Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Normal BMI, large waist.

117 replies

lasangoles · 08/09/2020 14:25

My BMI is 24. I'm a size 12. Feel like my weight is OK but could lose a bit. Reading the NHS website, it says you should lose weight if your waist is bigger than 31.5 inches, and see a GP if your waist size is over 34.5 inches and you're at risk of serious health conditions. My waist size is 37.5! Really anxious about my body image. If I lose 6 inches, surely my BMI will be really low? Anyone else experienced similar? I'm 5ft8 and weigh around 11 stone.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheBeesElbows · 27/10/2021 13:35

@Batshitbeautycosmeticsltd

I love all this 'See your GP' on nearly every other thread and the NHS itself pushing this, yet again on nearly every other thread is how shit the GP service is in a lot of places now, not able to get any appointment, only by phone, fobbed off, no tests being done. Honestly, the NHS isn't very good at getting to the bottom of things like this often enough. It's usually just 'Well, lose weight' and signposting to NHS diet sites is what you'll get.

I was put on a AD that is legendary for weight gain. Never told anything about it. I found out about it myself and staved off the weight gain by literally stuffing myself with veg whenever I'm hungry (it's an appetite stimulus) and/or caning water or veggie soup/broth based soup. But otherwise, I'd be overweight. As it is I'm apple shaped.

'I found out about it myself'... as in by reading the patient information leaflet that comes with the medication you are prescribed to give you, the patient, the information you need about the medication you are taking? When you say 'never told anything about it' - do you mean you feel your GP should have read the leaflet to you?
ArchwizardTVampirebat · 27/10/2021 13:00

BMI of 24 here as well and waist is 31 sucked in and 33 out. I've been losing weight and have about a stone to go so hoping it will go under 30.

My hips are only 34 inches - but I have a 40 inch bust - awful being an inverted triangle.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 27/10/2021 12:56

I am 5'10" with a BMI of 26.3 and have 41" waist. Shock All my perimenopause weight gain has gone straight around my middle - I look 6 months pregnant - how can I target this area specifically?

aussiechick01 · 27/10/2021 12:44

Drat! Have just seen how old this thread is Hmm

aussiechick01 · 27/10/2021 12:42

Haven’t read the full thread but your waist to hip ratio is probably a better gauge alongside the BMI as it’s a general population measurement that doesn’t really account for people with more muscle mass.

urbanbuddha · 27/10/2021 02:58

As pps have said it's visceral fat that's the problem. It's difficult to shift.

Marvellousmadness · 27/10/2021 02:29

Look into building muscle.
Instead of losing weight perhaps?

vladdy · 27/10/2021 01:55

Anyone still concerned over the "big waist" issue? it's so frustrating, being told I'm at "health risk" when my BMI is under 22, I'm 5'7" and 137 (in US, not UK)----yet because of a waist that is 33 and hips that are 371/2, I'm at risk.

Yet, if my hips were say, 43, then the ratio would be acceptable, which makes no sense, as I'd actually be fatter.

Is this still an issue?

MrsVeryTired · 13/09/2020 12:40

I suppose if you think about it, lots of people have different body shapes so the BMI healthy range is meant to account for that. People who are large built (broad shoulders, large hands and feet etc) will be heavier when carrying the same amount of excess weight as people of a petite build. If you aren't broad then its probably best for health purposes to aim for the lower end of BMI. So BMI of 24-25 is really only healthy for those who are larger built.

Basically if you have a BMI of 24 ish and a waist size over half your height it would be better for your health to lose weight.

Roae · 12/09/2020 18:24

This motivated me to just measure. That photo from spring is 38... I’m actually down to 34.5 today.
That’s a lesson in perception on how it creeps up, it hadn’t occurred to me to remeasure as I’d been around that size for a long time, not losing belly went I’d lost elsewhere over the year.

Roae · 12/09/2020 18:20

(And it’s a bit ridiculous to point out I’m not overweight elsewhere, that’s the whole reason I posted. I do not have an overweight BMI... so I couldn’t actually have a large belly AND be overweight elsewhere... or I’d be overweight full stop.
I do yoga, cycle, fun, shred and do a lot of exercise and eat better than I ever have. Weight loss though isn’t instant is it?
The point is for some it’s the hardest place and some of us are not proportionate or pear shaped)

Roae · 12/09/2020 18:15

@JinglingHellsBells please see my previous post just above yours.

You have misread my post (if you read it).

I’m well aware of ‘could’, but I’m on a journey where I have already lost a fair bit... and that was not in anyway the point of my post. I wasn’t asking for opinions, but explaining to some on here the how.

