Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult children still at home...

235 replies

CornishPastyEater · 09/08/2020 20:57

Hi all, my first post and I need your help, please!
Our two adult children aged 30 and 23 still live at home. The older one has a very well paid job but is showing absolutely no inclination to branch out and buy their own home, despite having told us that there are some savings and a very good income. Pays a modest monthly 'keep' but as lazy as anything and creates work.
The younger one's job has gone so is looking for other employment.
Am I being unreasonable to try to make it clear the older one needs to make their own way in the world? I'm fed up with being a constant mummy!
If I broach the subject there's always a row, shouting and stomping.
How do I make it clear change is needed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ahsoka2001 · 05/06/2023 22:03

Shatteredconfidence · 10/08/2020 00:12

This is happening with my parents. My youngest sibling is almost 31, still at home, well paid full time job.

My parents cook them dinner every night.

They have to be nagged to clean up after themselves.

Contributes nothing to household, neither money nor groceries nor helping out.

My parents have bought them a car which they fuel, insure and maintain.

I honestly think it is pathetic and I despair.

I have tried to speak to my mum but it is pointless.

At least they're working full-time though? It's not like they're sitting around without a job

Ragwort · 14/08/2020 14:01

What a tough situation Jules - you sound much more tolerant than I would be Grin.

julesbythesea · 14/08/2020 12:56

Xenia and Ragwort - dd's bf lives a 4 hr drive away and he got a job near us so we agreed he could stay here while they saved - it's just gone on a bit longer than we'd hoped. I normally love my dd's company and we've had a few "discussions" to try and clear the air but feel I'm becoming passive aggressive a lot of the time, esp that I'm in the middle trying to keep the peace. I suppose the lockdown situation - everyone wfh (5 of us in the house!) doesn't help. Thanks guys for your comments. x

monkeyonthetable · 14/08/2020 09:23

I don't have any problem with adult children returning to the family nest as adults. Lots of cultures have several generations of adults living together and it can be a real bonus. But they must behave like adults. Fair financial contribution. Fair share of cooking, cleaning, maintenance. Respect for the existing house rules (eg how clean and tidy the place should be kept day-to-day; noise levels etc.) Adult children who want a very different way of living have to find their own accommodation.

Ragwort · 14/08/2020 08:27

We are all different Big - personally I love peace and quiet in my own home Grin. Of course I love my DS but I also want him to live an independent life, to make his own 'home' and future and have the sort of lifestyle that he wants ....... just as I love my own parents but I don't want to live with them.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 14/08/2020 07:40

Some of these posts do seem a bit harsh and unfeeling, as though you can’t wait for your DCs to grow up and piss off!

I understand we need to enable independence etc but don’t you enjoy their company?

Me, DH and our DDs (19) have our cross irritable moments with each other but I genuinely enjoy their company most of the time. They bring a lot of life to the house with their youth, friends, music etc. I will miss them, I don’t want a quiet show house.

BitOfFun · 14/08/2020 00:34

That's pretty much my feeling on it too, Ragwort. I understand that there's a housing crisis, but boyfriends/girlfriends can have the crisis at their own parents' place, surely? There's got to be some motivation for them to be independent.

Ragwort · 13/08/2020 09:57

jules why does the BF have to live with you?

I would be furious to have my adult DS's GF (or BF) living in our home, paying cheap 'rent', earning more than me yet swanning around playing golf etc.

Why put up with it? I do think many parents make it far too cosy for their adult DC, sounds tough but I have made it plain to my DS that 'lovers' are not allowed to stay overnight (unless by pre arrangement in the guest room Grin) and certainly not 'move in' even on a temporary basis.

I couldn't wait to leave home and start living independently, yes I know it's hard these days but plenty of young people do manage it. If my DS and I fall out over that decision - so what, I had plenty of heated discussions with my parents when I was growing up but we got through it, I respect their decisions and we get on absolutely fine.

Xenia · 13/08/2020 09:15

This is a very interesting thread and shows how differently many parents deal with these issues. I live in the London borough with the most hindus who actually make lovely neighbours as divorce rates are low and everyone is very stable and works very hard indeed. They often (not always) live with the husband's parents in multi generational homes and there are pros and cons to that - not all women want to live with their mother in law.

At school one of my friends (white British) had to share a bed with her grandmother who sometimes wet the bed. That was pretty awful and my own mother always said put me in a home when older as I have seen far too many old people become a burden and ruin the lives of the family. Other families find it works well.

In my family history work the census records for our family back to 1841 provide a wonderful snap shot every 10 years of how the family lives and who lived with whom. Often I see a widowed parent of either gender moving in with one of the children and their family or a woman widowed young who then lived with one of her sons for life if the son never married even back in the 1800s that was common and of course then some of those boys would have been gay so not surprisingly they never married.

