Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Normal BMI, large waist.

117 replies

lasangoles · 08/09/2020 14:25

My BMI is 24. I'm a size 12. Feel like my weight is OK but could lose a bit. Reading the NHS website, it says you should lose weight if your waist is bigger than 31.5 inches, and see a GP if your waist size is over 34.5 inches and you're at risk of serious health conditions. My waist size is 37.5! Really anxious about my body image. If I lose 6 inches, surely my BMI will be really low? Anyone else experienced similar? I'm 5ft8 and weigh around 11 stone.

OP posts:
Aisforharlot · 08/09/2020 16:46

@Anyonebut
I'm sorry but that's poor advice. You can't spot reduce fat. You can build core muscles up, which will give you more probability of seeing abs at a higher body fat percentage. But where you lose fat (which as a process must be achieved by calorie deficit) is determined by genetics.

AuntyPasta · 08/09/2020 16:43

It’ll come if you keep up the exercise. Planks (done right) are great, don’t take ages and can be done easily at home.

sirfredfredgeorge · 08/09/2020 16:43

'They' need to work out why this is and give advice to reverse the trend.

Because people are more overweight.

BMI is a range, because people are different and it can be a wide range, just like it's perfectly possible for the extremely muscular to not be overweight by BMI, it's also perfectly possible for the non-muscular to be overweight by BMI, hence why we have other measures that go along with it.

People who are not overweight by BMI, but are overweight by measurements are almost certainly overweight, with waist fat being the most correlated with poor outcomes it's probably more concerning than some people who are outside the BMI category.

BMI and waist measurements are both broad measures that could indicate a problem, seeing your GP is the correct advice. The advice does not exist to fat shame people, simply to try and improve the outcome for peoples health.

Aisforharlot · 08/09/2020 16:40

I'm Apple inclined 5" 8 and bounce between 27_32 depending on time of day and bloating. I strength train most days, which seems to help.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 08/09/2020 16:31

@lasangoles

Yes I do 30 mins at least every day. I go to spin classes, abs bums tums, core, I run and I use the stair master. Only recently started exercising regularly though (about 3 months ago).
You will see some difference soon.

Don't forget that fat isn't only what you can grab. As pp said visceral fat is a problem. If your waist is not in any way proportional to the rest of your body it can be indicative of some health issues.
That's why NHS has it there. Not to fat shame.

You should be able to talk to your gp and get some tests done. Fatty liver ain't fun. My shows slightly lower function now.

emmathedilemma · 08/09/2020 16:27

ok, i measured it in the correct place (this is with a DIY tape measure so a bit rigid but i can't find the other one) and mine is 31.5 if I pull it tight. That's well under half my height (66") and i exercise a fair bit, admittedly I've not done much strength work for 6 months thanks to the gym being closed but I've lost weight in that time (mainly through diet changes).

TheSockMonster · 08/09/2020 16:21

Are you absolutely sure you’re measuring your natural waist? A 37 inch waist would be size 18 - 20 in clothes, so highly unlikely you’d be wearing a size 12.

Your natural waist is in the gap between your lowest rib and hip bone. I am short waisted with barely 1mm space between the 2, but it is there! If I put a tape across my belly button I’d be measuring across my hips!

WeeWelshWoman · 08/09/2020 16:21

I have a BMI of 31. But my waist is 32 inches. I think a lot is down to shape/ height etc.

AuntieStella · 08/09/2020 16:14

Some people are just made without much of a waist - even when I'm really fit (distance runner) and down at my racing weight (BMI about 20) my waist is rarely below about 29.

But if it is outwith the NHS receommendation, then the concern if your fitness, and whether you are carrying visceral fat (ie your total body weight is OK, but you are actually carrying a lot of fat) as this raises your risk of a number of conditions, just as obesity does.

The solution is more exercise, including strength training (Pilates, yoga, weights) as well as cardio. It won't whittle your waist as such, but it should pull you into a healthier shape (which will include a firmer midriff)

Batshitbeautycosmeticsltd · 08/09/2020 16:08

I'm very apple shaped since perimenopause. I'd have to truly be miserable with the calories to achieve a small waist size, which I've never had.

lasangoles · 08/09/2020 16:05

Yes I do 30 mins at least every day. I go to spin classes, abs bums tums, core, I run and I use the stair master. Only recently started exercising regularly though (about 3 months ago).

