Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To feel like I'm losing my sister to conspiracy theories?

309 replies

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 13:24

My sister is a very intelligent, funny, interesting woman but recently , probably since lockdown she has been spending more and more time online and reading into conspiracy theories about the Hollywood elite and politicians and child sacrifices and all kinds of ludicrous claims.

This has utterly consumed her, you cannot have a conversation with the her that she does not turn to her trying to show some you tube video as "evidence". I'm so worried but do not know what to do as everything I say is met with "well that's what they want you to think".

OP posts:
Haffiana · 04/08/2020 16:51

Conspiracy Theories are just another religion.

It involves an unseen over-arching force that shapes the World, the special Chosen Ones that can see the Truth of this, a profound devotional Belief system, the Preaching of the Word and of course, the seeking for Converts.

Plus the belief that this is all sane and rational.

Twatalert · 04/08/2020 16:42

@Thestreets

I agree *@ComplexPTSDmaybe* I'm all for everyone having their own opinion but where it comes to believing COVID does not exist and has been made up so the sheeple will conform that is where the line is drawn between harmless and harmful.

My dsis will not sanitise her hands or wear a mask even when she had to take her DD into hospital last week. She did not care that there could be vulnerable people in the hospital that she might infect as COVID does not exist. She lied and said that she had trauma preventing her from covering her face which is despicable.

So? I was in hospital myself this weekend and staff could not have cared less whether i sanitize or not. I indeed expected to be told to do so before entering, but nope... I did wear a mask on arrival. No idea what they would have done had I tried to enter without. The doctor I saw touched doors and then my face - without sanitising.

You have been given advice here. I'm not sure what else you would like to hear? It almost seems you'd like as many people as possible to come forward and say how stupid conspiracy theories are.

Sometimes in life things take a turn we do not like. Your sister isn't the person you'd like her to be at the moment. By all means, contact SS if you feel the child is not cared for properly, for example because she is stoned all the time and/or the child is breathing in the weed smell (i find it horrendous). Or because the house is dirty, the child is not cared for properly etc. But she can believe what she wants and all you can do is try to get to a place to accept that you cannot change it. You can adapt, perhaps reduce the contact to as much as you can manage for your own wellbeing. All you can and should do is to manage YOUR response.

But I guess this isn't what you'd like to hear. You'd rather bash anyone who can sympathize with your sister on some level.

Chickenkatsu · 04/08/2020 16:36

Weed + You Tube + Over Active Imagination = Disaster

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 16:35

@Zaphodsotherhead

And I don't understand the anti-mask thing. Okay, it's one thing to not believe in Covid. But surely, wearing a mask isn't going to harm you, is it? It's not going to make you suffer (unless you have a pre existing condition). So why not wear one anyway? Just in case?

I think, by not wearing masks, they are trying to shout loud and proud that they are not falling for it and are somehow 'in the know'.

Thats exactly what it is certainly in my sisters case
OP posts:
foxychox · 04/08/2020 16:35

Maybe instead of spending her time looking into conspiracy theories she could take some time to find out where the weed that is fuelling her paranoia is coming from? Might take her mind of 5G and all that.....

Zaphodsotherhead · 04/08/2020 16:33

And I don't understand the anti-mask thing. Okay, it's one thing to not believe in Covid. But surely, wearing a mask isn't going to harm you, is it? It's not going to make you suffer (unless you have a pre existing condition). So why not wear one anyway? Just in case?

I think, by not wearing masks, they are trying to shout loud and proud that they are not falling for it and are somehow 'in the know'.

OchonAgusOchonO · 04/08/2020 16:33

[quote WinnieLo]@OchonAgusOchonO the last minute of that documentary was classic![/quote]
Brilliant. Every conspiracy theorist who isn't a flat earther should watch it. It would be interesting to see their reactions.

redbushtea · 04/08/2020 16:32

@Buccanarab
Being entitled to an opinion isn't the same as your opinion being right, or even acceptable. Opinions that are demonstrably false or wrong need to be challenged whenever they're raised

That works both ways. There is plenty which is demonstrably false about the mainstream media coverage of the current corona virus drama. In Nazi Germany, if more people had challenged mainstream opinion instead of slavishly going along with it, many lives would have been saved.

TulipsTwoLips · 04/08/2020 16:31

My brother in law is like this. That's why I deleted him off my social media and spend very little time around him. It makes me laugh really, he is all talk but no action. If you ask him what he is going to do about insert latest conspiracy theory, he's not actually going to do anything, because they are too rich or too powerful. I don't count him sharing posts to the 10 people who follow him as real action! Personally I don't see much point in all of the over-thinking he does if it never leads to action.

I think the best thing you can do is try to keep doing practical things with her. Give her a chance to be present and not so in her head. Walking, cooking, cinema etc, it doesn't need to be anything huge.

