Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult children still at home...

235 replies

CornishPastyEater · 09/08/2020 20:57

Hi all, my first post and I need your help, please!
Our two adult children aged 30 and 23 still live at home. The older one has a very well paid job but is showing absolutely no inclination to branch out and buy their own home, despite having told us that there are some savings and a very good income. Pays a modest monthly 'keep' but as lazy as anything and creates work.
The younger one's job has gone so is looking for other employment.
Am I being unreasonable to try to make it clear the older one needs to make their own way in the world? I'm fed up with being a constant mummy!
If I broach the subject there's always a row, shouting and stomping.
How do I make it clear change is needed?

OP posts:
Meruem · 10/08/2020 10:16

I find it interesting as well that people look back on their time in bedsits etc with fondness. I had to move out at age 16 and it was utterly shit. I remember one room I rented was a converted bathroom, tiny and no proper window. I cried myself to sleep every night. I would never want my DC to have to live in some of the shit places I lived in, forking out £££ for the privilege. I felt jealous of my friends living in a nice home with nice parents. All I did with my "independence" was get drunk (because I was so depressed) and sleep with unsuitable men! Ok 16 is a bit different to 30! But I have seen a lot of threads where people are saying to kick 17/18 yr olds out, saying it will be "the making of them" and maybe it will, but also maybe it won't. My life got a heck of a lot worse before it got better.

CorianderLord · 10/08/2020 10:16

23 and lost his job? V normal to stay home.

30 and not saving for a house but at home? Tel him he needs to think about leaving mummy's nest

Savingshoes · 10/08/2020 10:16

Put a "for sale" sign outside the home. When they ask, tell them you're bought a one bedroom flat in a remote area such as an island.
If they don't get the hint, you might need to put them out with the bins as they might be broken.

Flatpackback · 10/08/2020 10:09

They need telling that by living in the parental home as adults, they are there as contributing adults, not children. This means fair shares of cooking cleaning, good shopping, meal planning etc. You're doing them no favours in the long run by letting them duck these issues. Male children need to morph into men at some point otherwise their partners get a shoddy deal and relationships fail.

HUCKMUCK · 10/08/2020 10:01

*I dont think 172k is much nowadays. Of single, she could buy a flat but does she have a pension?

That kind of money wouldn't even take you far in major cities.*

Are you for real? It is a massive amount to have in savings. Of course it might not buy a property outright but most people don't do that anyway - that's what mortgages are for. This person could buy a decent house with a small mortgage and have it paid off well before retirement.

CantSleepClownsWillEatMe · 10/08/2020 09:58

@Fairyliz

I have DD’s in their 20’s and this is extremely common especially with men. Why should they leave home when they pay little board, have everything done for them and can bring partners home whenever they want? When I was that age (80’s), your parents wouldn’t have dreamt of letting a boyfriend stay over so that was a good push to leave home. So MN’s with teens be a little careful when you let your child’s boyfriend/girlfriend stay over.
I think that’s probably a good tip @Fairyliz Grin.
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/08/2020 09:55

There’s def. something to be said for the olden days of my yoof, when most people’s parents were on such a different planet, we couldn’t wait to move out. Even to a grotty bedsit with a shared bathroom where other tenants left their pubes 🤮in the bath.

Fairyliz · 10/08/2020 09:51

I have DD’s in their 20’s and this is extremely common especially with men. Why should they leave home when they pay little board, have everything done for them and can bring partners home whenever they want?
When I was that age (80’s), your parents wouldn’t have dreamt of letting a boyfriend stay over so that was a good push to leave home.
So MN’s with teens be a little careful when you let your child’s boyfriend/girlfriend stay over.

