Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off with my sister about 2 letter words in Scrabble?

56 replies

Destinysdaughter · 08/08/2020 23:28

Tonight I suggested to my sister and DP that instead of staring at our screens we played a nice game of Scrabble unfortunately it quickly came unstuck as I played a word underneath another word and the 2 letter words that it made were ed and da. They said that I was cheating as they were not real words. Admittedly they were using a dictionary from 1977 whilst I play on a Scrabble app which gives you the list of allowed 2 letter words which you need to learn ( although you don't need to learn the meanings) .

So we had a v v heated dispute that you should only be allowed to use words where you knew the actual meaning as it was a game about lexicology whilst I was arguing that actually it's a numbers game and it's about placing words in a way where you will gain the most points ( even if you don't know the meaning of them )

We abandoned the game but are still arguing about who us right. I think I am! AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ironblancmange · 12/03/2023 08:00

@ThatsNiceVeryNice Yes, I can do all the ones beginning with A and will do the rest.
Thanks to all for comments on this reopening of the thread. My questions are answered.
The house rules were clear. All regular players were familiar with the current words lists and 'dictionary' (word list book, no definitions). No problem for me except that my attempts to lay my hands on this stuff at home/on Google were not understood. All they wanted to do was to play 3 games in one afternoon like a sort of maths exercise, very fast because all knew the short words.
@singer15 We did have discussions as to whether we could check before playing. Opinions varied but the decision was: not allowed to check first. My pair could probably have decided otherwise but that didn't work because we had to ask the other four in order to check.

Destinysdaughter, the OP, put it in a nutshell:
"So we had a v v heated dispute that you should only be allowed to use words where you knew the actual meaning as it was a game about lexicology whilst I was arguing that actually it's a numbers game and it's about placing words in a way where you will gain the most points ( even if you don't know the meaning of them)"

except that I was on the other side of the argument.

singer15 · 11/03/2023 23:34

They're wrong, but it's always a good idea to agree to use a specific dictionary. We use a free one online that's designed by the company that makes the Scrabble game.

Our house rules say we're allowed to check that a word is "allowed" before we play it. We also draw 8 tiles instead of 7 to help the game move faster.

ChellyT · 11/03/2023 23:24

Dishwashersaurous · 08/08/2020 23:33

The most important rule before starting scrabble is agreeing which dictionary is being used for any dispute.

Then you need to agree to abide by that

This is the one and only clear rule/understanding needed!

ThatsNiceVeryNice · 11/03/2023 23:01

@ironblancmange I like to know the meaning too. Firstly because it's interesting and secondly because it helps me remember the words.

I can get right to the end of the sporcle quiz I linked to earlier but only because I know the meanings. ( well, most of the time. Sometimes I forget)

Luckypom · 11/03/2023 23:01

This - love it!

‘filthy’ 😂

ironblancmange · 11/03/2023 22:50

@ThatsNiceVeryNice Thanks, that is a good list with meanings and I have another too. As I said, I have used that wiki link myself and printed out the grid version (on right of page). But I had read somewhere else that EW was US only, but thanks for putting me straight there.

I am aware that there have been changes in the official list so, for example, 1977, 2018 and later lists can be confusing.

I personally want to know the meanings, not just in order to know whether I can put an S or ED or something on the end. I understand some people think it's not necessary to know the meanings or even think it's silly to want to know the meanings, but it's my decision. I don't mind if the people I play against don't want to know the meanings, I just think it's weird. They are using the CSW list with 127 words, but it is a version printed a few years ago which has been amended to show which words have been dropped and which added, so it's a bit confusing. I went to Wikipedia to get things straight.

jetadore · 11/03/2023 22:20

Sounds like they’re bad losers. May I suggest next week you try a relaxing game of monopoly instead?

ThatsNiceVeryNice · 11/03/2023 22:16

ironblancmange · 11/03/2023 17:49

Thanks, yes, I know that list and I have even printed out the grid version on a colour printer. The group I play with accept EW, although it's US only.
The problem is that I don't have these words in my head.
They have a printed sheet with those words, amended to update to 2022, plus a few other categories like 4-letter words with more than 2 vowels, all Q words with U and so on. I have taken a note of that but the problem is I will always be the slowest until I learn and practise those words!