As for today I would say be clear with people. My son knew I stopped supporting him on 1 July of this year when his finished his degree and he had known that for 10 years at least as I have the same deal with all 5 children although I wold not throw them on to the streets; the only caveat being if he did some sensible post grad studies I would support him in that (which is what he is now going to do starting next month for 2 years).

The poster a bit above who mentioned the child plus partner both earning more than both parents put together where the partner spends money on golf etc that sounds bit unreasonable. I feel once they have jobs they should really move out. The only reason my older son stayed longer is he is 10 years older than the twins, did not want to leave and was able to be their au pair, do school collection etc so I felt there was mutual use in that arrangement with a date for him to leave of when the twins left for university. He has lived independently since other than having the same help towards a property as his older sisters have.

BubblyBluePebbles · 13/08/2020 00:58

We've also got another property that they could move into and live in independently if need be, but they would need to be working FT in order to be able to afford the rent and running costs.

BubblyBluePebbles · 13/08/2020 00:52

*24 year old DD (not DS)

They would continue to only work PT if they could, to avoid having to move out. Pre-Covid, they already said that they're not planning on moving out anytime soon!

jimmyjammy001 · 13/08/2020 00:40

What you have to remember is there is a massive housing crisis in the UK and a renting crisis buying or renting now is not like you used to be able to do when you got married, kids need the bank of mummy and daddy, max out mortgage, max out help to buy schemes in order to just buy a one bed flat or else be stuck renting forever whilst rich landlords buy up multiple properties and rent them out for their retirement, usually kids live at home to save up a deposit but as prices of houses have gone thru the roof they have to stay at home longer to save up. If they were buying new cars and going on lots old holidays and wasting money then by all means kick them our

BubblyBluePebbles · 13/08/2020 00:33

Our eldest is 24. We also have 2 primary school aged DC. 24 yr old DS has only ever worked PT and finished uni 2 yrs ago. They've had PT jobs since they were 15. We were happy for them to live at home whilst at uni because they went to a specialist uni in London and London rents are obvs crazy. DC didn't take out a student loan, so only has to pay back tuition fees. We bought them their own laptop in their 1st year of uni. They paid for their own clothing (heavily discounted as they worked in fashion retail), socialising and travel into central London 3 days a week from their PT wages. We only started taking 30% contribution late last year. We gave DS the opportunity to suggest the percentage so they couldn't then complain down the line. 30% is also what we had in mind, so all good. We felt that a percentage would be better instead of a fixed figure until they find their desired post uni FT job as their PT wages fluctuate. We are secretly planning to give their 30% household contribution back to them for their future deposit on a property. Previous to contributing financially they were constantly ordering online (mainly clothing and takeaways), ordering Uber's instead of walking 10 mins to the tube station! They resigned from a job so they could go on holiday for 4 wks to an expensive destination, as they knew they wouldn't be granted leave during the Xmas/NY period! And then went off travelling again in Feb whilst unemployed. They were lucky to then get a temp keyworker 0 hours job a few wks into lockdown.
I do their laundry as I practically run a laundrette, as we're a 5 person household. If they did their own laundry they would mess up my production line, use more water, energy and we'd struggle for drying space for items that have to be line dried. They have to fold their own laundry. They know how to operate the washing machine and dryer. They buy most of their own food and cook for themselves most days and they sometimes cook for us all. I also sometimes cook for them. They hardly ever babysit their younger siblings as we both work, are always tired and hardly ever go out. They rarely help out with housework unless asked. I will leave their mess for them to clean up, including phoning and sending text msgs upstairs to them in their room to come down and sort it ASAP. I do most of the general cleaning as I work PT, but will not be picking up after my household like a skivvy. Our younger DC have age appropriate chores (helping to fold laundry, emptying dishwasher, making beds, making cereal breakfasts and sandwich/wrap lunches, dishwashing several items by hand, sweeping leaves on driveway, etc). DS has practically got a penthouse suite as they have the loft room with their own en-suite. They were very close to securing their dream FT job abroad, but seemingly lost out due to not being able to work at the location immediately, due to the uncertainty re. Covid travel restrictions. DS recently asked if they could reduce their contribution by 5% so they could save more (a family member told me they wanted to save more for travelling), I laughed and told DS to work more hours or to get another PT job if they wanted to earn more money 😄
Covid and lockdown has obviously set them back, but we've told them that we expect them to secure a permanent FT job, as soon as practically possible.

Hutella · 12/08/2020 16:05

@AmICrazyorWhat2 thanks. I get it. I guess most parents miss that freedom as a couple pre children!

In many parts of the world it can be acceptable or even preferred to have multi generations under one roof. Have a Greek friend for example and his family pretty much moved down the same street in outer london, with interlinked gardens.

