Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they are my sibling? (DNA results)

245 replies

PeanutButterFalcon · 20/09/2020 00:15

Hello,

I have done an heritage DNA test and have been linked to someone with a 100% chance they are a close relative (niece/nephew, grandparent, grand child, half sibling).

I have looked at my family trees and there is no link that I can see to their family. If I go back further, I would imagine, our DNA wouldn't be such a strong match. Over 25% of our DNA matches and we have the longest segment length of over 150. Although I'm not sure what the segment length means.

I cannot but help think one of my parents have had an affair and they are a sibling. I have so many questions and thoughts in my head. Are these tests reliable? How would we even go about working out if we are? I cannot ask my parents if they have and I do not think they would be honest with me anyway.

What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
Dugsbollox · 02/10/2020 14:15

However it turns out, OP, I wish you all the best.

DilysPrice · 02/10/2020 13:47

It could in theory be secondary infertility but while I can imagine turning to a best friend for informal sperm donation if you were desperate for a first child surely it’s very unlikely that you’d go to such extreme lengths for a third child.

Onceuponatimethen · 02/10/2020 12:56

That’s exciting op!!

Am I being stupid? Why does it depend who came first? Could be primary or secondary infertility?

PeanutButterFalcon · 02/10/2020 12:54

Off

OP posts:
PeanutButterFalcon · 02/10/2020 12:53

@Onceuponatimethen I guess it depends on who came first!

Test has been sent of today so we just wait for the results now I guess. Still talking to the other person, we sound very similar and they also want to know what's happened

OP posts:
Onceuponatimethen · 29/09/2020 11:26

@PeanutButterFalcon unless the best friend agreed to help @FeedtheFish123 HD’s parents to have another baby?

Arthersleep · 29/09/2020 11:15

Thanks for the update. I'm invested in this thread.

PeanutButterFalcon · 29/09/2020 08:47

Sisters DNA test has arrived. Need to arrange visiting her to do it.

OP posts:
Bigfatpicnic · 27/09/2020 21:18

This is fascinating. I really hope you find out the truth, without the collateral damage.
Maybe they are tip-toeing around the obvious questions too; as they don’t want to open a can of worms for you. It’s difficult, but your sister might hold the DNA key to this.

PeanutButterFalcon · 26/09/2020 22:33

@WildNorthEast the test should hopefully arrive within a week or so and then it can take up to 2 months for the results so we're in for a bit of a wait.

@Monday55 I have thought about this. I would be surprised if my parents had used sperm donation considering I'm one of many. It wouldn't surprise me if my Dad was short of money and sold his at one point (maybe more).

Still in conversations with the other person but they still haven't mentioned being a sibling so I'm not going to ask about sperm donation unless it comes up. No adoption in their family that they know of either and none in ours.

@Aknifewith16blades I hope it's not rape as that would mean one of our Dads is a rapist which would be awful.

@FeedtheFish123 what a shock for your DH! It's so many emotions to take in. I'm guessing his DF wouldn't of known otherwise they possibly wouldn't have stayed friends

OP posts:
Onceuponatimethen · 26/09/2020 19:42

I guess in @FeedtheFish123 scenario it could also be a known donor sperm donation due to believed primary infertility or actual secondary infertility

LadyEloise · 26/09/2020 19:15

FeedtheFish123
Wow that was some discovery.
Is your DH the eldest ? The youngest ? Or in the middle ?
What were his parent's relationship like.
The wife of his bio father - did she know ?
Do his real siblings/ half siblings know ?
So many unanswered questions.
The main one being why. Sad

Aknifewith16blades · 26/09/2020 17:49

OP, just as a thought, I'm seeing a lot of mentions of possible affairs here, but nothing about rape. While I would hope that isn't the case, it's good to think through all the possibilities.

FeedtheFish123 · 26/09/2020 17:43

My husband is my FILs best friends son.
We discovered this via a similar DNA test. looking at DH and his what we thought were full brothers and his 'new' half brother it is obvious to now we can't believe we missed it.

Sadly, or maybe thankfully the parents have all passed away before we found out but as the two families were brought up together and DH was taken by FIL and his best friend to see the best friends parents we do wonder if all the parents and grandparents were aware and only the kids didn't know.
We had always considered them family anyway so it hasn't made our day to day lives different but it has been difficult for DH to come to terms with without his parents to explain. He said it felt like grieving again, he doesn't understand why he was lied to, he wished he knew while they were all alive but is also glad they are not.
So I wish you luck, it is a tough road to tread.