Meruem · 10/08/2020 09:49

My DD and DS both have ASD. They are 29&30. Both have lived out of home in the past. DD was living with a partner but the relationship broke down so she moved back in. DS was working abroad but then Covid hit and he came home. They have for years now done their own washing, cooking etc, contributed to bills. We live in London so even a room in a shared house is £600 p/m. Honestly I didn't expect them to be living at home at this age and I sometimes wonder how it would be to live alone! But they are respectful and we all have an adult relationship. I don't "mother" them anymore. It works both ways in that I can (and do) go off myself for months at a time knowing the house is being kept running and taken care of. It is harder nowadays to branch out on your own and everyone's circumstances are different. But I do think it's important to shift from that mother/child relationship to adults sharing a house for it to work.

monkeyonthetable · 10/08/2020 09:48

There's a technique to booting them out called 'reduce the comfort'. Start making it less and less comfortable for them to be in your home. Impose strict rules. Expect absolute fairness in financial contributions - 25% of council tax, water, gas and electricity rates, food bills, house maintenance. expect them to do the garden, paint the walls, wash the windows, clean the bathroom, hoover the stairs, cook and clear up meals twice a week, do the weekly shop once a month and foot the bill for it, including having to schlep to another shop or two if the usual supermarket is out of some of the things on the list. Etc etc.

If they are adults, fully pulling their weight, then in some ways their presence should make life easier for you. Your workload should be reduced by 50% due to having two other adults helping out. If they won't do this, hugely increase what you charge them to live with you and explain it is because they cause extra expense and workload for you. generally, make life fair and adult until this feels normal to them.

stonecoasters · 10/08/2020 09:45

I'm 30 and find this crazy! No way would I even want to live at my parents house, I'd be so embarrassed.

CantSleepClownsWillEatMe · 10/08/2020 09:39

That's worrying because at 49, it's likely her parents are in their 70s and won't be around/in good health forever.

What will she do when they need her help or the inevitable happens and she's on her own?

I think that’s the trade off in this type of situation though isn’t it? The dc who had the benefit of this level of financial, emotional and practical support until well into middle age will most likely have to do the heavy lifting as the parents age. Tbh I don’t think that’s unfair.

Bmidreams · 10/08/2020 09:39

I think parents that are happy for older children to be home fail to recognise that they are impeding their child's development. They are doing them no favours whatsoever, they are harming them.

I also don't understand parents fearful to have the conversation due to strops etc. You hold all the cards, the power is all yours. It is they who should be endearing themselves to you! They have everything to lose, you have everything to gain.

mklanch · 10/08/2020 09:38

mu auntie lived with my nan and grandad with a child for about 8 years. she moved out at around 28 with her boyfriend, got pregnant has the baby they broke up and she was back to my nan and grandads when she was almost 30. she stayed there for almost 10 years, but to be honest she had an easy life with no finacial worry. she worked part time, (because she didnt want to work full time), she didnt help my nan and grandad in their fish and chip shop and had full time babysitters. also my nan and grandad paid for everything, eating out numerous times a week, and clothes my auntie wanted, everything for her child. (she was also one of those people that always wanted designer jeans etc)
even though i was just a kid at the time even we would say omg i would be embarrassed to be like that. but to be honest my nan and grandad allowed it so it was their fault. they constantly would offer to buy things and encouraged her to move in with them.
i think if you want you children to move out and be independent you have to be very firm and dont back down. in the long run if they continue to mooch of you then they wont ever be independant.

ClementineWoolysocks · 10/08/2020 09:37

@maddiemookins16mum

I know someone living with parents still, she’s nearly 41. Has 172K savings (she told me one night after drink had been taken). Doesn’t know how to use the washing machine. Earns 35K a year, 3 holidays a year. She gives her mum....£50 a month. Her mum is 66 and cleans in a supermarket to pay the bills.
What a POS, I'd be telling her a few home truths after drink had been taken.
Abraid2 · 10/08/2020 09:37

A lot of 23-year-olds are at home at the moment! THey left their cramped rooms in city flats at the beginning of lockdown and many have lost jobs or haven't been able to find jobs after graduating from fulltime higher education. My son is one such. Trying to find work, going for interviews. Next door there's a 24-year-old who just lost his job at the end of furlough.

BarbaraofSeville · 10/08/2020 09:30

@FortunesFave

My SIL is STILL at home and she's 49 years old. She's never left.

She had a baby by donor, by choice...and is now very reliant on her parents.

They don't complain but I know they worry about her. She can't be happy living the way she does. No job or real social life either.

It's arrested development. She's obviously not going anywhere now...not at almost 50.You don't want that do you OP?

That's worrying because at 49, it's likely her parents are in their 70s and won't be around/in good health forever.

