Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they are my sibling? (DNA results)

245 replies

PeanutButterFalcon · 20/09/2020 00:15

Hello,

I have done an heritage DNA test and have been linked to someone with a 100% chance they are a close relative (niece/nephew, grandparent, grand child, half sibling).

I have looked at my family trees and there is no link that I can see to their family. If I go back further, I would imagine, our DNA wouldn't be such a strong match. Over 25% of our DNA matches and we have the longest segment length of over 150. Although I'm not sure what the segment length means.

I cannot but help think one of my parents have had an affair and they are a sibling. I have so many questions and thoughts in my head. Are these tests reliable? How would we even go about working out if we are? I cannot ask my parents if they have and I do not think they would be honest with me anyway.

What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
KingsleyShacklebolt · 09/09/2021 08:12

@BonnyandPoppy

Would these kits tell me if my adult twin daughters were identical twins or not? Maybe I should get us all one for Xmas. I know my dad had lots of affairs so might find a half sibling or two as well.
Yes. An Ancestry test (the most widely used in the UK) would show identical DNA in identical twins, sibling DNA levels in fraternal twins.

Whether you find siblings or half siblings, or close cousins depends on whether other people have tested or not and this varies hugely. I'm from a big family with lots of siblings when you go back a couple of generations, all in the Scottish borders/lowlands, Northumberland, Northern Ireland.

But nobody has tested, my "best" match is a second cousin once removed - her great grandmother Anne was the sister of my grandfather James. 177 cM match between us. And just because you message someone doesn't mean they'll reply... I have thousands of matches at a much lower 4-6 cousin level and haven't managed to fit many of them in. Other people, especially in North America / Aus / NZ test to find their ethnicity breakdown and have no interest in matching with distant relatives, so never build a family tree and aren't interested in working out where you fit in.

DNA doesn't lie but doesn't always explain itself either. Everyone automatically assumes there's been an affair, and that's usually the case. Certainly appears to have been infidelity by the mother in the OP's case. But there could be other things going on too and that's why it's SO important to approach things delicately and with sensitivity. Non-consensual sex is another possibility, we all know now that women can't/don't report rape and things were a lot worse in the past. Before the late 1960s there wasn't the option to terminate an unwanted pregnancy easily either. Many people felt a huge degree of shame over infertility, especially when it was a male "problem". There's a really good podcast on this called the Immaculate Deception which is about the many offspring of a rogue fertility doctor tracking each other down.

So my advice to clients (i'm a genealogist) is always to proceed with caution. As the OP has, to tread gently and give it TIME to sink in rather than rushing off to email everyone, especially when it's very close. To think about counselling to process any unexpected information which comes up. And to respect people's choice not to talk to you about their past or their parents' pasts.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 09/09/2021 07:58

i dont think you should take this as gospel op. mistakes are made, particularly if you are having to pay money to a commercial dna testing lab

Standrewsschool · 09/09/2021 07:54

So basically, until now, you didn’t realise that your dad wasn’t your dad?! And your mum (and dad if he knew) has been keeping a huge secret?

ittakes2 · 09/09/2021 07:30

Peanutbutterfalcon are you the oldest child from your mother? Is there a chance you and your sister were born from a known relationship (rather than an affair) between your bio dad and your mum and the dad that raised you married your mother after they broke up? Have you seen their marriage certificate? I ask because children can’t remember when they were young. My b’n’law married a single mum when her child was 4. His bio dad had gone to prison for hurting his mum and the judge had said no contact. This 4 year old after a while starting calling my b’n’law dad and he completely forgot about his bio dad. His mum and stepdad never corrected him so he grew up thinking his stepdad was his bio dad. I was very worried about when he became an adult and realised all this and it did affect him. Is there a chance the lie your mum is protecting you from us the lie you think your dad is your bio dad rather than she had a secret affair? It could explain the timing of your half siblings existence - your bio dad left your mum and moved to this other place where your half sibling lives.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 09/09/2021 07:16

Gosh, it sounds like you have uncovered a lot of information you weren’t expecting. To get this right, you initially matched with your sister enough to show she is a full sister which lead you to believe your late DF was your bio-Dad, but more full sibling matches have since come through which couldn’t be related to your DF so now you think that both you and your sister were products of your mum’s affair? Do you have any other siblings who could take the test?

I think in your shoes I would be needing to tell my mum what I’d found and get the truth from her, although I understand it must be a shock to process and can see why you might not be ready to do that yet.

MrsPerfect12 · 09/09/2021 07:08

Wishing you the best of luck moving forward with this. Flowers

RantyAunty · 09/09/2021 07:05

Glad you came back to update. It's all fascinating.

I've done the match and found my much older half sibling that I didn't know existed. in the divorce, he got custody and my mother just put it all in the closet as he refused to let her see her.

The half sister had a child who she abandoned and was later adopted and she was found through the dna match too. I've talked to them a few times which was quite nice.

I found stories of relatives who were kidnapped as children from both native american and white families and raised in that family. There were a lot of massacres at that time.

It has all been quite interesting and would never have known without the DNA matching.

You mentioned having a brother. Has he taken the test?

MrsLargeEmbodied · 09/09/2021 07:03

do you have children op?
how do you know your dad isnt your dad if he is no longer alive?