EW is definitely an valid official UK Scrabble word. It's not always been a valid word but it is now. Check out the wiki list I linked to earlier or here is the same list from the Association of British Scrabble Players LINK HERE
There are 127 valid words. You have to be so careful with what dictionary you use and that any information is up to date but this list is!

aa
(Hawaiian) a type of lava > AAS.
ab
An abdominal muscle > ABS.
ad
(Coll.) advertisement > ADS.
ae
(Scots) one. No -S.
ag
(Short for) agricultural; (noun) agriculture > AGS.
ah
Interjection expressing surprise, joy etc > AHS, AHING, AHED.
ai
(Tupi) the three-toed sloth > AIS.
al
An E. Indian shrub > ALS.
am
Present tense of be.
an
Indefinite article; (noun) something that might have happened but did not, as in ifs and ans > ANS.
ar
The letter r > ARS.
as
In whatever way; (noun) a Norse god > AESIR; a gravel ridge or KAME > ASAR; a Roman coin > ASSES.
at
Preposition denoting position in space or time; (noun) a monetary unit of Laos > ATS.
aw
Interjection expressing disappointment, sympathy etc.
ax
(US) axe > AXES.
ay
(Noun) an affirmative vote > AYS. Also AYE.
ba
In ancient Egyptian religion, the soul > BAS.
be
To exist.
bi
(Short for) bisexual > BIS.
bo
Fellow; pal, buddy > BOS.
by
Beside, near; (noun) same as BYE > BYS.
ch
(Obs. dial.) pronoun meaning I.
da
(Burmese) a heavy Burmese knife > DAS. Also DAH.
de
From (as used in names).
di
(Pl.) DEUS, a god.
do
A musical note: DOS; (verb) to perform > DOES, DOING, DID, DONE.
ea
(Dial.) river > EAS.
ed
(Short for) education > EDS.
ee
(Scots) eye > EEN.
ef
The letter f.
eh
Interjection expressing enquiry; (verb) to say 'eh' > EHS, EHING, EHED.
el
The letter l > ELS.
em
The letter M; a unit of measurement in printing > EMS.
en
The letter N; a unit in printing > ENS.
er
An interjection expressing hesitation.
es
The letter S > ESES. Also ESS.
et
(Obs.) pt. EAT.
ew
Interjection used to express disgust.
ex
The letter X; someone no longer in a previous relationship > EXES; (verb) to cross out > EXING, EXED.
fa
A musical note, as in sol-fa > FAS.
fe
(Hebrew) a Hebrew letter > FES
fy
An interjection expressing reproach. No -S hook. Also FIE.
gi
(Japanese) a judo or karate costume > GIS. Also GIE.
go
To pass from one place to another > GOES, GOING, WENT, GONE; (noun) a board game > GOS.
gu
(ON) a kind of violin formerly used in the Shetlands. Also GUE, GJU.
ha
An interjection expressing e.g. surprise.
he
A male person > HES.
hi
An interjection calling attention.
hm
An interjection expressing hesitation. Also HMM.
ho
Interjection calling attention, expressing surprise etc. Also HOH.
id
A fish of the carp family > IDS. Also IDE.
if
On condition that; (noun) a condition > IFS.
in
(Verb) to take in > INS, INNING, INNED.
io
An interjection expressing joy, triumph, grief; (noun) a cry of 'io' > IOS.
is
(3rd.) BE, to exist.
it
The neuter of he she him or her.
