Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they are my sibling? (DNA results)

245 replies

PeanutButterFalcon · 20/09/2020 00:15

Hello,

I have done an heritage DNA test and have been linked to someone with a 100% chance they are a close relative (niece/nephew, grandparent, grand child, half sibling).

I have looked at my family trees and there is no link that I can see to their family. If I go back further, I would imagine, our DNA wouldn't be such a strong match. Over 25% of our DNA matches and we have the longest segment length of over 150. Although I'm not sure what the segment length means.

I cannot but help think one of my parents have had an affair and they are a sibling. I have so many questions and thoughts in my head. Are these tests reliable? How would we even go about working out if we are? I cannot ask my parents if they have and I do not think they would be honest with me anyway.

What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
espressoontap · 21/09/2020 09:51

Oh wow OP, you must have so many thoughts going through your head.

I'd love to do a DNA test but I'm scared of the results and the can of worms it would open. I know my dad left when I was small and when I got in touch with him my mum was horrible to me (that's for another thread!), I haven't the energy to investigate anything else.

I wish you well Thanks

BuffaloCauliflower · 21/09/2020 09:33

Seems more likely your Dad is her Dad. And you’re right, it could open a can of worms for them too. These things are always a minefield. I think starting by getting your sister a test is a good move. That at least gives you one extra level of knowledge.

PeanutButterFalcon · 21/09/2020 09:19

I don't know if my dad would of had two families but I would assume it was unlikely we were the secret one as we were well known to all his family and would often spend weeks at a time visiting them.

@Willitjuststop thank you. It's hard to know how the other person will handle this and how they are feeling. If my mum opened up to me this would stop that.

I don't think they could be an aunt/uncle. My mums parents were never apart from each other and too old to have a child of her age. My Dads parents were not alive when she was conceived. There's always the chance I could be their aunt which just wouldn't make sense as we're quite a distance apart and I do not think my Mum would take in another child when my brother was so unwell.

I agree it's likely we did share a dad. I also wondered if maybe my Dad (possible not the person I thought it was) is somehow related to their parents and I've inherited more of their DNA.

Thank you @BuffaloCauliflower for the positive story. I think for me it might explain some things however I'm aware for them it may rip things apart, which I don't want to do.

@midnightstar66 I am currently agreeing with you. They also look a lot like my siblings, which would explain this. Although, it could be a case of my Mum bumped into their Dad by chance somehow.

Definitely couldn't be my Mums child and it would appear I definitely couldn't be her Mums unless she had twins maybe. But I can't explain how I would end up here.

I'm aware me and my sister may have different Dads anyway and it might not help things. She's a lot younger than me however and the chance of her being conceived by the same man (if I'm from an affair) is lower. Also, my Dad was unwell at this point and had stopped travelling for 'work' so much so it's more likely that she was my Dads child. Additionally, we look identical.

OP posts:
Sexnotgender · 21/09/2020 09:04

@Bluntness100

She’s also said as her brother is only a few months older she can’t be her mothers. It doesn’t take long and is really easy to read the ops posts.
I did, please accept my humblest apologies that I missed it.
Sexnotgender · 21/09/2020 09:02

Ah, thanks @BuffaloCauliflower I missed that.

Bluntness100 · 21/09/2020 08:53

She’s also said as her brother is only a few months older she can’t be her mothers. It doesn’t take long and is really easy to read the ops posts.

BuffaloCauliflower · 21/09/2020 08:50

@Sexnotgender OP has said this person is younger than them

Sexnotgender · 21/09/2020 08:46

Families are funny. My great aunt had a child very young (and out of wedlock I think) and he was raised as my great grandparents child and no one outside the family would really have known.

Could this person have been adopted if your mum had them very young or does the age not fit?

Bluntness100 · 21/09/2020 08:31

I also think you should go carefully here op. For the other woman’s sake. Because if your dad is her dad, she might not know. And quite frankly maybe even her mother doesn’t either for sure, and put it out her mind, like the pp.

It’s still your mother refusing to look at her though, that i can’t get past, it’s not a normal reaction, which indicates she does know. As said, I’d show the woman’s image to your mum again and see if she still refuses to look and gauge her reaction.

midnightstar66 · 21/09/2020 08:26

I think it's far far more likely that your (known) dad is the link rather than this other persons. It sounds like you are distances apart and it's far more likely your dad was in the position to either be somewhere he wasn't expected to be or that the unknown person had a reason to be where your dad was than that another man was travelling a distance to see your mum while she cared for all of you dc wile your df was away. I also agree as who looks like your sister has uploaded to the site then it's not like she wants any potential family secrets hidden. Testing one sister might not be conclusive either. If your df was away regularly he could be your dad but not hers for example. It's quite the rabbit hole when you think about it!

BuffaloCauliflower · 21/09/2020 08:25

Just to add - my mum bought me the DNA test for my birthday as I was doing some family tree stuff and was interested. She definitely didn’t know there was anything to come out!

movingonup20 · 21/09/2020 08:18

Just an idea, we discovered my maternal grandfather had an affair and the resulting child was adopted after he passed away. Until the 60's adoption was common in such circumstances

BuffaloCauliflower · 21/09/2020 08:14

Hi OP. I did an Ancestry DNA test and found out my father was someone else. In my case my biological father had done a test already, so when I got my results I had a Nan’s name linked to me with ‘100% my parent or my child” so was unmistakable. In my case it’s ultimately been positive, he was an colleague and friend of my mums, she wasn’t even sure they’d had full sex (drunken night) and as she was married she put it out of her mind as she felt guilty, and when she found she was pregnant reasonably assumed it was her husband who she was having regular sex with - my mum and I are close and this hasn’t damaged our relationship at all. I know my mum and how her brain works and I don’t feel anything was deliberately kept from me. As soon as this came out she was completely honest which helped.