FelicityPike · 09/09/2021 06:59
Flowers
BonnyandPoppy · 09/09/2021 06:25

Would these kits tell me if my adult twin daughters were identical twins or not? Maybe I should get us all one for Xmas. I know my dad had lots of affairs so might find a half sibling or two as well.

nonevernotever · 09/09/2021 05:10

I second what @Ophanim said, and just wanted to add that human relationships have always been messy, it's just that the testing we have now makes it a bit more obvious. The figure of 10% quoted by pp is also what I've been told, and I know of one university lecturer who used to be quizzed regularly by his students along the lines of"you said X but you must be wrong because my parents blood groups are such and such." Even in my own family, without doing any testing I know that my paternal gf was the son of a chambermaid. When my parents wanted to marry it took them ages to get DGM to tell them who the father was and it was a traveling salesman who didn't know he'd had a child.on my mother's side, her gf was given the name of his mother's husband at the time of the birth, but she'd left him several years before and his real father was her employer. (This was all known in the family but not talked about, though there are clues there. His birth certificate for instance gives his presumed father's name, but occupation and address are actually his bio father's. She later married the bio father though, so possibly less of a stigma attached than there might otherwise have been.)

Ophanim · 09/09/2021 04:32

Wow, what a revelation! You come across as a very strong and reasonable person - I truly admire you.

PeanutButterFalcon · 09/09/2021 04:15

@DixonD it’s physically impossible for them to be aunties/uncles as well as niece/nephew or grandparent due to ages. These were the other possibilities of how they could be related.

@SusannahSophia you’re correct in your thinking. Going by how we look and act you can guess who has what Dad. But it is a guess I could by wrong and I may never know.

@FATEdestiny no I haven’t told her. I’m not sure if she would want to know. She did the test to help me and got the answer she/we wanted at the time. I’m not sure telling her this would be good for her currently.

@Schweetheart thank you. Me either there have been plenty of opportunities and she knows I don’t give up so I am sur prised.

@Itsnotallaboutyoubaby @Lovealovestory thank you x

@Ophanim thank you. Yes you’re correct. I’ve been sat on what I know for a while now trying to figure out what I do next but I can’t decide what’s best. I think about it daily so I know I have to do something.

OP posts:
Ophanim · 09/09/2021 03:18

OP, am I right that you and your sister are full sisters so have the same father, but he is not the man your mother was married to?
I admire your ability to remain level headed about all this. I’m sure that’s helped you make good decisions.

Lovealovestory · 09/09/2021 01:58
Flowers
Itsnotallaboutyoubaby · 08/09/2021 23:53

I think you are handling this really well OP Flowers for you. I hope you get those answers from your mum someday

Schweetheart · 08/09/2021 23:51

Wow op, what a “story”… I hope you’re ok through it all, must be very strange to have all these discoveries. Can’t believe your mum is not saying anything!

FATEdestiny · 08/09/2021 23:43

Does your full sister know?

SusannahSophia · 08/09/2021 23:43

OP, so your younger sister who was brought up with you, who also did the DNA test, is your full sibling? Your known mum and the mystery bio dad? But you don’t know about your other siblings brought up with you?

Sorry, just being nosy. It’s interesting as an anonymous thread, but it’s your life. Good luck with everything.

DixonD · 08/09/2021 23:31

[quote PeanutButterFalcon]@gingerfreckles over 1700. From what I've researched a full sibling is around 2300/400 and it's below that. Part of me hopes sometimes coincidently you can get this with absolute strangers and it's not from an affair.

@greenlynx from pictures they look younger than me, maybe late teens early 20s. I haven't spoken to them to get an exact age. Definitely not old enough to be a grandparent but to old to be a niece/nephew.

[/quote]
I share 1875cM with my uncle (my mum’s full brother).

It may not be a sibling.

PeanutButterFalcon · 08/09/2021 23:28

@SecretKeeper1 I do not honestly know. I was his favourite (everyone in my family will admit that), but was that to cover up or because he didn’t know. Without asking my DM I can’t say, but I’m not sure she’ll ever give me the answers I want.

Bio dad doesn’t know we know, neither have I met him or mentioned a name. I haven’t brought it up at home since I posted this thread as I worry the affect it could have on my other siblings

OP posts:
PeanutButterFalcon · 08/09/2021 23:24

@FATEdestiny no and no to both those questions. I’m guessing bio dads children and family are his. We’ve worked him out through other DNA matches.

OP posts:
SecretKeeper1 · 08/09/2021 23:22

This is fascinating and sad all at the same time, OP. The man that raised you is no longer with us, but do you think he knew you and your sister weren't biologically his? Obviously your mum must have a good inkling.

And, assuming you have a name for bio father, did you ever meet him? Have you mentioned his name to your mum to gauge her reaction?

PeanutButterFalcon · 08/09/2021 23:22

@SD1978 it wouldn’t be unbelievable if you knew my Dad. He probably has played around and fathered other children so she relied on that hoping I wouldn’t look further.

@Branleuse thank you. The whole time I have been considering my feelings, my families and everyone else involved. I didn’t do the DNA for family links I did it to see the ethnicity side and didn’t consider what it could uncover, maybe the adverts should warn you of this!

@CovidCorvid currently everyone except me and the other person I’ve been speaking too are unaware we know as much as we do. I don’t really know where to go next from here without causing upset to someone else, yet the questions play on my mind often.

@Pinklioness I hope those involved are ok, it’s hard to know you aren’t who you thought you are

OP posts:
FATEdestiny · 08/09/2021 23:19

So is your biological Dad now married to the mother of this person who's DBA you matched?

I take it he was a player. Goodness. Does your nin-biological Dad know?