Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people are still having kids?

688 replies

Tobythecat · 20/09/2020 19:21

I understand that the urge to reproduce is very strong, but the future looks incredibly bleak (I'm not talking about just covid, but also climate change). I fear for the future and what sort of quality of life people will have, considering Automation/competition over jobs, climate change issues (food/water shortages, extreme weather). Honestly, how can you think that everything will be fine and work itself out, or do you just not think about it? Children today will face unimagineable suffering in the next 20-30 years, how can you justify it to them? I wanted children desperately but decided not to because of the above, plus genetic factors.

People mention the war and how people kept having kids, but the threats we face have never been faced before and are multifaceted. Is existing to suffer better than not existing at all?

OP posts:
OliviaBenson · 20/09/2020 22:40

I agree with you op, but as you can see from the responses you have got, it never goes down well on here.

I'm also not having kids, and a huge factor is the environment (not that this is ever deemed acceptable a reason!)

We've had Covid, the floods at the start of the year etc etc. Life is only going to get harder, but then lots of people tell themselves is ok because they recycle.

Having a baby is one of the worst things for the environment, but it's a fact that nobody wants to accept.

More people need to think before they breed.

LeaLoo82 · 20/09/2020 22:40

Who needs extinction rebellion eh

sharpeidiem · 20/09/2020 22:39

@12frogsincoats

"Do you have undesirable traits @sharpeidiem? Or do you think poor health is preferable?"

Autism is a commonly used "undesirable trait". Additionally, if we're going to talk about how anxiety being a good enough reason to sterilise yourself (and / or a good reason to hate your mother if she thought you might be anxious) then I'm willing to demonstrate that some of my "undesirable traits" exist and yet I am still a happy and content person, with a fulfilling life.

WaterOffADucksCrack · 20/09/2020 22:38

I wanted children desperately but decided not to Which is a perfectly valid choice. Just as choosing to have children is. It doesn't make you better than anyone else despite how superior you clearly feel.

ChelseaDaggers · 20/09/2020 22:38

@TikkaBoo

PablosHoney if you can’t take that final step, which I truly hope you never do

Thanks - that actually means a lot, especially as I'm sure you abhor my views! You're a good person.
I can assure you I'm in no danger though - as I said, my determination to not have children is kind of what 'let me off the hook' to try and have a good time. My death will come - so I might as well try to enjoy life before then.
I guess in many ways it's similar to the reasons that people want children.... Grin

Very glad to read this^^. So...why would someone who is relieved not to have to have babies, let off the hook and loving life a lot more, come on to a parenting forum and join in a thread berating parents for...being parents? If you are happy with your choice, fantastic! Couldn't be happier for you! Could you maybe find it possible to respect other people's choices, as we respect yours and if you cannot, then maybe don't come on to a PARENTING forum?
Dilbertine · 20/09/2020 22:37

I haven’t read the FT, but the OP is right.
I have children and I only became aware of the true state of the world a few years ago.
I can’t regret having them, because they are the joy of my life and I would have missed out on so much by not having them, but the fear and distress that I feel when considering their future..
So many people think ‘someone’ is doing something about Climate Change, that it will all work out🤷‍♀️
I’m in a few support groups for similar-minded parents on Facebook, which helps, but I wish I could back to ignorance sometimes.

Feelingconfused2020 · 20/09/2020 22:36

Joining this thread late and it looks like it's taken a quite dark turn however I wanted to add this as I think it's important.

I am a teacher. Young people of today aren't like us, the environment and climate are at the forefront of their thinking. They will change the world and they will save it. That's my opinion.

Education is the key. Things don't stop overnight but they do improve with education. My son is 9 and he is furious when we leave lights on in the house. When I was 9 I wouldn't have given a toss. Is that enough in itself? No but if he's better than me surely it's better that he's here and trying to change things.

We could stop and ultimately the planet might be saved but humanity would be wiped out. It's a debate for another day but surely the best solution is to change our behaviours and I think the younger generation have and will. I trust them.

TikkaBoo · 20/09/2020 22:35

it is nothing to do with thinking people with mental health issues or disabilities 'shouldn't exist

Exactly. I think I have the same right to exist as any one else.
It's just that - like the OP - I can't imagine wanting even the slightest chance that I might have to watch my own children suffer in the same way.

PablosHoney · 20/09/2020 22:34

@SerenDippitty you are enough in yourself, your worth doesn’t relate to procreation, nature isn’t discriminatory and bad stuff happens to good people too.

12frogsincoats · 20/09/2020 22:34

[quote sharpeidiem]**@PablosHoney* @ChelseaDaggers I'm doing alright amongst the bullshit, I just really really* hope whoever comes along this thread later doesn't feel like shit for being genetically inferior or whatever nonsense is being spouted.

For anyone else who is talking about MH conditions and autism - both have been a difficult part of life for me, yes. They make social interactions quite difficult and I need a slew of coping mechanisms to keep pulling through. However, I'm also quite an empathetic person, I am highly concentrated and I try and my best to prevent anyone else from with MH or any kind of difficulty.

