Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Normal BMI, large waist.

117 replies

lasangoles · 08/09/2020 14:25

My BMI is 24. I'm a size 12. Feel like my weight is OK but could lose a bit. Reading the NHS website, it says you should lose weight if your waist is bigger than 31.5 inches, and see a GP if your waist size is over 34.5 inches and you're at risk of serious health conditions. My waist size is 37.5! Really anxious about my body image. If I lose 6 inches, surely my BMI will be really low? Anyone else experienced similar? I'm 5ft8 and weigh around 11 stone.

OP posts:
PinkGinny · 12/09/2020 00:33

I'm the complete opposite of many posters on here. Height 5' 3". Waist 32, size 14, boobs 34ff My excess weight is distributed all over - I've had many an argument about what I weigh. BMI around 30/31 so obese, definitely fat but [shrug]

My sister however 3 inches taller, 1 stone lighter - waist 38, type 2 diabetic BUT has PCOS. Must be a hormonal impact.

Notcontent · 12/09/2020 00:25

Some people do have an apple shape, but changing your diet could help. Not necessarily eating fewer calories but maybe less processed food, less sugar, etc.

OuiOuiKitty · 12/09/2020 00:18

I had to get my bmi down to 20 to get my waist below the recommended and my periods became irregular. I've just never had a waist, very straight up and down with a wide ribcage. I remember as a teenager weighing 8st at 5'6" and my friend weighing 10.5st at 5'4" having a smaller waist than me due to her having an hourglass figure and her laughing at me calling me fat Confused. That was the beginning of a really unhealthy relationship with dieting and food for me.

Lovely1a2b3c · 12/09/2020 00:07

*had, not has

Lovely1a2b3c · 12/09/2020 00:07

I'm obese (BMI 33) and my waist is 37 inches, dress size 18/20, however when I was a normal weight I always has a 28/29 inch waist and even now my hips are much wider than my waist (so massive!) and I'm an F cup so a very chunky hourglass.

APheasantPluckersSon · 11/09/2020 23:21

Sorry OP, I semi-hijacked your thread but am in a similar position with lots of visceral fat but ok size arms and legs (so don’t look overweight at a glance as I tend to hide my tummy).

APheasantPluckersSon · 11/09/2020 23:20

There are a few here who’ve mentioned being pre-diabetic - can I ask what happened? Did you reverse it? What did you do that was effective, if so?

I was recently diagnosed as pre-diabetic and the Dr has put me on Metformin. I’m trying hard to lose weight but it’s very slow (probably around 2kg in 3 months) and I have a similar problem with my stomach (37 / 38 inches but it has a tendency to bloat).

stopgap · 11/09/2020 23:09

I have that body shape, although I’m thin with it. I’m 32D-26.5-35 and nearly 5’8. If I gain, it only goes on my waist. My mum has the same hip size as me, but then a 34-inch waist. Two of her sisters are diabetic. I’m literally obsessed with keeping my weight— and therefore waist size—consistent, as I’ve already been pre diabetic through having insulin resistance.

Roae · 11/09/2020 22:53

I haven’t posted in a while, and I’ve NC-hopefully not recognised!

For all those in disbelief- I too have a waist around 37+. I’m going to attach an image to show it. Whilst I could obviously lose weight I’m generally fit and I don’t think if you saw me in the street you’d fall over in shock. My bmi is normal. Bit of a mum girth, but I’ve never gone in much. This is a pretty average picture, not flattering but not awful.

Just posting for those who say it can’t be true... Yes, I would benefit from losing it, but it’s far from an unbelievable number I think the reality is many people must as I feel quite middling when I’m out on the street

Normal BMI, large waist.
Floatyboat · 11/09/2020 22:26

That sounds quite unhealthy op. Are you sure you're measuring it right.

damnthatanxiety · 11/09/2020 21:55

@Egghead68

My BMI is around 22, I do 3-minute planks and loads of abs exercises and my waist is around 34 inches.
Having strong abs is unrelated to the amount of fat being carried around the middle. Fat people can have strong abs. Thin people can have weak abs. The time you can hold a plank is irrelevant
TheOrigBrave · 08/09/2020 22:12

@lasangoles

Hips I'm a size 12, occasionally 14. Boobs I'm a 34GG!
I mean in inches.
Pinkshrimp · 08/09/2020 22:09

@doadeer

I'm really confused by your measurements OP. I'm 5ft 8 too, still losing a bit of baby weight I'm 12st 2 which is an overweight BMI (just) have about 5 lbs to get to a healthy BMI but my waist is 30.5". Pre baby it was 27. I'm a size 14 at the moment (or a 13 if they existed)

Are you sure yours is 37" or did I misread?