ja
Yes.
jo
(Scots) a loved one > JOES.
ka
The spirit or soul of a dead person; (verb) to serve > KAS, KAING, KAED. Also KAE.
ki
(Japanese) the spirit of Japanese martial art > KIS. Also QI, CHI.
ko
(Maori) a digging-stick > KOS.
ky
Cattle. No -S. Also KYE.
la
A musical note > LAS.
li
(Chinese) a Chinese unit of distance > LIS.
lo
An interjection meaning see, look.
ma
(Coll.) mother > MAS.
me
A musical note > MES.
mi
A musical note > MIS.
mm
An interjection expressing agreement.
mo
A moment > MOS.
mu
(Greek) a letter of the Greek alphabet > MUS.
my
Of or belonging to me.
na
(Scots) no, not at all.
ne
(Obs.) not.
no
Word of negation > NOS or NOES.
nu
(Greek) a letter in the Greek alphabet > NUS.
ny
(Verb) to approach > NYES, NYING, NYED. Also NIE > NIES, NYING, NIES.
ob
An objection > OBS.
od
A hypothetical force; an old word for god, often used as a mild oath > ODS.
oe
(Scots) a grandchild > OES. Also OY, OYE.
of
Belonging to.
oh
An interjection; (verb) to say OH > OHS, OHING, OHED.
oi
An interjection used to express attention; (noun) the grey-faced petrel > OIS.
ok
(Adjective) all right.
om
An intoned Hindu sacred symbol > OMS.
on
(Verb) to go on with, to put up with > ONS, ONNING, ONNED.
oo
(Scots) wool > OOS.
op
(Short for) operation > OPS.
or
(Noun) the heraldic tincture gold > ORS.
os
(Lat.) 1. a bone > OSSA. 2. a mouthlike opening > ORA.
ou
(Scots) an interjection expressing concession; (noun) a bloke > OUS.
ow
An interjection expressing pain.
ox
A bovine animal > OXEN; also, a clumsy person > OXES.
oy
(Scots) a grandchild > OYS. Also OE, OYE.
pa
(Maori) a hill fort > PAS. Also PAH.
pe
(Hebrew) a Hebrew letter > PES. Also PEH, FEH.
pi
(Greek) a letter in the Greek alphabet > PIS.
po
(Short for) chamberpot > POS.
qi
(Chinese) the physical life-force postulated by certain Chinese philosophers > QIS.
re
A musical note > RES.
sh
An interjection requesting silence. Also SHA, SHH.
si
An earlier form of TI, a musical note.
so
In such a way; (noun) a musical note > SOS.
st
An interjection requesting silence.
ta
An interjection expressing thanks > TAS.
te
= TI, a musical note > TES.
ti
A musical note; a small Pacific tree > TIS.
to
In the direction of, towards.
ug
To dread, loathe > UGS, UGGING, UGGED. [ON ugga, to fear, dread].
uh
An interjection expressing surprise.
um
An interjection expressing doubt or hesitation; (verb) to express hesitation > UMS, UMMING, UMMED.
un
(Dial.) one > UNS.
up
(Verb) to move up > UPS, UPPING, UPPED.
ur
An interjection expressing hesitation.
us
Pronoun.
ut
A musical note > UTS.
we
Pronoun.
wo
Woe > WOS.
xi
(Greek) a letter in the Greek alphabet > XIS.
xu
A Vietnamese monetary unit > XU. No -S.
ya
an Asian pear >YAS.
ye
(Arch.) you.
yo
An interjection calling for effort or attention
yu
(Chinese) a precious jade > YUS.
za
(Sl.) pizza > ZAS.
ze
A gender-neutral pronoun.
zo
(Tibetan) a kind of yak > ZOS. Also ZHO, DZO, DSO, DZHO.