As much as you would not have had me, I'm glad to be alive and I'm glad to have the blessing of bringing children into the world.[/quote]
Respectfully, you are the only one who has mentioned autism on this thread.

sharpeidiem · 20/09/2020 22:33

[quote 12frogsincoats]@sharpeidiem No one is making that assumption. As I said, it is your choice, and it is nothing to do with thinking people with mental health issues or disabilities 'shouldn't exist.' All I know is that I have been in such low, terrible places that I have made very serious attempts on my life that have left lasting problems, and if there is even the smallest chance of a 'small person,' who I would love and care about like nothing else, going through that as well, I would like to stop that, and the only guarantee of it not happening is by not conceiving them in the first place.[/quote]
Like I've said - YOU do that. That's absolutely fantastic for you as a personal choice, I will never ever advocate for people to have children if they don't want them or can't support them. My point is - I shouldn't have to defend myself for wanting children, especially for the reasons of me having MH issues or autism etc etc. I respect your choice to not have children if that's what you want to do, so I'm asking everyone to please respect the choice of those who do want children. Neither is inherently selfish or immoral, providing you do your best with both.

Userzzz · 20/09/2020 22:33

Calm down will you.
As PP said, if we don’t reproduce, what’s the point? Life was always filled with war, famine, general suffering. The point is to move forward.

TikkaBoo · 20/09/2020 22:32

PablosHoney
if you can’t take that final step, which I truly hope you never do

Thanks - that actually means a lot, especially as I'm sure you abhor my views! You're a good person.
I can assure you I'm in no danger though - as I said, my determination to not have children is kind of what 'let me off the hook' to try and have a good time. My death will come - so I might as well try to enjoy life before then.
I guess in many ways it's similar to the reasons that people want children.... Grin

SerenDippitty · 20/09/2020 22:31

@Bunkumum

Because I know I’ve got shit hot genes, they’ve made it all the way to me through all those generations of challenges. Only fair I carry them on. Don’t want to let the side down.
Well I couldn’t pass mine on and I do feel I’ve let the side down. Then again perhaps they weren’t worth passing on. Perhaps nature was being wise
sharpeidiem · 20/09/2020 22:31

@PablosHoney @ChelseaDaggers I'm doing alright amongst the bullshit, I just really really hope whoever comes along this thread later doesn't feel like shit for being genetically inferior or whatever nonsense is being spouted.

For anyone else who is talking about MH conditions and autism - both have been a difficult part of life for me, yes. They make social interactions quite difficult and I need a slew of coping mechanisms to keep pulling through. However, I'm also quite an empathetic person, I am highly concentrated and I try and my best to prevent anyone else from with MH or any kind of difficulty.

As much as you would not have had me, I'm glad to be alive and I'm glad to have the blessing of bringing children into the world.

PablosHoney · 20/09/2020 22:29

@TikkaBoo do you have people round you that it would affect, I’m just wondering if maybe life doesn’t feel entirely pointless to you if you can’t take that final step, which I truly hope you never do.

12frogsincoats · 20/09/2020 22:28

@sharpeidiem No one is making that assumption. As I said, it is your choice, and it is nothing to do with thinking people with mental health issues or disabilities 'shouldn't exist.' All I know is that I have been in such low, terrible places that I have made very serious attempts on my life that have left lasting problems, and if there is even the smallest chance of a 'small person,' who I would love and care about like nothing else, going through that as well, I would like to stop that, and the only guarantee of it not happening is by not conceiving them in the first place.

GinWithASplashOfTonic · 20/09/2020 22:28

@Funkypolar

Strange thing to post on a forum called Mumsnet.
I thought this too!!!
CoronaBollox · 20/09/2020 22:28

God the dramatics. People have babies all the time. During wars, extreme poverty and other difficult circumstances. It will never change, plus we need people to have kids to keep the world moving. Paying in to pensions, becoming healthcare professionals etc. Who else will you vent to when you're old and grey, still moaning that after you were born people dared to reproduce.

I cringe when people come out with corkers like "human race deserves to die we have killed the planet, let it have a fresh start" Well you first then let me know how fun that is for you...

Also sod the kids what's happening in 20 to 30 years?? Il only be late 40s early 50s.

ChelseaDaggers · 20/09/2020 22:27

[quote RickJames]**@sharpeidiem

Don't stress about people who know nothing. MH issues don't necessarily affect your children. The genetic element is there but it takes something to trigger it generally. I'm not stressed about my genetic legacy, if I wanted to get all eugenical and Hitlerish then I'd say mine had loads of great inheritances. There's a chance they'll struggle but I'm just kind to them, love them, support them, unlike what my lovely parents decided to do to me. Genetics might load the gun but environment pulls the trigger. You are perfect just as you are, please believe me.[/quote]
Yes, this.

My mom had serious MH issues. I and my siblings do not. She is now dead. Died quite young and I remember her as the most wonderful person. I am so glad she was my mum and that I had the privilege of knowing her. Her MH issues barely feature in my evaluation of her and how amazing she was. I really hope this thread hasn't done too much damage to you or anyone else @sharpeidiem. Can't believe it has been allowed to stay.

Glad you found each other @12frogsincoats and @TikkaBoo. Good for you. Now maybe you can go and find a forum which isn't primarily for parents where you can enjoy each other's company? Just a suggestion.

SerenDippitty · 20/09/2020 22:27

I couldn’t have children but my sadness about that is mixed with relief.

TikkaBoo · 20/09/2020 22:27

Why do you think that is @TikkaBoo?

Not sure. Perhaps because the other stuff is not doing things (absence of action) whereas suicide is an act?

WatershipDown7 · 20/09/2020 22:27

@DameFanny

Because people don't for the most part comprehend the totality of the damage we've done to the environment and how increasingly quickly we're reaching each next tipping point
Yes to this
sharpeidiem · 20/09/2020 22:27

@ChelseaDaggers @RickJames Thank you both

PablosHoney · 20/09/2020 22:26

@sharpeidiem you’ve been remarkably patient, great parenting trait right there