BelleHathor · 04/08/2020 16:31

@L8Bloomer

let her figure it out on her own eventually.

A friend was telling me a couple of weeks ago about some hormone ''chromium'' that was released when children were in terror and that various celebrities used it as a fountain of youth potion. I remember thinking what.the.fuck......... I got home and googled chromium and it's a skit from a film.

It's called Adrenochrome, oddly enough there is a scene about it in the film fear and loathing in Las Vegas m.youtube.com/watch?v=m6kFCNsnQpQ
Zaphodsotherhead · 04/08/2020 16:30

With the Conspiracists that I've come into contact with , there has seemed to be a direct inverse correlation between intelligence and belief in The Big Theories. They want to appear to be more clever and more 'with it' than others (probably because they've never been in that position before in the real world), so they take the little bits of various theories that make sense to them, build on them in their own heads, construct their own theories and then put them out into the world.

Where they are picked up by others in the same boat, and put forward as being 'true', even though they were just dreamed up by someone else joining the dots, and inserting their own dots when the picture wasn't what they wanted it to be.

L8Bloomer · 04/08/2020 16:28

The flat earth documentary made me see how these slightly marginalised types got to finally belong to group. Suddenly they had a social life, people to communicate with, conferences to go, causes to get behind, friendships, romantic partners even.

Just finally a sense of belonging really. It was just a random, relatively harmless platform on which to create the platform for that sense of belonging. It could have been 'We wear Pink on Wednesdays''

JasperRising · 04/08/2020 16:26

I think mistrust of mainstream media (which generally have some degree of bias), social media and the difficulty of verifying sources, the internet meaning content can be shared worldwide combined with Covid-19 has created the perfect environment for conspiracy theories to become more prevalent. Humans react in funny ways to fear and events outside their control. Having something to believe in can make you feel more in control.

That said, conspiracy theories can turn out to have kernels of truth. We should be careful not to dismiss conspiracy nuts without at least thinking about what they are saying. For example: coronovirus being made to control us/fear of it being used to control us. I don't believe there is a global 'they' seeking to control us but on an individual basis people/governments are taking advantage. Was it Hungary(?) where laws passed for quick decision making in relation to covid-19 were used to pass legislation unrelated to covid-19. And I know lawyers in the UK who are concerned about sloppy wording in recent legislation plus the blurring of lines between guidance and law and what is enforceable how - all of which could have future consequences.

Sadly, I fear there is little you can do to help your sister as it sounds like she is well into extreme conspiracy territory and any objections from you will be rationalised as part of the conspiracy.

WinnieLo · 04/08/2020 16:22

@OchonAgusOchonO the last minute of that documentary was classic!

Buccanarab · 04/08/2020 16:21

@redbushtea

Everybody is entitled to their opinion and that includes your sister.

Being entitled to an opinion isn't the same as your opinion being right, or even acceptable. Opinions that are demonstrably false or wrong need to be challenged whenever they're raised.

OchonAgusOchonO · 04/08/2020 16:17

Behind the Curve on Netflix is an interesting documentary about flat-earthers and how the cement their views. Even when they carried out an experiment themselves to supposedly prove the earth was flat and it didn't work they just made excuses.

Lovemusic33 · 04/08/2020 16:16

I think the best way to handle this is the same way you handle psychosis , so not disagree with her, do not tell her she’s crazy but do question her, ask her what evidence there is to back up these theories? Ask her why these things have not been spoken about in the main news (BBC)? Make her see that these are not logical theories.

It sounds like she’s become obsessed, maybe to fill her time whilst feeling lonely, she needs to find other things to keep her brain busy, intelligent people are great at over thinking everything and blowing things out of proportion.

OchonAgusOchonO · 04/08/2020 16:09

@Devlesko

She's not entirely wrong is she? Do you believe what the media tell you to believe or do you have a mind of your own.
The problem with conspiracy theorists is they believe nothing unless it backs up their theories. If it backs up their beliefs then they will believe it without any critical analysis or proof.

Yes, of course we should all apply critical thinking to what we read. However, very few conspiracy theorists, despite telling us how we are being fooled and need to critique media reports, actually apply any level of critical thinking at all to the lunacy they are peddling.

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 16:09

@Jihhery I think that would do more harm than good because at the moment my nice stays over quite a bit of the time to play with her cousins and I would be afraid that dsis would cut me off. I dont believe they would be able to help her either if I'm honest, it would just prove her theories right of authority being out to silence her because she is speaking up.

OP posts:
Chocolateoo · 04/08/2020 16:07

My partner is obsessed with Bill gates and a name that I can't remember today annoyingly. He mentions the elite or control most days. The thing is sometimes I think he has points. But he lets himself down by being too invested.

For example yesterday their was apparently a big riot in London for wearing masks. This was shown on a new channel called RT but not the BBC etc. The RT channel is alot more real.