Monday55 · 26/09/2020 17:29

Sorry OP I skimmed through all the possibilities that have been mentioned since my last post. Not sure if this has been mentioned but is it also possible that someone donated sperm for quick cash ? To fertility clinics?

WildNorthEast · 25/09/2020 21:45

Do you know how long it will take for your sister's DNA test to get back?

PeanutButterFalcon · 21/09/2020 20:41

@MountainPeakGeek from our conversations so far I don't think they have got this far into thinking about how we might match. If they get there and want to look further then I'd like to. If they don't then I have to respect that and I'll know from my sisters DNA if it's her dad or mine. I think the best situation for both of us would be our Dads have had the affair (although technically not an affair for my Dad) however it means one of our mums has had to.
I would be upset my mum hasn't been honest with me as we do try to be open with each other but then again I have not asked her directly.

We seem quite a like in wanting to know but it sounds their upbringing was much more happier than mine and I don't want to disrupt those memories.

@AbbieFB we've just been talking about our families and looked at each other's tree so far. I can't see anything recognisable and neither can they.

@Squoon I think affairs and illegitimate children even now have a huge 'negative' association. I can imagine every families have secrets they do not want shared. So you have an uncle who is really your mums cousin! I'm guessing they all know about it now?

OP posts:
Squoon · 21/09/2020 19:41

I find this all very fascinating, i hope it all has a positive outcome for you OP.

I haven't done any dna tests but do wonder what it would bring up. My great Aunt had a child she didn't want to keep (she was married but it definitely wasn't her DH's) so her sister (my nan) took the newborn baby boy in. She was 7 months pregnant with my mum at the time. Apparently great Aunt had another baby boy at some point that she gave up for adoption. We only learnt this a few months before my nan died at the age of 90. Its amazing how long people can keep family secrets for.

AbbieFB · 21/09/2020 18:51

Maybe message her and tell her the surnames of your parents and grandparents and ask if any of the surnames are shared.

Hope it all works out well for you.

MountainPeakGeek · 21/09/2020 18:12

I don't think they could be an aunt/uncle. My mums parents were never apart from each other and too old to have a child of her age. My Dads parents were not alive when she was conceived. There's always the chance I could be their aunt which just wouldn't make sense as we're quite a distance apart and I do not think my Mum would take in another child when my brother was so unwell.

No, I agree that it's not at all likely that you're her aunt as you'd need to be her full aunt for that degree of DNA match, i.e. one of her parents would need to be a full (and unknown) sibling to you, sharing both of your parents DNA. So it really does look like she's going to be a half sibling with the same dad as you. I hope this works out okay for you both, and for your mother too.

PeanutButterFalcon · 21/09/2020 15:38

Last thing*

OP posts:
PeanutButterFalcon · 21/09/2020 15:38

@Willitjuststop Thank you. The last think I was to cause is any heartbreak.

@Besom thank you. If the choose not to look into it I will respect that.

@espressoontap I think I was naive going into it and just thought I'd find more about where my family are from. I was disappointed when I got the results and it was no where exotic! It's definitely a lot more than what you anticipate it to be.

@BuffaloCauliflower it would be interesting to find out if my sister is a full relation or not. She's prepared for the results already.

I've had a response! Seems we are similar in wanting to know although they haven't mentioned being siblings and I'm not going to bring it up. They too have been looking in to their family tree to see if they could have any unknown connections with us.

OP posts:
Willitjuststop · 21/09/2020 14:32

@PeanutButterFalcon

Quick update- I've messaged them today. Waiting for a reply. I've decided not to mention that I think we may be siblings and go from there
I hope all goes well.

I messaged my closest dna relative before I found out the truth so may have planted a seed in the mind over that side of the family.

However there is nothing to gain but heartbreak for my dad if this was to all come out. So I'm keeping quiet.

PeanutButterFalcon · 21/09/2020 13:18

Quick update- I've messaged them today. Waiting for a reply. I've decided not to mention that I think we may be siblings and go from there

OP posts:
Besom · 21/09/2020 11:56

The can of worms is already open and since it isn't possible to know what he other person knows or wants to know - OP can only do what feels right for herself.

Just need to be prepared for all eventualities. They could ignore you - this sadly happened to my friend. They could have issues which are difficult to deal with - another friend of mine discovered a half sibling but they had substance misuse issues and relationship has broken down. On the other hand it could all be lovely.