JinglingHellsBells · 12/09/2020 18:03

@Roae Comparing yourself to other people is not a good idea as more than 60% of people are overweight.

From your photo, I'd say just looking at it and not seeing a 3D version of you, that you could lose anything from 7lbs to a stone to get rid of the midriff bulge.

It's not about how 'fit' you are, (as in being able to cycle) because the fat you can see on the outside is often replicated on the inside, around your organs like liver , pancreas and heart.

Eventually, 'fitness' will change into a chronic health issue because of where the fat is stored.

The good news is you don't look overweight anywhere else, so maybe in 6 -8 weeks with dropping carbs and portion sizes, you could easily lose the the midriff ?

Roae · 12/09/2020 17:40

Apologies for my tone then, I thought you were being deliberately obtuse (and I’m sensitive about my belly!)

Griefmonster · 12/09/2020 17:19

@Roae thank you for pointing out I did misread your post. I thought you were the OP with a name change. I am sorry.

Roae · 12/09/2020 11:46

If anyone sees that and doesn’t want to scroll back- I posted for those saying she was measuring incorrectly. I was demonstrating it was quite likely to be an accurate measurement and wasn’t unbelievable someone could be that shape. Lots of people were exclaiming before my post it just couldn’t be right.

Roae · 12/09/2020 11:44

@Griefmonster re-read my post slowly and in full, you’ll be less het up than the post you’ve imagined where you believe I’m justifying it or don’t acknowledge I would benefit from losing it.

Griefmonster · 12/09/2020 11:34

@Roae and others who are concentrating on how you look, particularly in comparison to other people or what other people would think if they saw you. It doesn't work like that!

Waist measurement over half your height is a really good indicator of an unhealthy distribution of fat. It could be genetics, body shape, frame, diet, whatever. The underlying indication though is that it will increase risk factors.

Makes no difference if you fit in to a size 12, 14 whatever or "nobody would think I was fat!" It doesn't mean those risk factors are reduced. If you are interested in protecting against those risk facrors, then you need to get to know more about your body. If that isn't your focus, then why be on this thread?

BlueberryDream · 12/09/2020 08:59

I posted a thread about this at one stage too

For people saying clothes won't fit - what happens is because your hip size is generally the right size, you can still get into clothes that fit you even if your waist is large.

I'm 5'5'' and a bit and when I was overweight at 72kg I still fitted in 12-14 clothes even though my waist size was enormous (my hips were still 38'' and my waist was 34/35'')

I had to get down to 60kg before it even became a reasonable size but I'm still undoubtedly an apple no matter what I do. I don't think perimenopause/menopause is helping

ChasingRainbows19 · 12/09/2020 08:56

I’ve never had a tiny waist and it was over 31 inches and I assumed it was just my shape straight up no curve there, I was active and swam and did spin classes

.im pear shaped so not a big tum that’s my thighs and arse butI was wrong.. Now still a similar weight but my waist is under 30 thanks to yoga of all things ( taken 2 years probably) but I have a little definition and a waist that now goes in! I haven’t tried it’s just happened with all the core work in yoga. So there was obviously more there than I thought.

Just offering a different view

IamMaz · 12/09/2020 08:46

I have just measured mine - it's bloody 37" !!!!!

pinkbalconyrailing · 12/09/2020 07:59

There are a few here who’ve mentioned being pre-diabetic - can I ask what happened? Did you reverse it? What did you do that was effective, if so?

because I also had an unhappy liver the dr recommended I do an interval fasting programme plus lowish fat.

I did 5/2 for about 3 months and the blood test showed normal blood sugar and improved liver function.
then switched to 16/8 for maintenance. I've been doing 16/8 since then (3years) but not very strict. my bloods now are fine.

Destinysdaughter · 12/09/2020 06:44

I'm an apple shape and the only way I've managed to lose weight from my middle is to do low carb, I don't know why, I think bloating from sugar may be part of it?

stopgap · 12/09/2020 01:10

@OuiOuiKitty, same. I have a friend who’s 5’2 and weighs the same as me (125 pounds, but I’m nearly 5’8) and she is two dress sizes smaller on account of having a big butt and legs but small waist. Clothes are not made with our body shape in mind. But we usually have fabulous legs, so there’s that!

stopgap · 12/09/2020 01:08

@APheasantPluckersSon, I started inositol and that alone reversed my insulin resistance. I have PCOS, so insulin resistance comes with the territory. I was already eating lowish carb, and continue to do so. I’m thin (nearly 5’8 and 125 pounds) so don’t do without carbs completely as I look drawn.