The thing is there are some issues at the moment about the world in general. We don't need 5G. We really don't. Technology like this could lead to more health issues. Mobile phones on their own will do that. WiFi and stuff isn't good for the brain. I do think technology has gone too far. I don't particularly think about it until he starts. But when he does start I can see machines are taking over. You can see that by going in Asda and realising humans no longer operate the tills and they are adding more and more in to cut staff down.

I don't know about vaccines. Alot of people think bill gates is a nasty piece of work and has an agenda.

The thing with coronavirus stats is to actually look on the NHS website daily stats. You will find way less are dying when you see it on there. What you have to remember too is the testing system is corrupt. They don't do postmortems and tests on every human that has died. many have died from other things or with Covid on top of an end of life illness. But they just put it down as covid. Ofcourse some have died. It's absolutely tragic. But thankfully there's not many young healthy people dying. Infact theres not many middle aged people dying either. A huge majority are over 80 and we don't even know if it really was covid. The usual media outlets are controlled. They can only print certain things.

Masks will not be as amazing as people think. They make you feel safer. But really half of them are made by random people who perhaps are not using a material that's protective enough or it doesn't fit right. Many disposable ones are snapping etc. Read reviews on Amazon. The government are really messing people around.

But you can't live in fear and over think these things. Most of it is likely crap. But the world isn't what it seems either.

Look at things like the NHS and it's underfunding for cancer and many other things. All the cut backs. Closing maternity units. Shutting local a&es. Yet they have found billions for Coronavirus. it's almost like they don't want to save people.

Thestreets · 04/08/2020 16:04

I agree @ComplexPTSDmaybe I'm all for everyone having their own opinion but where it comes to believing COVID does not exist and has been made up so the sheeple will conform that is where the line is drawn between harmless and harmful.

My dsis will not sanitise her hands or wear a mask even when she had to take her DD into hospital last week. She did not care that there could be vulnerable people in the hospital that she might infect as COVID does not exist. She lied and said that she had trauma preventing her from covering her face which is despicable.

OP posts:
AuntMasha · 04/08/2020 16:00

I think people turn to conspiracy theories during times of social and economic turmoil and when people feel disenfranchised or at odds with mainstream society. Knowing a bit of history, there is absolutely nothing new about the basic Apocalyptic fantasy - a powerful elite who perform satanic rituals involving the sacrifice of children and a ‘saviour’ who will come to save this dark world from an ‘Antichrist’ - it is as old as the hills. In medieval Europe during the Black Death, for example these ideas spread and spawned all kinds of outbreaks of violence, specifically against the Jewish communities in Germany and France. It was believed the plague was deliberately started by Jewish people poisoning the wells.

I’m not saying there are no conspiracies - we know, historically there have been and are - but the kind of QAnon, satanic evil elite sacrificing babies in a Pizza restaurant are just a continuation of the old fantasies of the Middle Ages and have little to do with reality.

Norman Cohan’s ‘Pursuit of the Millennium’ is a good book on this subject.

Jihhery · 04/08/2020 15:58

I'm concerned about your sister's child, OP. Please call SS and explain what's happening.

ComplexPTSDmaybe · 04/08/2020 15:56

I actually think the Covid conspiracy people are dangerous tbh. I work in a hospital, in health research and see the daily figures and my job is to read the peer reviewed research papers that show exactly what impact Covid-19 is having on the nations health (direct and indirect).

These people who are saying 'They are manipulating the stats, EVERYONE is dying from covid according to death certificates, its all a scamdemic to control us etc' are dangerous.

People say they are entitled to their opinion but what if their opinion is scaring people or affecting people's behaviour or spreading disinformation?

contrmary · 04/08/2020 15:56

People are more worried because seemingly "normal" people are more likely to believe conspiracy theories nowadays, in the past the tin-foil hat brigade were outcasts so nobody batted an eyelid when they raised a wacky theory or two.

It's harder to understand when someone we believed rational starts believing something so obviously irrational. However it's a product of our time, more people are realising how biased mainstream media is and so more people are turning to alternative outlets (unfortunately ones that spout bollocks).

One only has to look to the coverage of the climate change riots or BLM protests to see how one-sided it is. Dissent cannot be tolerated, even support isn't tolerated if it is not deemed supportive enough. This leads people to think that the BBC, for instance, will only show one side of the argument on other issues too.

All news sources have an agenda they are trying to push. Some are obvious (Daily Mail, Guardian etc) but in increasing numbers people are realising "respectable" outlets like the BBC are just as bad. In some ways worse, they are better at hiding their angle and conning people.

It's no surprise that in this climate people turn elsewhere. A conspiracy theory just means that the "right" people don't support it. All the claims of Russia meddling in western elections are a conspiracy theory, but the correct people believe in it so it is treated as news.