My dad who raised me was passed at the point this came out, but we hadn’t had the best relationship. When I reached out to bio father (by slightly frantic Facebook message) he was glad to be in touch and admitted he’d wondered if I was his but hadn’t wanted to rock the boat, and there were no DNA tests in the 80s. We’ve built a really good relationship and most of my friends and family know about him, though its not completely public. I’m much more like my bio dad than I ever was the dad I grew up with, and it’s actually answered a lot more questions that it’s created. He has a good relationship with my mum, and his wife and children (my half siblings) are all great. Though of course it was the shock of my life at the time, I’d never had cause to suspect anything. I’m in a Facebook group for people this has happened too and my version of this story is definitely the best one.

Just to say really - shocking things can come out of this, but there can be positives with that. From the CMs you’ve given a half sibling seems likely and there’s multiple ways that could have come about, but you’ve sat on it for a while now and you’ll just drive yourself nuts if you don’t reach out and see. Just be prepared that there’s many ways this can go and it may take a lot from you as you pursue this. Good luck, and please reach out by DM if you’d like to chat privately Smile

Bluntness100 · 21/09/2020 07:18

I also think op thr only reasonable explanation is you share a parent. And as your mum couldn’t have been pregnant, and your link to folks on your mothers side. It’s clearly not your mum,

So you share a dad.

MountainPeakGeek · 21/09/2020 05:22

Hi OP,

I think you're going to find that they're a half sibling. There's no way that you'd share that much DNA with a 1st cousin (i.e. the idea that one of your parents was an unknown sibling to one of their parents.)

You would get that degree of a match if they're your aunt/uncle though. My husband has only recently found his dad (via Ancestry DNA) and his bio father has other children that are closer in age to our dcs than they are to DH, so our kids' aunt (DH's half sister) looks more like she should be their sister than his. Is that sort of thing a possibility...?

Willitjuststop · 21/09/2020 00:40

No my half sibling does not know.

I linked on ancestry to people I had no idea who they were and didn't get any hits relating to my dad.

I questioned my mother about some of the names that came up and she then told me.

SirVixofVixHall · 20/09/2020 23:23

Half sibling is the most likely scenario. I discovered a family secret too, an illegitimate child, but the people concerned are all dead now so that makes it easier. Do you think it possible that your Dad had two families ?

PeanutButterFalcon · 20/09/2020 22:49

@MyBedIsMyDesk thank you for sharing your experience. Did your mum give you this information or have you figured it out?
I can definitely understand the thought of having two Dads. Whatever happens my Dad is my Dad.

I am constantly trying to think of other ways we could be related. I don't know how open the other person maybe to the thought of sharing a parent and I'm guessing there are other possible reasons we may be related and by chance we have inherited similar DNA. I'm wondering if our parents may unknowingly be siblings.

I'm going to sleep on it and contact the other person. @Rayn I may use that as it's not too direct thank you.

OP posts:
Rayn · 20/09/2020 22:13

People who do DNA tests have to expect something like this so the OP is not been selfish. The DNA test I did resulted in my mum having a brother she knew nothing about. He was illegitimate. Y grandfather r died so we will never know whether he knew about the child or not.

The other person whom you match OP is obviously interested and will be aware that it can potentially open a can of worms . Personally I would be in contact and say wonder how we match?

MyBedIsMyDesk · 20/09/2020 21:59

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PeanutButterFalcon · 20/09/2020 21:35

@MimiSunshine I would imagine we would be a difficult family to be a secret. I have quite a few more siblings and all my dads family know about us. Although again It could be entirely possible they were in on the secret.

Him working away could be to see a secret family or potentially my mum used it as a cover up for separations knowing he would eventually come back. Thus, giving them both opportunities to see other people. I wouldn't necessarily be the product of an affair then.

I have asked my sister to do a test as it should be able to identify if we are half or full siblings. From there I will be able to work out if there dad is mine or if my dad is there's I'm guessing.

In the meantime I'm going to see a friend in the week and ask for her assistance in contacting the possible sibling. I think a non biased third party will help with what to say without causing upset.

OP posts:
MimiSunshine · 20/09/2020 21:26

OP my thoughts are that you and your sister are your dads secret 2nd family.

Him “working away” Could easily be time back at home with his 1st family and actually working and time with your mum was him “Travelling for work”.

That would explain why your mum refused to look at the photo as she knows and doesn’t want to explain.
Maybe she didn’t know at the start of her relationship with your dad but did eventually find out

Sexnotgender · 20/09/2020 21:22

Good luck OP, what a difficult situation.

SandyY2K · 20/09/2020 21:04

@Sacredspace

Perhaps you were fathered by their father, rather than them being fathered by yours?
Could that be why your father left soon after your birth? So what I’m saying is perhaps it was your mother that had an affair?

Very possible....

I thought this when the OP said her mum wouldn't look at the picture.

Anyone who puts their DNA on the site, should be prepared for anything...and I totally disagree that the OP is selfish.

I would never put my DNA on there. I have all the family I need, although having watched long lost family (USA)... you can still be traced via other family members uploading their DNA.

All very interesting.

flourbroach · 20/09/2020 20:52

@81Byerley

I know how much my children have valued the relationship they have with their half brother, whom they found out about as adults (My ex husbands son by the girl he went out with before me), so I'd say go for it!

I was reminded of a conversation I had with a woman one day. She said "I always get a shock when I see that man over there. He's my cousin, and he looks identical to my late dad". I said it's funny how these family resemblances come out in different generations" and she laughed and said "Yes, the problem is, he's not on my dad's side, he's the son of my Mum's sister" .

Shock Whoops!

That woman - I wonder if she ever put two and two together...?