Like you said your friend's 30 year old is doing well living his own life. While the minority in UK, multi generational living is rising, given the cost with urbanisation. Obviously you need right types of spaces to accommodate that (child instead of granny annexe!) but most of our housing are for nuclear families, and new build supply is ever smaller.

depending on how my children turn out as adults I quite like the idea, as I imagine I would retire from work then, my young children would have finally have some semblance of a rational adult brain, and I'd quite like more frequent company. But it seems from the response it is a cultural no no.

Theres some benefits in an ageing society e.g. care for grandchildren and later on, elderly care

Bananalanacake · 12/08/2020 15:48

My mum told me to move out at 21, I was happy to, I like my own space. Living with parents past 25 must be really smothering, I'd hate it.

Devlesko · 12/08/2020 15:44

Just remembered can anyone remember the paint advert where mum and dad wee decorating the son's room an awful colour.
That just sums it up for me, small room and decorated how you want it.
Nice pink rose wallpaper, should do it Grin

netflixismysidehustle · 12/08/2020 15:39

I think you need to give a deadline then hike it up to market rent

www.comparethemarket.com/home-insurance/content/pa-rental/

Devlesko · 12/08/2020 15:39

I think for your own sanity and your relationship with your partner there comes a time when you need to put you first.
You've done your bit and if they are taking the piss earning lots and spending it on hobbies instead of saving then they should go.
I also refused having partners to live with us, more than welcome to stay a couple of nights a week at most.
jules
Don't let it become a bigger issue, talk to them about a deadline and ask why they aren't saving everything they can?

julesbythesea · 12/08/2020 15:30

Hi, this is my first post too. YANBU! Like you, have 2 dc at home, for 18 months eldest dd (26) has her bf living here. They are saving to buy a place but are holding off actually buying because they think there is going to be a property slump therefore can get something cheaper. They both earn c.£35k each and pay us £200/month each rent, which I am sure they think is too much as many of their friends still living at home don't pay anything. My dh and I don't earn together what one of them earns! My dh gets very frustrated with dd bf, he is a nice guy but an only child and not very tidy, so I get it in the ear all the time from dh. What gets me is even though they are meant to be saving, he plays golf and cricket all the time which isn't the cheapest of hobbies. I hate the person the situation is turning me into, getting frustrated over petty things. It's coming between me and my daughter, I don't want to fall out with her over it.

AmICrazyorWhat2 · 12/08/2020 15:09

One of my friends started seeing someone ( and eventually married) a bloke who was still living with his parents. Granted, he travelled extensively internationally for his job so she said it wasn’t worth him getting his own place.

Tbh, I still found it slightly odd that 30 year old on a good salary had never left home...everything’s worked out for them though so he obviously wasn’t completely spoilt by Mum and Dad.🤣

lilgreen · 12/08/2020 15:09

Oh and DH was taught to iron and cook and clean by my MIL. I’m eternally grateful.

lilgreen · 12/08/2020 15:08

DH and I married from home at 25. All good,both paid board at home, looked after myself and saved, bought a house on our own with no help which I moved into just before we married. Still together 24 years later.

billy1966 · 12/08/2020 15:04

@Devlesko

I agree.
People marrying from home is not a good look.
Living on your own, sharing a house, paying bills, budgeting are very important life skills.

I have heard of more than one young couple finding the early years of marriage challenging in their first home, having come straight from the family home.......throwing 50 quid at Mum does not cover your costs in your own home by a mile.

Xenia · 12/08/2020 14:59

My daughters move home after university for 2 years of law school then legal training which was fine by me as a specific end in sight and then they did leave and indeed later I helped them buy a property each. My older son stayed after graduating and being 10 years old was a kind of au pair to the twins whom he collected from school every day fitting it around his work so that was fine and I paid him for that 3 hours a day he worked for me. I also helped him buy a house which he let out for a year before moving into it.

I just made clear that when the twins went to university I expect to be on my own and he knew that and was happy to move into his own house then. Now we are at the next stage - twins just graduated but are doing 2 years of law school so I am not quite at the point of everyone gone but they know that point will come. I am not living with adult children and nor did my parents. My father used to joke that you divorce your children at 18 and only pay for their university. He didn't really mean it in a sense of never seeing parents but he meant the adult children then have to make their own lives.

Devlesko · 12/08/2020 14:59

Maybe a bit harsh, but it is true.
Who wants a man who still makes a mess for mummy at 30 years old.
There are threads full of women complaining about useless men and this is one of the reasons.

I was cruel and made mine pull their weight, and leave home when working. They paid proper board at home and were responsible for their share of the work, why wouldn't they be?

The eldest was moved into the box room when he was 18, the same with the next one when he was 18.
They'd have preferred a bigger bedroom to turn into a type of bedsit, but no way Grin

It's each to their own, but you make a rod for your own back if you don't get them out when you can.
I love all my kids and we have a good relationship, most importantly dil's are happy with them and ds1 is a great dad because he was brought up having to do stuff and help with his baby sister.

Swipe left for the next trending thread