ColdHandsHotHead · 11/03/2023 21:22

There used to be a book of 'Official Scrabble words' published and it was just list after list. If a word was in, you could use it. However it didn't give meanings, therefore I would say no you don't need to know the meanings.

adulthumanfemalemum · 11/03/2023 21:22

Agreeing on house rules before you start is probably the way forward.

But technically you are correct. There was a guy who won the national Scrabble tournament in France without being able to speak French at all. He didn't know what any of the words meant or how to pronounce them, he had just memorised the dictionary.

The rules state you can't look up a word before placing it but if it is challenged then you can check it. There are specific Scrabble word books but you can also check online by typing the word and Scrabble and it will say if it's a valid Scrabble word.

SomePeopleAreJustBloodyStupid · 11/03/2023 21:20

Play Monopoly instead 😂

mamange · 11/03/2023 21:17

If I understand your post correctly you guys were using a dictionary (you mention it’s from 1977)… to me it’s then easy, if your words are in the dictionary they are ok if not they aren’t. Seems to me you signed up to this at the start of the game?

AlwaysLatte · 11/03/2023 21:03

We've memorised all the two letter words so there's no argument about that! But occasionally one of us will put down a chancer word, say 'bronk' or something and look hopefully at the other. 'What does it mean then,' usually sorts it!

ironblancmange · 11/03/2023 17:49

Thanks, yes, I know that list and I have even printed out the grid version on a colour printer. The group I play with accept EW, although it's US only.
The problem is that I don't have these words in my head.
They have a printed sheet with those words, amended to update to 2022, plus a few other categories like 4-letter words with more than 2 vowels, all Q words with U and so on. I have taken a note of that but the problem is I will always be the slowest until I learn and practise those words!

ThatsNiceVeryNice · 11/03/2023 14:30

The are 127 words.

ThatsNiceVeryNice · 11/03/2023 14:26

https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Scrabble/TwoLetterr_Words This is the definitive current two letter word list for scrabble players in the Uk.

It's different in different countries.

ironblancmange · 11/03/2023 09:53

(Just getting used to mumsnet re tagging etc.) Thanks very much, I did actually find a quiz too, I just wondered about the app where you play some version of Scrabble and it helps you with the words. But probably the quiz is better. I found this, where you can turn the flashcards over to see the meaning. But I haven't signed up there.
quizlet.com/2558/scrabble-2-letter-words-flash-cards/

@midlifecrash I suppose people use various rules. I definitely intend to learn the meanings. But the rule in this group I have been to is: play the word, the other player challenges, and someone checks whether it exists (not what it means). If it doesn't exist, you miss your turn.

This is what is driving me mad, this rule that all two-letter words allowed are good but no one cares what they mean! They have all been playing for years the same way, but the group is thinning out, of the former 25 or so there are only 5 left - some have died! And I feel really uncomfortable playing so slowly but that's how it is.

ThatsNiceVeryNice · 11/03/2023 08:50

@ironblancmange Sorry meant to tag you in my post.

ThatsNiceVeryNice · 11/03/2023 08:49

TWO LETTER WORD QUIZ

I found this two letter word quiz on sporcle. It uses all the proper UK scrabble two letter words. It's free and you don't have to sign up. Doesn't give the meaning though.

midlifecrash · 11/03/2023 08:28

I think if you’re challenged about a word and you can’t say what it means you can’t have it, I thought that was a rule. But maybe my mum made it up

ironblancmange · 11/03/2023 08:25

I know I'm late on this thread but OP what app do you use that helps you learn the two-letter words? I use Wordmaster Pro and it doesn't. I have been to a Scrabble playing group and I don't know many two-letter words, so I was a bit slower than most and I won't go back till I've learnt them. They have official lists and I can find them on Wikipedia etc. CSW22 is the main one: Collins Scrabble Words 2022. I want to learn them AND know the meanings. The modern way is apparently "We don't care what they mean".

curiousierandcouriser · 09/08/2020 01:02

Basically, none of you are wrong - you are just playing using different variations of the rules. Before you start playing, you need to choose a dictionary to use and agree whether or not a player must define a word. A few minutes discussion at the beginning can save a lot of arguments during the game.

rosiejaune · 09/08/2020 00:57

YANBU in that you don't need to know the meanings of the words to play them. Unless it is a house rule that you have agreed in advance.

But you also need to agree which dictionary to use in advance - were your words in it or not?

ChloeCrocodile · 09/08/2020 00:49

You don’t even have to be good at spelling to be a good scrabble player.

We once played a game where every word had to be spelled incorrectly. It was surprisingly tough!

Under normal circumstances tho, we use our household dictionary to settle disputes.

Boohoohoohooho · 09/08/2020 00:27

I’m an avid scrabble player and the Queensbury rules are that you should absolutely be able to give the definition if challenged by the opponent

Haha, I’d be stuffed if this were the case. You don’t even have to be good at spelling to be a good scrabble player.