental health issues and is aware it's genetic. It shocks me that anyone would risk putting another human through an entire lifetime of suffering (which is what severe depression/anxiety so often is) purely for their own selfish reasons.
sharpeidiem · 20/09/2020 21:44

[quote 12frogsincoats]@sharpeidiem

I live with absolutely (to use your word) debilitating anxiety and if I thought my mother had given birth to me despite knowing I would suffer this way, I would truly, truly despise her.[/quote]
I have debilitating anxiety too and I couldn't hate my mum for that reason! She was abusive as shit for other reasons, but I'm not going to hate or blame her solely for having a child.

Do you feel the same about women who keep their children who have Down Syndrome or Autism, or another form of disability that affects them? There is no guarantee my children will get any of my MH conditions (DH and his family don't have them at all) but if they did, I'd support them through it.

ReeseWitherfork · 20/09/2020 21:44

Have I missed some news aside from the usual climate change, covid etc somewhere?
I think we all have, and OP hasn’t been back to enlighten us! Can’t believe someone would tell us the world is ending in a couple of decades but not tell us how.

ScarletZebra · 20/09/2020 21:44

I wasn't going to have children because there was going to be a nuclear war. In the 1980s. Obviously there wasn't, and I did have them. Every generation has had some catastrophe looming.