People are different. What’s confusing? At 5ft 9 weighing 11stone 3 my waist was 34.5 inches Now at 9 stone 4 my waist is 29.1 inches, not much less than yours even though I’m lighter. People carry weight differently.
thecatsthecats · 08/09/2020 21:53

@JinglingHellsBells

I have a BMI of 31. But my waist is 32 inches. I think a lot is down to shape/ height etc.

BMI 31 is classed as obese. Wherever that weight is stored, it's too much.

Well, not necessarily a disaster.

I have a bmi of just under 30 - I have a big muscle mass AND some fat. My waist is less than half my height, blood pressure perfect, can run 10k. Can score a beep test result that would qualify me for the fire service. Resting heart rate of an elite athlete.

Yes, I can lose weight, and yes, I will lose the rest. But the process of losing six stone of weight has made me very attuned to MY body and health, not standardised measurements, and I'm healthy as a horse.

Griefmonster · 08/09/2020 21:49

OP using clothing sizes as a measurement is pointless. If you want to understand your body and risk factors you need to be more precise. And waist measurement is one of the most reliable. But as a PP has said - it is your choice. If you don't mind, are willing to live with some risks to you health associated with large waist size , than that is your choice.

lasangoles · 08/09/2020 21:43

Hips I'm a size 12, occasionally 14. Boobs I'm a 34GG!

OP posts:
TheOrigBrave · 08/09/2020 21:40

What are your hips and bust size?

SchrodingersImmigrant · 08/09/2020 19:59

An awful lot of minimising of the risks going on here and people saying they are a rectangle etc.

Sadly I agree. And pp had a point about GPs brushing it off often. It's really crap. Everyone in my family with big belly while ok elsewhere had some health issues ranging from diabetes 1 to heart failure. Or both🙄

KizzyWayfarer · 08/09/2020 19:57

Hmm. Are you allowed to pull your tummy in? If I measure ‘where I crease when I bend sideways’ I get 34 inches relaxed and 31 if I pull my muscles in. This is straight after dinner when I do tend to look like I’m a few months pregnant!

Batshitbeautycosmeticsltd · 08/09/2020 19:56

but if your waist is as big as the OP's or close to that, you need to lose it. It's a no brainer.

No, you don't. You can chose to live with it knowing some risks are higher, but that doesn't mean they are a certainty. But it's a choice adults can make.

UnaCorda · 08/09/2020 19:53

Yeah, to fat shame people.

Don't be ridiculous. Whatever your opinion of the NHS I don't think fat shaming is one of their objectives.

JinglingHellsBells · 08/09/2020 19:52

An awful lot of minimising of the risks going on here and people saying they are a rectangle etc.

You can still be a rectangle rather than an hourglass- I am ( small boobs, small hips) - but if your waist is as big as the OP's or close to that, you need to lose it. It's a no brainer.

British Heart Foundation here...

www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/heart-matters-magazine/medical/measuring-your-waist#:~:text=A%20larger%20waist%20usually%20also,coronary%20heart%20disease%20and%20diabetes.

Ernieshere · 08/09/2020 19:47

My posture is shocking though.Sad

SkatingWithPenguins · 08/09/2020 19:47

To explain to those wondering about trousers. I have a 36.5 waist, hips are about the same. Bum is small. So not big on the trousers as they sit under my belly button before the bit that should go in. Dresses are harder. I’m totally straight up my thoughts, hips and waist. Don’t need to undo trousers to take them on or off

SkatingWithPenguins · 08/09/2020 19:43

Hello, you appear to be me!
I’m 5’9, healthy bmi comfortably. I’m fit, cycle everywhere, row, do yoga. Easily do ten miles on the bikes on hill with a double trailer as boggy group regularly. Resting pulse v low.

...but....my waist is 36.5, more if bloated. It’s not a pot belly at all, just doesn’t go in at all, I’m a rectangle.

Swipe left for the next trending thread