Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours Ring doorbell

138 replies

Mumz3 · 17/09/2020 09:21

So I live in a block of flats and noticed earlier my neighbour has installed a Ring doorbell which directly faces my flat door. There’s a fire door between our flats so unless it’s open she won’t be recording my actual door all the time but as far as I know these doorbells record any motion they sense for 20/30 seconds? So she’s recording the communal close area whenever someone passes her door (which is very often because her flat is directly to the left of the main door) and I do have to walk past her door to get to the letterboxes or to take my bins out. She’ll inadvertently record anyone that comes to my flat thru the main door as well (so that’s everyone that visits me) and my son at primary school age will be recorded every time he goes to school and back. There is a back door to the flats that I can use but it means a detour round the car park to get to the letterbox or to go to the bin shed. Am I being unreasonable to want her to take the doorbell down?

OP posts:
SafeInBed · 17/09/2020 15:51

The problem is I don't want to be filmed and recorded. Why should I be?

You object to actual cctv in shops etc now too? Even when they can be used to catch criminals?

OneForMeToo · 17/09/2020 15:46

You are allowed to record in public area so your shared footpath issue isn’t an issue.

Inside a communal area within a flats isn’t a public area as such but it’s not a private area either so you would have to check.

To have cctv covering you need to display signs and have correct time stamps etc for it to be legal. We catch part of our neighbours garden and they catch ours we are all ok with it.

Just at the end of our little street is 5/6 houses with known cameras your just as likely to be caught by an outside camera entering your block as you are by the ring camera.

If you complain and it’s all legit though don’t expect any help if you ever need the footage I’d say.

Mumz3 · 17/09/2020 15:46

@Cissyandflora sorry but I don’t agree with the statement that no one would watch just for the sake of it. People are nosy and they probably would. I agree we get watched everywhere as it is and she could just watch thru her spy hole yes but she does have to leave the house to go to work etc and if someone was watching you thru their spy hole constantly it would be weird, the same as recording someone’s door constantly is weird imo

OP posts:
mummydoingamasters · 17/09/2020 15:40

[quote Mumz3]@mummydoingamasters we live in a really good area (one I wouldn’t be able to afford to stay in if we rented privately). Obviously there is some crime but we’ve never been affected by any. If I see her I’ll say to her, we’ve had issues in the past but we’re on talking terms 😂 I just try to avoid her because It’s always gossip about someone.[/quote]
To be honest, I only have mine because we had it at our old house.

To us it's just a doorbell but I can see how others might think of it in as intrusive.

In our case, the opposite neighbour is the gossip 😂 if I go out I have to allow an hour just in case I get stuck 🤦🏻‍♀️

Mumz3 · 17/09/2020 15:33

@mummydoingamasters we live in a really good area (one I wouldn’t be able to afford to stay in if we rented privately). Obviously there is some crime but we’ve never been affected by any. If I see her I’ll say to her, we’ve had issues in the past but we’re on talking terms 😂 I just try to avoid her because It’s always gossip about someone.

OP posts:
Cissyandflora · 17/09/2020 15:31

Something ate someone’s cat? You’re not highly strung to worry about that. That’s a pitchforks response.

Terrace58 · 17/09/2020 15:16

The ring owner tailors the motion sensor zone. Ours tries to capture people approaching our door, but not cars driving by. So it may not actually be triggering on your movement depending on how the owner set it up.

My neighborhood is now covered by cameras. I’m happy about that. It meant I didn’t have to buy one for one side of my house because I knew the neighbors already had it covered. Plus if there is an incident we all check our cameras for any footage that might be useful. That is the culture of our neighborhood though. We are all mostly a bit high strung parents to growing children and things like a pumpkin getting taken from a porch and smashed or something eating someone’s cat are big news.

Cissyandflora · 17/09/2020 15:07

Ask me how I know who stole it

unmarkedbythat · 17/09/2020 15:07

@Iminaglasscaseofemotion

And there's cctv all over the place. When you walk down the street and go into shops, you are being filmed. Whats the problem?
Lots and lots of people have raised this as a problem. Just because it's happening absolutely doesn't mean we are all ok with it. For some people the surveillance we are under is acceptable and makes them feel safer- that's certainly not the case for all of us.

The problem is I don't want to be filmed and recorded. Why should I be?

Cissyandflora · 17/09/2020 15:06

And my first one was stolen by a neighbour who was angry that I had it.