What will she do when they need her help or the inevitable happens and she's on her own?

sbhydrogen · 10/08/2020 09:28

I'm in my early 30s and have just moved back home (!!) with DH and DD in order to supersave for a deposit within the next year. However, I do all our own washing, cooking, cleaning etc.

You need to tell the older one that they need to pull their weight around the house or start paying up.

Burnthurst187 · 10/08/2020 09:27

@Greyblueeyes

Your 30 year old sounds incredibly immature. You need to stop doing anything for him. No cooking, cleaning, laundry. Honestly, I would be pretty disgusted by his attitude. I would tell him he needs to move out.

It's one thing if he's respectful and pulls his weight. Your son sounds like a spoiled child and needs to grow up

Him?

Why have you automatically assumed the eldest is male?

Neither sexes have been mentioned before your post

TitsOutForHarambe · 10/08/2020 09:27

£172k isn't much. Really, its not.

Ok.

MN is so surreal sometimes

Burnthurst187 · 10/08/2020 09:25

Why would the oldest want to move out when they have everything they need at home, basically get to keep their entire salary each month to spend how they want, contribute basically nothing to the household and have Mummy to still pander to their every need?

I take it they aren't in a relationship?

The oldest should be saving money in every single area wherever possible to build up a huge deposit and then get a big foot up on the housing ladder. You don't mention this. I feel for your youngest, loosing their job and also they're seven years younger. Big difference in 23 and 30 and having no job compared to a good job

I think you need to set some targets for the oldest. No plans to move out doesn't sound particularly healthy to me

Pinklynx · 10/08/2020 09:22

Obviously I'd be there for my kids if they needed a stop gap, unemployment, in between rented flats etc. But it would always be a short term measure past 25. For instance if they wanted to save for a deposit, I wouldn't have them there for longer than 18 months. They'd also have to help in the house and look after their own washing and ironing.

OP it's good for confidence, independence, learning to be a good partner, parent etc to live on their own. It's really not being kind to allow this to continue. Prepare your strategy. Don't be manipulated by complaints that you don't love them (I'm doing this because I love you etc.). Give them a deadline and stick to it. Keep reminding them of how long they have left every week. They'll just have to move into a hostel or hotel if they won't find anything.

It will also be a reminder for your other child.

No neurotypical adult needs to live with their parents forever.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 10/08/2020 09:20

My DD is 33 and would LOVE to be able to move out.

There are no full-time jobs in the area (all p/t or zero hours). She pays £100 month board but as she is on minimum wage and 16hours/week I think that's reasonable, and also does her own washing etc.

She's working towards a qualification with the OU that she hopes will give her more than just a massive student debt. My heart aches for her sometimes - she tries so hard, but seems to get nowhere. SHe's very bright, too - but Asperger's so finds some things eg interviews very, very challenging.

FortunesFave · 10/08/2020 09:20

My SIL is STILL at home and she's 49 years old. She's never left.

She had a baby by donor, by choice...and is now very reliant on her parents.

They don't complain but I know they worry about her. She can't be happy living the way she does. No job or real social life either.

It's arrested development. She's obviously not going anywhere now...not at almost 50.You don't want that do you OP?

CantSleepClownsWillEatMe · 10/08/2020 09:16

This is the other side of all those threads we see where posters declare they simply wouldn’t dream of charging their adult dc to live in “their own home” and insist that it will always be theirs as much as the parents.

The problem arises when you get this failure to launch situation which actually isn’t only about the adult dcs independence but also very much impacts the parents lives, practically and financially.

I know some adults who do live with parents but it’s usually for a reason such as helping support a single mum or the adult dc can’t afford market rent or mortgage. The difference is they have a grown up relationship so contribute properly to the household, not just financially but in terms of shopping, cooking, cleaning, home maintenance etc.

I will never understand how adult dc carry on seeing their parents only as mum and dad, whose primary reason for existing is seemingly to meet the dcs needs Confused. Unfortunately OP you’ve allowed this situation to go on too long! Time for a direct conversation with 30 year old, making it clear that you are no longer going to parent them as though they are children and that you expect them to make plans to move out within a reasonable period of time.

It sounds like the younger one can’t afford to but that doesn’t mean you can’t make changes. Tell them they must step up and start pulling their weight and if they don’t like it they need to look for alternative accommodation.