OP posts:
ShivD · 08/09/2020 15:59

What @AuntyPasta said. This is an exercise issue rather than weight loss.

Do you do any exercise OP?

CorianderLord · 08/09/2020 15:53

I'm the same, but a bit smaller. I'm 9st 7 (but shorter than you) and my stomach protrudes - i always look pregnant at 35in. I'd say at 11st you could probably drop a stone and be healthy, but if your stomach doesn't also shrink see a doctor.

I'm going to do this and also improve my fitness as its likely I'm just flabby.

sleepyhead · 08/09/2020 15:43

When I was 11 stone 5 my waist was 39 inches at 5' 6". There's a huge variety.

I had to get down to around 9 stone 12 to get the measurement down to 31.5.

I never had much fat on my legs or arms - my bust was bigger and I carried some on my face, but most of it was sitting round my waist.

BarbaraofSeville · 08/09/2020 15:26

Are you sure you're measuring correctly?

I'm an inch shorter and a stone heavier than you, yet my waist is about 32 inches.

Are you male or female? Do you have noticeable excess weight around your middle?

Although they do say that women's waists have increased more than height, hip size and weight over the past few decades. 'They' need to work out why this is and give advice to reverse the trend.

MrsVeryTired · 08/09/2020 15:22

@Ranunculi cross posted, I am the same height and quite slim when I'm 10.5 stone, waist usually about 31 at that weight, currently about 11 stone and waist about 33, but have broad shoulders and large feet, people can carry weight so differently.

Anyonebut · 08/09/2020 15:21

I agree with AuntyPasta. Given that your concern is your waistline I would concentrate on specific exercises for that area rather than dieting.

damnthatanxiety · 08/09/2020 15:21

@amijustparanoidorjuststoned

Yeah, to fat shame people.

Imagine if every single person in the world, regardless of height, build, career (think rugby player or builder), had a waist under 31.5. It would be pretty odd if someone's body physically will not allow them to shrink their waist to that level without them being seriously underweight.

Err....rugby players don't have thick middles. They have well developed legs and glutes but they are toned and tight through the core.
OwlBasket · 08/09/2020 15:18

I’m not in the UK and the waist size advice is slightly different here: waist size shouldn’t be allowed exceed half of your height.

Is indeed to do with visceral fat, having the limit based on height rather than being fixed takes frame size into account, well a bit anyway. IMO the NHS does tend to massively oversimplify in its advice.

MrsVeryTired · 08/09/2020 15:17

I think the recommended thing is that your waist is less than half your height as clearly the same waist size on someone 5ft and 5ft 10 will not represent the same thing.

Agree with others, you measure the slimmest part of your waist.

Are you bloated at all, or maybe not very fit? When I'm fitter (been ill lately so fitness has declined), I'm chubbier although the same weight as being more toned firms me up more, so same weight but slimmer.

AuntyPasta · 08/09/2020 15:15

Targeted exercise. Exercise brings your waist measurement down and lowers your body fat % without necessarily lowering your weight. It builds muscle.

Eloundahigh · 08/09/2020 15:13

On the recent Michael Mosley TV programme it said waist should be less than half height.

Ranunculi · 08/09/2020 15:03

I posted a thread about this a few days ago. I’m 5ft6, 10.5st and my waist measures 34ins. My BMI is normal (just under 24) but I’m visibly fat, especially on my tummy. I’ve come to the conclusion that it depends on your frame and shape. I have a very small frame and I carry weight on my tummy so 10.5st is fat for me, whereas someone with a bigger frame who carries their weight differently would look slim at the same weight.

Shayisgreat · 08/09/2020 15:01

I think apple shaped women are more likely to have a waist measurement over 31.5 inches as this is where they carry their weight. I think the reason they look for it to be below that is, as pp mentioned, visceral fat around the middle is more dangerous to overall health.

BMI is a useful measure and so is waist measurement. Usually you can stand to lose some weight if either of them are over the recommended number. Obviously build and muscle mass have an effect on it but not so much that either should be totally disregarded.

JemimaTiggywinkle · 08/09/2020 14:55

You’re meant to measure your waist at it’s narrowest point.
I think the reason that waist size is mentioned by NHS is because it’s a risk factor/ indicator for heart problems.

Swipe left for the next trending thread