Cissyandflora · 17/09/2020 15:05

I’ve got one and I could watch 3 neighbours but honestly I never even look at it. If someone rings the bell then we look. If you think about it I’m sure on your school run and on the way to the shops you will be caught on camera many times. The posh houses all have cameras. I think my neighbours are unimpressed with mine but as above- it’s no different just because it’s a flat. And no one would watch just for the sake of it. I mean they could watch you through a door spy hole if they wanted.

Mumz3 · 17/09/2020 15:02

@Fantabulous1 yes we do have a buzzer system but it’s just a phone not a camera. We do have spy holes on our doors as well tho so if someone did got let in by accident then u could also just double check before you opened the door

OP posts:
Fantabulous1 · 17/09/2020 14:52

@Mumz3 do you have an external buzzer system to let people in from outside? If so, it wouldn't make any sense for your neighbour to have it on only when the doorbell is pressed as she/he would already know who is at the door.

The doorbell has red lights appear when it is in record mode. Keep an eye on it and you'll know that way if it is recording when you're around. As an FYI mine has started recording overnight from about 8pm to 8am regardless of motion (i think its a new feature)

Astella22 · 17/09/2020 14:45

I one who is in the it’s a positive camp. I think if your doorway was in your own private drive/hall way then I wouldn’t like it so much but your hall is shared and she probably already hears all the comings and going’s you do so I can’t say the ability to potentially record this activity is going to far or breaching my privacy.
Have a chat and see how u feel afterwards

mummydoingamasters · 17/09/2020 14:19

I live in a block of flats and I have a ring door bell. Mine faces the neighbours door also (I actually thought this was about me it was so similar).
Mine is not set to record, I have to pay a monthly fee to keep any activity footage over 30 days and I've turned off motion alerts but you wouldn't know it unless I showed you the app.

I live in an area with a moderate level of crime and I see it as security but I can also see the flip side of someone assuming that they are being recorded.

Do you have a good enough relationship to ask them if there's a reason they got it?

ohbrightlight · 17/09/2020 14:13

Before you complain OP go and knock on your neighbours door and talk to her. It could be that it’s not recording and storing the video, she could set up an exclusion zone or she can explain to you why she has one.

Maybe she feels unsafe in her flat now there has been a burglary and that isn’t a crime.

newsyoucanuse · 17/09/2020 14:02

I wouldn't like this. People are odd, and do stuff all the time that they aren't supposed to. Our neighbour across the road let slip that he likes to keep his camera on all the time and live stream from his phone when he's at work. For no other reason than he can, and see who's going up and down the street. We're on a road with a school, right by the gates so he sees the kids going in and out.
I think it's a bit weird. Why does he bother? I realise that he could sit at his window all day and watch the street too in theory but he doesn't and I would find that odd too...

We're too quick in this country to embrace this big brother camera culture - I think we give up too much privacy for the 'good' all these cameras bring...

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 17/09/2020 13:56

And there's cctv all over the place. When you walk down the street and go into shops, you are being filmed. Whats the problem?

Craddle64 · 17/09/2020 13:53

I'd be happy there is added security and couldnt careless if im recorded as i pass by. I have nothing to hide and if something happened then it will hopefully be evidence in my favour. There are bigger privacy concerns online than that imo.

BigusBumus · 17/09/2020 13:41

We have a lot of CCTV at our property, 10 cameras in all and continuous recording. The ones that pick up neighbours houses, i went round to each and asked if they would like their house "masked", that is creating a black rectangle around their houses and NONE of them said yes. They are all pleased that their houses have the security too.

The least she should have done is ask you first.

SafeInBed · 17/09/2020 13:39

There is a difference, the OP is reasonable to expect privacy when she’s at home.

Outside her door is a communal area, not her home.

MintyMabel · 17/09/2020 13:33

Also her security concerns don’t trump your right to privacy.

Do we have a right to privacy in a public area? There’s no law that stops someone seeing who goes in to my home.

ThePluckOfTheCoward · 17/09/2020 13:27

I wouldn't be happy about that Op, especially at the thought she could be recording your DC. The fact she is a gossip makes it even more worrying.

CausingChaos2 · 17/09/2020 13:19

@SafeInBed

don't have to be up to no good not to want to be watched and recorded!

If you walk down the street people can record you all they want. I don't see the difference.

There is a difference, the OP is reasonable to expect privacy when she’s at home.

It could also be used for nefarious reasons if the neighbour was a wrong’un and could see exactly when her neighbours properties were empty.

SafeInBed · 17/09/2020 13:11

don't have to be up to no good not to want to be watched and recorded!

If you walk down the street people can record you all they want. I don't see the difference.